Rural Metro — Proxy Contest (November 2006)
22 slides from Rural Metro's proxy contest presentation, Nov 17, 2006
Slide 1: Accipiter Capital Management Presentation: Rural/Metro 2006 Annual Meeting
ACCIPITER CAPITAL MANAGEMENT PRESENTATION RURAL/METRO CORPORATION 2006 ANNUAL MEETING
Slide 2: Our objective
Our objective We are one of the largest RURL stockholders. Our goal is to maximize stockholder value for all stockholders. Step 1: Replace two incumbent directors at the Annual Meeting on December 1, 2006 + Management and Board unresponsive to stockholders + Refusal to provide stockholders with any
Slide 3: Step 1: Replace two incumbent directors at the Annual Meeting
Step 1: Replace two incumbent directors at the Annual Meeting on December 1, 2006
Slide 4: Accipiter Background
ACCIPITER BACKGROUND + New York based hedge fund investing solely in healthcare, approx. $500 million AUM. + Not an “activist” investment firm, only second proxy contest in nearly 4 years since 12/02 inception. + Seeking minority position on Rural’s Board (only 2 of 7 seats on classified Board) + Wi
Slide 5: Accipiter history with Rural
Accipiter history with Rural * One of 10 largest stockholders for over one year + Shelf offering filed Feb. 2006; Rural refused to provide to public specific metrics for issuance of additional shares + Request to contact an independent board member rebuffed + Letter to Board dated May 5, 2006 +Cordi
Slide 6: Lack of Transparency
Lack of Transparency + Narrow-minded policy involving refusal to provide stockholders with any financial projections regarding any operating metrics. + Impossible to determine specific metrics utilized for management compensation. * Continual earnings restatements + Financial and operating metrics d
Slide 7: Potential Dilutive Secondary Offering
Potential Dilutive Secondary Offering *RURL filed a shelf registration statement to sell up to $120 million of debt and/or equity securities in February 2006 —Stock declined over 15% from the date of filing to date of Accipiter nominations (disclosed on Schedule 13D) —Management did not specify on w
Slide 8: ee) os on en (a) (4)
ee) os on en (a) (4) cee onee wos 4 (oa ey oo 0a (ae) os on ee) (38) ars, cee sonst ws 9 (oa) ey oo) 0a
Slide 9: hres. pars meget
hres. pars meget FEES oe
Slide 10: Additional Examples of Stockholder Alienation
a= Additional Examples of Stockholder Alienation + Form 10-K filing for FY 2001, 2002, 2003, 2005 and 2006 all late; Form 10-Q for Q1 FY 2007 late +Insufficient time for stockholders to digest operating results “Press release issued at 6:15 pm Sept 12" announcing Q4 FY 2006 earnings release date of
Slide 11: Rural's Board: A Long-Term History of Stockholder Value Destruction
SS t—‘“‘—S Rural’s Board: A Long-Term History of Stockholder Value Destruction *Disastrous rapid acquisition strategy in late 1990s, >50 acquisitions in 4 years *Debt ballooned from $66 million in 1996 to $292 million in 2000 -1999 EPS from continued operations = $1.06 —2006 EPS from continued opera
Slide 12: Poor stock performance
Poor stock performance significantly, as evidenced in the graphs below. A_Long-term history of Stockholder Value Destruction Rural’s director nominees have served on Rural’s Board for 9 and 14 years, respectively. During the entirety of their and the CEO’s tenure at Rural, the stock price has droppe
Slide 13: Poor stock performance
Poor stock performance Using a shorter term horizon, such as the beginning of Fiscal Year 2006 through the filing of the notice of nomination of Accipiter’s nominees, Rural’s stock price has also significantly underperformed. Performance from Beginning of Fiscal Year 2006 on July 1, 2005 to Septembe
Slide 14: Plunging Stock Price — Stagnant Board
Plunging Stock Price — Stagnant Board 4 of 6 independent directors have served for >7 years —Cor Clement: January 1992 —Louis Jekel: | August 1998 —Henry Walker: September 1997 —Mary Anne Carpenter: January 1998 *Stock price lower today than when each of the nominees joined the Rural Board *Rural’s
Slide 15: Lack of accountability & sub-standard corporate governance
Lack of accountability & sub-standard corporate Where does Rural currently stand on corporate governance practices? Itis obvious that Rural has long-ignored proper corporate governance: +Poison pill renewed in August 2005 +Staggered board -Supermajority voting provision that requires vote of at leas
Slide 16: Disproportionate Compensation
Disproportionate Compensation + Board — 100% cash compensation + Higher than industry average: $70k annual retainer, Chairman $50k additional, 2 Vice Chairmen §20k additional. Ironically, the Chairman and a Vice Chairman are up for re-election at this year's annual meeting. + Management incentive pa
Slide 17: Rural's Misleading Materials Filed With the SEC
Rural’s Misleading Materials Filed With the SE What Rural Says vs. The Facts Rural’s Use of ‘Smokescreen Tactics to Divert Attention From Real Issues Rural’s materials make the following misleading claims regarding Accipiter’s investment in a primary competitor, Emergency Medical Services Corporatio
Slide 18: Step 2: Take action to maximize stockholder value
Step 2: Take action to maximize stockholder value
Slide 19: Why our nominees should replace two incumbent directors
Why our nominees should replace two incumbent directors Accipiter is incentivized to maximize stockholder value + The Committee has a substantial financial incentive to maximize stockholder value + Accipiter owns approximately 7.7% of Rural — our incentive is aligned with the other stockholders + Th
Slide 20: Take action to maximize stockholder value: Accipiter's Plan
Take action to maximize stockholder value ACCIPITER’S PLAN +Engage an investment banking firm to assist the Board in evaluating all strategic options, including: —Review capital structure —Evaluate refinancing options that would be accretive to forward fiscal year cash EPS from operations —Contact p
Slide 21: Why our nominees should replace the incumbent directors
Why our nominees should replace the Experienced nominees with clear mandate — maximize stockholder value Gabe Hoffman: +8 years in public healthcare investing, 6 years in senior positions +Founder, sole principal, portfolio manager, Accipiter, 2002-present *Co-Manager, Welch Life Sciences Fund, 2000
Slide 22: Accipiter letter to Rural/Metro Board dated May 5, 2006
Accipiter Capital Management, LLC 399 Park Avenue, 38 th Floor New York, NY 10022 May 5, 2006 Rural/Metro Corporation Board of Directors 9221 East Via de Ventura Scottsdale, AZ 85258 To the Board of Directors of Rural/Metro Corporation: Accipiter Capital Management, LLC, together with its affiliates