ALTERRA CAPITAL HOLDINGS Ltd

ALTERRA CAPITAL — Max Capital Group — Merger or Acquisition (May 2009)

22 slides from ALTERRA CAPITAL's merger presentation, May 12, 2009

  1. Slide 1: Max Specialty Insurance Company

    Exhibit 99.2 Max May A member Specialty 11, 2009 of the Insurance Max Capital Company Group BERMUD AIRELAND UNITED STATES LLOYD’S

  2. Slide 2: Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-Looking Statements

    CAUTIONARY constitute and “Risk such Form revise plans terms statements, of events financial and/or transaction the We ADDITIONAL This connection OTHER INFORMATION request Roberts, PARTICIPANTS IPC proposed Information shareholders; 2 important proposed do uncertainties, and presentation statements.

  3. Slide 3: Max Specialty: Profitable business in property and casualty throughout the market cycle

    Nationwide Three Significant Start-up On Internal Licensed Now Use Strong Placed Target Loss Max 3 target of Specialty ratio have distinct combined third with financial sponsorship structure inin to on the 2007 product 49 excess favorable write party target; divisions: people –states contributes str

  4. Slide 4: An Important Product of Max Capital Diversification

    An Important Product Bermuda/Dublin U.S. 31% 1% 15% Max 49% 20% Marine General Total (1) 4 (1) Specialty Property Capital = 34% $1,254 $194 Max diversification 31%Max 2008 at million Casualty and 2008 million Lloyd’s Insurance at Growing GPW Lloyd's GPWallows acquired Business Bermuda/Dublin resourc

  5. Slide 5: E&S Market Overview

    E&S Market Overview

  6. Slide 6: Characteristics of the E&S Market

    Characteristics E&S Only ?insured’s Unique: High-capacity: What The Property High-hazard D&O Special Environmental Typically Distribution 6 Free majority market after is risks specific E&O toevents the unusual catastrophe use state distributed insureds does E&S offers products policy of coverages? r

  7. Slide 7: E&S Market Outperformance

    Innovative Unique Unlike ($ Total % P&C Outperformance E&S Source: 7 in millions) of industry Market Industry U.S. the policy A.M. Insurance traditional underwritng Overview Best. 6.3% has Combined forms 2002 14.4% historically enjoyed 7.2% 2003 Industry and marketplace, 7.8% strategies rates Ratio

  8. Slide 8: E&S Combined and Loss Ratios Outperform Industry

    Combined 120% 76.0% 95.4% E&S Loss 100% Total 52.4% 67.5% 25 20 15 10 5 8 0 %%(5)% 1997 20.9% P&C Ratios Outperforms sector Returns Source:100% 90% % 1999 Ratios 80% has Industry 14.7% A.M. 80% on (10)% 2001 materially consistently 70% Surplus 60% Best.the 60% Domestic 2003 P&C 2005outperformed 50%

  9. Slide 9: E&S Market Growth and Premium Share

    Net 5% 100 1974 P&C 6% 14% 1987 Source: E&S Evidenced Events Florida 9/11 2005 And 9 Premiums % most is Market DWP companies 1979 1997 Hurricane Industry 80 include: the 2004 A.M. %recently by 1984 2007 Insurance CAGR 60 Share hurricanes Best. significant Domestic Written % Katrina have 1989 40 Hurr

  10. Slide 10: Max Specialty

    Max Specialty

  11. Slide 11: Key Success Factors

    KeyManaging Experienced Disciplined Underwriting Prudent Contract Strong Formal Process 80 83 Operates Product Underwrites Compensation Structured Utilizes Provides 11 wholesale Success relationships appointment means strong use diversification binding alternatives through inunderwriting of for mana

  12. Slide 12: Experienced Management Team

    Management Executive Steve Bryan Jon Mike Buddy Phil Stephen 12 Hahn Vedell Miller Vaccaro Sanders Anckner Loderick VP Previous SVP CUO Team Western President E&S SVP 13VP, Specialty With SVP, Experience Division, Max CFO Region & Significant CAO, Bermuda COO and Division 18 Hilb, Years Director Tre

  13. Slide 13: Disciplined Underwriting Approach

    Disciplined Experienced Strong Prudent Conservative Proactively Data Monitoring, Approach Max Different Softer This Loss Combined 13 underwriting Specialty is ratio classes underwriters inuse distribution “real tested of ratio manage Underwriting of managing underwriting 56.5% underwriting complimen

  14. Slide 14: Four Underwriting Divisions Add Diversification

    Four 1% Each Underwriting Adds Max 20% Marine 6% 33% Brokerage Total 14 Specialty’s Specialty Managers unique division =diversification $194 Property Casualty divisions million teams led 2008 Diversified by40% Contract with GPW to a allow seasoned Maxsignificant resources Premium Capital Binding pro

  15. Slide 15: Brokerage Division Strategy and Profile

    Capacity—$25 Property Middle Brokerage Underwriting Attract Individual Collaborative Focus Budget Target Premiums, Average 48% 75% 72% Limit $0M $10M $15M > 45.7% 2.2% 0.0% 5.1% 7.6% 15$20M of to 10.0% Profile on to GPW net 27.3% and /market limits policies $1M premium Plan $15M $20M catastrophe non

  16. Slide 16: Brokerage Division Market Conditions

    Brokerage Apartment Largest Florida, Top AmWINS, Market -Loss Zone Non-catastrophe Seeing 16 Capacity Price Producers effected Aincreases some Conditions pricing and Occupancy State California, reductions Division bldgs, CRC, B,accounts Exposures layers, California and and exposed Swett office capac

  17. Slide 17: Contract Binding Division Strategy and Profile

    Contract Capacity Property Casualty Umbrella Underwriting Acceptable Agents “Trust Budget Target Premiums Average 90% 100% Limit $0M $1M $5M $10M $15M > 10.4% 89.6% 0.0% 17$20M of to 0.0% 25.0% Profile of to but GPW net underwrite /limits $1M $5M $10M premium limits Plan $15M $20M Binding non-catast

  18. Slide 18: Contract Binding Division Market Conditions

    Contract Largest Casualty—Florida, Top Jimcor, Market Property Casualty 18 Producers Conditions Quaker, Occupancy State Binding – New rates habitational, contractors, Exposures flat York, TAPCO, Division to on New Types down smaller Massachusetts, habitational, lessors York, Bliss (cont’d) 5%risks,

  19. Slide 19: Marine Division Strategy and Profile

    Marine Capacity—$25 Inland Ocean Non-admitted Underwriting Majority Increase classes Use Budget Target Premiums Average 57% 89% Limit $0M > 28.4% 0.0% 11.3% 19$20M of of to 10.0% Profile GPW net marine 28.7% Max Division /limits $1M premium the Plan ofcombined loss and the America GPW 20.0% of $1M (

  20. Slide 20: Marine Division Market Conditions

    Marine Leading Contractors Max Having Admitted water Top CRC, Market Overall Rate 20 Producers America increases reductions AmWINS, business Division Conditions admitted rates Classes product paper equipment, are Insurance onis are of (cont’d) flat capabilities Swett loss promotes essential Business

  21. Slide 21: Significant Increase in Premium Writes Expected

    Significant Increase Writes Continue Existing Expanding Our Opportunistic Every Renewal To Retention 21 date distribution broker E&S most penetration platform business strategy percentages the distribution Growth premium written isgeographic underwriting carefully system supports of provides Opportu

  22. Slide 22: A Diversified E&S Specialty Underwriter

    A Diversified Disciplined relationships E&S Average Specialty Max (1) (2) 22 Specialty: Specialty companies Price expertise (1) underwriting 1.54x Growth Includes/contributes Book trade HCC, that 1.75x MXGL,Value at Opportunity RLI, isastrategy 1.21x complementary premium toMultiple AGII, IPCR,Max 1

Max Capital Group — Merger or Acquisition (May 2009) on 6ix