SpartanNash — Proxy Contest (May 2022)
10 slides from SpartanNash's proxy contest presentation, May 18, 2022
Slide 1: Reinforcing the Need for New, Qualified and Independent Directors at SpartanNash
May 2022 REINFORCING THE NEED FOR NEW, QUALIFIED AND INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS AT SPARTANNASH Rebuttal to SpartanNash Company’s May 16th Investor Presentation
Slide 2: Disclaimer
DISCLAIMER The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Macellum Home Fund, LP, Ancora Holdings Group, LLC and the other participants named in this proxy solicitation (collectively, the “Investor Group”) and are based on publicly available information with respect to Sp
Slide 3: Entrenched and Reactive Long-Tenured Directors Need to Be Replaced to Create Value
ENTRENCHED AND REACTIVE LONG-TENURED DIRECTORS NEED TO BE REPLACED TO CREATE VALUE Three long-tenured directors, Mr. Hacker, Mr. Voss and Ms. Atkins, with an average of 19 years on the Board, still serve in critical leadership roles and have overseen: • Value destroying acquisitions, including the i
Slide 4: SpartanNash's Entrenched Board Continues to Try to Mislead Shareholders
SPARTANNASH’S ENTRENCHED BOARD CONTINUES TO TRY TO MISLEAD SHAREHOLDERS ➢ SpartanNash’s May 16th investor presentation is littered with false and misleading statements. In the presentation, the Company: o Continues to point to short-term stock performance from a low starting point induced by its own
Slide 5: SpartanNash Has Misrepresented the Investor Group's Performance
SPARTANNASH HAS MISREPRESENTED THE INVESTOR GROUP’S PERFORMANCE WE HAVE A STRONG RECORD OF HELPING CREATE LONG-TERM SHAREHOLDER VALUE AT LAGGING CONSUMER COMPANIES, INCLUDING AT SPARTANNASH. SINCE OUR ENGAGEMENT, SPARTANNASH STOCK HAS OUTPERFORMED THE S&P RETAIL INDEX BY OVER 25 PERCENTAGE POINTS1 ×
Slide 6: Board Has Presided Over Underperformance vs. Relevant Food Distribution and Retail Peers
THE BOARD HAS PRESIDED OVER UNDERPERFORMANCE VS. MOST RELEVANT FOOD DISTRIBUTION AND RETAIL PEERS OVER 3- AND 5-YEAR TIME HORIZONS ➢ The Board’s most recent attempt to reshape SpartanNash’s peer groups includes adding a ‘performance peer group,’ which adds companies with lower short-term stock perfo
Slide 7: SpartanNash's Stock Has Also Underperformed During CEO Tony Sarsam's Tenure
SPARTANNASH’S STOCK HAS ALSO UNDERPERFORMED SIGNIFICANTLY DURING CEO TONY SARSAM’S TENURE TSR STARTING AT THE HIRING OF TONY SARSAM (09/14/2020 – 03/17/2022) SPTN UNFI IMKTA & WMK Average Performance Peer Group Average1 Proxy Peer Group Average 2 151% 138% 103% 106% 88% Source: Bloomberg LP. Data as
Slide 8: Our Nominees Possess the Right Skills & Experience to Help Lead the Company
CONTRARY TO THE BOARD’S CLAIMS, OUR NOMINEES POSSESS THE RIGHT SKILLS & EXPERIENCE TO HELP LEAD THE COMPANY ➢ SpartanNash falsely claims that John Fleming and Michael Lewis do not have supply chain, logistics, strategic transaction and corporate strategy expertise • John Fleming has held several exe
Slide 9: Despite Touting Its Q1 Results, They Are Well Below Performance Peers
DESPITE TOUTING ITS Q1 RESULTS, THE REALITY IS THEY ARE WELL BELOW PERFORMANCE PEERS WHO HAVE ALREADY REPORTED ➢ SpartanNash has touted its recent Q1 results, but they still trail the Company’s grocery retail performance peers1 who have reported thus far ➢ Revenues experienced a decline since pre-pa
Slide 10: SpartanNash Has Trailed Performance Peers in Revenue and EBITDA Growth
DESPITE CLAIMING STRONG HISTORICAL OPERATING PERFORMANCE, SPARTANNASH HAS TRAILED ITS PERFORMANCE PEERS IN TERMS OF REVENUE AND EBTIDA GROWTH ➢ In its latest attempt to defend its dismal share price performance, Company created a new “performance peer group” that overstates its relative TSR ➢ The Bo