Consolidated Communications — Proxy Contest (January 2024)
34 slides from Consolidated Communications's proxy contest presentation, Jan 11, 2024
Slide 1: Transaction with Searchlight is the Best Strategic Alternative Available to Shareholders
Transaction with Searchlight is the Best Strategic Alternative Available to Shareholders Consolidated Communications Holdings, Inc. January 10, 2024
Slide 2: Legal Disclosure: Forward-Looking Statements
2 Legal Disclosure Forward-Looking Statements Certain statements in this communication are forward-looking statements and are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements reflect, among other things, the Company
Slide 3: Executive Summary
3 Executive Summary Transaction Offers a Compelling Valuation, and Shifts Execution, Liquidity and Market Risk to Buyers 1 ✓ All-cash offer at a 70% premium to unaffected1 price is significantly higher than public and take-private precedent transactions, and exceeds analysts’ price targets ✓ Implied
Slide 4: Transaction Offers a Compelling Valuation, and Shifts Execution, Liquidity and Market Risk to Buyers
4 Transaction Offers a Compelling Valuation, and Shifts Execution, Liquidity and Market Risk to Buyers
Slide 5: Transaction Offers Shareholders a Compelling and De-Risked Valuation
(80%) (60%) (40%) (20%) - 20% 40% Apr-22 Oct-23 5 Sources: FactSet (as of October 13, 2023), company filings Notes: 1. Peers include Frontier Communications Parent, Inc., Lumen Technologies, Inc., Cable One, Inc., Shenandoah Telecommunications Company, ATN International, Inc., WideOpenWest, Inc., Al
Slide 6: Special Committee Won a 70% Price Premium Even As Peers Were Falling
(22%) (Unaffected2 ) +13% (26%) +16% (62%) (30%) (Unaffected3 ) 6 Special Committee Won a 70% Price Premium Even As Peers Were Falling Share Price Returns1 since Special Committee Process Began (April 12, 2023 – December 29, 2023) Sources: FactSet (as of December 29, 2023, December 8, 2023 and Octob
Slide 7: Premium is Meaningfully Higher than Precedent Transactions
34% 51% 63% 80% 25th percentile Median Mean 75th percentile 21% 32% 45% 53% 25th percentile Median Mean 75th percentile 7 Premium is Meaningfully Higher than Precedent Transactions Sources: company filings, Refinitiv, FactSet (as of October 13, 2023) Notes: 1. Includes all-cash going-private transac
Slide 8: Multiple is Higher than Any Relevant Public LEC Precedent in a Decade
9.6x 5.5x 5.0x 7.6x 6.4x 5.0x 6.1x 9.4x 6.0x 7.3x 6.7x 4.8x Target Acquiror EV ($bn) $3.1 $7.5 $0.3 $3.1 $0.2 $1.4 $0.7 $0.9 $1.6 $0.3 $10.5 $2.0 Date Oct-23 Aug-21 Jan-21 Mar-20 Dec-19 May-19 Jul-17 Feb-17 Dec-16 Jun-14 Jan-14 Dec-13 8 …While Multiple is Higher than Any Relevant Public LEC Preceden
Slide 9: Comparison to Frontier Demonstrates How Compelling This Offer is
14% (1%) (60%) (40%) (20%) - 20% 40% Dec-22 Feb-23 Apr-23 Jun-23 Aug-23 Oct-23 Dec-23 2 2024E EBITDA $354 (x) Multiple 6.4x Implied EV $2,250 (-) Net Debt (1,922) (-) Other Adjustments (592) Implied Eq. Value ($264) Implied CNSL Equity Value Assuming CNSL Trades at 6.4x EV / '24E EBITDA ($m) 6.4x FY
Slide 10: Review of Alternatives: Execute on Standalone Plan
10 Special Committee Conducted an Exhaustive Review of Alternatives Conclusion: Standalone Plan has Significantly More Downside Risk than Upside Execute on Standalone Plan ▪ Requires a further delay of build, as necessary, to preserve capital / re-accelerate build when financing markets improve and/
Slide 11: Review of Alternatives: No Third-party Alternative is Available or Viable
11 Special Committee Conducted an Exhaustive Review of Alternatives Conclusion: No Third-party Alternative is Available or Viable Sell to Another Financial Buyer ▪ Potentially facilitates greater valuation so long as the Company is able to find a buyer willing to write a bigger equity check and the
Slide 12: Review of Alternatives: Sale of Entire Company is Most Compelling
12 Special Committee Conducted an Exhaustive Review of Alternatives Conclusion: Sale of Entire Company is Most Compelling Strategy Involving Searchlight Sell Entire Company to Searchlight / BCI ▪ All-cash proposal at a significant premium ▪ Transfers all execution, liquidity and financing risk to bu
Slide 13: Thorough Process Delivered the Highest Value Available
$2.76 $4.00 $4.20 $4.35 $4.50 $4.55 $4.65 $4.70 $6.00 $5.25 $5.05 $4.80 $4.70 April 12, 2023 Initial Offer Revised offer #1 SC Counteroffer #1 Revised offer #2 SC Counteroffer #2 Revised offer #3 SC Counteroffer #3 Revised offer #4 SC Counteroffer #4 Revised offer #5 SC Counteroffer #5 Agreed Price
Slide 14: Third-Party Analysts Endorse Both the Valuation and the Sale Strategy
Prior to April Offer Price Target $4.50 $2.50 $4.00 Mar 1, 2023 Mar 1, 2023 Mar 1, 2023 Methodology DCF1 DCF2 / OIBDA2 DCF Transaction Premium3 +4% +88% +18% After April Offer Announced Price Target $4.50 $3.50 $4.00 Apr 13, 2023 Apr 13, 2023 Apr 13, 2023 Methodology DCF1 Offer4 / Other4 DCF Transac
Slide 15: Standalone Plan Carries More Downside Risk than Upside
15 Standalone Plan Carries More Downside Risk than Upside
Slide 16: Significant Investment Required to Reposition Residential and Commercial Businesses
Significant Investment Required to Reposition and Transition Both the Residential and Commercial Businesses to Return to Growth 16 Maintaining Competitiveness Requires a Complex Technology Transformation Residential / Consumer Commercial / Carrier 2023E Revenue1 / 3-year Historical CAGR ~$450m ’20 –
Slide 17: CapEx and EBITDA Underperformance Has Led to Higher Leverage
4.0x 4.5x 3.9x 4.2x 4.8x 5.5x 5.7x 6.2x 1Q22 2Q22 3Q22 4Q22 1Q23 2Q23 3Q23 4Q23 17 CapEx and EBITDA Underperformance Has Led to Higher Leverage ▪ Consolidated has spent a significant amount of capital on fiber investments but has not generated sufficient EBITDA ̶ 10 consecutive quarters of EBITDA de
Slide 18: Resulting in Significant Near-Term Liquidity Constraints
$630 $231 $89 $11 $26 2022A 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E 18 …Resulting in Significant Near-Term Liquidity Constraints ▪ The Company expects to operate with a narrow cash balance and limited liquidity through 2026 and beyond, fully utilizing its available cash balance and drawing on its revolver to fund i
Slide 19: Liquidity Preservation Mode Forced Revision of Build Plan
Liquidity Incremental Fiber Passings 19 …Which Forced the Business into Liquidity Preservation Mode Sources: August Standalone Plan, Illustrative Buyer Plan (Including Pre-Closing Capital) Note: 1. Reflects Illustrative Buyer Plan (Including Pre-Closing Capital) Illustrative Buyer Plan1 August Stand
Slide 20: Irreversible Delays in Fiber Build Plan
403 222 75 45 60 Historical average: 300k+ HP per year 2022A 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.4 1.5 1.7 1.9 0.3 0.6 1.0 1.3 1.5 1.7 1.9 1.9 1.9 1.9 2020A 2021A 2022A 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E 2027E 2028E 2029E 20 …And Resulted in Irreversible Delays in Fiber Build Plan Sources: August Standalone
Slide 21: Long-Term Viability at Risk in a Highly Competitive Market
21 … Putting Long-Term Viability at Risk in a Highly Competitive Market Announced Network Upgrades Underscore Strategic Urgency of Build Plan Competitive Risks for Consolidated ▪ Broadband sector evolving into a “three-player” market in many parts of the country ̶ Fiber-equivalent speeds required to
Slide 22: Declining Legacy Business Underscores Urgency of Transformation
$597 $589 $576 $542 $532 $516 2019A 2020A 2021A 2022A 2023E 2024E Chart Title $208 $212 $209 $185 $161 $140 2019A 2020A 2021A 2022A 2023E 2024E Chart Title $181 $171 $161 $143 $127 $120 2019A 2020A 2021A 2022A 2023E 2024E Chart Title Legacy Consumer DSL Business Quickly Unwinding ($m) 22 Declining L
Slide 23: Challenges Fiber Conversion Continues to Face
13% 20% 14% 24% 1-year Mark Q3 22 Cohort 2-year Mark Q3 21 Cohort Chart Title 23 …Exacerbated by Challenges Fiber Conversion Continues to Face Source: August Standalone Plan Notes: 1. Cohort ready for sale (RFS) excludes certain multi-dwelling units (MDU’s) and multi-tenant units (MTU’s). In aggrega
Slide 24: Optimistic Strategic Plan with Little Margin for Error
$132 $10 $2 $36 $128 33% 3% 1% 8% 24% 2022A 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E 24 The Result is an Optimistic Strategic Plan with Little Margin for Error Source: August Standalone Plan Note: 1. Illustrative EBITDA miss in respective period that would breach springing leverage covenant on revolver and immediate
Slide 25: Standalone Strategy Has Significant Downside Risk
40% 36% 50% 50.5% 32% 45% 25 Standalone Strategy Has Significant Downside Risk Sources: August Standalone Plan, FactSet (as of December 29, 2023), Wall Street research Notes: 1. Based on range of 2023E EBITDA margin estimates of Wall Street research analysts; includes Shenandoah Telecommunications C
Slide 26: Following Wildcat's Lead Would Be Disastrous For Shareholders
26 Following Wildcat’s Lead Would Be Disastrous For Shareholders
Slide 27: Wildcat's Unrealistic Demand for $14.00 Per Share
27 ▪ Wildcat’s wildly unrealistic demand for $14.00/share is, in reality, a demand for a 407% premium over the unaffected stock price ̶ Wildcat’s implied calculation of $10.70 suffers from the same fatal errors and represents a similarly unrealistic estimate of risk-adjusted value ▪ Wildcat’s call t
Slide 28: Wildcat Cherry Picks Data Points to Misdirect Shareholders
28 Sources: Wildcat Capital public statement, FactSet (as of December 29, 2023), company filings Notes: 1. Assumes balance sheet as of June 30, 2023 as per CNSL Management; FDSO of 118.5m as of October 11, 2023 per CNSL Management 2. Unaffected date is April 12, 2023, the last trading day prior to p
Slide 29: Wildcat's Analysis of Build Cost Financing is Misinformed
Wildcat’s Misleading Claims Sources: Wildcat Capital public statement, company filings 29 Wildcat’s Analysis of Build Cost Financing is Misinformed What the Facts Show CNSL does not have any material cash remaining, forcing it to trade fiber development priorities against funding constraints in a re
Slide 30: Wildcat Misleadingly Compares a Mature Frontier Market to CNSL's Network
30 Sources: Wildcat Capital public statement, company filings, Fitch Note: 1. Fiber Gig+ Capable (on fiber passings) consumer broadband penetration % as of Q3 2023 2. Per August Standalone Plan Wildcat Misleadingly Compares a Specific, Mature Market in Frontier’s Network to CNSL’s Entire Network Wha
Slide 31: Shareholders Should Vote to Approve the Sale to Searchlight
31 Shareholders Should Vote to Approve the Sale to Searchlight ✓The offer is compelling: o All-cash consideration at a 70% premium to the unaffected price o Significantly higher than public and take-private precedent transactions o Exceeds analysts’ price targets prior to unaffected date ✓The proces
Slide 32: Appendix
Appendix Consolidated’ communications 32 e
Slide 33: Special Committee has Extensive Sector Knowledge and M&A Experience
33 Special Committee has Extensive Sector Knowledge and M&A Experience Robert J. Currey Chairman, Independent Director ▪ Former Director, CEO and President of Consolidated Communications ▪ Former Vice Chairman of RCN Corporation ▪ Former President and CEO of 21st Century Telecom Group ▪ Former Direc
Slide 34: Several Key Factors Constrain Consolidated's Strategic Flexibility
34 Several Key Factors Constrain Consolidated’s Strategic Flexibility ▪ Searchlight has certain consent rights over debt incurrence and equity issuances; the Special Committee, when considering the alternatives, believed that Searchlight would be unlikely to approve investments (such as a capital ra
Consolidated Communications Holdings — Proxy Contest (January 2024) on 6ix