Guess? — Proxy Contest (March 2022)
54 slides from Guess?'s proxy contest presentation, Mar 31, 2022
Slide 1: Addressing The Marciano Discount
Guess?, Inc. (NYSE: GES) Addressing The Marciano Discount www.ABetterGuess.com March 2022
Slide 2: Table of Contents
Section Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Deeply Troubling Sexual Harassment Allegations 20 3 The Board’s Failure to Act 28 4 Excessive Related Party Transactions with Marcianos 37 5 The Company’s Troubling Engagement 45 6 Conclusion 51 FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 1/29/
Slide 3: Legion Partners
Section Legion Partners 1 Strategic Stock Selection $509 • High-quality businesses trading at a significant discount relative to their intrinsic value million1 Assets under • Small-cap companies which offer the greatest upside potential management • Concentrated, high-conviction portfolio based on r
Slide 4: Business Overview
Section Business Overview 1 Guess (GES) is an apparel and accessories brand and retailer ▪ Directly operates 1,068 stores across ~100 countries and has 563 additional retail stores worldwide run by partners 1 o Brand image viewed as fashionable and sexy o 3 distribution channels: direct-to-consumer
Slide 5: Marciano Brothers Pose a Significant Risk to Guess' Brand, Reputation and Valuation
We Believe The Marciano Brothers Pose a Significant Section 1 Risk to Guess’ Brand, Reputation and Valuation At least 17 women have accused Paul Marciano of sexual harassment and/or assault Continuous Settlement Payments and Significant Risk to Brand and Litigation Fees Shareholder Value Settlements
Slide 6: We Believe There Is a Marciano Discount
Section We Believe There Is a Marciano Discount 1 GES seems to experience a persistent valuation discount vs. peers ▪ GES’ TEV / EBITDA valuation gap vs. peers widened after Lindsey Ring’s allegation in 2009 ▪ While it briefly narrowed after GES launched an investigation into allegations of improper
Slide 7: Paul Marciano's Sexual Abuse Allegations Have Long Been Public and the Board Likely Has Been Aware
Paul Marciano’s Sexual Abuse Allegations Have Long Section Been Public and the Board Likely Has Been Aware 1 7 Source: Media Reports CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 8: Board Continues to Keep Paul Marciano in Leadership Positions Despite Repeated Request for His Removal
Board Continues to Keep Paul Marciano in Leadership Section Positions Despite Repeated Request for His Removal 1 “My allegations are not the first. I strongly fear that if Paul Marciano is not stopped now and removed from Guess that he will only continue to abuse his place of power to sexually haras
Slide 9: This campaign is about improving shareholder value by driving accountability
This campaign is about improving shareholder value by driving accountability and removing the existential risk to Guess' brand we believe is posed by the continued involvement of Paul and Maurice Marciano It is time for #ABetterGuess CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 10: Why Are We Running This Campaign?
Section Why Are We Running This Campaign? 1 Multiple Allegations of The Board Seems to Have Been Sexual Assault & Time for Action Unable to Take Action Harassment ▪ Paul Marciano has been the ▪ The Board has been aware of long list of ▪ We believe the removal of the subject of multiple allegations a
Slide 11: We Suspect the Total Number of Claims Against Paul Marciano Exceeds 17
We Suspect the Total Number of Claims Against Paul Section Marciano Exceeds 17 1 We question how many confidential settlements have been made over time We are aware of 17 separate allegations over the past 40 But multiple questions remain: years and $920k of settlements since 2018 ? How many complai
Slide 12: Paul Marciano's Alleged Victims Have Been Profoundly Impacted
Section Paul Marciano’s Alleged Victims Have Been Profoundly Impacted 1 “I experience flashbacks, panic attacks, nightmares, debilitating depression Amanda Rodriguez and suicidal thoughts…I call on Guess to do the right thing and to finally listen Former GES model to the women that are telling them
Slide 13: Models Hesitate to Model for Guess
Section Models Hesitate to Model for Guess 1 GES seems to have a bad reputation in the industry as a result of Paul Marciano’s alleged sexual misconduct, which appears to have resulted in reduced access to potential talent 13 Source: The Daily Beast (1/22/2021) CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 14: Consumer Attitude Towards a Brand Is Damaged by Allegations Against Its Founder
Consumer Attitude Towards a Brand Is Damaged by Sexual Section Assault/Harassment Allegations Against Its Founder 1 What do Guess consumers think? How would sexual assault/harassment accusations against Are you aware that several former Guess models its founder impact... are suing a Guess founder fo
Slide 15: Investigations Have Left Us Guessing
Section Investigations Have Left Us Guessing 1 2018 Allegations 2021 Allegations Allegations Sexual assault including oral rape, rape, Against Paul Sexual assault and harassment as well as sexual harassment Marciano Committee Formation – More than 13 months later Formed to Formation – 3 months later
Slide 16: GES Shares Have Materially Underperformed
Section GES Shares Have Materially Underperformed 1 The Company’s Total Shareholder Returns (TSR) have been disappointing and have persistently lagged its peers and relevant indices over a variety of time frames GES Relative TSR vs. Peer Groups and Major Benchmarks Pre-COVID to GES vs. Present 1 Yea
Slide 17: GES Peer Sets and Indices
Section GES Peer Sets and Indices 1 Legion primarily utilizes a peer set that includes apparel brands and retailers for benchmarking, and uses ISS peers as well as GES’s self-selected indices for TSR comparison Peers ISS Peers Company Selected Indices 1. COLM 6. HBI 11. AEO 1. CAL 11. ANF 18. DECK S
Slide 18: A GES Director Who Receives More Withheld Votes Than For Votes Shall Submit a Letter of Resignation
A GES Director Who Receives More “Withheld” Votes Than Section “For” Votes Shall Submit a Letter of Resignation 1 GES has a plurality voting standard for uncontested director elections ▪ Since Legion is not proposing an alternate slate of directors, the election is considered to be uncontested despi
Slide 19: Time for #ABetterGuess
Section Time for #ABetterGuess 1 We urge fellow stockholders to vote the BLUE proxy card to vote WITHHOLD against Paul Marciano and Maurice Marciano ▪ We believe a Board absent the Marcianos’ influence should be able to: ✓ Reinvigorate Guess' brand and reputation, which should improve the Company's
Slide 20: Table of Contents
Section Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Deeply Troubling Sexual Harassment Allegations 20 3 The Board’s Failure to Act 28 4 Excessive Related Party Transactions with Marcianos 37 5 The Company’s Troubling Engagement 45 6 Conclusion 51 FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 1/29/
Slide 21: Setting the Stage
Section Setting the Stage 2 Guess has a brand identity associated with a young, sexy and adventurous lifestyle and is known for its fashion campaigns – becoming a “Guess Girl” is the dream for many young aspiring models who are vulnerable targets WWD Interview: “I like to meet the models, but even m
Slide 22: Paul Marciano Seems to Have Exploited His Senior Executive Role at Guess
Paul Marciano Seems to Have Exploited His Section Senior Executive Role at Guess 2 Public allegations suggest Paul Marciano appears to be using his position as the Guess Chief Creative Officer to scout young models and take advantage of them – he has been named in a number of claims of sexual assaul
Slide 23: Paul Marciano Has Faced Almost No Meaningful Repercussions Over the Years
Paul Marciano Has Faced Almost No Meaningful Section Repercussions Over the Years 2 Paul Marciano’s alleged misconduct began as early as the 1980s according to public reports, while the GES Board didn’t take any apparent action until 2018 – despite Paul announcing plans to retire from management by
Slide 24: Company's Own Insurance Carrier Filed a Complaint Related to Paul Marciano's Wrongful Acts
Company’s Own Insurance Carrier Filed a Complaint Section 2 Related to Paul Marciano’s “Wrongful Acts” GES and Paul Marciano’s insurer is distancing from him and the Company amid sexual misconduct claims, citing multiple “interrelated wrongful acts” by Paul Marciano Dec 2021 Complaint: “Beazley seek
Slide 25: Maurice Marciano's Time on The Board Must Come to an End
It Is Also Imperative That Paul Marciano’s Brother Section Maurice’s Time on The Board Come to an End 2 We have heard reports of Maurice dismissing Paul’s sexually predatory behavior for years – Maurice was also Chairman of the Board when the Board reinstated Paul in January 2019 “That’s Just Paul”
Slide 26: Maurice Marciano's Pattern of Missing Board Meetings
Maurice Marciano's Pattern of Missing Board Meetings Is Section 2 Another Strong Reason For His Removal In August 2020, GES announced Maurice Marciano’s injury in a bicycle accident – since then, Maurice has missed Board meetings and the 2021 annual meeting, casting serious doubt on his ability to p
Slide 27: Maurice Marciano Has Held Key Board Positions During Multiple Allegations
Maurice Marciano Has Held Key Board Positions During Section Multiple Allegations and Board Investigations 2 Maurice Marciano’s Positions: Chairman Executive Chairman Emeritus & Non-Executive Director & CEO Chairman Director Chairman Celebrity model Kate Upton Beazley, Guess claimed verbal and Marci
Slide 28: Table of Contents
Section Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Deeply Troubling Sexual Harassment Allegations 20 3 The Board’s Failure to Act 28 4 Excessive Related Party Transactions with Marcianos 37 5 The Company’s Troubling Engagement 45 6 Conclusion 51 FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 1/29/
Slide 29: The Cumulative Alleged Victim Count Continues to Grow
Section The Cumulative Alleged Victim Count Continues to Grow 3 Year Made Cumulative Number of Year of Incident Public Accuser Key Allegations Allegations 1983 2021 Eileen Toal Sexual assault 1 Sexual harassment, assault, 1990-1994 1994 3 Individuals 4 and retaliation Early 2000s 2022 2 individuals
Slide 30: The Board Has Not Effectively Addressed the Issue
Section The Board Has Not Effectively Addressed the Issue 3 After an investigation by the Guess Board (with the assistance of an outside counsel, Glaser Weil, LLP) that reviewed 1.5mm pages of documents and interviewed 40+ people in 2018, Paul resigned as Executive Chairman and was supposed to leave
Slide 31: The Board Has Not Effectively Addressed the Issue (Con't)
Section The Board Has Not Effectively Addressed the Issue (Con’t) 3 Despite the attempt to bury Paul Marciano’s reinstatement announcement, the market reacted quickly and loudly: GES share price dropped by 15% and market valuation plummeted by $265m in one day following the news “Davia Temin, whose
Slide 32: The Board Seems to Have Ignored Harassment Allegations
Section The Board Seems to Have Ignored Harassment Allegations 3 No apparent “disciplinary” actions have been taken against Paul Marciano since the GES Code of Ethics (CoE) approved by the Board took effect in July 2018 Excerpt of the GES CoE Amended July 2018: ▪ GES did not amend Paul Marciano’s em
Slide 33: The Guess Board's Response
Section The Guess Board’s Response 3 Situation: At least 17 women have alleged sexual assault and/or harassment against Paul Marciano Response: Unbelievably, Guess Board has allowed Paul Marciano to continue employment as Chief Creative Officer and a Board member receiving more compensation than CEO
Slide 34: Removing the Marcianos Should Improve Function of the Guess Board
Removing the Marcianos Should Improve Function of Section 3 the Guess Board 3 Insiders 4 Independent Directors1 Carlos Alberini Laurie Ann Goldman1 Deborah Weinswig Cynthia Livingston (Age: 66) (Age: 59) (Age: 51) (Age: 70) CEO Nom./Gov. Chair Nom./Gov. Member Nom./Gov. Member Director since 2019 Di
Slide 35: Independent Directors Have Repeatedly Let Paul Marciano off the Hook
We Believe the “Independent” Directors Have Section Repeatedly Let Paul Marciano off the Hook 3 Paul Marciano’s alleged misconduct began as early as the 1980s according to public reports, while the GES Board didn’t take any apparent action until 2018 – despite Paul announcing plans to retire by 2019
Slide 36: Independent Directors Have Abdicated Their Responsibility
We Believe the “Independent” Directors Have Section Abdicated Their Responsibility 3 Key committees have been run by current independent directors including Board Chair Yemenidjian and Nom./Gov. Chair Goldman1 – yet they all seem to turn a blind eye on sexual harassment allegations against Paul Marc
Slide 37: Table of Contents
Section Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Deeply Troubling Sexual Harassment Allegations 20 3 The Board’s Failure to Act 28 4 Excessive Related Party Transactions with Marcianos 37 5 The Company’s Troubling Engagement 45 6 Conclusion 51 FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 1/29/
Slide 38: Marciano Brothers Have Exploited the Company for Their Personal Benefit
We Believe the Marciano Brothers Have Exploited the Section 4 Company for Their Personal Benefit The Marciano Brothers1 were paid $97m over past decade There are substantial family connections in the executive suite Paul Marciano (Age: 70) Brother Maurice Marciano (Age: 73) Co-Founder, Chief Creativ
Slide 39: Real Estate Lease Payments to Marciano Entities
Section Real Estate Lease Payments to Marciano Entities 4 GES has leased warehouse and administrative facilities, including its headquarters in Los Angeles, from partnerships affiliated with the Marciano Entities since at least 19961 Aggregate Lease Costs ($mm) $8.5 $113m and $58m lease payments to
Slide 40: Aircraft Charter Payments to Marciano Entities
Section Aircraft Charter Payments to Marciano Entities 4 GES has periodically chartered aircraft owned by the Marciano Entities through informal arrangements with the Marciano Entities and independent third-party management companies since 20041 Aircraft Arrangement Fees ($mm) $21m and $14m aircraft
Slide 41: Substantial Family Connections in the Executive Suite
Section Substantial Family Connections in the Executive Suite 4 GES has rewarded more than $97m in compensation to the Marcianos over the past decade Paul Marciano (Age: 70) Brothers Maurice Marciano (Age: 73) Co-Founder, Chief Creative Officer and Founder and Director, Former Director, Former Chair
Slide 42: Paul Marciano's Alleged Behavior Is Abysmal and His Compensation Is Outrageous
Paul Marciano’s Alleged Behavior Is Abysmal and His Section Compensation Is Outrageous 4 For FY 2021, Paul Marciano received a total compensation of $11.2 million or 1.3% of GES’ average market cap during FY 2021, the highest percentage among Chief Creative Officers in the apparel retail industry Ch
Slide 43: Paul Marciano's Outrageous Compensation Highlights a Lack of Board Oversight
Paul Marciano’s Outrageous Compensation Even After Section 2018 Investigation Highlights a Lack of Board Oversight 4 Compensation Committee has approved $187m in compensation for Paul Marciano including $37m post the 2018 investigation Paul Marciano Compensation ($m) Paul Marciano $17.1 announced to
Slide 44: Erroneous Healthcare Claim Payments for Marciano Entities' Employees
“Erroneous” Healthcare Claim Payments for Marciano Section Entities’ Employees for Two Decades 4 GES “erroneously” paid the medical expenses of the employees of Marciano Entities for 20 years, totaling $5.3m per the Company’s own estimates – the Marciano Brothers reimbursed GES $2.7m in 2020 Increme
Slide 45: Table of Contents
Section Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Deeply Troubling Sexual Harassment Allegations 20 3 The Board’s Failure to Act 28 4 Excessive Related Party Transactions with Marcianos 37 5 The Company’s Troubling Engagement 45 6 Conclusion 51 FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 1/29/
Slide 46: Meeting at Guess Headquarters
Section Meeting at Guess Headquarters 5 On February 22, 2022, Legion met with Chairman Alex Yemenidjian and CEO Carlos Alberini ▪ Legion expressed concern about the risk to the Company and brand from the long pattern of sexual assault/harassment allegations, and reiterated our previous public statem
Slide 47: Follow-up Letter to GES
Section Follow-up Letter to GES 5 Legion requested to meet with the Nominating and Governance Committee Guess rejected Legion’s request to meet with the Nominating and Governance Committee Source: Legion Partners 47 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
Slide 48: Proposed Settlement Offer
Section Proposed Settlement Offer 5 On March 7, 2022, Chairman Alex Yemenidjian suggested two paths for moving forward Path #1 Path #2 ▪ “Rough and Tumble” ▪ “Elegant Solution” o Significant buyback o Governance ? o ‒ ‒ Add a 9th Board member Form a new ESG committee Remove related party transaction
Slide 49: Legion's Litigation Demand and 220 Demand
Section Legion’s Litigation Demand and 220 Demand 5 GES has stated that it intends to strongly refute claims and vigorously defend Paul Marciano, seemingly frontrunning any investigation effort Legion issued a press release and Legion sent a formal Legion sent to the presentation litigation demand t
Slide 50: GES Has Experienced Significant Board and Management Turnover Following Allegations
GES Has Experienced Significant Board and Section Management Turnover Following Allegations 5 Four Directors (including last two Chairs of Nom./Gov. Committee) and the highest profile female executive have all left GES During the Past Month Laurie Ann Goldman, Chair of Nom./Gov. Committee, Joseph Gr
Slide 51: Table of Contents
Section Table of Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Deeply Troubling Sexual Harassment Allegations 20 3 The Board’s Failure to Act 28 4 Excessive Related Party Transactions with Marcianos 37 5 The Company’s Troubling Engagement 45 6 Conclusion 51 FY refers to fiscal year (FY 22 is the year ended 1/29/
Slide 52: Time for #ABetterGuess
Section Time for #ABetterGuess 6 We urge fellow stockholders to vote the BLUE proxy card to vote WITHHOLD against Paul Marciano and Maurice Marciano ▪ We believe a Board absent the Marcianos’ influence should be able to: ✓ Reinvigorate Guess' brand and reputation, which should improve the Company's
Slide 53: Disclaimer – Important Information
Section Disclaimer – Important Information THIS PRESENTATION IS FOR DISCUSSION AND INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. THE VIEWS EXPRESSED HEREIN REPRESENT THE OPINIONS OF LEGION PARTNERS ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLC AND ITS AFFILIATES (COLLECTIVELY, “LEGION PARTNERS”) AS OF THE DATE HEREOF. LEGION PARTNERS RESER
Slide 54: CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY