iMedia Brands — Valuevision Media — Proxy Contest (June 2014)
13 slides from iMedia Brands's proxy contest presentation, Jun 2, 2014
Slide 1: Schedule 14A - ValueVision Media, Inc.
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ¨ Check
Slide 2: Date Filed
(4) Date Filed:
Slide 3: Important Information
On May 30, 2014, ValueVision Media, Inc. (“ValueVision”) provided Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. (“ISS”) with a slide presentation (the “Supplemental Presentation”) pertaining to certain matters to be voted upon at ValueVision’s 2014 Annual Meeting of Shareholders scheduled for June 18, 201
Slide 4: Supplemental Presentation on Clinton Group's Misleading Messaging
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT ON CLINTON GROUP’S MISLEADING MESSAGING ValueVision Media (NASDAQ: VVTV) SUPPLEMENTAL INVESTOR PRESENTATION May 30, 2014
Slide 5: Setting the Record Straight on Clinton Group's Misleading Messaging
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT ON CLINTON GROUP’S MISLEADING MESSAGING Clinton Group’s May 27, 2014 Presentation to ISS Included Multiple Inaccurate and Misleading Statements Clinton Group’s Selection of a Variety of Baseline Comparisons for Operating Performance and Shareholder Returns is Self-Serving
Slide 6: ValueVision Share Performance: Setting the Record Straight
VALUEVISION SHARE PERFORMANCE: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT Only One Member of Current Executive Management and the Board was at the Company Prior to October 2008 VVTV Share Price Performance Clinton Group Selects Returns Dating Back to 1999, More Than Nine Years …and Shows that Prior Management Took
Slide 7: ValueVision Revenue Performance: Setting the Record Straight
VALUEVISION REVENUE PERFORMANCE: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT We Typically Gauge Our Share Against the Broader Retail Environment, but Clinton Group’s Selective and Incomplete Data Warrants Correction Historical Revenue Revenue Share VVTV HSN Segment QVC US VVTV VVTV Clinton Group’s (7%) +22% +26% 10
Slide 8: ValueVision Merchandising & Distribution Strategy: Setting the Record Straight
VALUEVISION MERCHANDISING & DISTRIBUTION STRATEGY: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT We Aim to Generate Shareholder Return through Prudent and Opportunistic Merchandising and Programming Strategies that will Resonate with Both Our Vendors and Customers Proprietary Brands Exclusive Products “[ValueVision]
Slide 9: Merchandising & Distribution Strategy (Cont'd)
VALUEVISION MERCHANDISING & DISTRIBUTION STRATEGY: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT (CONT’D) Product Mix Programming and Distribution “[ValueVision’s] product mix [is] vastly “Programming that is monotonous and different than competitors” repetitive…” Clinton Group “Progress [to shift product mix] has “V
Slide 10: ValueVision Board of Directors: Setting the Record Straight
VALUEVISION BOARD OF DIRECTORS: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT Director What Clinton Group Stated What the Facts Are Prior to serving as Chief Merchandising Officer, Mr. Ronning was EVP at QVC Randy Ronning for 6 years Former EVP and Chief • “Ronning served as Chief Merchandising Officer of QVC for 18
Slide 11: Board of Directors (Cont'd)
VALUEVISION BOARD OF DIRECTORS: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT (CONT’D) Director What Clinton Group Stated What the Facts Are Mr. Hobbs has 20 years of media experience and 30 years of finance Landell Hobbs expertise and served as the CFO of Time Warner Cable in addition to his Former CFO and COO role
Slide 12: Committed to Strong Corporate Governance and Shareholder Stewardship
COMMITTED TO STRONG CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND SHAREHOLDER STEWARDSHIP ValueVision is Committed to Strong Governance and Shareholder Accountability Subject Clinton Group’s Claim The Facts “[Clinton Group’s] Special Meeting request As Clinton Group is well aware, Clinton Group’s requests for a was reje
Slide 13: Clinton Group's Poorly Conceived & Risky "First Ninety Days"
CLINTON GROUP’S POORLY CONCEIVED & RISKY “FIRST NINETY DAYS” Clinton Group’s Poorly Conceived Ninety-Day “Plan” Lacks Substance, Demonstrates Little Strategic Insight and Fails to Account for the Risk and Damage That Could Derail the Company’s Ongoing Momentum (Clinton Group Presentation Reference –