Penn Millers — Investor Presentation (December 2009)
32 slides from Penn Millers's investor presentation, Dec 18, 2009

Slide 1: Penn Millers Holding Corporation 2009
NASDAQ Symbol: PMIC 2009 PENN MILLERS HOLDING CORPORATION

Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements
2 Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may include forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements include comments with respect to our objectives and strategies, and the results of our operations and business. By their nature, however, these forward-looking statements involve n

Slide 3: Why Invest in Penn Millers
3 Why Invest in Penn Millers The Price Invest at low percentage of book value per share - there remains an opportunity in the secondary market to purchase Penn Millers' stock at near IPO pricing level Commitment to Shareholder Value On October 27, 2009 the board of directors authorized the repurchas

Slide 4: Conversion Offering Summary
4 Conversion Offering Summary Shares Sold: 5,444,022 Price: Fixed at $10.00 per share Trading Began: October 19, 2009 on NASDAQ under PMIC Proceeds: Gross proceeds $54,440,220 Less offering expenses (est.) (3,867,369) Less ESOP loan (5,399,990) Net proceeds $45,172,861 ESOP Participation: $5.4 milli

Slide 5: Conversion Offering Summary
5 Conversion Offering Summary Transaction structure created below book value offering opportunities for investors.

Slide 6: Marketplace and Business Overview
6 Marketplace and Business Overview Douglas A. Gaudet, President and Chief Executive Officer

Slide 7: Marketplace Opportunities - Insurance Cycles
Marketplace Opportunities - Insurance Cycles

Slide 8: The Industry's Premium Cycles
8 The Industry's Premium Cycles Source: Insurance Information Institute Hard Market Soft Market Hard Market Hard Market Soft Market Soft Market

Slide 9: The Insurance Cycle - Returns on Equity
9 The Insurance Cycle - Returns on Equity The P&C Industry experiences regular cycles of significant premium increases which leads to acceptable profitability, followed by periods of low growth and low profitability: Estimated ROE without the significant hurricanes: 2004 4 Florida Hurricanes 2005 Ka

Slide 10: Penn Millers' Cycle Management
10 Penn Millers' Cycle Management Management reduced hurricane coastal exposures [---Modest growth ---] in soft market [----Significant growth ---] in hard market [---Focused growth ---] in soft market Source for Industry: Insurance Information Institute

Slide 11: Business Overview
Business Overview a

Slide 12: Why Invest in Penn Millers: Leadership
12 Why Invest in Penn Millers: Leadership Douglas A. Gaudet - President and Chief Executive Officer Penn Millers' President and Chief Executive Officer since December 2005. Worked in the insurance industry for 30 years. Experience in prior positions with other insurance companies includes the develo

Slide 13: Why Invest in Penn Millers: Leadership
13 Why Invest in Penn Millers: Leadership Kevin D. Higgins - Senior Vice President of Claims Served with Penn Millers since January 2003. Has over 27 years experience in the claims field. Prior to Penn Millers, he served in progressive claims leadership roles with Royal & SunAlliance, including as P

Slide 14: Overview of Business Segments
14 Overview of Business Segments

Slide 15: Overview of Business Segments: Agribusiness Insurance
15 Overview of Business Segments Agribusiness insurance Experience writing agribusiness insurance for over 120 years Specialty/niche market Excellent industry reputation 3rd largest writer of commercial agribusiness Specialized underwriting, loss control and claims personnel Service businesses in 33

Slide 16: Agribusiness States and Brokers
Agribusiness 16 States 33 Brokers/State 6 Number of Brokers 200 Average Size $43,000 Target customers:

Slide 17: Agribusiness Financial Highlights
17 Agribusiness Financial Highlights

Slide 18: Overview of Business Segments: Commercial Insurance
18 Overview of Business Segments Commercial Insurance Experience writing Commercial Business insurance for over 50 years Solutions(r) (Businessowners Policy) Preferred small commercial customers in select small-to-medium classes of business Target markets include retail and service, "Main Street" bu

Slide 19: Commercial Business Distribution 2009
19 Commercial Business Distribution 2009 States 8 Agents per State 32 Number of Agents 260 Retailers, including beverage stores, floor covering stores, florists, grocery stores, office equipment and supplies stores, and shopping centers Hospitality, such as restaurants and hotels Artisan contractor

Slide 20: Commercial Business Financial Highlights
20 Commercial Business Financial Highlights

Slide 21: Penn Millers - Expansion Product
21 Penn Millers - Expansion Product Introduced new PennEdge product to enable company to write customized coverages on mid-sized accounts. Expected Account Premiums Range: up to $500,000 Average Size: $20,000 Select Middle Market Niches - target markets include wholesalers, light manufacturers, prin

Slide 22: Distribution & Growth Opportunities
22 Distribution & Growth Opportunities Increase Current Agent/Broker Penetration Penn Millers penetration in agent/broker office low due to narrow focus PennEdge will allow us to write greater share of business Majority of our commercial agencies write middle market business Majority of Agribusiness

Slide 23: Overview of Penn Millers' Strategy
23 Overview of Penn Millers' Strategy Identify underwriting risks where competition is limited and products can be differentiated from existing competitors Add value through personal service to producers and insureds Policy servicing and direct bill Loss control Claims Expand geographic distribution

Slide 24: Financial Overview
Financial Overview Michael O. Banks, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Slide 25: Penn Millers Income Statement
25 25 Penn Millers Income Statement 2008: Investment market upheaval- realized losses on equity investments of $5.7 million Discontinued operations - Sold assets of two non-insurance company subsidiaries & realized losses on sales We are now focused solely on our P&C underwriting operations

Slide 26: Stop Loss Reinsurance Contract Impact
26 Stop Loss Reinsurance Contract Impact The Company maintains a whole account, accident year aggregate excess of loss (aggregate stop loss) contract that covers the 2008 and 2009 accident years. The purpose of the contract was to provide a comprehensive level of protection for our capital adequacy,

Slide 27: Penn Millers Balance Sheet
27 27 Penn Millers Balance Sheet Strong Balance Sheet Conservative investment portfolio Adequate loss reserves Backed by highly rated reinsurers Minimal debt

Slide 28: Penn Millers - Conservative Investments
28 Penn Millers - Conservative Investments In December 2008, we liquidated our entire portfolio of equity securities Our fixed maturity investment portfolio is professionally managed by a registered independent investment advisor specializing in the management of insurance company assets Conservativ

Slide 29: Penn Millers - Loss Reserves
29 Penn Millers - Loss Reserves Estimating the ultimate liability for loss reserves is an inherently uncertain process. Our reserve policy recognizes this uncertainty by maintaining reserves at a level providing for the possibility of adverse development relative to the estimation process. Starting

Slide 30: Penn Millers - Supported by Strong Reinsurers
30 Penn Millers - Supported by Strong Reinsurers Our reinsurance providers, the majority of whom are longstanding partners who understand our business, are all carefully selected with the help of our reinsurance broker, Towers Perrin. We monitor the solvency of reinsurers through regular review of t

Slide 31: Why Invest in Penn Millers
31 Why Invest in Penn Millers The Price Invest at low percentage of book value per share - there remains an opportunity in the secondary market to purchase Penn Millers' stock at near IPO pricing level Commitment to Shareholder Value On October 27, 2009 the board of directors authorized the repurcha

Slide 32: Penn Millers Holding Corporation
Penn Millers Holding Corporation NASDAQ Symbol: PMIC 2009
Source: SEC EDGAR · 8-K filed Dec 18, 2009
