Agrium — Proxy Contest (August 2012)
12 slides from Agrium's proxy contest presentation, Aug 20, 2012
Slide 1: Investor Update
Investor Update August 20, 2012
Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements
Forward-Looking Statements Certain statements and other information included in this presentation constitute “forward-looking information” within the meaning of applicable Canadian securities legislation or constitute “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of applicable U.S. securities legi
Slide 3: Recent Developments
Recent Developments • On May 31, JANA advised Agrium that it made a Hart-Scott-Rodino filing and that it held just under 5% of Agrium and intended to acquire more shares – JANA also said that Agrium should spin off its Retail business (“Retail”) • In early June, Agrium retained Morgan Stanley to pro
Slide 4: Recent Developments (continued)
Recent Developments (continued) • On August 2, Morgan Stanley presented its views to the independent directors of Agrium • On August 3, Agrium called JANA to advise them that the Board unanimously determined not to pursue a spin off of Retail – Agrium offered to meet with JANA and a meeting was sche
Slide 5: Retail Spin Off Not in Best Interests of Shareholders
Retail Spin Off Not in Best Interests of Shareholders • Agrium is confident that it has an effective long-term strategy and structure to create sustainable value for shareholders – Record sales, gross profit, EBITDA, and net earnings in 2011 and 1H/2012 – Shares have increased 49% YTD (vs 13% for th
Slide 6: Recent Meeting with JANA
Recent Meeting with JANA • On August 15, Agrium and Morgan Stanley met with JANA in New York • Agrium advised JANA that its Board carefully considered JANA’s position over a period of 2 months and that the Board unanimously determined that a spin off of Retail would not be in the best interests of s
Slide 7: Recent Meeting with JANA (continued)
Recent Meeting with JANA (continued) • Morgan Stanley also reviewed certain significant flaws and errors in the materials that JANA presented to Agrium on July 11, and which Morgan Stanley had reviewed with the Agrium Board on August 2 – JANA’s analysis of operating expenses did not factor in the im
Slide 8: Our Strategy and Performance
Our Strategy and Performance • Agrium’s strategy is to invest and operate across the agricultural inputs (fertilizer, chemicals, and seeds) value chain through production, distribution, and retail sales • Our strategy allows us to: – Achieve operating synergies through greater utilization of assets
Slide 9: Morgan Stanley View of Distribution Peer Trading Valuations
Morgan Stanley View of Distribution Peer Trading Valuations • On August 2, Morgan Stanley advised the Board that it believed investors would consider a broad set of peers to assess where Retail would trade as a separate public company, and Morgan Stanley discussed the group of comparables illustrate
Slide 10: Morgan Stanley View of Distribution Peer Trading Valuations (continued)
Morgan Stanley View of Distribution Peer Trading Valuations (continued) Enterprise Value / 2013E EBITDA(1) 15.0 Peer Median: 8.2x Basic Material Distributors 10.9x 10.9x General Industrial Distributors / Retail 10.0 9.4x 8.3x 8.2x 8.2x 8.2x 7.0x 6.7x 5.9x 5.9x 5.0 0.0 Tractor Watsco Grainger Genuine
Slide 11: Retail Target EV/EBITDA Multiples
Equity Analyst “Target” Multiples for Retail • For equity analyst “target” multiples published since the August 3 earnings call, the average analyst “target” multiple for Retail is approximately 8x Sum-of-the-Parts Retail Multiple (Published Since Earnings Announcement) 12 Retail Target EV/EBITDA Mu
Slide 12: Morgan Stanley View of Wholesale Peer Trading Valuations
Morgan Stanley View of Wholesale Peer Trading Valuations • Morgan Stanley examined where Agrium’s Wholesale business (“Wholesale”) would likely trade as a separate public company without Retail • Morgan Stanley believes any analysis should be based on actual trading multiples of the peers, not “targ