ALTERRA CAPITAL HOLDINGS Ltd

ALTERRA CAPITAL — Max Capital Group — Merger or Acquisition (April 2009)

32 slides from ALTERRA CAPITAL's merger presentation, Apr 21, 2009

  1. Slide 1: Creating a World Class Specialty Insurer and Reinsurer

    Filed by Max Capital Group Ltd. pursuant to Rule 425 under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and deemed filed pursuant to Rule 14a-12 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended Subject Company: Max Capital Group Ltd. (Commission File No.: 000-33047) Creating a World Class Specialty

  2. Slide 2: Information Concerning Forward Looking Statements and Certain Other Information

    INFORMATION CONCERNING FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS AND CERTAIN OTHER INFORMATION This presentation includes statements about future economic performance, finances, expectations, plans and prospects of both IPC Holdings, Ltd. (“IPC”) and Max Capital Group Ltd. (“Max”) that constitute forward-looking s

  3. Slide 3: Max Capital Today

    Max Capital Today Global underwriter of specialty insurance and reinsurance Short-Tail 38% Multiple operating platforms - Bermuda, Dublin, United States, and Lloyd’s Diversified business profile across specialty classes of business Highly experienced management with proven track record 62% Long-Tail

  4. Slide 4: Global Reach Through Established Platforms

    Global Reach Through Established Platforms Bermuda / Dublin Bermuda / Dublin Lloyd’s U.S Specialty Insurance Reinsurance Insurance Agriculture Aviation Personal accident General liability Aviation Excess liability Financial institutions Marine Excess liability Professional liability Professional lia

  5. Slide 5: Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes

    Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes … Bermuda / Dublin Insurance Bermuda / Dublin Reinsurance 2008 GPW - $389 million 2008 GPW - $420 million Property 14% Excess Liability 32% 14% Aviation 41% Professional Liability Working layer excess business Working layer excess / quota share F

  6. Slide 6: With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd's

    … With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd’s U.S. Insurance Max at Lloyd’s 2008 GPW - $194 million 2008 GPW - £65 million (1) Accident & Marine Health 17% 20% Property 45% Treaty Fin. 18% Property 49% Institutions 31% General 19% 1% Casualty Prof. Employers' Indemnity / Public Liabil

  7. Slide 7: A Merger of Strength – Transaction Overview

    A Merger of Strength – Transaction Overview Structure Stock-for-stock merger of equals Exchange Ratio Fixed exchange ratio of 0.6429 IPC shares for each share of Max Pro Forma Ownership 58% by IPC shareholders (Fully Diluted) 42% by Max shareholders Board of Directors 12 directors in total – 6 direc

  8. Slide 8: IPC/Max Creates A World Class Specialty Company

    IPC/Max Creates A World Class Specialty Company A truly diversified, balanced global underwriting platform Strong and vibrant franchise serving both property & casualty markets Strong capital base with over $3 billion in equity and minimal leverage Greater size enhances “margin of safety” and financ

  9. Slide 9: Strong and Well-Capitalized Company

    Strong and Well-Capitalized Company 12/31/2008 Company Equity Combination provides greater size and scale 1 Everest Re $4,960 Enhances valuation multiples and ratings 2 AXIS 4,461 profile 3 PartnerRe 4,199 4 Arch Capital 3,433 Average 5 Transatlantic 3,198 3-Year 2007 2008 Current Rating (3) IPC + M

  10. Slide 10: Strong Balance Sheet and Capital Base

    Strong Balance Sheet and Capital Base As of December 31, 2008 Combined (2) ($mm) Investment Portfolio(1) $2,235.2 $5,356.9 $7,592.1 Total Assets $2,388.7 $7,252.0 $9,640.7 Loss & LAE Reserves $355.9 $4,305.1 $4,661.0 Stockholders' Equity $1,850.9 $1,280.3 $3,131.3 Corporate Debt $75.0 $241.4 $316.4

  11. Slide 11: A Truly Diversified Operating Platform

    A Truly Diversified Operating Platform IPC Holdings Max Capital Combined Insurance 35% 47% Insurance Reinsurance 53% 65% Reinsurance 100% Reinsurance Property / property cat Property / Life & annuity property cat Life & annuity 19% 20% 15% Property / 39% property cat 19% Other short-tail 32% P&C lon

  12. Slide 12: Opportunistic Expansion in a Hardening Market

    Opportunistic Expansion in a Hardening Market A merger creates excess capital to support new business Total property / property catastrophe premiums of over $550 million Peak catastrophe risk (1 in 250 PML) will be limited to 20% of capital Retentions on Max’s seasoned casualty insurance business ex

  13. Slide 13: Benefits of Combining Short and Long Tail Business

    Benefits of Combining Short and Long Tail Business Diversified portfolio of risks will generate increased and more stable underwriting returns Each $1 of catastrophe business is equal to writing 2.5x to 3.0x of casualty business, depending on the class Aggregate underwriting profit is similar – whil

  14. Slide 14: Max Investment Portfolio Highlights

    Max Investment Portfolio Highlights Max maintains a highly rated and highly liquid portfolio Cash Distressed Securities 18% 15% Long / Short funds Arbitrage 44% 14% Alternatives 22% Strategies 68% 3% Fixed Income Opportunistic 17% Emerging / Global Markets Alternatives allocation is decreasing 35% A

  15. Slide 15: IPC and Max Maintain a High Quality Investment Portfolio

    IPC and Max Maintain a High Quality Investment Portfolio IPC and Max have similarly positioned investment portfolios Alternatives / equities of combined portfolio to be reduced to 10% - 12% of total IPC Holdings Max Capital Cash Equities Cash 3% Alternative 9% 18% Investments 8% Alternative 14% Inve

  16. Slide 16: Max is Committed to the IPC Transaction

    Max is Committed to the IPC Transaction Choice for IPC Shareholders – Vote to Approve Max Merger or NO Transaction March 31, 2009: Validus announces unsolicited, stock-for-stock, below book value, takeover proposal of IPC April 7, 2009: IPC Board unanimously determines Validus proposal is NOT “Super

  17. Slide 17: Max Offers Certainty vs. No Deal with Validus

    Max Offers Certainty vs. No Deal with Validus Validus’ Offer is Risky… …Max Offers Certainty There is no "deal" with Validus IPC shareholders have deal-in-hand with Max Deal vs. Voting against Max merger does not mean IPC Max meets strategic and financial objectives of IPC No Deal would choose to se

  18. Slide 18: Max Maintains Truly Diversified Underwriting Platforms

    Max Maintains Truly Diversified Underwriting Platforms Max offers IMMEDIATE diversification across both short-tail and casualty classes Max’s casualty lines are developing favorably, with 65-75% in IBNR Validus has no diversification – 94% of 2008 GPW is short-tail business Other short-tail lines in

  19. Slide 19: Diversified Platforms Generate More Consistent Margins

    Diversified Platforms Generate More Consistent Margins Property Focused Reinsurers Diversified Reinsurers Validus began 300% 252% 300% operations following Hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Wilma 150% 150% Validus had the worst 140% combined ratio relative to 124% 125% its mono-line peers 116% 125% 104%

  20. Slide 20: Max Has Significantly Less Cat Exposure Versus Validus

    Max Has Significantly Less Cat Exposure Versus Validus Max seeks to limit its exposure to catastrophic events (probable maximum loss based on a 1 in 250 year event) to a maximum of 20% of surplus, often operating below this level Validus has significant volatility embedded in its underwriting operat

  21. Slide 21: Max's Diversified Portfolio Limits CAT Losses

    Max’s Diversified Portfolio Limits CAT Losses Validus had the greatest loss as a percentage of common equity among all its broad peer group Hurricane Ike is considered a 1 in 10-15 year event so large losses of capital would not be expected Ike/Gustav Ultimate Net Losses as a % of 6/30/08 Common Equ

  22. Slide 22: Research Analysts Emphasize Diversification

    Research Analysts Emphasize Diversification Research analysts have expressed strong support for an IPC / Max merger, placing significant emphasis on the diversification that Max provides IPC “Yes a premium, but few convincing strategic reasons: “Although the VR bid is currently a 5% premium to the A

  23. Slide 23: Max Provides IPC Shareholders More Value than Validus

    Max Provides IPC Shareholders More Value than Validus As of December 31, 2008 Diluted Tangible Book Value per IPC Share $40.00 $35.00 $33.83 Max delivers 29% more value to $30.00 $26.19 IPC’s shareholders vs. Validus $25.00 $20.00 Max Validus As a multiple of IPC 1.03x 0.80x Diluted Book Value per I

  24. Slide 24: Validus is Underperforming the Market Since Going Hostile

    Validus is Underperforming the Market Since Going Hostile Performance Since Validus Offer 10.4% S&P 500 Validus has significantly underperformed the market and its peers since going hostile on IPC (1) 9.3% Composite 13.4% underperformance vs. IPC reinsurance composite 5.7% IPC increase driven by str

  25. Slide 25: Max Offers More Upside to IPC Shareholders

    Max Offers More Upside to IPC Shareholders Price as a % of 52 Week High Historical Price to Book Value Comparison 100% 91% Average 81% Since 80% 73% 3 - Year VR IPO 2007 2008 Current 57% 60% Max 1.00x 0.90x 1.11x 0.87x 0.75x Validus NA 0.92 1.07 0.85 0.93 40% 20% 0% Max has historically traded at a

  26. Slide 26: Max Offers a Higher Implied Price to IPC Shareholders

    Max Offers a Higher Implied Price to IPC Shareholders Average Implied Price to IPC $50.0 Since YTD VR IPO 2007 2008 2009 (1) Max Capital $35.86 $41.72 $35.61 $26.46 $45.0 (2) 27.94 29.34 27.13 28.62 Validus $40.0 Max Average $35.0 $30.0 $25.0 Validus Average $20.0 $15.0 $10.0 7/25/07 10/3/07 12/12/0

  27. Slide 27: Validus's Hostile Takeover Makes No Sense

    Validus’s Hostile Takeover Makes No Sense Max: Merger-of-Equals Validus: Hostile Takeover Value Enhancing Value Destruction Max provides IPC with 29% more tangible Places no value on IPC’s strong franchise book value per IPC share than Validus VR does not meet strategic objectives of IPC Significant

  28. Slide 28: Appendix

    Appendix Max

  29. Slide 29: Calculation of Standalone Book Value Per Share

    Calculation of Standalone Book Value Per Share As of December 31, 2008 IPC Max Validus Shares outstanding Basic shares 55,855,103 (7) 55,805,790 (10) 75,624,697 (16) Warrants (net) 0 635,728 (11) 2,856,884 (16) Stock options (net) 18,608 (8) 120,685 (12) 848,758 (16) (8) Restricted stock awards 474,

  30. Slide 30: Calculation of Combined Book Value Per Share (IPC / Max)

    Calculation of Combined Book Value Per Share (IPC / Max) As of December 31, 2008 Value Delivered Combined (a) by Max per IPC IPC Max (per IPC share) Share (0.6429) Shares outstanding Basic shares 55,855,103 (7) 55,805,790 (10) 35,877,542 91,732,645 Warrants (net) 0 635,728 (11) 408,710 408,710 Stock

  31. Slide 31: Calculation of Combined Book Value Per Share (IPC / VR)

    Calculation of Combined Book Value Per Share (IPC / VR) As of December 31, 2008 Value Delivered Combined (b) by VR per IPC IPC Validus (per IPC share) Share (1/1.2037)(a) Termination Fee Shares outstanding Basic shares 55,855,103 (7) 75,624,697 (16) 62,826,865 118,681,968 Warrants (net) 0 2,856,884

  32. Slide 32: Footnotes

    Footnotes Note: Book value per share, diluted book value per share, tangible book value per share, and diluted tangible book value per share are all “non-GAAP financial measures” as defined in Regulation G. Combined figures exclude purchase accounting adjustments. For more information on GAAP purcha

Max Capital Group — Merger or Acquisition (April 2009) on 6ix