Stec — Proxy Contest (June 2013)
63 slides from Stec's proxy contest presentation, Jun 20, 2013
Slide 1: Unlocking Value at sTec
Unlocking Value at sTec June 20, 2013
Slide 2: About Balch Hill and Potomac Capital
About Balch Hill and Potomac Capital > Founded by Simon J. Michael in 1998, Balch Hill Capital, LLC (“Balch Hill”) is an investment adviser and is the General Partner of Balch Hill Partners, L.P.,a hedge fund. Locatedin San Francisco, Balch Hill takes a contrarian approach to investing in high tech
Slide 3: Why Change is Needed at sTec
Why Change is Needed at sTec + The current Board has overseen the destruction of significant shareholder value. — sTec’s stock price has declined approximately 89% since August 2009." — Revenues have declined 7%over the past two years. = sTec’s market share has declined from an estimated 68.6% in 20
Slide 4: Timeline
Timeline BALCH HILL s
Slide 5: sTec Business Overview
sTec Business Overview * sTec became the early leader in Solid State Drives (SSDs) for the enterprise market after acquiring Gnutek, Ltd., a technology innovator in high performance SSDs, in October 2006. * SSDs in the enterprise market can read/write data hundreds of times faster than Hard Disk Dri
Slide 6: SSD Market Expected to Triple from 2011 - 2016
SSD Market Expected to Triple from 2011 - 2016 ) Market Trends* Enterprise SSD Market Revenue omer mpce mses sara | "Exteral Storage ‘intemal Storage (3 of more dives) ass ‘Cloud (Direct or OOM Purchase) arc cache Low Enaiade Server ‘mworrstation sece:100 ‘Source: sTacinvestor Presentation February
Slide 7: Demand for Enterprise Storage SSDs is Incredibly Strong
Demand for Enterprise Storage SSDs is Incredibly Strong Strong Growth in Enterprise Storage SSDs (Sin lions) $3,500.0 $3,000.0 $2,500.0 $2,000.0 $1,500.0 $1,000.0 $500.0 $0.0 2010 2011 2012 2013€ 2014€ ‘Source: Stfe/Gartner estimates BALCH HILL
Slide 8: sTec Understood the Growth Potential...
sTec Understood the Growth Potential... The Company confidently predicted dramatic growth for sTec on its February 14, 2011 earnings call: “if you look at overall SSD or ZeusIOPS that we are shipping today, it ranges between 20,000 to 25,000 units per quarter. The discussions that we are having with
Slide 9: The Current Board Did Not See Crisis Coming
The Current Board Did Not See Crisis Coming At the Company's conference call held on November 8, 2011, Manouch Moshayedistated, — “Because we continue to invest heavily in our R&D and have plans to introduce new products that are faster; lower priced and more efficient, we expect to have a large mar
Slide 10: What Happened?
What Happened? The current Board did not see the crisis coming and has overseen a dramatic deterioration in the Company’s stock price and operating and financial performance, squandering sTec’s early market lead, even as the SSD market grows strongly. a BALCH HILL
Slide 11: Significant Destruction of Shareholder Value
Significant Destruction of Shareholder Value Since Manouch and Mark Moshayedi sold approximately $279 million of sTec stock in August 2009 at $31.00 per share, the stock has dropped 89%, to $3.44 on June 17, 2013, resultingin the destruction of over $1.3 Billion. Daily (%Change) (Left) STEC-STEC INC
Slide 12: Dismal Share Performance
Dismal Share Performance sTec’s stock price has also materially underperformed its peers 1 year vs. Peers a a a a a a a a) STEC US Equity (STEC Ine) Graph 315 Copyrightt 2013 Bloomberg Finance LP. a7-2un-2013 1181356 BALCH HILL
Slide 13: Dismal Share Performance years vs. Peers
Dismal Share Performance 3 years vs. Peers 100 oo 40 0 20 7 30 Dec War Seat Sep Dee Harn Sap Baar Sor 2011 2012 2013 STEC US Equity (STEC Inc) Graph 315 Weekly 182010-1720N2013 Copyrights 2013 Bloomberg Finance LP. 7-2un-2013 11454 BALCH HILL
Slide 14: Dismal Share Performance years vs. Peers
Dismal Share Performance 5 years vs. Peers mstec us FIO.US NOK US Bwocus 2008 2009 2010 STEC US Equity (STEC Inc) Graph 315 Weekly 189UN2008-179UN2013 BALCH HILL 20 212 Copyright 2013 Bloomberg Finance L., 203 17-dun-2013 11:16:02
Slide 15: Plummeting Revenues
Plummeting Revenues Total revenue for the three months ended March 31, 2013 are down 56% from the same period a year ago and down 77% from the same period two years ago, despite significant increases in R&D spending. sTec Revenues ‘Sin thousands) Moros. Sep-09 © Mando Sep-d0.— Marat Sept Mart2 Sept
Slide 16: Soaring R&D Expenses
Soaring R&D Expenses sTec has spent over $66 million in R&D for the year ended December 31, 2012, an over 58% increase since fiscal 2009, and only reduced its R&D spend in a meaningful way after we filed our initial Schedule 13D in November 2012. sTec R&D Expense in thousands) BALCH HILL
Slide 17: "Life Threatening" Operating Performance
“Life Threatening” Operating Performance sTec has suffered operating losses of over $103 million for the year ended December 31, 2012, an over 510% decline in operating income from the year earlier. Operating losses have continued in 2013, with the Company reporting an operating loss of over $25 mil
Slide 18: A Once Strong Balance Sheet is Now in Serious Decline
A Once Strong Balance Sheet is Now in Serious Decline sTec Cash and Liquid Assets inthewsan) $350,000 $300,000 $200,000 $150,000 4 sooo | | 350000 + 30 » we s o 9 Cad we ecash A equialents — mettajor Liquid Assets less Payables “Our model forecasts cash/investments to decline from $2.84/share ending
Slide 19: Abysmal Corporate Governance Culture
Abysmal Corporate Governance Culture + Manouch Moshayedi remained Chairman and CEO while facing an SEC investigation for insider trading and for two months after he was charged by the SEC with insider trading. * The Nominating Committee chose to re-nominate him to the Board in 2013, even though the
Slide 20: Excessive Executive Compensation
Excessive Executive Compensation * Since 2009, Manouch Moshayedi has received over $9.7 million in total compensation and Mark Moshayedi has received over $5.8 million, despite the Company’s declining financial and stock price performance. * Manouch Moshayedi continued to receive the same salary and
Slide 21: Excessive Executive Compensation
Excessive Executive Compensation Manouch Moshayedi, Mark Moshayedi, Raymond Cook (CFO) and Robert Saman (Chief Counsel) collectively are entitled to receive approximately $4.5 million in largely cash benefits if they are terminated after a change of control. In March 2013, Raymond Cook (CFO) and Rob
Slide 22: Manouch and Mark +$285 million vs. Shareholders -$1.3 billion
Manouch and Mark +$285 million vs. Shareholders -$1.3 billion Manouch and Mark Moshayedi combined have received over $285 million from sTec since the beginning of 2009: Sale of stock in August 2009 = approximately $268 million in gross proceeds Total compensation = over $15.5 million sTec leases two
Slide 23: The Rise and Fall(s) of sTec
The Rise and Fall(s) of sTec 2008 2009 | 2010 I 2011 22 2013 STEC US Equity (STEC Inc) Graph 335 ‘Copyright® 2013 Bloomberg Finance LP. 7-3-2013 11:22:00 BALCH HILL 2
Slide 24: The Rise: sTec Transforms to the Enterprise SSD leader
The Rise: sTec Transforms to the Enterprise SSD leader * October 2006 ~ sTec (then SimpleTech) acquires Gnutek, Ltd, a technology innovator in high performance SSDs. * January 2007 — sTec begins shipping enterprise class SSD + January 2008 - EMC selects Zeus-IOPS drives for deploymentin Symmetrix en
Slide 25: The Rise and Fall(s) of sTec
The Rise and Fall(s) of sTec sTec’s Flagship Product: Zeus-IOPS $120,000 ——Zeus-lOPS Revenues (Sin thoussnds) —ii-Total Revenues 100,000 80,000 60,000 40,000 20,000 0 Mar-08 Jul-o8 Nov-08 Mar-09 Jul-09 Nov-09 Mar-10 Jul-10 Nov-10 Mar-11 Juki. Nov-11 | Mar-12 Juk12 Nov-12 Mar-13 BALCH HILL
Slide 26: The Rise: Zeus-IOPS Growth Drives Higher Profitability
The Rise: Zeus-IOPS Growth Drives Higher Profitability * sTec enjoyed a virtual monopoly on enterprise SSD * Zeus-lOPS (enterprise class SSD) revenues skyrocketed to $58 million in Q2 2009 from $12 million a year earlier. * Zeus-lOPS drove Q2 2009 revenues to $86.3 million, up 53.7% from prior year
Slide 27: Current Board Squanders sTec 2009 Golden Opportunity
Current Board Squanders sTec 2009 Golden Opportunity + sTec was 2 years ahead of the competition in technology in 2009, and should have builtlong term relationships by walking the fine line of “pricing for value” + Instead, sTec charged high prices that we believe created an incentive for customers
Slide 28: Two Parts to sTec Fall
Two Parts to sTec Fall A yn Part 1: CK ‘ontroversial | Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses of $31.00, Huge stock sale by Moshayedis at stock price rather than raising capital for the Company. Three months later, stock plummets upon disclosure that a major customer's demand was less than expected. De
Slide 29: The Fall of sTec — Part 1: Controversial Insider Stock Sale
The Fall of sTec — Part 1: Controversial Insider Stock Sale + According to the SEC’s Complaint filed against Manouch Moshayedi for insider trading, the SEC alleges: Manouch sought to take advantage of a dramatically upward trend in the stock price of sTec through a secondary offering; The secondary
Slide 30: The Fall of sTec — Part 1: Controversial Insider Stock Sale
The Fall of sTec — Part 1: Controversial Insider Stock Sale SEC Complaint Timeline Daily (Standard* ) (Let) STEC=STECINC Bar 008 40}-| 7/28/2009: sec alleges Manouch learnslargest customer's demand may notbe as expectedfor30. Manouch 3s|_| sendsthe fllowingemal “knew asking youguysfore fovor would g
Slide 31: Fallout from SEC Litigation is Still Happening
Fallout from SEC Litigation is Still Happening SEC sought to add newand troubling facts to their Complaint in April 2013 * SEC alleges “Moshayedi falsely claimed that he had ‘no idea’ how much inventory EMC had accumulated or expected to accumulate” on November 3, 2009. * SEC alleges, in fact, Mosha
Slide 32: The Fall of sTec — Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses
The Fall of sTec — Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses Customer demand recovers after inventory issue, but OEM customers flee sTec when alternatives become available > 42009 revenues are $106 million, but decline 63% in Q1 2010 due to customer inventory issue. > From Q1 2010 to Q1 2011, revenues cli
Slide 33: The Fall of sTec — Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses
The Fall of sTec — Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses * Zeus-lOPSas a percent of Enterprise Storage SSD market declined rapidly, from an estimated 68.6% in 2009 to an estimated 3.3% in 2013. + IfsTec had been able to hold onto even a 20% market share, Zeus-IOPS revenues for 2012 would have exceeded
Slide 34: The Fall of sTec — Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses
The Fall of sTec — Part 2: Massive Market Share Losses $250,000 $200,000 $150,000 $100,000 $50,000 A BALCH HILL x STEC 2011 Top 3 Customers Revenues in 2012 vs. 2011 201 meme mien fe Hetscht
Slide 35: Analyst Details Severe Revenue Declines by Key Customers
Analyst Details Severe Revenue Declines by Key Customers “It's clear that despite strong products, STEC's traditional OEM customers appear to be abandoning the company.” - March 14, 2013, Edward Parker, Lazard Capital Markets STEC Revenue by Key Customer $70 1008 2008 3a08 4008 1009 2a09 3009 4a09 I
Slide 36: Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec?
Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec? Was the issue a static market? No. Market is Robust! * August 3, 2010: Manouch states “we believe that the adoption that is happening today in the market with the introduction of all of the data tiering softwares that are coming out, by mid-2011 the adoption should h
Slide 37: Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec?
Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec? Was sTec technology surpassed? No. Technology is still strong. + March 15, 2013 (Richard Shannon, analyst, Craig-Hallum,) "We are maintaining our Hold rating given our assumptions about the activists’ success and our continued belief in STEC’s products/technology. Ou
Slide 38: Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec?
Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec? Was the issue scale? No. sTec performed worse than its similarly-sized competitors. Revenues: STEC vs. FIO vs. OCZ ilions USERS ELS SELLELBAER STEC’s revenue performance has dramatically underperformed compared to stand alone SSO suppliers, particularly FIO STEC’srev
Slide 39: Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec?
Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec? We believe the SSD market is transitioning and scale matters, but it does not explain sTec’s dramatic underperformance * The two customers who hurt sTec the most were HGST and Samsung, two very large competitors of sTec. * However, sTec still dramatically underperfor
Slide 40: Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec?
Why Did OEM Customers Flee sTec? » Customers sought to “design out” sTec (i.e., to completely replace sTec as a supplier) rather than to seek a second source supplier to create more competitive pricing > We have extensively surveyed industry participants, and this is what we hear about sTec: = Found
Slide 41: We Are Concerned With sTec's Strategy
We Are Concerned With sTec’s Strategy sTec’s Strategy to Replace Customers Rather than Management is a “Red Herring” * The current Board realizes sTec has lost massive OEM market share. In response, the Board has developed a new sales strategy of direct-to- customer sales and channel sales. A strate
Slide 42: Pursuing a Strategy Previously Dismissed
Pursuing a Strategy Previously Dismissed “First of all, building a distribution channel is not something that can be done overnight. It takes months if not years to build a proper channel out there. But, at the end of the day, this is a product that has to get integrated into an OEM system... ...[a
Slide 43: Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Unlock Value at sTec
Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Unlock Value at sTec a a BALCH HILL
Slide 44: Addressing Potential Leadership Vacuum
Addressing Potential Leadership Vacuum If Mark Moshayedi decides to step-down as CEO following the election of our Nominees, we have identified three highly qualified CEO candidates to serve on an interim basis until the Board selects anew CEO after a thorough search process. Each of these candidate
Slide 45: Hire Well-Qualified, Independent CEO
Hire Well-Qualified, Independent CEO * Our nominees would push the Board to immediately engage in a thorough search for a new, independent CEO. * We believe most customers simply will not reengage with sTec while Manouch and Mark are in control, or are perceived to be in control. * Board must hold t
Slide 46: Mark Moshayedi was the Wrong Person to Replace Manouch
Mark Moshayedi was the Wrong Person to Replace Manouch * Mark Moshayedi sold along side Manouch in the secondary offering that is the subject of the SEC enforcement action against Manouch for insider trading (over $134 million worth of sTec stock). + MarkMoshayedi was President and COO during the ev
Slide 47: Mark Moshayedi Admits His Role Is Temporary
Mark Moshayedi Admits His Role Is Temporary Are you CEO or interim CEO of sTec? “Lam the interim CEO of the company.” —Mark Moshayedi When will you be replaced? “There is a case against my brother who use to be CEO and due to some regulations that exist in the U.S., he could no longer be the CEO. I'
Slide 48: Focus on sTec's Core Products
Focus on sTec’s Core Products sTec’s Technology Remains Outstanding! * Our nominees would push the Board to refocus its efforts and resources on SAS SSD sales to large storage OEM customers. * Company does have a broad, impressive product array: SAS, SATA, PCI Express, Caching software, but today’s
Slide 49: Reduce Costs and Closely Examine R&D Spending
Reduce Costs and Closely Examine R&D Spending * Cost structure is bloated. Our nominees would seek to rigorously reexamine all operating expenses to reduce costs. * Our nominees would set performance benchmarks for R&D spending. * R&D spending was $66 million in 2012 vs. $55 million in 2011, $44 mil
Slide 50: Explore All Strategic Alternatives
Explore All Strategic Alternatives Strategic Activity is High in the Solid State Storage Market Date Industry Incumbent Target Transaction March 2013 Toshiba Violin Memory Partnership March 2013 Western Digital Skyera Equity Investment- undisclosed sum January 2013 Seagate Virident Equity Investment
Slide 51: Our Nominees Are Better
Our Nominees Are Better ~~ BALCH HILL
Slide 52: Comparison of Directors
Comparison of Directors rience Clark Masters + Adam Leventhal + Erie Singer . Three decades of experience inthe technology industry Prior public company board experience within thetechnology industry, Currently, Senior VP, HANA Cloud Computingfor SAPAG, amultinational software company. revioushy was
Slide 53: Board Composition — Change is Necessary
Board Composition — Change is Necessary + Given the poor track record of the current sTec Board, we could make a strong argument that a majority of the Board should be changed. * Instead, we elected to nominate three directors (a minority) to preserve continuity andavoida change in control. We belie
Slide 54: Our Nominees Have the Right Experience to Address sTec's Problems
Our Nominees Have the Right Experience to Address sTec’s Problems Product Development Operational Oversight Evaluating R&D Spending Adam Leventhal: SNS Restoring Credibility With Market Reengagement with OEM customers Overseeing Leadership Change Clark Masters: SSS Shareholder Accountability Oversee
Slide 55: Adam Leventhal
Adam Leventhal * Age: 33 * Currently, CTO of Delphix Corp. * Former Director of Systems Engineering at Delphix * Lead Flash Engineer at Sun Microsystems and later at Oracle Corporation followingits acquisition + FoundingEngineer in Sun’s Fishworks group that designed and developed the ZFS Storage Ap
Slide 56: Clark Masters
Clark Masters Relevancyto sTec + Age: 63 + Currently, Senior VP, HANA Cloud Computing for SAP AG * Former President and CEO of Astute Networks * Former President and Chairman of Sun Microsystems Federal Inc. and held several other executive positions with Sun Microsystems. * Former director of Sonic
Slide 57: Eric Singer
Eric Singer + Age: 39 * Currently, co-managing member of Potomac Management Il and Potomac Management Ill * Current Chairman of the Board of Sigma Designs * Former Director of Zilog Corporation Relevancy to sTec + 18+ years of significant financial and investment experience + Proven track record of
Slide 58: Appendix
Appendix - Analyst Commentary - Additional Information on Peers A BALCH HILL
Slide 59: Analyst Commentary
Analyst Commentary + “We expect that STEC will continue to operate much as it has in the past as Mark and Manouch are on the same strategic page and Manouch is remaining with the company. As opposed to an OCZ-situation, where the CEO resigns from all roles within the company, this is merely a rearra
Slide 60: Analyst Commentary
Analyst Commentary + “Balch Hillis right. STEC results have been dire; there is no immediate remedy at hand, and it was on existing management's watch that things fell apart... the STEC chairman has so few good cards to play and is saying, in effect: "Trust us. (Whisper; we fouled up, but) we're bes
Slide 61: Who are sTec's Best Peers?
Who are sTec’s Best Peers? FUSION:IO Western Digital’ Samisk Fusion-I0, Ine. (NYSE:FIO} $1.34billion market cap /$433 million trailing 12 month revenues Revenue predominantly from solid state storage and software Leading provider of PCle based solid state storage solutions, just as sTec was ‘once le
Slide 62: Who are sTec's Best Peers?
Who are sTec’s Best Peers? OCZ IS NOT A GOOD PERFORMANCE PEER FOR STEC OCZ would be a good comparable but in late 2012 the Company disclosed that they had discovered accounting irregularities that have caused the restatement of multiple quarters. This restatement is still not complete. Notably, upon
Slide 63: sTec's Peers
sTec’s Peers Fusion /O Best comparable because of amilar scale and addresses the enterprize SSD server and storage market Western Diital Good comparable because ovns Hitachi GST, which isa leading supplier of SAS 880s although HODs are a much bigger driver of company's overall performance, SanDisk G