Portland General Electric Co · NYSE:POR

Portland General Electric — Corporate Update (August 2016)

97 slides from Portland General Electric's corporate update, Aug 17, 2016

  1. Slide 1: 2016 Integrated Resource Plan Roundtable #16-3

    2016 Integrated Resource Plan Roundtable #16-3 August 17, 2016

  2. Slide 2: Meeting Logistics

    Meeting Logistics Local Participants:  World Trade Center facility  Wireless internet access  Sign-in sheets Virtual Participants:  Ask questions via ‘chat’ feature  Meeting will stay open during breaks, but will be muted  Electronic version of presentation: portlandgeneral.com/irp >> Integrat

  3. Slide 3: Safety Moment – PGE Fleet

    Safety Moment – PGE Fleet (as of June 2016)  Corporate commitment to allocate 10% of fleet budget on electrification  38 Electric Vehicles Electrification Benefits  Safe  Reliable  Efficient  Clean 3

  4. Slide 4: Today's Round Table Topics

    Today’s Round Table Topics  Stakeholder process  Resource need assessment  Scenario analysis and results  Draft Action Plan  Energy Storage evaluation  Next Steps 4

  5. Slide 5: Public Process Overview

    Aa Sp’ Ss Cooriana General v4 Electric

  6. Slide 6: IRP Guiding Philosophy

    Guiding Philosophy PGE’s IRP is framed by four directional drivers  Compliance  Contingency  Corporate Policy Reliability  Regional Responsibility Adequacy IRP  Efficiency  Cost Effective Technology Price  Diversity  Stability Providing the opportunity to obtain the best resource portfolio w

  7. Slide 7: Round Table Meeting Schedule

    Round Table Meeting Schedule* PGE holds quarterly round tables to communicate with and receive feedback from stakeholders Q1 – • RPS Landscape  Resource Adequacy March 9 • Scoring Metrics  Portfolios Q2 – • RPS Strategy (SB 1547 Compliance) May 16 • Resource Flexibility Q3 – • Discuss Results and

  8. Slide 8: 2016 IRP Development

    2016 IRP Development PGE, in collaboration with Stakeholders, continues to evolve the IRP Changing Environment  Clean Power Plan  Energy Imbalance Market  Senate Bill 1547 Total Resource Portfolio Analysis  Updated Load Forecast methodology  New Resource Adequacy methodology  Integration of al

  9. Slide 9: Resource Adequacy Update

    Cooriana General v4 Electric t Sp’ Ss

  10. Slide 10: Review Load Forecast

    Review Load Forecast Summer peak demand grows at a slightly faster rate than winter peak demand (1.2% vs. 1.0% for 2022-2050) 5,000 4,000 MWa Energy, MW Peak Demand 3,000 2,000 1,000 - Residential Commercial Industrial Winter Peak Summer Peak * 1-in-2 forecast from June 2015 Load includes 5-year dir

  11. Slide 11: Resource Adequacy Update

    Resource Adequacy Update Feb 2016 Jun 2016  Modeled 2021, 2025, 2030 RECAP Runs  Interpolation and  Modeled 2017-2050 extrapolation for other years  Removed before Jan 1, Colstrip 3 & 4  Removed after 2035 2035 Dispatchable  All years based on early  IRP target acquisitions for Standby foreca

  12. Slide 12: Updated RECAP Results

    Updated RECAP Results • June 2016 Study shows remaining capacity need after incremental actions for DR/DSG and with updated contracts 4000 PGE Capacity Need 3500 3000 2500 2000 MW 1500 Study 2021 2025 2030 1000 Feb 2016 928 1393 1651 500 Jun 2016 819 1142 1335 0 2017 2019 2021 2023 2025 2027 2029 20

  13. Slide 13: Demand Response Comparison

    Demand Response Comparison • Total DR acquisitions included in all portfolios did not change • Updated modeling in RECAP • Feb 2016 Study: ~40 MW fixed DR value for all years in RECAP • June 2016 Study: Targeted DR acquisitions for each year 250 Demand Response Forecasts 200 150 MW 100 50 0 2017 201

  14. Slide 14: Capacity Need After EE, DR, DSG Actions

    Capacity Need After EE, DR, DSG Actions A capacity gap of 819 MW is expected in 2021, driven mainly by Boardman cessation of coal-fired generation in 2020 and contract expirations 6000 MW 1:2 Peak Load + Reserves* 5000 4000 2021: 819 MW Deficit 2035: 1864 MW Deficit 3000 2000 1000 0 2017 2019 2021 2

  15. Slide 15: Capacity Heat Map for 2021 (Jun 2016 RECAP)

    Capacity Heat Map for 2021 (Jun 2016 RECAP) Heat map shows seasonal and hourly nature of PGE’s capacity needs Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 1 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.03 Resources included 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.01

  16. Slide 16: 2021 Capacity Need and LOLE Target

    2021 Capacity Need and LOLE Target Resource adequacy target1 of 1-day-in-10-year metric  Reliability metrics change substantially for ~±100 MW change to capacity addition2 Capacity Reliability 928 MW > 1-in-20 819 MW ~ 1-in-10 721 MW < 1-in-5  PGE’s capacity need continues to increase after 2021 

  17. Slide 17: Capacity Contribution – Incremental Wind/Solar

    Capacity Contribution – Incremental Wind/Solar Marginal ELCC values for 100 MW incremental additions calculated in RECAP1  Marginal ELCC values decline as incremental 100 MW additions are included in the system  RECAP was used to calculate ELCC values for each IRP portfolio 17 1 ELCC values based

  18. Slide 18: RPS REC Obligation and Production

    RPS REC Obligation and Production MWa 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 2017 2019 2021 2023 2025 2027 2029 2031 2033 2035 2037 2039 REC Obligation REC Production 2017 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 RPS Obligation % 15% 20% 27% 35% 45% 50% PGE REC Obligation, MWa 309 417 600 828 1135 1347 18 PGE REC Product

  19. Slide 19: Energy Load-Resource Balance

    Energy Load-Resource Balance An energy gap of 388 MWa is expected in 2021, of which a portion may be met with renewable portfolio standard (RPS) compliant resources 3500 MWa Load excl. opt‐outs 3000 2500 2035: 1225 MWa Deficit 2021: 388 MWa Deficit 2000 1500 1000 500 0 2017 2019 2021 2023 2025 2027

  20. Slide 20: Scoring Metrics/Scoring Results

    Scoring Metrics/Scoring Results

  21. Slide 21: Draft 2016 IRP Portfolio Analysis Output

    Draft 2016 IRP Portfolio Analysis Output $42,000 Worst outcome $41,000 25% of outcomes $40,000 $39,000 $38,000 $37,000 $36,000 $35,000 (2016$, million) $34,000 NPVRR $33,000 $32,000 $31,000 $30,000 $29,000 $28,000 $27,000 $26,000 $25,000 50% of outcomes $24,000 25% of outcomes Best outcome $23,000 2

  22. Slide 22: Example Distribution of Results

    Example Distribution of Results $42,000 Ref CO2, Ref Gas, Ref Load $41,000 Ref CO2, Ref Gas, Low Load $40,000 Ref CO2, Ref Gas, High Load Worst outcome High CO2, High Gas, High Load Ref CO2, High Gas, Low Load $39,000 Ref CO2, High Gas, High Load Ref CO2, High Gas, Ref Load $38,000 Ref CO2, High Gas

  23. Slide 23: Filter to Actionable Portfolios (Draft)

    …Filter to Actionable Portfolios (Draft) $42,000 Actionable $41,000 Portfolios for 2017-2020 $40,000 Filter set of Portfolios for: $39,000 $38,000 $37,000 • Resource $36,000 Adequacy $35,000 • Diverse wind transmission breakeven (2016$, million) $34,000 NPVRR $33,000 $32,000 • Actions $31,000 beyond

  24. Slide 24: Action Plan Portfolios (Draft)

    Action Plan Portfolios (Draft) $42,000 $41,000 $40,000 $39,000 $38,000 $37,000 $36,000 (2016$, million) $35,000 NPVRR $34,000 $33,000 $32,000 $31,000 $30,000 $29,000 $28,000 $27,000 $26,000 $25,000 24 Reference Case 10% Worst 10% Best

  25. Slide 25: Scoring Metrics

    Scoring Metrics • Cost, Severity, Variability, Future Durability, Curtailment metrics calculated for each Portfolio • Normalized score 0–100 (worst to best) is determined for each Portfolio under each metric based on Portfolio’s performance relative to best result • Portfolio Scoring results are rel

  26. Slide 26: Scoring Metrics: Cost

    Scoring Metrics: Cost Cost – Net Present Value of Revenue Requirements (NPVRR) $42,000 $41,000 Annually, 2017-2050: [ Resource Fixed Cost + Resource Variable Costs + (Purchases – Sales)] $40,000 Present Value at PGE cost of capital $39,000 $38,000 Lowest value (best) = 100 points $37,000 Highest val

  27. Slide 27: Scoring Metrics: Severity

    Scoring Metrics: Severity $42,000 Highest-Cost 3 Worst $41,000 Futures (worst): $40,000 Value = $40,226 High Carbon/Gas/Load Score = 0 Lowest-Cost 3 Worst $39,000 Futures (best): Reference Carbon, High Gas/Load $38,000 Value = $38,106 NPVRR (> Reference Case) $37,000 Score = 100 High Carbon/Gas, Ref

  28. Slide 28: Scoring Metrics: Variability

    Scoring Metrics: Variability $9,000 $8,000 NPVRR (Relative to Reference Case) $7,000 $6,000 Highest Variability Portfolio (worst): $5,000 Value = 2,957 (2016$, million) Score = 0 Lowest $4,000 Variability Portfolio (best): Variability – Dispersion of Futures, NPVRR > Value = 2,700 $3,000 Score = 100

  29. Slide 29: Scoring Metrics: Future Durability

    Scoring Metrics: Future Durability 100% ←Frequency of top‐third 80% Highest Durability (best): outcome→ 60% Value = 100% Score = 100 40% 20% 0% ←Frequency of bo om‐third 20% outcome→ 40% 60% Lowest Durability (worst): 80% Value = -100% Score = 0 100% Durability – frequency of top- or bottom-third ra

  30. Slide 30: Scoring Metrics: Potential Curtailment

    Scoring Metrics: Potential Curtailment Potential Curtailment – Discounted future potential curtailment of resource mix 2,400 2,300 2,200 REFLEX study-based approximation of potential renewable curtailment 2,100 2,000 1,900 Lowest value (best) = 100 points 1,800 Highest value (worst) = 0 points 1,700

  31. Slide 31: Apply Scoring Metrics

    …Apply Scoring Metrics DRAFT Weights 50% 15% 15% 15% 5% Score Rank Score Rank Future Future Future Total Total Portfolio Name Cost Severity Variability Durability Curtailment Cost Severity Variability Durability Curtailment Cost Severity Variability Durability Curtailment Wtd Wtd RPS Wind 2018 31,30

  32. Slide 32: Preferred Portfolio

    SN Cooriana General v4 Electric

  33. Slide 33: Draft 2016 IRP Preferred Portfolio

    Draft 2016 IRP Preferred Portfolio • Based on portfolio analysis and scoring, Preferred Portfolio: “Efficient Thermal 2021” • Resource strategy comprises: • Capacity adequacy • Efficient dispatchable resource (i.e., flexible, low heat rate) addition in 2021 in lieu of low fixed cost, low efficiency

  34. Slide 34: Capacity Heat Map for 2021

    Capacity Heat Map for 2021 A portion of PGE’s capacity need may be suited to seasonal products Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 1 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.03 Resources included 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.01  Existing por

  35. Slide 35: Seasonal Capacity Products

    Seasonal Capacity Products A portion of the capacity need may be met by seasonal products • The optimal blend of seasonal and annual products will depend on several factors, including capacity needs, flexibility needs, fixed costs, and variable costs/benefits • RECAP was used to estimate example sea

  36. Slide 36: Seasonal Price Scenario Example

    Seasonal Price Scenario Example Scenarios examine relative costs for a range of annual/seasonal combinations that achieve the same reliability target Price Scenario Example (25%) 1. To simplify values, set annual resource cost for 760 MW (no seasonal products) equal to $100M/yr, (~$11/kW-mo) 2. Set

  37. Slide 37: Seasonal Capacity Products – Price Scenarios

    Seasonal Capacity Products – Price Scenarios Optimal seasonal acquisition depends on pricing relative to annual resources Scenario 25% Summer Scenario 50% Summer 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 0 100 92 87 84 83 83 83 84 85 86 86 0 100 93 89 86 8

  38. Slide 38: Draft Responsive Action Plan

    Draft Responsive Action Plan1 Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Action Timing 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Renewable 20% RPS 2016 IRP All Resource / Capacity Acknowledged Supply-side  Renewable2 0-175 MWa  Capacity 800-850 MW  Annual 400-850 MW (dispatchable)  Seasonal 0-600 MW (summer)  Seasonal 0-500 MW (winte

  39. Slide 39: Preliminary Energy Storage Evaluation

    Preliminary Energy Storage Evaluation

  40. Slide 40: Energy storage evaluation

    Energy storage evaluation With increasing renewable penetration, dropping technology costs, and new market paradigms in the West, energy storage economic evaluation is gaining importance in long term planning exercises. This discussion will cover:  Energy storage value streams under consideration i

  41. Slide 41: Primary energy storage value streams identified by PGE

    Primary energy storage value streams identified by PGE 41

  42. Slide 42: Energy storage value streams evaluated on a preliminary basis in 2016 IRP

    Energy storage value streams evaluated on a preliminary basis in 2016 IRP 42

  43. Slide 43: Preliminary Evaluation Methodology

    Preliminary Evaluation Methodology Methodology under ongoing development  IRP will include preliminary evaluation of energy storage with the goals of identifying promising value streams and establishing a framework for evaluating energy storage in future resource procurement decisions  Sets the st

  44. Slide 44: Resource Optimization Model (ROM)

    Resource Optimization Model (ROM) Background  ROM was originally built by PGE to calculate the wind integration cost adder  ROM solves for the least cost commitment and dispatch of PGE’s resource fleet at a 15-min timestep over the course of a future test year  ROM captures operational costs asso

  45. Slide 45: Energy storage value streams quantifiable in ROM

    Energy storage value streams quantifiable in ROM 45

  46. Slide 46: ROM Battery test portfolio

    ROM Battery test portfolio PGE Test Portfolio  2021 Scenario developed for the 2016 IRP Integration Cost Adder Study Test battery systems  Six systems were dispatched in ROM:  50MW 2-hr, 4-hr, and 6-hr batteries  100MW 2-hr, 4-hr, and 6-hr batteries  Roundtrip efficiency: 81%  No ramp rate lim

  47. Slide 47: Visualizing Battery Storage Dispatch

    Visualizing Battery Storage Dispatch Max Discharging Max Charging Charging Discharging 47

  48. Slide 48: Visualizing Battery Storage Dispatch

    Visualizing Battery Storage Dispatch Maximum State of Charge (SOC) Charging Discharging 48

  49. Slide 49: Visualizing Battery Storage Dispatch

    Visualizing Battery Storage Dispatch Areas represent ancillary service provisions from battery’s remaining dispatch capability 49

  50. Slide 50: Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (January week)

    Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (January week) Scheduled dispatch is frequently zero  On some days, battery provides ancillary services without making use of full energy Maximum SOC storage capabilities Battery never reaches maximum state of charge 50

  51. Slide 51: Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (June week)

    Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (June week) Scheduled dispatch reaches maximum charge/discharge levels  On other days, battery provides both ancillary services and significant Maximum SOC energy shifting services Battery cycles over full range once per day 51

  52. Slide 52: Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (Seasonal and diurnal behavior)

    Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (Seasonal and diurnal behavior) Average Net Schedule (MW) Month 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ Battery tends to: 2 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ 3 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐  Charge at relatively high levels during off- 4 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ peak

  53. Slide 53: Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (Seasonal and diurnal behavior)

    Example 50MW 4-hr battery dispatch (Seasonal and diurnal behavior) Average Net Schedule (MW) Average State-of-Charge (MWh) Month Month 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ 1 2 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ 2 3 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ 3 4 ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐ 4

  54. Slide 54: Example ancillary service provisions (Annual average)

    Example ancillary service provisions (Annual average) Average reserve requirements and portions met with 50MW 4-hr battery in 2021 test portfolio (preliminary) Upward Reserves Average amount met with storage* Downward Reserves Average system need* Battery system tends to provide:  A significant por

  55. Slide 55: Preliminary operational cost impacts in 2021 test portfolio

    Preliminary operational cost impacts in 2021 test portfolio  Energy storage systems modeled in 2021 test portfolio saved between ~$4.4M/yr and ~$7.5M/yr of operating costs, depending on size and duration, assuming PGE dispatch  This translates into per unit operational value of: ~$90/kW-yr for a 5

  56. Slide 56: Energy shifting versus ancillary services

    Energy shifting versus ancillary services Ancillary services Energy shifting  Operational value encompasses both energy shifting and ancillary services  50MW, 2-hr battery system in 2021 test portfolio:  ~60% energy shifting, ~40% ancillary services  This breakdown is anticipated to vary by port

  57. Slide 57: System peaking capability

    System peaking capability  Two methodologies are used to approximate system peaking capability/capacity contribution of a grid-connected battery system being operated by PGE Duration-based approximation RECAP-based approximation (Upper bound) (Lower bound)  Background: Other jurisdictions (e.g. 

  58. Slide 58: Portfolio cost impact

    Portfolio cost impact  Capacity value represents the cost savings associated with avoiding procurement of additional capacity resources to meet reliability requirements  In IRP portfolio analysis, Frame Combustion Turbines (CTs) are the default capacity resource incorporated into each portfolio to

  59. Slide 59: Capacity value approach

    Capacity value approach  Sometimes it is easier to think about the economic comparison between a battery and the “capacity-equivalent” default capacity resource through a capacity value or system peaking value associated with the battery Example: 50MW 2-hr battery cost effectiveness relative to Fra

  60. Slide 60: Storage economic analysis in 2016 IRP

    Storage economic analysis in 2016 IRP  The operational cost impacts of the 2-hr and 4-hr duration storage cases in the ROM 2021 test portfolio were used to evaluate the cost effectiveness of four potential energy storage devices/fleets:  2-hr Lithium Ion Batteries (50MW and 100MW)  4-hr Redox Flo

  61. Slide 61: Additional considerations and next steps

    Additional considerations and next steps  The methodology presented here is under ongoing development Next steps:  Engage the ROM Technical Review Committee to refine modeling  Continue to research methodologies for determining the capacity contribution of energy storage resources  Expand energy

  62. Slide 62: Additional considerations and next steps

    Additional considerations and next steps  Energy storage technology costs are rapidly dropping and highly uncertain Vehicle battery cost trajectories Grid‐connected batteries Source: Nykvist & Nilsson, Nature Climate Change, 2015.  This environment requires ongoing evaluation and incorporation of

  63. Slide 63: Next Steps

    Aa Sp’ Ss Next Steps Cooriana General v4 Electric

  64. Slide 64: 2016 IRP Timeline

    2016 IRP Timeline The 2016 IRP evaluates a planning horizon through 2050 2016 2017 - 2020 2021 - 2050 August 17, 2016 2013 IRP Distribute File OPUC 20% RPS Clean 50% RPS Update Draft IRP Final IRP Acknowledgement Power Boardman cease Plan coal operations (Dec 2015) (Sept 2016) (Nov 2016) (2017) (202

  65. Slide 65: IRP, RPIP, and RFP Timelines

    IRP, RPIP, and RFP Timelines Efficient acknowledgement processes are required to meet resource need timing Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 2017 ‘17 Q2 ’17 Q3 ‘17 Q4 2016 IRP 2016 IRP Development Draft Review 2016 IRP Commission Process Distribute Draft File Final OPUC 2016 IRP 2016 IRP Acknowledgement 2016

  66. Slide 66: Draft Responsive Action Plan

    Draft Responsive Action Plan1 Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Action Timing 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Renewable 20% RPS 2016 IRP All Resource / Capacity Acknowledged Supply-side  Renewable2 0-175 MWa Quickly evolving resource needs  Capacity 800-850 MW plus  Annual 400-850 MW (dispatchable)  Seasonal 0-600 M

  67. Slide 67: 2021 Incremental Capacity Need

    2021 Incremental Capacity Need MW 1,400 • Estimated annual contributions1 RFP Acquisitions • Need includes EE actions, Spot 1,200 Market, new DSG, and new DR, 1,000 • Renewable: 0-60 MW1 Annual resource: 400-850 MW 2021 Capacity Need • 800 • Seasonal product: 0-300 MW1 winter 0-500 MW 600 summer 0-6

  68. Slide 68: Responsive Action Plan

    Responsive Action Plan Enables resource acquisition through an adaptable roadmap which is responsive to changes which occur from the time the Action Plan is acknowledged - Periodically update information (i.e. more frequently than with IRP filing) - Gas price forecast (annual) Key drivers of resourc

  69. Slide 69: Next IRP

    Ari Aa Sp’ Ss Next IRP Cooriana General v4 Electric

  70. Slide 70: Next IRP

    Next IRP Key issues and potential areas of focus for next IRP General industry/national trends Flattening/declining load Carbon policy uncertainty Aging Infrastructure Changing resource diversity Variable and distributed resource integration Increasing capacity and ancillary services needs Loss of c

  71. Slide 71: Next IRP

    Next IRP Research to inform the next IRP is conducted through Enabling Studies Wholesale Market Risk Evaluate the financial and physical risks of the wholesale market given shifts in the region which may move the system to a regional capacity deficit. Energy Imbalance Market Study how Western EIM pa

  72. Slide 72: Thank You!

    Thank You! Feedback welcome 24/7 at:  https://www.portlandgeneral.com/forms/ pge-stakeholder-feedback  www.portlandgeneral.com/irp  irp@pgn.com 72

  73. Slide 73: 2016 IRP Feedback Roundup

    Cooriana General v4 Electric \ eas t Sp’ Ss

  74. Slide 74: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed For stakeholder questions, provide a General Passing the mic was cumbersome. stationary microphone at a podium or mics at 4/13/2015 each table. Update schedule slides to account for automation. Plan to revise and post updated Pro

  75. Slide 75: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Load Forecast For future discussion, how is the ETO PGE to address questions about EE projection 7/15/15 and Methodology forecast in later years developed? in the future. Refer to April 2nd Slide 31. 7/16/15 Comment on in‐fill vs

  76. Slide 76: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is engaging the ETO on a number of DR programs, particularly with Energy Partner and the smart thermostat pilot. Our current plan is to How is PGE using the convergence of EE only attribute incremental demand reductions Deman

  77. Slide 77: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Would PGE provide a copy of the DR study, Demand along with the assumptions (particularly PGE uploaded the final report to 02/16/16 Response materials supporting the basis for electric portlandgeneral.com heating load control)? R

  78. Slide 78: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is willing to host detailed modeling Can there be discussions about the Clean discussions; we look forward to receiving Futures Power Plan and mass vs. rate‐based detailed feedback regarding the specific 12/17/15 modeling? as

  79. Slide 79: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The definition is dependent on the What is PGE's definition of dependable particular capacity assessment question. hydro capacity or what does it mean in this PGE presented an overview of the PRM Study 12/17/15 context? What meth

  80. Slide 80: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Can PGE provide clarification on the net The plant capacities were discussed in the PRM Study 12/17/15 capacities used in winter and summer? 12/17/15 Public meeting. As in the 2013 IRP, the PRM Study models Why does DSM not chang

  81. Slide 81: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Is PGE going to treat Carty as an existing Yes. PGE’s correspondence with EPA Clean Power resource? Can PGE provide the regarding Carty is ongoing. PGE is willing to 12/17/15 Plan correspondence between PGE and EPA share the lett

  82. Slide 82: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Can the report be provided to Yes. The report will be included in the 2016 Climate Study Est. 7/29/2016 stakeholders? IRP. Is the study providing information about plant cooling requirements? Transmission No. The focus of the rep

  83. Slide 83: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE forecasted commercial energy growth rate of 0.9% (presented at the June 2015 load forecast workshop, slide 14) reflects growth in secondary delivery voltage service, of which small commercial (defined Commercial growth rate a

  84. Slide 84: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE tracks economic indicators such as the unemployment rate, unemployment claims, employment levels and growth by industry sector and building permits for the state of Oregon and counties within PGE service territory. PGE’s sour

  85. Slide 85: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE collaborates with the Energy Trust to increase customer awareness and participation in Energy Trust small to mid‐sized commercial energy efficiency programs through outreach and marketing activities. PGE has a three outreach

  86. Slide 86: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed How has PGE focused on the smaller commercial customer group to realize PGE primarily focuses on lighting projects in Energy potential in conservation through lighting the activities described below due to the 03/09/16 Conservati

  87. Slide 87: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Energy Trust and PGE are co‐marketing the Rush Hour Rewards program with the Energy Trust’s smart thermostat rebates. Both parties are providing links to the other’s websites/enrollment portals. Energy Trust promotes Rush You men

  88. Slide 88: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The uncertainty lies in the opt‐in components, in particular time‐of‐use rates without a peak time rebate component. Preliminary results of initial enrollment show that signing up customers on these rates can be tough and often r

  89. Slide 89: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE’s year 1 evaluation is available upon request. The final year 2 report will be provided to staff along with our annual report 4/29/16. Please share your evaluation of the Energy In general, participants in Energy Partner are

  90. Slide 90: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed What does “identifying the system benefit The evaluation will identify both the benefit of targeted peak energy usage both in terms of average peak reductions Integrated Grid education….” mean? Does it mean (our planning estimate

  91. Slide 91: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The biggest component that differentiates the high case form the others is the default time‐variant rates. We have received If the High Case programs are cost feedback from several stakeholders (most effective, listing the barrie

  92. Slide 92: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE presented data from RECAP runs for 2025 and 2030 in the 03/09/2016 meeting Slide 89 (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015) states (Roundtable #16‐1). The presentation also that generalizations will be made for capacity included capacit

  93. Slide 93: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE discussed this issue in the 12/17/2015 Public Meeting and the 03/09/2016 Round Slide 91 (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015), Table. It is on the list to investigate for the Please add energy efficiency to this list of next IRP cycle

  94. Slide 94: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is studying 2021, 2025, and 2030 for Generally, why study 2021 for ELCC and resource adequacy and renewable capacity Futures & 2025 for portfolio coverage? Why the contribution. Resource portfolio cross‐ 05/16/2016 Portfolios

  95. Slide 95: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE’s portfolio creation process was generally described verbally rather than illustrated visually, and did not consider How was this portfolio creation process factors such as ELCC or attempt make Futures & illustrated in the pa

  96. Slide 96: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Please describe the methodology used in Futures & determining the Capacity needs vs the PGE needs more information to address this 05/09/2016 Portfolios market needs for slides 99 and 100 (Public question. Meeting, 12/17/2015). P

  97. Slide 97: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status

    2016 IRP: Feedback Status Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Futures & Please provide an exploration of how SB The May 16, 2016 presentation will address 05/16/2016 Portfolios 1547 affects resource choices near‐term. this feedback. Discuss how later RPS obligations (2025; Futures & 2030; 2

Portland General Electric — Corporate Update (August 2016) on 6ix