Post Properties — Proxy Contest (May 2003)
32 slides from Post Properties's proxy contest presentation, May 6, 2003
Slide 1: Institutional Shareholder Services Presentation May 6, 2003
CONFIDENTIAL Institutional Shareholder Services Presentation May 6, 2003
Slide 2: Forward-looking statements
Certain statements made in this presentation and other written or oral statements made by or on behalf of the Company, may constitute "forward-looking statements" within the meaning of the federal securities laws. Statements regarding future events and developments and the Company's future performan
Slide 3: Board and management committed to enhancing value for all shareholders
Post's current Board and management team are committed to enhancing value for all shareholders Introduction The current management team has had to overcome the challenges created by Mr. Williams' more recent expansion Post is executing an effective business plan We believe Mr. Williams is intensely
Slide 4: Williams announced his resignation as CEO on March 26, 2002
Williams announced his resignation as CEO on March 26, 2002 with an effective date of July 1, 2002 As CEO, Mr. Williams Presided Over a Substantial Decline in Operating Results and Stock Price - Resulting in His Departure as CEO Resignation followed a series of earnings disappointments, starting wit
Slide 5: Williams presided over decline in operating results and stock price
Date Post Properties, Inc. As CEO, Mr. Williams Presided Over a Substantial Decline in Operating Results and Stock Price - Resulting in His Departure as CEO 10/2/00: Post's earnings pre- announcement 3/26/02: Williams announces his resignation as CEO of Post, effective July 1, 2002 7/1/02: Williams
Slide 6: Analyst commentary on Williams' tenure as CEO
Mr. Williams, as CEO Presided Over a Substantial Decline in Operating Results and Stock Price - Resulting in His Departure as CEO "Remember, Mr. Williams only relinquished control in July 2002, well after the problems for PPS began. In fact, over the past nine months since Chief Executive Officer Da
Slide 7: Management overcoming challenges of Williams' geographic and product expansion
The Current Management Team Has Had to Overcome the Challenges of Mr. Williams' More Recent Geographic and Product- Type Expansion Under Mr. Williams, Post pursued an overly aggressive expansion of development initiatives into several unfamiliar markets, which led to significant cost overruns Spread
Slide 8: Significant development cost overruns under Williams
(1) Source: Post Properties (2) Source: Post Properties' Form 10-K filing for year ended 12/31/02 $ in millions The Current Management Team Has Had to Overcome the Impact of Significant Development Cost Overruns Under Mr. Williams Legend Text Budgeted Actual 543 646 $103 mm Over Budget Post's 15 dev
Slide 9: Atlanta and Dallas are among the most challenging multifamily markets
Source: Provided by Axiometrics, Inc. on 4/15/03. Top 31 Markets with the largest concentration of REIT owned apartments 2000 2001 2002 Atlanta 0.956 0.945 0.919 Dallas 0.954 0.946 0.917 Top 31 Markets 0.955 0.948 0.937 2000 2001 2002 Atlanta 0.046 0.005 -0.093 Dallas 0.073 0.009 -0.054 Top 31 Marke
Slide 10: Williams' missteps led to inferior total return performance
Missteps caused Post to significantly under-perform its peers during the 12, 24, 36, 48 and 60 month periods leading up to Williams' departure as CEO (2) Legend Text Post Properties, Inc. 15 Peers 12 Months -12.8 12.5 24 Months -18.8 40.4 36 Months -6.4 58.1 48 Months 6.9 69.1 60 Months 8 86.9 (3) M
Slide 11: Post is executing an effective business plan
Post Is Executing an Effective Business Plan Improving operating performance Strengthening the Post(r) brand Executing an effective asset sales and self-funding strategy to focus geographically, improve operating efficiency and strengthen the balance sheet Successfully managing and redirecting the d
Slide 12: Second half 2002 same-property expense growth
PPS -0.022 AIV 0 AML 0.001 CPT 0.011 UDR 0.018 SMT 0.024 EQR 0.025 BRE 0.025 GBP 0.035 MAA 0.043 ASN 0.047 TCT 0.063 ESS 0.063 TCR 0.068 AVB 0.071 HME 0.094 Second Half 2002 Same-Property Expense Growth (1) Includes property tax savings recorded in the fourth quarter of 2002. Excluding these savings
Slide 13: Resident satisfaction is increasing
Very Satisfied Satisfied 2001 0.67 0.27 2002 0.68 0.28 Oct. '02 0.69 0.29 Commitment to customer service and the Post(r) brand has resulted in steadily- increasing resident satisfaction scores over the last two years Overall Resident Satisfaction 94.7% 95.4% 96.1% Resident Satisfaction Is Increasing
Slide 14: Portfolio has substantial upside as markets recover
Incremental Earnings per Share Overall +5.0% NOI Growth 0.25 +7.5% NOI Growth 0.375 +10.0% NOI Growth 0.5 +12.5% NOI Growth 0.625 +15.0% NOI Growth 0.75 Due to the cyclically-weak multifamily market, same-property NOI declined during 2001 and 2002. Each percentage point improvement in NOI produces a
Slide 15: Executing an effective disposition strategy
Executing an Effective Disposition Strategy Objectives of Post's asset sales and self-funding strategy: Focus geographically in fewer markets and reduce exposure to Atlanta, Dallas and Tampa markets Ensure highest overall portfolio quality by selling older, less competitive assets Improve operating
Slide 16: Maximizing sales pricing through a competitive auction process
Source: Post Properties, Inc. Maximizing Sales Pricing Through a Competitive Auction Process Since January 1, 2000, Post has generated $572 million of gross proceeds from the sale of 23 multifamily properties 5 highly-qualified brokerage firms used A very competitive auction process with, on average
Slide 17: On track to meet 2003 asset sales goal
(1) Estimate. There can be no assurance that the transactions will close at the negotiated prices or terms Source: Post Properties, Inc., $ in millions On Track to Meet 2003 Asset Sales Goal Currently on target to achieve 2003 asset sales goal of $100 - $150 million
Slide 18: Successfully managing and redirecting the development pipeline
Post 10 Peers 12/31/1999 0.27 0.092 12/31/2000 0.217 0.084 12/31/2001 0.199 0.083 12/31/2002 0.096 0.097 The development pipeline has been moved to an appropriate size and is now in line with peers Development Costs as % of Asset Value (1) 19 Projects 15 Projects 10 Projects 6 Projects (1) Multifami
Slide 19: Development process back on track
Source: Post Properties, Inc., $ in millions Projects started since January 1, 2001 are on-time and on-budget Development Process Back on Track
Slide 20: Controlling expenses and improving efficiency
(1) Reflects internal personnel and associated costs capitalized to construction and development activities Source: Post Properties' Form 10-K filing for the year ended 12/31/02. Headcount reduction per Post Properties, Inc. $ in millions In 2002, personnel and administrative costs were reduced by 2
Slide 21: Improving disclosure and restoring credibility
Post's improved disclosure and transparency are helping to restore credibility with investors and Wall Street Improving Disclosure and Restoring Credibility Established new quarterly supplemental reporting package starting 2Q'03 Expanded balance sheet disclosure Public debt financial covenant calcul
Slide 22: Williams focused on his own personal circumstances
We believe Mr. Williams is motivated by self-interest, not shareholders' interest We Believe Mr. Williams Is Intensely Focused on His Own Personal Circumstances We believe Mr. Williams is motivated by an inability to relinquish control to his successors We believe Mr. Williams is also motivated by a
Slide 23: Highly-qualified, independent-minded Board of Directors
(1) Does not include John A. Williams or Arthur M. Blank (Mr. Blank has announced his intention to resign at the time of the Company's annual shareholders' meeting on May 22, 2003) (2) Based on Post Properties' Supplement to its Proxy Statement (filed with the S.E.C. on 4/23/03) (3) Includes shares
Slide 24: Existing Board is independent-minded and highly qualified
The Existing Board Is Independent-Minded, Highly-Qualified, Committed to Good Corporate Governance and Is Making the Right Decisions Highly-qualified directors The CEO is the only insider on the Board Board has a track record of action The Company is building on a solid foundation of good corporate
Slide 25: The Board has a track record of action
The Board Has a Track Record of Action Assertively implemented CEO succession process Elected non-executive Chairman Proactively adjusted the dividend Prepared to take action to limit Williams' disruptive access to Company employees and Company information and to remove Williams' office from Post's
Slide 26: Board is committed to corporate governance practices
The Board is prepared to do what is right for all shareholders The Board Is Committed to Corporate Governance Practices That Ensure The Interests of All Shareholders Are Served Post's Board is independent-minded 9 out of 10 Board members are non-management Separate CEO and Chairman positions Elimina
Slide 27: Board committed to governance practices serving all shareholders
The Board Is Committed to Corporate Governance Practices That Ensure The Interests of All Shareholders Are Served Elimination of Classified Board Post is committing to eliminate its existing classified board structure and will ask shareholders to vote to do so at next year's annual meeting Restricti
Slide 28: Sign the WHITE proxy card
Sign the WHITE proxy card & allow your current Board and management team to enhance shareholder value Conclusion Post is executing an effective business plan The current management team has had to overcome the challenges created by Mr. Williams' more recent expansion We believe Mr. Williams is inten
Slide 29: Appendix: Supplemental Information
Appendix: Supplemental Information
Slide 30: Regulation G Disclosure
Regulation G Disclosure The year-to-year percentage change in Same-Property Net Operating Income for the Atlanta and Dallas markets presented on page 11 is a non-GAAP financial measure. In this presentation, we define Net Operating Income as rental and other revenues from real estate operations less
Slide 31: Regulation G Disclosure (cont'd)
Regulation G Disclosure (cont'd) The Same-Property Unit Maintenance, Landscaping and Capital Expenditures numbers are non-GAAP financial measures. In Table 2 and Table 3 we refer to Maintenance, Landscaping and Capital Expenditures as Repairs and Maintenance, including payroll, Landscape Maintenance
Slide 32: Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Financial Measures - Table 3 (1) Information derived from the Post Properties' Form 10-K filing for the year ended 12/31/02 and company records (2) Consists of commercial properties and assets classified as discontinued operations under SFAS No. 144 $ in thousands, except