Jefferson Bancshares — Merger or Acquisition (January 2014)
16 slides from Jefferson Bancshares's merger presentation, Jan 23, 2014

Slide 1: HomeTrust Bancshares Acquisition of Jefferson Bancshares
HometTrust Bancshares, Inc. Acauisition of efferson Bancshares, Inc. January 2014 x HomeTrust Bancshares, Inc. Lt just bettor here

Slide 2: Forward Looking Statements
Forward Looking Statements WE This presentation may contain certain forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements include statements regarding anticipated future events and can be identified by the fact that they do not relate strictly to historical or current facts. They often include word

Slide 3: Additional Information
Additional Information i . HomeTrust, Bancshares, Inc. willfile a registration statement on Form S-4 with the SEC in connection with the proposed transaction. The registration statement will include a proxy statement of Jefferson Bancshares, Inc. that also constitutes @ prospectus of HomeTrust, whic

Slide 4: Key Transaction Terms
Key Transaction Terms x + $8.00 per share Transaction Value + Approximately $51.2 million of aggregate transaction value* + Approximately 102% of tangible book value Consideration + 50% HomeTrust stock, 50% Cash + Jefferson Bancshares, Inc. shareholder approval + Regulatory approvals Required Approv

Slide 5: Compelling Strategic Partnership Rationale
Compelling Strategic Partnership Rationale 7 + Acquisition in higher-growth markets consistent with HTBI’s long term growth strategy Strategic + Creates an institution with $2.1 billion in assets, well-positioned in key NC, SC Rationale and TN markets * Strong community relationships with an experie

Slide 6: Pro Forma Franchise
Pro Forma Franchise Follows Interstate 40 and Interstate 26 Corridors p = ( VIRGINIA hlights 33 $2.1 billion $15 billion Deposits $1.6 billion Equity $392.0 million ee”

Slide 7: Jefferson Bancshares, Inc. (JFBI)
Jefferson Bancshares, Inc. (JFBI) 4% a Company Highl Headquarters Morristown, TN Bank Established 1963 Branches 12 Total Assets $498.6 million * Total Loans, Net $314.0 million * Total Deposits $396.0 million * Tier 1 Leverage Ratio 10.10% * Total Common Equity / TotalAssets 10.69% * NPAs / Assets.

Slide 8: Jefferson Market Highlights
Jefferson Market Highlights x se Market Overview Market Demographic Highlights + Branch footprint in large, high-growth Population of JFBI markets Tennessee metropolitan areas + 1,480,266 + The Tri-Cities are home to East j i 1 Tennessee State University, Eastman Projected Population Growth Chemical

Slide 9: Financial Impact of Strategic Partnership
Financial Impact of Strategic Partnership x EEE Merger Assumptions Pro Forma Analysis Gross credit mark of 3.3% or $10.5 Balance Sheet million on Jefferson Bancshares, Inc. (As of 09/30/2013) Pre-tax merger related costs of $5.5 Total Assets $2.1 billion million Total Loans $1.5 billion Expected TBV

Slide 10: Loan Portfolio
Loan Portfolio x HomeTrust Jefferson Owner- Occupied CRE oe Consumer 1% Const & Consumer Other Fond 1% CRE 9% Owner- Occupied CRE Multifamily 21% on Multifamily 3% Total Loans: $1.2 billion * Total Loans: $0.3 billion * Pro Forma Consumer Const & 1% ‘Land ‘Owner- ‘Occupied CRE 11% Multifamily 2% Tot

Slide 11: Deposit Portfolio
Deposit Portfolio x EEE HomeTrust Jefferson Pro Forma Jumbo Time dushe Time Deposits epost 21% 23% Total Deposits: $1.3 billion Total Deposits: $0.4 billion Total Deposits: $1.6 billion Total Checking: $299.8 million Total Checking: $108.0 million Total Checking: $407.8 million * Data as of Septembe

Slide 12: Company Overview: HomeTrust Bancshares, Inc.
Company Overview: HomeTrust Bancshares, Inc. x (NASDAQ: HTBI) + Founded in 1926 Overview + 10th largest North Carolina community bank + In July 2012, converted from the mutual to stock form of organization Dedicated to long-term community banking model Banking Model / Goal is to compete with larger

Slide 13: Infrastructure and Experience For Strategic Partnerships
Infrastructure and Experience For Strategic Partnerships x SSL - Most significant way to build franchise and market share Pursuing See Capture synergies and economies of scale GUreiicramm - See opportunity for earnings growth with new partnerships + Significant experience with bank acquisitions — th

Slide 14: Drivers for Community Banks to Consider HTBI
Drivers for Community Banks to Consider HTBI x asa Se Partner Regulatory climate Reason to Partner Low growth economic environment Find a strong partner and “ride their currency” through the consolidation wave Increasingly complex regulatory and technological environment to navigate Regulatory Conme

Slide 15: Transaction Summary
Transaction Summary x EEE Transaction positions HTBI for EPS growth of approximately $0.18 per share and overall increased shareholder value Expansion into Kingsport/Johnson City, Knoxville, and Morristown markets with the right personnel and platform to support growth Ability to increase loan volum

Slide 16: Investor Contacts
Investor Contacts x EEE Dana Stonestreet Chairman, President & CEO Tony VunCannon Senior VP, CFO & Treasurer 10 Woodfin Street Asheville, NC 28801 (828) 259-3939 www.hometrustbanking.com
Source: SEC EDGAR · 425 filed Jan 23, 2014
