Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — Reg A Offering (June 2016)
49 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's offering presentation, Jun 19, 2016
Slide 1: Unemployment (Fears), Precautionary Savings, and Aggregate Demand
Unemployment (Fears), Precautionary Savings, and Aggregate Demand Wouter J. Den Haan (LSE/CEPR/CFM) Pontus Rendahl (University of Cambridge/CEPR/CFM) Markus Riegler (University of Bonn/CFM) June 19, 2016
Slide 2: What we do
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI What we do Show that the interaction between 1 One friction in …nancial markets: incomplete risk sharing 2 Two frictions in labor markets: sticky nominal wages: dW/dP < 1 matching can give rise to "aggregate demand" like propagatio
Slide 3: Interaction of two frictions key
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Interaction of two frictions key Complete risk sharing =) Sticky nominal wages dampen e¤ect shocks Flexible nominal wages =) Incomplete risk sharing dampens e¤ect shocks Both shocks magnify e¤ect shocks
Slide 4: Key components behind these results
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Key components behind these results Aggregate risk UI policy implications di¤erent without aggregate risk Asset price volatility Portfolio rebalancing towards liquid/unproductive asset during recession Nonlinearities induced by sta
Slide 5: Four cases
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Four cases 1 Complete markets and ‡exible wages 2 Complete markets and sticky wages 3 Incomplete markets and ‡exible wages 4 Benchmark:Incomplete markets and sticky wages
Slide 6: Case 1: flexible wages & complete markets
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Case 1: ‡exible wages & complete markets usual matching stu¤: productivity# =) expected future productivity# =) job creation # =) employment rate # =) unemployment rate " =) expected duration unemployment "
Slide 7: Case 2: Sticky nominal wages & complete markets
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Case 2: Sticky nominal wages & complete markets productivity# =) Upward pressure on prices =) downward pressure on real wages =) nominal wage rigidity dampens shocks!
Slide 8: Case 3: Flexible nominal wages & incomplete markets
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Case 3: Flexible nominal wages & incomplete markets productivity # =) investment in job creation # =) unemployment " =) idiosyncratic risk " =) precautionary savings " =) reduction in job creation is smaller =) incomplete markets d
Slide 9: Case 4: Sticky nominal wages & incomplete markets
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Case 4: Sticky nominal wages & incomplete markets Incomplete markets: Precautionary savings " when unemp "=) precautionary demand for money "=) downward pressure on P =) W/P " (sticky W) =) job creation investment # by more not by
Slide 10: Main results
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Main results 1 Incomplete markets together with sticky wages amplify shocks, but on their own repress shocks 2 Increase in unemployment insurance from 50% to 55% =) everybody better o¤ not true in economy without aggregate risk
Slide 11: Just a little bit of empirical motivation
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Just a little bit of empirical motivation
Slide 12: Euro Area
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Euro Area A: Price level (*) 1.1 1.05 1 0.95 0.9 0.85 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 B: Price level (*) and nominal wage (+) 1.15 1.1 1.05 1 0.95 0.9 0.85 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
Slide 13: Euro Area
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI 0.85 Euro Area 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 B: Price level (*) and nominal wage (+) 1.15 1.1 1.05 1 0.95 0.9 0.85 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 C: Price level (*) and nominal unit labor cost (o) 1.1 1.05 1 0.95
Slide 14: Model: Key ingredients
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Model: Key ingredients 1 Heterogeneous households and incomplete markets 2 Nominal wages do not respond 1-for-1 with P 3 Search frictions in the labor market 4 # jobs = # …rms = # shares
Slide 15: Existing firms
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Existing …rms One-worker …rms Pro…ts are given by Dt = Pt exp (zt ) Wt ωP zt ωz Pt Wt = ω 0 z P z P Key parameter is ω P 1 Aactive …rms do not make decisions
Slide 16: Individual households
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Individual households one-worker households employed workers earn nominal wage (1 τ t ) Wt unemployed earn µ (1 τ t ) Wt & search for jobs idiosyncratic risk exogenous job loss probability, δ lower chance of getting a job in a rece
Slide 17: Individual households
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Individual households 2 00 1 1 ζ 13 1 γ Mi,t+1+j ∞ ci,t+j 1 1 6 B Pt + j C7 max Et 4 ∑ βj @@ A+χ A5 j=0 1 γ 1 ζ with respect to Pt ci,t + Jt (qi,t+1(1 δ) qi,t ) + Mi,t+1 = (1 τ t ) Wt ei,t + µ (1 τ t ) Wt (1 ei,t ) + Dt qi,t + Mi,t
Slide 18: First-order conditions
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI First-order conditions " # γ Jt ci,t+1 Dt+1 Jt+1 = βEt + (1 δ) Pt ci,t Pt+1 Pt+1 ζ γ Pt γ Mi,t ci,t = βEt c +χ Pt+1 i,t+1 Pt Marked departure from literature: Individual MRS is used in both Euler equations Inequality constraints ig
Slide 19: Equity market equilibrium
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Equity market equilibrium Z ht + ((1 δ) qi q (e , q , M ; s )) dF (e , q , M ) |{z} i2A | {z i i i t } t i i i Equity creation Equity sold Z = (q (ei , qi , Mi ; st ) (1 δ) qi ) dFt (ei , qi , Mi ) , i2A+| {z } Equity bought with A
Slide 20: Employment
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Employment Z qt = q (ei , qi , Mi ; st ) dFt (ei , qi , Mi ) i2A+ Z + q (ei , qi , Mi ; st ) dFt (ei , qi , Mi ) i2A = (1 δ ) q t 1 + ht
Slide 21: Money market equilibrium
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Money market equilibrium Equilibrium Z ( Mi M (ei , qi , Mi ; st )) dFt (ei , qi , Mi ) i2B | {z } Money sold Z = (M (ei , qi , Mi ; st ) Mi ) dFt (ei , qi , Mi ) , i2B+ | {z } Money bought Money supply, M, is constant in the bench
Slide 22: Government
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Government τ t qt Wt = (1 qt ) µ (1 τ t ) Wt (1 qt ) τt = µ qt + µ (1 qt )
Slide 23: Calibration
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Calibration ω P : range of values ωP zt ωz Pt Wt = ω 0 z P z P One-year post-displacement consumption drop is 34% (Kolsrud, Landais, Nilsson, & Spinnewijn 2015; Sweden) Expected unemployment duration 3.57 quarters
Slide 24: Model Properties
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI MODEL PROPERTIES
Slide 25: Money holdings upon displacement
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Money holdings upon displacement 0.7 Cond. on expansion 0.6 Cond. on recession 0.5 Money holdings 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Unemployment duration (quarters)
Slide 26: Money demand
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Amount invested in liquid asset 0.9 Employed in expansion 0.8 Unemployed in expansion Employed in recession 0.7 Unemployed in recession 0.6 Money demand 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 Real cash on hand
Slide 27: Business Cycles
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI BUSINESS CYCLES
Slide 28: Type of experiment considered
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Type of experiment considered productivity zt # Representative-agent version: Pt "=) dW/dP #=) nominal-wage stickyness dampens shocks
Slide 29: IRFs with sticky nominal wages
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI IRFs with sticky nominal wages #10-3 Productivity Employment 0 0.2 -1 0 -2 Log deviation Ppt. deviation -3 -0.2 -4 -0.4 -5 -0.6 Incompl. markets -6 Compl. markets -7 -0.8 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 10 20 30 40 50 Output #10-3 Real wage 0 6
Slide 30: IRFs with flexible nominal wages
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI IRFs with ‡exible nominal wages #10-3 Productivity Employment 0 0.1 -1 0 -2 -0.1 Log deviation Ppt. deviation -3 -0.2 -4 -0.3 -5 -0.4 Incompl. markets -6 -0.5 Compl. markets -7 -0.6 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 10 20 30 40 50 Output #10-3 Re
Slide 31: Unemployment Insurance
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE
Slide 32: Unemployment Insurance
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Unemployment Insurance Two unemployment insurance (UI) experiments 1 Compare economies with di¤erent replacement rates 2 Unexpectedly increase replacement rate and take into account transition Two ways to deal with e¤ect on wages 1
Slide 33: Unemployment insurance
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Unemployment insurance Mechanism emphasized in the literature Replacement rate " =) 1 Agents better insured =) savings # =) employment # 2 Through bargaining wage " =) employment # This also happens in our model too, but ...
Slide 34: Mean employment rate and higher UI
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Mean employment rate and higher UI ... there is a strong countervailing e¤ect arising from aggregate uncertainty: Replacement rate " =) 1 Asset prices less volatile =) demand equity " =) employment " 2 Employment is concave in equi
Slide 35: UI and employment
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI UI and employment ω =0.7, µ does not affect wages P 0.91 0.91 0.9 0.9 Employment level 0.89 0.89 0.88 0.88 0.87 0.87 0.86 0.86 0.85 0.85 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 0 ωP=1, µ does not affect wages
Slide 36: Switch to alternative UI policy
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Switch to alternative UI policy 1 Replacement rate increases from 0.5 to 0.55 2 Switch is unexpected 3 Switch is permanent 4 Agents take transition into account
Slide 37: Average welfare effect of change in UI
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Average welfare e¤ect of change in UI ω =0.7, µ affects wages P 1.5 1 0.5 0 −0.5 −1 −1.5 1 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 ω =1, µ affects wages P
Slide 38: Who likes/dislikes higher UI?
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Who likes/dislikes higher UI? µ=0.55, ω0 unchanged µ=0.55, ω0 increases 1.5 1.5 1 1 Welfare gain 0.5 0.5 EE UU UE EU 0 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0.5 1 1.5 2 Real cash−on−hand Real cash−on−hand
Slide 39: Concluding comments
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Concluding comments With incomplete markets and sticky nominal wages, a decline in productivity sets o¤ a self-reinforcing aggregate demand e¤ect This happens despite the fact that both incomplete markets as well as sticky nominal
Slide 40: Creation of new jobs/firms/equity
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Creation of new jobs/…rms/equity number of new …rms created: η 1 η ht = ψvt ut vacancy yield: η 1 ht vt =ψ vt ut
Slide 41: Supply of new equity
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Supply of new equity Matching function zero-pro…t condition =) η/(1 η ) ψ Jt ht = ψ ut κ Pt
Slide 42: Creation of new jobs/firms/equity
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Creation of new jobs/…rms/equity zero-pro…t condition =) vacancies as a function of Jt /Pt : η 1 vt Jt κ=ψ ut Pt supply of new equity (job/…rm creation): η/(1 η ) ψ Jt ht = ψ ut κ Pt "back to main"
Slide 43: Unemployment duration
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Unemployment duration 0.4 0.35 Cond. on expansion Cond. on recession 0.3 0.25 Frequency 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 Duration of unemployment spell (quarters)
Slide 44: Equity holdings upon displacement
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Equity holdings upon displacement 1 0.9 Cond. on expansion 0.8 Cond. on recession 0.7 Equity holdings 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 −1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Unemployment duration (quarters)
Slide 45: Portfolio choice: fraction in liquid asset
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Portfolio choice: fraction in liquid asset 1 employed in boom 0.9 unemployed in boom 0.8 employed in recession unemployed in recession share of money in portfolio 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 real cash on hand
Slide 46: Technical challenges
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Technical challenges Even rep-agent version not trivial to solve accurately non-linearity matching function matters su¢ ciently volatile employment =) volatile surplus volatile equity prices "go to accuracy graph rep-agent model" A
Slide 47: Log employment level
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Log employment level -0.08 -0.1 -0.12 2-nd order perturbation -0.14 -0.16 -0.18 -0.2 -0.22 5th-order projec tions -0.24 method -0.26 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 50 "back to main"
Slide 48: Increase in UI & transition dynamics
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Increase in UI & transition dynamics Increase in UI …rst period of recession No change in wage rule =) equity less risky =) average employment " less de‡ationary spiral =) recession less deep =) employment " Change in wage rule =)
Slide 49: Switch to higher level of unemployment benefits
Intro Empirical motivation Model Model properties Business Cycles UI Switch to higher level of unemployment bene…ts Employment 0.91 0.9 0.89 0.88 0.87 µ=0.5 0.86 µ=0.55 µ=0.55, ω0 increases 0.85 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Time (quarters)
Banque Nationale De Belgique — Reg A Offering (June 2016) on 6ix