Meadowbrook Insurance Group Inc

Meadowbrook Insurance — Q4 2013 Earnings Presentation

32 slides from Meadowbrook Insurance's earnings presentation, Mar 4, 2014

  1. Slide 1: Investor Supplement Fourth Quarter 2013 Update

    Investor Supplement Fourth Quarter 2013 Update

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures

    MEADOWBROOK™ EES insurance Group Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures This investor presentation may provide information including certain statements which constitute fonvard-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27Aof the Secunties Act of 1933, as amended, and Section

  3. Slide 3: Investments

    MEADOWBROOK™ € insurance croup Investments

  4. Slide 4: Investment Portfolio Review

    . MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Investment Portfolio Review We maintain a high-quality, low-risk investment portfolio. Low equity risk exposure 93% fixed income 7% equity High credit quality 99% of bonds are investment grade Average S&P rating of AA-/ Moody's of Aa3 Duration Fixed income effective du

  5. Slide 5: Conservative Investment Philosophy

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Conservative Investment Philosophy Our high quality investment portfolio is well matched to our loss reserves and generates a predictable stream ofincome. 2013 net investment income was $46M from $50M in 2009 Invested asset base increased to $1.6B ($1.78 including cas

  6. Slide 6: Government and Agency — December 31, 2013 Profile

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Government and Agency — December 31, 2013 Profile Summary Profile Government & Agency vs. Entire Portfolio | $25.4M market value; approximately 2% of the managed portfolio. Rated Aaa by Moody's and AA+ by S&P December 31, 2013 net unrealized gain was $385K Average invest

  7. Slide 7: Corporate Fixed Income — December 31, 2013 Profile

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Corporate Fixed Income —- December 31, 2013 Profile Summary Profile | Quality Indicators $538.5M market value; 34% of the investment Corporates portfolio [Average Quality A December 31, 2013 net unrealized gain was Investment Grade 100% $3.6M. Average investment yield

  8. Slide 8: Municipal Bonds — December 31, 2013 Profile

    INSURANCE GROUP Municipal Bonds — December 31, 2013 Profile Summary Profile | $735.4M market value; 47% of the investment portfolio December 31, 2013 net unrealized gain was $5.4M Tax exempt unrealizedgain $3.6M Taxable unrealized gain $1.8M Average tax equivalent yield: 4.34% Municipals vs. Entire

  9. Slide 9: Structured Securities — December 31, 2013 Profile

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Structured Securities — December 31, 2013 Profile Summary Profile | Quality Indicators $163.8M market value; 10% of the investment portfolio RMBS | CMBS [Average Quali Aas [AAs As of December 31, 2013, unrealized loss of investment Grade 99% 99% $2.1M; MBS unrealized

  10. Slide 10: Equities - December 31, 2013 Profile

    Equities - December 31, 2013 Profile Summary Profile $109.8 million market value; 7% of the investment portfolio December 31, 2013 net unrealized gain was $14. 4M .6 MEADOWBROO! ISH INSURANCE GROUP Equity Mix Common stock unrealized gain $13.7M Bond mutual fund unrealized gain $0.7M Average tax equi

  11. Slide 11: Convertible Debt Offering

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Convertible Debt Offering

  12. Slide 12: $100M Convertible Debt Offering

    EADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP $100M Convertible Debt Offering $100 million Cash Convertible Senior Notes Giese Procesds $100.0M Underlying “Equivalent” Shares —10.9 million 5.00% Cash Coupon Use of Proceeds Surplus Enhancement $70.0M Holding Company Debt Service $16.1M Call Spread / Warrants $9.9M Fee

  13. Slide 13: MIG Convertible Note

    MIG Convertible Note We have issued debt with a 5.00% coupon We will pay additional cash if our share price exceeds the $9.19 lowerstrike price (on 10.9 million “equivalent” shares) We have boughta bond hedge requiring counter parties to pay us the same amountwe pay to the note holders in B above We

  14. Slide 14: MIG Convertible Note Settlement

    2.6 MEADOWBROOK~ INSURANCE GROUP MIG Convertible Note Settlement $110 zt < $9.19 > $11.69 Payout at Maturity (§ in mi ——— Mic Convertibie + Call Spread Due 2020 $6.68 $7.00 $8.00 $9.00 $10.00 $11.00 $1169 $1269 $1369 $14.69 «$15.69 $90 Stock Price at Maturity IMG Share Price <$9.19 IMG Share Price >

  15. Slide 15: Accounting for Convertible Debt Offering

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Accounting for Convertible Debt Offering The following was recorded in Q1 2013 related to the convertible debt offering (in millions) Proceeds: Gross Proceeds (recorded as) Debt Derivative Liability related to conversion feature Underwriting Fees Other Legal and Audit

  16. Slide 16: Capital Enhancements

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Capital Enhancements

  17. Slide 17: Q4 2012 Gain Harvesting Program Results

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Q4 2012 Gain Harvesting Program Results Gross Realized Gains of $51m, $37m net of taxes in fourth quarter of 2012 Netproceeds in excess of $500 million: The overall portfolio mix remains consistent with 99% investment grade Minor change to security sectors with inclus

  18. Slide 18: Quota Share — Terminated 9/30/2013

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Quota Share — Terminated 9/30/2013 Quota share agreementincreased statutory surplus at December 31,2012 by $20.8 million Provided an easily integrated form of capital relief by utilizing the capital of Swiss Re Initial term was one year with multiple extension and exit o

  19. Slide 19: $100M Convertible Debt Offering

    EADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP $100M Convertible Debt Offering $100 million Cash Convertible Senior Notes Giese Procesds $100.0M Underlying “Equivalent” Shares —10.9 million 5.00% Cash Coupon Use of Proceeds Surplus Enhancement $70.0M Holding Company Debt Service $16.1M Call Spread / Warrants $9.9M Fee

  20. Slide 20: Holding Company Capital Contributions

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Holding Company Capital Contributions Q4 2012 Contribution Q1 2013 Contribution $10 million to Star $70 million total Starcontributed: $55 million to Star $5 million to Savers Starcontributed: $5 million to Ameritrust $10 million to Savers $5 million to Williamsburg $5 m

  21. Slide 21: Reserve Supplements

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Reserve Supplements

  22. Slide 22: Net Reserves Strengthened

    Net Reserves Strengthened MEADOWBROO! s INSURANCE GROUP Reserves, net of reinsurance recoverables, totaled $1.1 billion as of December 31, 2013 GAAP Reserves, Net of Reinsurance Recoverables, at 12/31/13 (Sin lors) Net Reserves at 12/31/2013 $297 Line of Business CA Workers’ Compensation Non-CA Work

  23. Slide 23: CA Workers' Compensation LOB

    MEADOWBROO! s INSURANCE GROUP CA Workers’ Compensation LOB Achieved significant rate increases in the CA workers’compensation business mmm Adjusted AY Loss & ALAE Ratio (Excl. Term Bus) ‘Cumulative Achieved Written Rates ‘Cumulative Achieved Earned Rates ——Net Trended UIt Loss and ALAE Ratio * (Exel

  24. Slide 24: Non-CA Workers' Compensation LOB

    MEADOWBROO! s INSURANCE GROUP Non-CA Workers’ Compensation LOB Achieved accelerating rate increases in the non-CA workers’ compensation business me Adjusted AY Loss & ALAE Ratlo (Excl. Term Bus) Cumulative Achieved Written Rates ‘Cumulative Achieved Earned Rates Net Trended Ut Loss and ALAE Ratio* (

  25. Slide 25: Commercial Auto LOB

    MEADOWBROO! s INSURANCE GROUP Commercial Auto LOB Commercial auto experienced significant rate increases in 2012, continuedin 2013 mm Adjusted AY Loss & ALAE Ratio (Excl. Term Bus) ‘Cumulative Achieved Written Rates Cumulative Achieved Earned Rates ——Net Trended Ult Loss and ALAE Ratio * (Excl. Term

  26. Slide 26: CMP/General Liability LOB

    MEADOWBROO! s INSURANCE GROUP CMP/ General Liability LOB Significantrate increases have beenachievedin the CMP/ GL line of business in 2013 mmm Adjusted AY Loss & ALAE Ratio (Excl. Term Bus) ‘Cumulative Achieved Written Rates ‘Cumulative Achieved Earned Rates ——Net Trended Ult Loss and ALAE Ratio* (

  27. Slide 27: Other Lines of Business

    MEADOWBROO! s INSURANCE GROUP Other Lines of Business Other lines have achieved accelerating rate increases in recentyears mmm Adjusted AY Loss & ALAE Ratio (Excl. Term Bus) ‘Cumulative Achieved Written Rates ‘Cumulative Achieved Earned Rates ~— Net Trended Ult Loss and ALAE Ratio” (Excl. Term Bus)

  28. Slide 28: California Workers' Compensation

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP California Workers’ Compensation

  29. Slide 29: California Workers' Compensation Reserve Development

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP California Workers’ Compensation Reserve Development As planned, we hired new claim adjusters to manage increased claim volume due to the growth of our California workers’ compensation business in recentyears. As we hired new adjusters, the case load per adjuster wentdow

  30. Slide 30: California Workers' Compensation Low Hazard Mix of Business

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP California Workers’ Compensation Low Hazard Mix of Business How does our business mix compare to California workers’ compensation industry? Low hazard group mix We write approximately 70% of our premium in hazard groups 1 & 2 vs. 55% for the industry Almostno premium in

  31. Slide 31: Low Hazard Mix of Business (Continued): Hazard Group Distribution

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP California Workers’ Compensation Low Hazard Mix of Business (Continued) We write our premium in less hazardous groups and more favorable CAWC industries Hazard Group Distribution 5% 6&7 mw Hazard Groups 1&2 Hazard Groups 3&4&5 m Hazard Groups 6 & 7 NOTE: %'s above are ap

  32. Slide 32: Low Hazard Mix of Business (Continued): Industry Group Distribution

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP California Workers’ Compensation Low Hazard Mix of Business (Continued) We write our premium in less hazardous groups and more favorable CAWC industries Industry Group Distribution Construction Other 3%2% Office &Clerical 6% = Goods and Services Manufacturing = Office an

Meadowbrook Insurance Group — Q4 2013 Earnings Presentation on 6ix