Kansas City Southern — Proxy Contest (August 2021)
20 slides from Kansas City Southern's proxy contest presentation, Aug 4, 2021
Slide 1: Canadian Pacific Proxy Statement in Opposition to CN Merger
Canadian Pacific Proxy Statement in Opposition to CN Merger CONFIDENTIAL August 3, 2021
Slide 2: Forward Looking Statements and Information
Legends FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS AND INFORMATION This presentation includes certain forward-looking statements and forward looking information (collectively, FLI). FLI is typically identified by words such as “anticipate”, “expect”, “project”, “estimate”, “forecast”, “plan”, “intend”, “target”, “b
Slide 3: CN-KCS Merger Proposal Entails Serious Risk to Certainty of Value and Delay
CN-KCS Merger Proposal Entails Both Serious Risk to Certainty of Value and Significant Delay to KCS Shareholders The CN Voting Trust proposal faces major regulatory headwinds, most recently from Rep. DeFazio, Chair of the U.S. House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, which oversees the STB
Slide 4: CN-KCS Combination Would Reduce Competition and Impede Passenger Service
CN-KCS Combination Would Reduce Competition and Impede Passenger Service combination has significant public interest harm Creates competitive issues and more challenges for existing Amtrak service Reduces competition Creates immediate pressure for downstreaconsolidation Impedes passenger service CN
Slide 5: KCS Shareholders Should Vote AGAINST the CN-KCS Merger Proposal
KCS Shareholders Should Vote “AGAINST” the CN-KCS Merger Proposal to Retain Flexibility Given Regulatory Uncertainty VOTE “AGAINST” the CN-KCS Merger Proposal to ensure KCS shareholders:  Are not locked into a binding agreement until February 2022 even if the CN Voting Trust is rejected by the ST
Slide 6: The STB Has Already Approved CP's Use of a Voting Trust
The STB Has Already Approved CP’s Use of a Voting Trust, While CN Faces Significant Regulatory Uncertainty Offer  Subject to STB Pre-2001 Rules “The [STB] finds that the waiver provision [of new merger rules] should apply to this Transaction for several reasons.” “If approved, the combination of
Slide 7: CP-KCS Combination is the Only Viable Option
CP-KCS Combination is the Only Viable Option CP is continuing to pursue its application process for authority to control KCS, so that the pro-competitive CP-KCS combination can be reviewed by the STB and implemented without undue delay in the event that KCS’ agreement with CN is terminated STB has a
Slide 8: CP-KCS is a Compelling Strategic Combination
CP-KCS is a Compelling Strategic Combination and the Only Viable Class 1 Combination Combination offers significant benefits to rail shippers and the supply chain KCS shareholders benefit from clear path to closing Clear Path to Closing with the Voting Trust Already Approved by STB Creates the First
Slide 9: Appendix A – CN's Voting Trust Likely Will Not Be Approved
Appendix A – CN’s Voting Trust Likely Will Not Be Approved
Slide 10: CN-KCS Combination Is Not in the Public Interest
CN-KCS Combination Is Not in the Public Interest • We will know soon whether the CN Voting Trust can be approved; shareholders would be unwise to vote on the assumption that it will be approved • The STB has already rejected CN-KCS’s assertions about the narrowness of the public interest standard un
Slide 11: Public Interest Standard (Cont'd)
Public Interest Standard (Cont’d) • In the CN-KCS proceeding the STB explained that the public interest standard applicable to the approval of CN’s Voting Trust is far broader than CN-KCS claim: STB Decision No. 3 in CN-KCS (5/17/21): “financial integrity … one of five factors, at a minimum, that th
Slide 12: Even if the Public Interest Test Were as Narrow as CN Claims, CN's Trust Would Flunk
Even if the Public Interest Test Were as Narrow as CN Claims, CN’s Trust Would Flunk the Test • CN acknowledges that financial risks are a relevant factor • Yet CN’s voting trust papers fail to address the financial implications – in terms of pressure to raise rates or cut back on investment – posed
Slide 13: CN and KCS Fail to Address the Other Prongs of the Public Interest Test
CN and KCS Fail to Address the Other Prongs of the Public Interest Test Focused on Impact on Competition for CN’s Voting Trust • STB has signaled that this is an important factor: CN-KCS Decision No. 3 cited DOJ comments emphasizing that competitive harm could arise during the Trust period STB Decis
Slide 14: CN Has Repeatedly Taken an Unduly Narrow View of Rail-to-Rail Competition
CN has Repeatedly Taken an Unduly Narrow View of the Rail-to-Rail Competition that the STB will Seek to Protect CN has repeatedly acted as if the only relevant competitive issues are “2-to-1” direct served shippers (which it says it will remedy with its proposed divestiture) CN Voting Trust Motion,
Slide 15: CN's Proposed Divestiture is Illusory
CN’s Proposed Divestiture is Illusory Although CN calls its proposal a “divestiture,” it is not really a transfer of the rights that KCS has today given that CN will retain trackage rights to operate over the entire line and serve every shipper on the line CN Voting Trust Motion (5/26/21): “CN-KCS w
Slide 16: No Realistic Prospect for an Appeal to Overturn a Negative STB Ruling
There is No Realistic Prospect for an Appeal to Overturn a Negative Ruling by the STB on CN’s Trust CN’s disdain for the STB’s authority over voting trusts is longstanding, but its narrow view of the STB’s authority has consistently been rejected CN in EP 582 (11/17/00): argued that use of voting tr
Slide 17: Appendix B—Uncertainty Surrounds Ultimate Approval of CN Control of KCS
Appendix B—Uncertainty Surrounds Ultimate Approval of CN Control of KCS
Slide 18: Ultimate Approval of CN Control of KCS Remains Highly Uncertain
Ultimate Approval of CN Control of KCS Remains Highly Uncertain The 2001 Rules fundamentally changed the STB’s approach to proposed mergers, shifting the presumption to one disfavoring further consolidation, especially where competition would be reduced STB in EP 582 (10/3/00) (proposing new rules):
Slide 19: CN Ignores the Significance of Its Historically Bad Relationship with Amtrak
CN Ignores the Significance of Its Historically Bad Relationship with Amtrak Biden Executive Order makes clear that a merging railroad’s history of compliance with its statutory obligations to Amtrak is an important factor in any merger proceeding Exec. Order Sec. 3(n)(iv): “in the process of determ
Slide 20: A CN-KCS Combination Poses Numerous Other Serious Public Interest Concerns
A CN-KCS Combination Poses Numerous Other Serious Public Interest Concerns It extinguishes the possibility of CP-KCS combination, which injects new competition and investment in North-South rail corridors, intensifying competition with larger Class I railroads like UP, BNSF and CN – without any need