Synacor Inc

Synacor — Proxy Contest (April 2015)

29 slides from Synacor's proxy contest presentation, Apr 6, 2015

  1. Slide 1: Enhancing Stockholder Value at Synacor, Inc.

    Concerned Stockholders of Synacor April, 2015 Enhancing Stockholder Value at Synacor, Inc. 1 R ATIO C APITAL M ANAGEMENT

  2. Slide 2: Disclaimer

    Disclaimer 2 This presentation is for discussion and general informational purposes only. It does not have regard to the specific investment objective, financial situation, suitability, or the particular need of any specific person who may receive this presentation , and should not be taken as advic

  3. Slide 3: Table of Contents

    • Why we each invested in Synacor • What happened after we invested in Synacor Why we Invested in Synacor Reasons Change Is Warranted Our Platform & Nominees • Poor stock performance • Poor business performance • Track record of poor acquisitions and poor capital allocation decisions • Poor corporat

  4. Slide 4: Why we invested in Synacor

    Why we invested in Synacor 4

  5. Slide 5: Why we invested in Synacor (1)

    Why we invested in Synacor (1) 5 2012 2013 2014 o JEC and Ratio each have independently followed Synacor since 2012 as we each have other investments (past and present) that provide industry insight, experience, and perspective. o After the operating results worsened and the share price declined dra

  6. Slide 6: Why we invested in Synacor (2)

    Why we invested in Synacor (2) 6 o In October of 2013, JEC made its initial investment in Synacor. JEC bought and owns approximately 4.8% of the outstanding common stock of Synacor. In February of 2014, Ratio made its initial investment in Synacor. Ratio bought and owns approximately 4.8% of the out

  7. Slide 7: What happened after we invested in Synacor

    What happened after we invested in Synacor 7 After making our investments and throughout 2014, in our view things went from bad TO WORSE at Synacor, including: - Poor stock price performance REPEATED INSIDER SELLING - Declining revenue, operating losses, and declining cash balance A GREATER THAN 10%

  8. Slide 8: Reasons Change is Warranted

    Reasons Change is Warranted 8

  9. Slide 9: 1. Poor Stock Performance

    1. Poor Stock Performance 9

  10. Slide 10: Synacor Stock (1)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor Stock (1) 10 2012 2013 2014 o On January 30, 2012, Synacor filed an amended registration statement indicating it expected to price its IPO between $10.00 and $12.00 per share. o In February, 2012 Synacor went public and its shares were priced at $5.00 per share. o

  11. Slide 11: Synacor Stock (2)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor Stock (2) 11 The stock price performance demonstrates, in our view, that the Board of Directors has been unable to produce stockholder value. In fact, the Board has destroyed stockholder value while underperforming its peer group and benchmarks by a very wide marg

  12. Slide 12: 2. Poor Business Performance

    2. Poor Business Performance 12

  13. Slide 13: Synacor's Business (1)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor’s Business (1) 13 Synacor is in a market segment that has rapidly changed and experienced significant opportunity and organic growth the past few years. Synacor’s revenue has declined since 2012. It is expected to continue to decline in 2015. Synacor has also been

  14. Slide 14: Synacor's Business (2)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor’s Business (2) 14 Synacor’s core business (approximately 80% of revenue) is start pages and search and display advertising revenue. We believe the Board failed to anticipate and then failed to address the following shifts effecting 80% of its revenue. As a result,

  15. Slide 15: Synacor's Business (3)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor’s Business (3) 15 Synacor is a product company. Its core business (≈80% of reported revenue) has been declining in revenue and recently lost a large customer. In our view, that means: 1. Synacor’s Product is not compelling to its customers ▪ Microsoft: Moved Synac

  16. Slide 16: Synacor's Business (4)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor’s Business (4) 16 2012 2013 2014 Search & Display 101,559$ 90,447$ 83,906$ Subscription 20,422 21,360 22,673 Total Revenue 121,981$ 111,807$ 106,579$ Net Income (Loss) 3,815 (1,367) (12,931) Cash and Cash Equivalents 41,944 36,397 25,600 Source: Synacor 2014 Form

  17. Slide 17: Synacor's Business (5)

    Years of Poor Performance – Synacor’s Business (5) 17 $, In millions Change, Year over Year Annual Expense Level (1) (1) After we pointed out the cumulative ‘research and development’ expense from 2012 through 2014 would exceed $100 million, whic h is more than twice the enterprise value, the Compan

  18. Slide 18: 3. Track Record of Poor Acquisitions and Poor Capital Allocation Decisions

    3. Track Record of Poor Acquisitions and Poor Capital Allocation Decisions 18

  19. Slide 19: Acquisitions / Capital Allocation

    Years of Poor Performance – Acquisitions / Capital Allocation 19 No mobile compatible product until Q4 2014 DESPITE the following acquisitions: ▪ May 2012: Carbyn , an HTML5 platform that delivers apps across Net - connected devices including smartphones, tablets, laptops and connected TVs. ▪ Novemb

  20. Slide 20: 4. Poor Corporate Governance

    4. Poor Corporate Governance 20

  21. Slide 21: Corporate Governance (1)

    Years of Poor Performance – Corporate Governance (1) 21 5 of the current 7 Directors were Board members at the time of the IPO. It is likely or at least possible these directors influenced and/or determined the corporate governance policies for Synacor. Many of these practices are not best practices

  22. Slide 22: Corporate Governance (2)

    Years of Poor Performance – Corporate Governance (2) 22 Shareholders have taken notice, 2014 Annual Shareholder Meeting: The two directors ‘elected’ each received only 45% VOTES FOR.

  23. Slide 23: Corporate Governance (3)

    Years of Poor Performance – Corporate Governance (3) 23 Mr. Levy and Mr. Kau have combined to serve over 27 years on this Board. Mr. Kau is employed by a significant shareholder of Synacor – a venture capital firm that sold a company to Synacor in 2000. Given their long standing Board participation

  24. Slide 24: Our Platform & Nominees

    Our Platform & Nominees 24

  25. Slide 25: Our Platform – Now is the time for change (1)

    Our Platform – Now is the time for change (1) 25 ▪ The current Synacor directors have overseen Synacor’s poor performance. ▪ Two of three incumbents up for election at this meeting, including the Chairman of the Board, are the longest tenured directors ▪ Other incumbent is first year CEO. He is also

  26. Slide 26: Our Platform – Now is the time for change (2)

    Our Platform – Now is the time for change (2) 26 1. Recover, then create and maximize stockholder value over the optimum time horizon. ▪ The current directors have destroyed millions in stockholder value. 2. Reassess Strategy ▪ Synacor’s products are not compelling, as evidenced by declining revenue

  27. Slide 27: Our nominees are ready to create value (1)

    Our Platform – Our nominees are ready to create value (1) 27 Jeff Misthal ▪ Mr. Misthal has significant expertise and business experience in the media and telecommunications industry in which Synacor operates. ▪ Specifically, Mr. Misthal brings a ‘ competitor perspective ’ to the Board having spent

  28. Slide 28: Our nominees are ready to create value (2)

    Our Platform – Our nominees are ready to create value (2) 28 Nominee Telecom and Media Operations Telecom CapEx and Ecosystem Cross Platform Product Development and Management Search, Advertising, an d Video M+A Legal and Contracts Jeff Misthal Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Dilip Singh Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

  29. Slide 29: Our nominees are ready to create value (3)

    Our Platform – Our nominees are ready to create value (3) 29 The current Board of Synacor has failed to create value for stockholders. Incumbent directors Mr. Levy and Mr. Kau have served a combined 27 years on the Board – and stockholders have lost over 50% of their value since the IPO in 2012. The

Synacor — Proxy Contest (April 2015) on 6ix