Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — presentatie sveen
24 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's investor presentation, Mar 28, 2012
Slide 1: Capital Accumulation, Sectoral Heterogeneity and the Taylor Principle
Capital Accumulation, Sectoral Heterogeneity and the Taylor Principle Tommy Sveen BI Norwegian Business School March 28, 2012 TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 1 / 24
Slide 2: Introduction: Research Question
Introduction Research Question How does capital accumulation change the determinacy properties of new Keynesian models? TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 2 / 24
Slide 3: Introduction: Motivation
Introduction Motivation There is a sizeable literature on determinacy properties of NK models (see, e.g., Clarida et al 1999): The Taylor principle: the central bank should change the nominal interest rate by more than one-for-one with changes in in‡ation. TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 3 / 24
Slide 4: Introduction: Motivation
Introduction Motivation The analysis has been extended to allow for capital accumulation: Carlstrom and Fuerst (2005): capital accumulation make it almost impossible for forward-looking rules to deliver determinacy. Sveen and Weinke (2005): …rm-speci…c capital accumulation make the Taylor principle
Slide 5: Introduction: Motivation
Introduction Motivation Most analyses of determinacy in the existing literature have been conducted in the context of highly simply…ed models: The goal of the present paper is to analyze determinacy in the context of a model featuring two sectors: One sector produces investment goods and the other s
Slide 6: Introduction: Motivation
Introduction Motivation The aim of the analysis is twofold: Analyze determinacy properties in an interesting extention of the "baseline" model: Recent interest in business cycle analysis in "investment speci…c shocks" and "relative price of investment goods" (e.g. Justiani et al 2010). Compared to a
Slide 7: The Model: Three types of agents
The Model Three types of agents Households Firms Producers of consumer goods Procucers of investment goods Monetary authorities TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 7 / 24
Slide 8: The Model: Households
The Model Households In…nitely lived families consisting of two types of family members: One type working in the investment goods sector and the other in the consumer goods sector. Consider also the case with integrated labor market across the two sectors. Household members maximize lifetime utility
Slide 9: Consumer (investment) goods firms
The Model Consumer (investment) goods …rms Produce di¤erentiated consumer (investment) goods using capital and labor. Invest and accumulates their own capital stock (…rm-speci…c capital). Firms act under monopolistic competition and set prices in a staggered fashion. TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 9
Slide 10: Market Clearing and Monetary Policy
The Model Market Clearing and Monetary Policy Markets clear for all goods and for all types of labor. Monetary policy take the form of a simple interest rate rule. TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 10 / 24
Slide 11: Log-linearized model
The Model Log-linearized model The household optimality problem gives rize to a standard consumer Euler equation for consumption, ct : ct = E t f ct + 1 g rrt , (1) where: rrt rt Et π c ,t +1 ρ is the consumption real interest rate. rt and π c ,t are the nominal interest rate and CPI in‡ation. TS (N
Slide 12: Log-linearized model
The Model Log-linearized model Nominal wage in‡ation, ω t , is given by: ω j ,t = βEt fω j ,t +1 g + κ w [mrsj ,t wj ,t ] for j = c, i (2) The the marginal rates of substitution, mrst , and the (consumer) real wages, wt , are mrsj ,t = ct + φnj ,t for j = c, i (3) wj ,t = wj ,t 1 + ω j ,t π c ,t , w
Slide 13: Log-linearized model
The Model Log-linearized model Aggregate production in sector j, yj ,t , is: yj ,t = (1 αj ) nj ,t + αj kj ,t for j = c, i (4) where kj ,t is the capital stock and αj is the capital share in sector j. The law of motion of capital stocks kj ,t +1 = (1 δ) kj ,t + ij ,t for j = c, i (5) where it is inv
Slide 14: Log-linearized model
The Model Log-linearized model Price setting implies familiar NK Phillips curves π c ,t = βEt fπ c ,t +1 g + κ c ,p mcc ,t , (6) π i ,t = βEt fπ i ,t +1 g + κ i ,p (mci ,t bI ,t ) , p (7) where pbI ,t = p bI ,t 1 + π i ,t π c ,t is the relative price of investment goods. Real marginal costs are mcj
Slide 15: Log-linearized model
The Model Log-linearized model The investment/capital ratios ij ,t = kj ,t + eψ (qj ,t bI ,t ) p (9) Tobin’s Q in the two sectors qj ,t = βEt fqj ,t +1 g + (1 β (1 δ)) Et fmsj ,t +1 g bI ,t +1 g δβEt fp (rt Et fπ i ,t +1 g) for j = c, i (10) The real shaddow rental prices of capital msj ,t = mcj ,t
Slide 16: Log-linearized model
The Model Log-linearized model Clearing in the consumer goods market: ct = yc ,t (12) Clearing in the investment goods market: IC II yi ,t = ic ,t + ii ,t (13) YI YI Monetary policy: rt = τ π Et π c ,t +k for k 2 f0, 1g (14) TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 16 / 24
Slide 17: Results: Calibration
Results Calibration I choose standard parameter values: Parameter Value Justi…cation β 0.99 Steady state annual real interest rate of 4%. η 1 Labor supply elasticity of 1. eN 6 Mark-up in wage setting of about 20%. θw 0.75 Nominal wage stickiness of 4 quarters. e 11 10% mark-up on goods. α 0.36 Capi
Slide 18: Current-looking monetary policy: integrated labor markets
Results Current-looking monetary policy Integrated labor markets and common price stickiness Integrated labor market 15 10 c π τ 5 Determinacy Indet. 0 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 θ TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 18 / 24
Slide 19: Integrated vs sectoral labor markets
Results Current-looking monetary policy Integrated vs sectoral labor markets: Integrated labor market 15 10 c π τ 5 Determinacy Indet. 0 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 θ Sectoral labor market 15 10 c π τ 5 Determinacy Indet. 0 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 θ TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 19 / 24
Slide 20: Adding heterogeneity in price stickiness
Results Current-looking monetary policy Adding heterogeneity in price stickiness: TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 20 / 24
Slide 21: Adding more heterogeneity
Results Current-looking monetary policy Adding more heterogeneity: TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 21 / 24
Slide 22: Forward-looking monetary policy
Results Forward-looking monetary policy Forward-looking policy and heterogeneity in price stickiness: 5 4 3 Indeterminacy c π τ 2 Det. 1 0 In d 0.8 e te rm in a 0.7 cy 0.6 0.6 0.4 0.2 θ 0.5 0 c θ i TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 22 / 24
Slide 23: Adding more heterogeneity
Results Current-looking monetary policy Adding more heterogeneity: 5 4 3 Indeterminacy c Determinacy π τ 2 1 0 In d 0.8 e te rm in a 0.7 cy 0.6 0.6 0.4 0.2 θ 0.5 0 c θ i TS (NB) Indeterminacy 28/03/12 23 / 24
Slide 24: Conclusion
Conclusion Related literature overstate the likelihood of indeterminacy in New Keynesian models with capital accumulation if the central bank follows the Taylor principle. Key to the increased probability of determinacy is volatility of the real price of investment goods. In stark contrast to the ex