Firsthand Technology Value Fund Inc · OTC:SVVC

Firsthand Technology Value Fund — Proxy Contest (May 2023)

27 slides from Firsthand Technology Value Fund's proxy contest presentation, May 9, 2023

  1. Slide 1: Our Plan for Enhancing Stockholder Value at Firsthand Technology Value Fund, Inc.

    Slide 1: Our Plan for Enhancing Stockholder Value at Firsthand Technology Value Fund, Inc.

    Our Plan for Enhancing Stockholder Value at Firsthand Technology Value Fund, Inc. Nasdaq: SVVC

  2. Slide 2: The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Star Equity Fund, LP

    Slide 2: The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Star Equity Fund, LP

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 1 The materials contained herein (the “Materials”) represent the opinions of Star Equity Fund, LP and the other participants named in the proxy solicitation (collectively, the “Star Equity”) and are based on publicly available information with respect to Firsthand Technolo

  3. Slide 3: It Is Time for Change at Firsthand Technology Value Fund (SVVC)

    Slide 3: It Is Time for Change at Firsthand Technology Value Fund (SVVC)

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 2 It Is Time for Change at Firsthand Technology Value Fund (SVVC) SVVC Shareholders have endured years of value destruction under the incumbent directors In our view: • The incumbent directors are entrenched, and their interests are misaligned with those of shareholders •

  4. Slide 4: The Incumbent SVVC Directors Have Overseen Colossal Value Destruction at SVVC

    Slide 4: The Incumbent SVVC Directors Have Overseen Colossal Value Destruction at SVVC

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 3 The Incumbent SVVC Directors Have Overseen Colossal Value Destruction at SVVC

  5. Slide 5: SVVC Stock Price Performance

    Slide 5: SVVC Stock Price Performance

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 4 SVVC Stock Price Performance $10,000 invested in SVVC since inception* Source: SVVC’s 2023 proxy statement. *Includes reinvestment of dividends; as of 12/31/2022 • Since inception on April 18, 2011, the total return of SVVC’s stock price has been - 95% • Since inception,

  6. Slide 6: SVVC Stock Price Performance contd.

    Slide 6: SVVC Stock Price Performance contd.

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 5 SVVC Stock Price Performance contd. • SVVC’s stock price has severely underperformed the S&P 500 Index, the NASDAQ Composite Index, and the US BDC Index over the short, medium, and long term 10-Yr 5-Yr 3-Yr 1-Yr SVVC (1)(2) -93.7% -91.7% -74.3% -71.7% NASDAQ Composite In

  7. Slide 7: SVVC Stock Price Performance contd.

    Slide 7: SVVC Stock Price Performance contd.

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 6 SVVC Stock Price Performance contd. SVVC’s stock continues to trade at a significant discount to its NAV/share • The huge discount to NAV implies the market believes: o NAV/share is significantly overstated o NAV/share is going to decline in the future, or BOTH 0.00 0.10

  8. Slide 8: SVVC Share Price vs NAV

    Slide 8: SVVC Share Price vs NAV

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 7 0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 Q4 2018 Q1 2019 Q2 2019 Q3 2019 Q4 2019 Q1 2020 Q2 2020 Q3 2020 Q4 2020 Q1 2021 Q2 2021 Q3 2021 Q4 2021 Q1 2022 Q2 2022 Q3 2022 Q4 2022 SVVC: Share Price vs NAV Share Price NAV SVVC Stock Price Performance contd. • SVVC has consist

  9. Slide 9: SVVC's Investment Performance Has Been Dismal

    Slide 9: SVVC's Investment Performance Has Been Dismal

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 8 SVVC’s Investment Performance Has Been Dismal

  10. Slide 10: SVVC Investment Performance

    Slide 10: SVVC Investment Performance

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 9 SVVC Investment Performance Company Primary Industry Investment Cost Basis Value Gain/Loss EQX Capital, Inc. Equipment Leasing Common Stock $20,000 $11,130 ($8,870) EQX Capital, Inc. Equipment Leasing Preferred Stock - Series A $1,950,000 $865,995 ($1,084,005) Hera Syste

  11. Slide 11: SVVC Has Underperformed its Peers and Trades at a Larger Discount to NAV than its Peers

    Slide 11: SVVC Has Underperformed its Peers and Trades at a Larger Discount to NAV than its Peers

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 10 SVVC Has Underperformed its Peers and Trades at a Larger Discount to NAV than do its Peers

  12. Slide 12: SVVC Performance vs. Comparables

    Slide 12: SVVC Performance vs. Comparables

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 11 SVVC Performance vs. Comparables SVVC Total Return vs. Peers as of 5/5/23 Source: CEFdata.com Peers are equity - focused BDCs with a market cap of less than $100mm – see Appendix for more detail. SVVC has significantly underperformed in comparison to its Peer Group

  13. Slide 13: SVVC Performance vs. Comparables contd.

    Slide 13: SVVC Performance vs. Comparables contd.

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 12 SVVC Performance vs. Comparables contd. SVVC Total Return vs. Peers SVVC stock price has significantly underperformed in comparison to its Peer Group Source: CEFdata.com Peers are equity - focused BDCs with a market cap of less than $100mm – see Appendix for more detail

  14. Slide 14: SVVC's Incumbent Directors are Entrenched and Misaligned

    Slide 14: SVVC's Incumbent Directors are Entrenched and Misaligned

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 13 SVVC’s Incumbent Directors are Entrenched and Misaligned

  15. Slide 15: Incumbent Directors are Not Aligned with Shareholders

    Slide 15: Incumbent Directors are Not Aligned with Shareholders

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 14 Incumbent Directors are Not Aligned with Shareholders • The incumbent independent directors hold very little stock in the company, and thus do not have “skin in the game” • We believe this contributes to the Board’s complacency around the horrendous performance of SVVC’

  16. Slide 16: The Incumbent Directors Have Ignored Repeated Displays of Shareholder Frustration

    Slide 16: The Incumbent Directors Have Ignored Repeated Displays of Shareholder Frustration

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 15 The Incumbent Directors Have Ignored Repeated Displays of Shareholder Frustration

  17. Slide 17: The Incumbent Directors Have Consistently Ignored Shareholders

    Slide 17: The Incumbent Directors Have Consistently Ignored Shareholders

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 16 The Incumbent Directors Have Consistently Ignored Shareholders The Incumbent directors have entirely ignored frustrated shareholders and has used its anti - shareholder bylaws to thwart participation at the Company: • For the 2020 Annual Meeting, fellow shareholder Dona

  18. Slide 18: The Incumbent Directors Have Consistently Ignored Shareholders contd.

    Slide 18: The Incumbent Directors Have Consistently Ignored Shareholders contd.

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 17 The Incumbent Directors Have Consistently Ignored Shareholders contd. • None of these proposals has ever been addressed by the Board, and SVVC’s bylaws make it so proposals must receive a majority of all outstanding (not those voted) shares to pass • SVVC’s 2020 Annual

  19. Slide 19: SVVC Maintains an Egregiously Anti-Shareholder Investment Management Agreement

    Slide 19: SVVC Maintains an Egregiously Anti-Shareholder Investment Management Agreement

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 18 SVVC Maintains an Egregiously Anti - Shareholder Investment Management Agreement

  20. Slide 20: SVVC Maintains an Egregiously Anti-Shareholder Investment Management Agreement

    Slide 20: SVVC Maintains an Egregiously Anti-Shareholder Investment Management Agreement

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 19 SVVC Maintains an egregiously Anti - Shareholder Investment Management Agreement • SVVC maintains an egregiously Anti - Shareholder investment management agreement with Firsthand Capital Management (“FCM”) o FCM is an affiliated party, an investment management firm run

  21. Slide 21: FCM Has $9 Million in Accrued and Unpaid Management Fees

    Slide 21: FCM Has $9 Million in Accrued and Unpaid Management Fees

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 20 • FCM has $9 million in accrued and unpaid management fees as of 12/31/2022 • We believe the Board should eliminate these accrued fees entirely given SVVC’s terrible performance SVVC Maintains an egregiously Anti - Shareholder Investment Management Agreement contd. Sour

  22. Slide 22: Star Equity's Nominees are Highly Qualified, Highly Motivated, and Fully Prepared

    Slide 22: Star Equity's Nominees are Highly Qualified, Highly Motivated, and Fully Prepared

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 21 Star Equity’s Nominees are Highly Qualified, Highly Motivated, and Fully Prepared to Immediately Effectuate Meaningful Change at SVVC

  23. Slide 23: Star Equity Fund Nominee – Robert G. Pearse

    Slide 23: Star Equity Fund Nominee – Robert G. Pearse

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 22 Star Equity Fund Nominee – Robert G. Pearse • Currently serves as a Managing Partner at Yucatan Rock Ventures, an investment and consulting firm, since 2012 • Previously, he served as VP of Strategy and Market Development for NetApp, Inc. (NASDAQ: NTAP), a publicly - tr

  24. Slide 24: Star Equity Fund Nominee – Hannah M. Bible

    Slide 24: Star Equity Fund Nominee – Hannah M. Bible

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 23 Star Equity Fund Nominee – Hannah M. Bible • Currently serves as Chief Legal Officer and Corporate Secretary for Star Equity Holdings, Inc. (“Star Equity Holdings”) (NASDAQ: STRR) (f/k/a Digirad Corporation), a diversified holding company with a private equity strategy,

  25. Slide 25: If Elected, Our Nominees Would Push For:

    Slide 25: If Elected, Our Nominees Would Push For:

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 24 If Elected, Our Nominees Would Push For: 1. Immediate termination of the investment management agreement with FCM 2. Changing the anti - shareholder bylaws including the highly restrictive voting requirements on director nominees and shareholder proposals 3. Better faci

  26. Slide 26: APPENDIX

    Slide 26: APPENDIX

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 25 APPENDIX

  27. Slide 27: SVVC Comp Set

    Slide 27: SVVC Comp Set

    STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL PAGE 26 SVVC Comp Set SVVC Comp Set Name Ticker Market Cap (1) Business Highlights Rand Capital Corp. RAND 32.9 BDC focused on small to midsized private businesses in the technology, industrial, health care, and service industries. Suro Capital Corp. SSSS 105.7 Non - diversifie

Source: SEC EDGAR · DFAN14A filed May 9, 2023