Barnes & Noble — Proxy Contest (September 2010)
56 slides from Barnes & Noble's proxy contest presentation, Sep 13, 2010
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Definitive Additional Materials
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A (RULE 14a-101) SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ¨ Check
Slide 2: Investor Presentation September 2010
Investor Presentation September, 2010
Slide 3: Important Information and Safe Harbor
Important Information and Certain Information Regarding Participants On August 25, 2010, Barnes & Noble, Inc. (“Barnes & Noble”) filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) a definitive proxy statement in connection with its 2010 Annual Meeting and has mailed the definitive proxy s
Slide 4: Why You Should Support Barnes & Noble
Why You Should Support Barnes & Noble We're here to ask you to support the Barnes & Noble Board of Directors highly qualified Director nominees and to reject Yucaipa's proposed resolution and Board slate. Our argument for supporting the Company and slate of nominees is six fold: 1) The book industry
Slide 5: The Bookselling Industry is Transforming
The Bookselling Industry is Transforming 4
Slide 6: Today's Investments in Our Strategy Will Lead to Significant Value Creation
We Are Confident Today’s Investments in Our Strategy Will Lead to Significant Value Creation for Shareholders $ in millions Total Comparable Sales EBITDA $10,000 $8,900 $600 > $500 $9,000 $500 $8,000 $7,100 $400 $7,000 $281 $5,810 $235 - $275 $300 $6,000 $200 $5,000 $4,000 $100 $3,000 $0 2010 2011P
Slide 7: Barnes & Noble – The World's Largest Bookseller
Barnes & Noble T –he World’s Largest Bookseller Barnes & Noble is a leading retailer in large multi-billion dollar markets. The company has approximately 18% market share 1 of the $23 billion consumer book industry 2 and 15% share of the $12 billion collegiate book market. 2 Additionally, Barnes & N
Slide 8: The Bookselling Industry is Transforming
The Bookselling Industry is Transforming Consumer spending on new physical books is expected to decline from $20.5 billion in ($ in millions) 2009 to $19 billion in 2014 CAGR 2009 2014 2009 - 2014 Spending on digital books is expected to New Books $20,536 $19,049 (1.5%) grow at a CAGR of 56.4%, from
Slide 9: Well Positioned to Gain Physical Book Market Share
Well Positioned to Gain Physical Book Market Share B&N is by far the strongest bookstore 2010 BKS Market Share* operator in the segment, having consistently outperformed the competition B&N has consistently gained bookstore market share against the competition Approximately 50% of books are sold at
Slide 10: Superior Bookstore Execution Has Led to Market Share Gains
Superior Bookstore Execution Has Led to Market Share Gains Source: Public Filings Source: Public Filings 9
Slide 11: Transformative Digital Strategy Leads to Further Market Share Gains
Transformative Digital Strategy Leads to Further Market Share Gains B&N believes the eBook market will be significantly less fragmented than 20% the physical book market. Within 12 months of the launch of its eBookstore, the company had 20% market share and established itself as the #2 player in thi
Slide 12: B&N's Multi-Faceted Digital Approach
B&N’sMulti-Faceted Digital Approach Created the most advanced eReaders in the marketplace Multi-channel/Multi-reach strategy differentiates Barnes & Noble from anyone else in this space Apps allow for support for over 400 devices Established partnerships with Best Buy (NOOK fixtures in 1,070 Best Bu
Slide 13: Digital Strategies are Driving Big Sales Increases
Digital Strategies are Driving Big Sales Increases The launch of the eBookstore served as 80% 75% a catalyst for comparable sales increases at BN.com and that has 70% further accelerated with the launch of 60% 53% NOOK – the company expects fiscal 50% 2011 comparable sales to increase 75%. 50% Membe
Slide 14: Bookstores are Driving NOOK Sales
Bookstores are Driving NOOK Sales… The company reaches over 40 million customers and is leveraging its leading market position to educate its customers about its digital products offerings. Simply put, Barnes & Noble Bookstores attract the core NOOK customer. Bookstores provide a distinct see, feel,
Slide 15: Digital Programs Are Driving Traffic Back To The Bookstores
And, Digital Programs Are Driving Traffic Back To The Bookstores The company is also using NOOK to drive traffic back to the bookstores after customers purchase the device through innovative features such as: – Read In Store™, where customers can browse and read complete eBooks for free while they a
Slide 16: Transforming the Bookstore Experience
Transforming the Bookstore Experience As B&N reduces the amount of space dedicated to shrinking categories such as music, it intends to leverage its brand and locations by selling additional complementary products. The company is in the process of rolling out its Toys & Games department, which is cu
Slide 17: Accelerating eCommerce Sales
Accelerating eCommerce Sales B&N’s investments in its digital platform, combined with recently BN.comComparable Sales introduced new strategies, such as every day low pricing and free 80% 75% unlimited express shipping for 70% Members are translating into strong business momentum and accelerated 60%
Slide 18: Transforming the Campus Bookstore
Transforming the Campus Bookstore Barnes & Noble is utilizing the strength of its digital platform and is at the forefront of transforming the college bookstore industry. The company offers college students and faculty the most comprehensive textbook offering in the marketplace. Since the College Bo
Slide 19: Digital Strategy Transforms Barnes & Noble into a Technology and Growth Company
Digital Strategy Transforms Barnes & Noble into a Technology and Growth Company $ in millions $9,000 $8,000 $7,000 $6,000 $5,000 $4,000 $3,000 69% Retail $2,000 $1,000 $0 2010 2011P 2012P 2013P 2014P Booksellers College bn.com 2010 Includes College results since acquisition date 18
Slide 20: BKS's Stock Performance Reflects Decline of Traditional Retail Bookselling
BKS’sStock Performance Reflects Decline of Traditional Retail Bookselling Ron Burkle’sattempt attempt to blame BKS’s stock performance on related party transactions is misleading 19
Slide 21: Analysts Recognize Potential in eBooks
Analysts Recognize Potential in eBooks “Barnes & Noble’s digital strategy has begun to pay off, with a 50% increase in ecommerce sales in 4Q10 and a forecasted 75% increase in fiscal 2011.” (Bank of America/Merrill Lynch, June 30, 2010) “The firm’s 20% market share of digital books (newly disclosed)
Slide 22: An Independent Special Committee is Reviewing Strategic Alternatives
An Independent Special Committee is Reviewing Strategic Alternatives to Maximize Shareholder Value 21
Slide 23: Review of Strategic Alternatives
Review of Strategic Alternatives We believe the market is undervaluing the digital opportunity for B&N On August 3, 2010, Barnes & Noble announced that its Board had formed a Special Committee to review strategic alternatives The Special Committee consists of four independent board members The Speci
Slide 24: Review of Strategic Alternatives
Review of Strategic Alternatives TheDelawareChanceryCourtrejectedRonBurkle’sargumentthat the Special Committee lacks independence – “The strategic process is to be led by a special committee of four of the company’s independent directors, a group that does not include any director this decision has
Slide 25: The Company's Related Party Transactions Support The Business
The Company’s Related Party Transactions Support The Business 24
Slide 26: Overview of Related Party Transactions
Overview of Related Party Transactions Relatedparty transactionprecededBKS'sIPOin 1993– whenall companies (B&N, B&N College, MBS) were privately owned All have been disclosed in SEC filings since IPO Independent Audit Committee reviews all related party transactions both when they occur and again ea
Slide 27: History of Related Party Transactions and the Barnes & Noble Brand
History of Related Party Transactions and the Barnes & Noble Brand 1965: B&N College founded by Len Riggio 1986: B&N College acquired B. Dalton Bookseller (754 stores) jointly with Vendex – B&NCollegeandBarnes& Noblewerekept astwo separateprivatecompaniesto provideVendexwith 50% ownership of Barnes
Slide 28: GameStop – Value Creation for Barnes & Noble Shareholders
GameStop –Value Creation for Barnes & Noble Shareholders GameStop Investment Return Acquired Babbage's ($209m) from Len Riggio in ($MM) 1999 and publicly traded Funco ($159m) in 2000 and consolidated them under GameStop brand Babbage's acquisition negotiated by independent special committee Expanded
Slide 29: College Transaction: Reunited Brand and Supports Digital Transformation
College Transaction: Reunited Brand and Supports Digital Transformation College owned Barnes & Noble trade name; reuniting the brand and reintegrating businesses was a top priority of the Board for many years By reuniting the brand and owning College, BKS has been able to: – Integrate its Internet a
Slide 30: College Transaction: Attractive Financial Terms Support Digital Strategy
College Transaction: Attractive Financial Terms Support Digital Strategy Independent special committee and independent financial and legal advisors reviewed and negotiated the transaction to ensure fairness to all shareholders $514 million purchase price includes $75 million of cash College had at c
Slide 31: MBS Supply Agreement is Key Competitive Advantage for College
MBS Supply Agreement is Key Competitive Advantage for College College has long-term Supply Agreement with MBS Textbook Exchange, Inc. (“MBS”), a leading U.S. wholesaler of new and used textbooks (majority owned by Len Riggio) – College purchases new and used printed textbooks from MBS prior to buyin
Slide 32: Ronald Burkle is Cherry-Picking Analyst Comments on The College Transaction
Ronald Burkleis Cherry-Picking Analyst Comments on The College Transaction Burkleclaims on slide 18 of his presentation that Bank of America/Merrill Lynch criticized the acquisition of College Booksellers, but here is what they said: – “... [W]e view the transaction favorably as it provides the comp
Slide 33: Ronald Burkle's Self-Serving Agenda is not in the Best Interest of Shareholders
We Believe Ronald Burkle’s Self-Serving Agenda is not in the Best Interest of Barnes & Noble Shareholders 32
Slide 34: Why You Should Reject Yucaipa's Nominees
Why You Should Reject Yucaipa’s Nominees Ronald Burklehas a history of taking control of companies without paying shareholders a premium –many with highly negative consequences We believe Mr. Burkle’sactions are part of his ongoing effort to gain control of Barnes & Noble – Yucaipa and Aletheia toge
Slide 35: Burkle and Aletheia – A Clear Pattern Emerges
Burkleand Aletheia– A Clear Pattern Emerges Barnes & Noble Ownership Percentage 3/31/2008 6/30/2008 9/30/2008 12/31/2008 3/31/2009 6/30/2009 9/30/2009 12/31/2009 3/31/2010 6/30/2010 Aletheia 0.4% 0.4% 0.6% 0.4% 5.7% 4.7% 4.8% 13.1% 17.1% 15.7% Yucaipa n/a n/a n/a 8.3% 8.3% 8.0% 8.0% 17.8% 18.7% 19.6
Slide 36: Mr. Burkle Claims That He Barely Knows Aletheia
Mr. BurkleClaimsThatHe “BarelyKnows”Aletheia– But Look at the Remarkable Pattern of Their Investments Barnes & Noble Whole Foods Market 12,000,000 12,000,000 10,000,000 10,000,000 8,000,000 8,000,000 6,000,000 6,000,000 4,000,000 4,000,000 2,000,000 2,000,000 0 0 3/31/2008 9/04/2008 2/08/2009 7/15/2
Slide 37: Shareholders Should Not Let Burkle Increase His Ownership
Shareholders Should Not Let Burkle Increase His Ownership He Has Proven to Serve His Own Interests Time and Time Again As the Delaware Chancery Court found: “Despite its protestations, Yucaipa’s prior investing history is replete with the sortsof investmentsthat often leadto transactionsin which pub
Slide 38: Shareholders Should Think Twice Before Allowing Burkle to Increase His Ownership
ShareholdersShouldThinkTwiceBeforeAllowingBurkleto IncreaseHisOwnership He Has Proven to Serve His Own Interests Time and Time Again Company Issue Comments Aletheia Follows No Shareholder Rights Plan was in place to protect shareholders and Yucaipa and Aletheiatogether now control approximately 45%
Slide 39: Shareholders Should Think Twice Before Allowing Burkle to Increase His Ownership
ShareholdersShouldThinkTwiceBeforeAllowingBurkleto IncreaseHisOwnership He Has Proven to Serve His Own Interests Time and Time Again Company Issue Comments Creeping Whileowning lessthan a majority of Source,Mr. Burkletook controlof board by reducingboardsizeso that Burkle’sdesigneesconstituted a maj
Slide 40: Shareholders Should Think Twice Before Allowing Burkle to Increase His Ownership
ShareholdersShouldThinkTwiceBeforeAllowingBurkleto IncreaseHisOwnership He Has Proven to Serve His Own Interests Time and Time Again Company Issue Comments Burkle Mr. Burkleacquireda 22%stakein SimonWorldwide (fkaCyrk)via warrants and convertible preferred shares and received 3 of 7 Board seats (Bur
Slide 41: Shareholders Should Think Twice Before Allowing Burkle to Increase His Ownership
ShareholdersShouldThinkTwiceBeforeAllowingBurkleto IncreaseHisOwnership He Has Proven to Serve His Own Interests Time and Time Again Company Issue Comments Ron Burklemade investments in Kmart (11/2000) and Fleming Companies Burkle (2/2001) Reportedly In same month Mr. Burklemade his investment in Fl
Slide 42: The Record Is Clear: Ron Burkle Pursues His Own Interests
In Our View The Record Is Clear: Ron Burkle Pursues His Own Interests – NOT That of All Shareholders Mr. Burkle’s 40+ page investor presentation lacks a single positive idea, plan or strategy for BKS TheBKSBoardbelievesBurkle’snomineeshavenovision,nostrategyand norelevantexperience to buildvalueat B
Slide 43: The Current Rights Plan is Necessary to Keep Burkle and Aletheia from Gaining Control
We Believe the Current Rights Plan is Necessary to Keep Burkle and Aletheiafrom Gaining Control Without Paying a Premium 42
Slide 44: Shareholder Rights Plan
Barnes & Noble Shareholder Rights Plan Adopted November 17, 2009 with a three-year term 20% triggering threshold Leonard Riggio frozen at pre-existing ownership level of approximately 30%, which includes options Barnes & Noble publicly committed to put the Rights Plan to a shareholder vote by Novemb
Slide 45: Rights Plan Protects Shareholders against the Formation of a Control Bloc
Rights Plan Protects Barnes & Noble Shareholders against the Formation of a Control Bloc Mr. Burkleclaimshe wants to level the playingfield, but his proposalto increase the ownership threshold to 30% would allow formation of an absolute control bloc –Burkleand Aletheiaalready own 34% Amongother thin
Slide 46: What Did the Court Say about Yucaipa and Aletheia?
What Did the Court Say about Yucaipa and Aletheia? What did the Courtsayabout Yucaipaand Aletheia’sdiscussionsabout Barnes & Noble? – “Theevidenceat trial alsoshowedthat EichlerandBurklehadmet for lunchin both August2009and January2010,althoughBurkledisclaimshavinghadanyseriousdiscussionsaboutBarnes
Slide 47: What Did the Court Say about the Rights Plan?
What Did the Court Say about the Rights Plan? What did the Court say about the Board’s adoption of the Rights Plan? – The Board’s“adoption anduseof the RightsPlanwasa good faith, reasonableresponseto a threat to Barnes & Noble and its stockholders” (p. 87) – “In response to this threat that the corp
Slide 48: How Can You Believe Burkle Does Not Want Control?
How Can You Believe BurkleDoes Not Want Control? Last November, Mr. Burkle’sSECfilingsreserved the right for Yucaipa to acquire all of the Company’s stock and Yucaipa notified the Company that it had requested U.S. antitrust clearance to do so This July, he testified in Court that he considered offe
Slide 49: Highly Qualified Slate With Two New Independent Nominees
Highly Qualified Slate With Two New Independent Nominees 48
Slide 50: Highly Qualified Slate with Two New Independent Nominees
Highly Qualified Slate with Two New Independent Nominees Leonard Riggio Visionary Founder, Chairman and former CEO of Barnes & Noble with 45+ years of entrepreneurial, executive and board-level experience Mr. Riggiohas led Barnes & Noble to become the nation's top bookseller brand for seven years in
Slide 51: The Board Believes Mr. Burkle's Nominees Are Neither Independent Nor Qualified
The Board Believes Mr. Burkle’s Nominees Are Neither Independent Nor Qualified Yucaipa’s “independent” nominees have been hand-picked by Burkle, are each being paid $100,000 to run andhaveeachhadprior dealingswith Burkle(1) In the Board’sview, Burkle’snomineesdo not havethe experienceto buildvalueat
Slide 52: Electing the Board's Nominees is in the Best Interests of B&N Shareholders
Electing the Board’s Nominees is in the Best Interests of B&N Shareholders Board nominees include the Founder and largest shareholder and two new highly-qualified independents Significant Experience in Book Industry, Technology, Education, Corporate Governance and Strategic Alternatives Strong Gover
Slide 53: Conclusion
Conclusion Barnes & Noble is at a crucial inflection point: Executing value-creating strategy in evolving industry with positive early results Requires focused execution to drive shareholder value Supported by an experienced and engaged Board Independent Special Committee reviewing strategic alterna
Slide 54: Appendix
Appendix 53 So
Slide 55: Overview of Other Ongoing Related Party Transactions
Overview of Other Ongoing Related Party Transactions Expense Transaction Since Comments (FY’10) Aircraft Time Pre-IPO $0.4MM Use of jet aircraft owned by LR Enterprises Management LLC ownedby Len Sharing Agreement Riggioand others (prior to 2010, used aircraft owned by B&N College) Reimbursement of
Slide 56: College: EBITDA Reconciliation Table
College: EBITDA Reconciliation Table Pro Forma Fiscal 2010 ($ 000's) 12 Month Operating Profit $ 49,241 Depreciation & Amortization 37,350 12 Month EBITDA $ 86,591 Pre-Acquisition Adjustments: Seller Paid Employee Bonuses 96,861 Gain on Transfer of Stock (72,466) Non-Cash Asset Impairments 6,163 Tot