Shutterfly Inc

Shutterfly — Proxy Contest (May 2015)

44 slides from Shutterfly's proxy contest presentation, May 27, 2015

  1. Slide 1: Creating Value for All Stockholders

    CREATING VALUE FOR ALL STOCKHOLDERS Investor Presentation May 2015

  2. Slide 2: Safe Harbor Disclaimer

    Safe Harbor Disclaimer 1934, as amended, competes for d beyond. identi believe,” “expect,” “will,” “should,” “would,” “guidance,” “estimate,” “future,” “vision,” “long-term” look d date These th d Please refer to the “Risk Factor: ud 10-K and 10-0, i A ‘econciliation of these non-« this presentation

  3. Slide 3: Agenda

    Agenda Proven Track Record of Value Creation Clear Vision for Continued Success Setting the Record Straight About Marathon’s Proxy Fight The Right Board and Leadership to Execute on our Vision [ Conclusions and Recommendations UW DS OD NY SHUTTERFLY ©

  4. Slide 4: Voting For Long-term Value Creation

    Voting For Long-term Value Creation Proven Track Record of Value Creation Clear Vision for Growth Dedicated to Creating Sustained Value SHUTTERFLY © v SS LAs % 57 consecutive quarters of revenue growth Eight consecutive years of adjusted EBITDA growth Grew free cash flow by more than 74%, revenue an

  5. Slide 5: Performance & Opportunity

    Performance & Opportunity Another Record Year for Revenue, Adjusted EBITDA and Free Cash Flow s200 ‘Annual Revenue ‘Adjusted EBITDA “Free Cash Flow faawe wee move ma me men Be Leading and Extending Market Share srapfish.com 10% Walgen = Viet Shutterty 55% ZA = tees — Be ~S_F Pe sept Photo 3% si Der

  6. Slide 6: Shutterfly Then & Now

    Shutterfly Then & Now SHUTTERFLY © ) 2005 2015, 103 ) 2000 eee, Soe © 6% 68% é 84M 1,053M = oe y poe) $100M $1.88 SHUTTERFLY © ( 2© 6) @ @ Transforming the way consumers think about capturing, sharing and preserving memories through innovation 4 Billion 123 Peta ‘old (als) bytes © of data - rae) Mem

  7. Slide 7: Shutterfly is Executing on a Plan to Create Significant, Sustainable Long-term Value

    Shutterfly is Executing on a Plan to Create Significant, Sustainable Long-term Value Shutterfly is making critical investments designed to drive long-term growth and competitiveness. We believe Marathon’s Board slate would seek to slow or stop these investments, jeopardizing significant value creati

  8. Slide 8: Marathon's Proxy Fight Creates Risk & Uncertainty

    Marathon’s Proxy Fight Creates Risk & Uncertainty © The Shutterfly Board and have a proven track record and are critical to delivering long-term stockholder value © Marathon has nominated three people for the Shutterfly Board, two of whom are inexperienced and unqualified and own an insignificant am

  9. Slide 9: Shutterfly has Engaged Constructively and Responsibly with Marathon

    Shutterfly has Engaged Constructively and Responsibly with Marathon Shutterfly’s Proactive Actions: Marathon’s Position: Y Offered two Board seats, incuding posers on key x committees; one for Mario Cibelli and one fora mutually two of which are inexperienced and unqualified ceptabl phil Shutterfly

  10. Slide 10: Proven Track Record of Value Creation

    PROVEN TRACK RECORD of VALUE CREATION SHUTTERFLY ©

  11. Slide 11: Proven Track Record of Value Creation

    Proven Track Record of Value Creation Revenue Transacting Customers {in millions) {in thousands) CN CR a8 ae $473, 4,069 3281 i 2,387 I é $187 I 4219 1,725 gu 34884 sag 900 . se | 2002 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 20132014 2003 2008 2005 2006 2007 2008 20092010 2011 2012 2013. 201 8

  12. Slide 12: Comparison to US e-Commerce Leaders

    Comparison to US e-Commerce Leaders 2015E Revenue Growth and EBITDA Margin for Top e-Commerce Companies Revenue Growth Y/Y EBITDA Margin 28% 31% 23% Average: 13% Average: 13% 15% 10% sy, 5% | : lily Netflix Amazon —SFLY_—Vistaprint Blue Nile Groupon eBay _—SFLY_—_Vistaprint Groupon Amazon Netflix Bl

  13. Slide 13: Our Family of Premium Lifestyle Brands

    Our Family of Premium Lifestyle Brands SHUTTERELY @9 Shutterfly Where your photos come to life in photo books, cards and gifts. GROOVE BOOK ‘A great way to print, share and preserve your mobile photos month after month, SHUTTERFLY © tinyprints. WEDDING PAPER DIVAS* stationery for all life's ‘occasio

  14. Slide 14: Scale Matters

    Scale Matters U.S. Online Photo Industry Reported & Estimated 2014 Revenue Totals $ Millions SHUTTERELY © 100, amo ee picaboo | (al) Picasa GE were] @zazzke ee ay @ _ minted. cafe OJ photobucket SHUTTERFLY © “4

  15. Slide 15: Track Record of Winning Against Large Incumbents

    Track Record of Winning Against Large Incumbents Shutterfly has consistently beaten large consumer incumbents entering the online photo space through a relentless focus on: Customers Superior Quality Innovation FUJIFILM SHUTTERFLY © 15

  16. Slide 16: Millions of Memories to Share and Preserve with Shutterfly

    lions of Memories to Share and Preserve with Shutterfly 80 million families Stationery so ion us, with children F - under 18 Greeting entary- oe 41 million po d children active youth sports a participants Calendars tinyprints WEDDING PAPER DIVAS 4 million OAL RRER 2+ million U.S. Births Photo Gifts’

  17. Slide 17: Clear Vision for Continued Success

    CLEAR VISION for CONTINUED SUCCESS SHUTTEREFLY ©

  18. Slide 18: Evolving Our Consumer Business for the Next Leg of Growth: Shutterfly 3.0

    Evolving Our Consumer Business for the Next Leg of Growth: Shutterfly 3.0 © Building a world-class memory management system connected to the smartest personalized e- Kids commerce solution o Direct integration o Consolidation of mobile apps o Intelligent features SHUTTERFLY 3.0 Key Building Blocks e

  19. Slide 19: Vertical Integration Enhances Competitive Position

    Vertical Integration Enhances Competitive Position and Operational Efficiency Increased Investment in Shakopee, MN. Manufacturing © Scale Optimized Economies Proposition Phoenix & Fort Mill, SC iomosise High Customer bovalty an High Customer Satisfaction supplement our three owned and operated produ

  20. Slide 20: Leveraging Existing Capabilities to Create New Shutterfly Business Solutions

    Leveraging Existing Capabilities to Create New Shutterfly Business Solutions (SBS) Solution _ ca me Sf SHUTTERFLY © Multi-channel campaign management platform Organic creation of a new business that leverages our assets more effectively Variable Print-on-Demand solutions for Fortune 1000 companies T

  21. Slide 21: What the Future Holds...

    What the Future Holds... Our tmeestments in Shutterfly 3.0, our verticall ur SBS offering combine to pd tremendous opportunity: capability and e Sustainable revenue growth e Return of adjusted EBITDA margins to >20% © Capital expenditure requirements decreasing to 7-8% of revenue e FCF and adjusted

  22. Slide 22: The Right Board and Leadership to Execute on Our Vision

    The RIGHT BOARD and LEADERSHIP to EXECUTE on OUR VISION SHUTTERELY ©)

  23. Slide 23: Committed to Strong Corporate Governance

    Committed to Strong Corporate Governance Independent Leadership and Oversight Executive Compensation Best Practices Stockholder Engagement & Alignment All directors except CEO are independent Separate Chairman/ CEO roles Two new experienced independent directors in past 24 months All directors posse

  24. Slide 24: A Strong, Experienced Board

    Vt ‘ownership = ‘sre SY beni ‘sua A A SETOng , Experienced Board Philip Marineau (Chairman) "20 year global consumer marketing veteran _farine at NKPrines sce 208 Form ant and CEO of Levi Perma . Compensation Committees), Meredith rp. (Chairman of Audit Committee), rgetown Uni Stephen Kill profile p

  25. Slide 25: Setting the Record Straight about Marathon's Proxy Fight

    SETTING the RECORD STRAIGHT about MARATHON’S SHUTTERFLY ©

  26. Slide 26: Setting the Record Straight on...

    Setting the Record Straight on... . Management Compensation and Incentives . Board Alignment . Capital Allocation and M&A . Operating Performance . Stock Price Performance OB WN SHUTTERFLY © 26

  27. Slide 27: Responding to Stockholder Feedback on Executive Compensation

    Responding to Stockholder Feedback on Executive Compensation Based on feedback from anit ie and other third-party experts, the Compensation Committee has made a number of important program adjustments beginning in 2014 Most Common Changes Following a Failed Say on Pay Vote Change in Met ighting 26 P

  28. Slide 28: 2015 CEO PBRSU Grant

    2015 CEO PBRSU Grant Following the pause in the strategic sale process in November 2014, extenuating circumstances caused the Shutterfly Board to accelerate the 2015 RSU and PBRSU award to CEO Jeffrey Housenbold The Shutterfly Board had cause for concern about its ability to retain its CEO due to in

  29. Slide 29: Proactively Addressing Executive Compensation

    Proactively Addressing Executive Compensation Based on feedback from an in ion consultant and other third- arty experts, the Cc ion Committe the following guidelines for Shutterfly’s 2015 and 2016 executive compensation program: ° Modified 2015 CEO compensation plan: increased adjusted EBITDA thresh

  30. Slide 30: Free Cash Flow Per Share Metric

    Free Cash Flow Per Share Metric Shutterfly defines FCF as adjusted EBITDA less capex... Adjusted BIT Historically Tracks Cash Flow FO) m Operations (CF 200 100 a ee 2011 2012 2013 2014 —Adiusted EBITDA Capex ——FCE_ ——=cFFO* Marathon’s view of FCF is different...and includes non-cash items © Marathon

  31. Slide 31: PBRSU Targets

    PBRSU Targets If Shutterfly achieves $1.1B in revenue, $50M above midpoint of February guidance: $180M* Incremental Enterprise Value $20M Incremental Adjusted EBITDA $50M Incremental Revenue $180 million increase in Enterprise Value creates ~$5 million incremental PBRSU expense a SHUTTERFLY ©

  32. Slide 32: SBC & the Importance of Talent

    SBC & the Importance of Talent Shutterfly views stock-based compensation (SBC) as a critical tool for attracting and retaining employees. e@ Weare based in Silicon Valley, which is experiencing historic competition for executive and engineering talent The Shutterfly Board has reduced share dilution

  33. Slide 33: Shutterfly's Nominees are Highly Qualified Leaders

    Shutterfly’s Nominees are Highly Qualified Leaders Responsible Stewards of the Ongoing Execution of Shutterfly’s Vision for Growth Jeffrey Housenbold President and Chief Executive Officer SHUTTERFLY© President, CEO, Director Former Vie President, Business Development and intern net Marketing ae Cheg

  34. Slide 34: Marathon's Inexperienced and Unqualified Nominees

    Marathon’s Inexperienced and Unqualified Nominees LLC ® Has never served on a public or private company board Robotti & Company candidate ‘Thomas D. Hughes * Partner of Cedar Grove Investments, LLC ere! and investor i ynacor, Inc, a mi in company's shares trade at less than half the IPO price + Chie

  35. Slide 35: The Facts About Marathon's Quest for Board Seats

    The Facts About Marathon’s Quest for Board Seats SHUTTERFLY © Marathon owns 5.4% of Shutterfly’s common stock but is seeking three seats, replacing 33% of the Shutterfly Board, including the CEO Jeffrey Housenbold However, we have made multiple offers to add Mario Cibelli to the Shutterfly Board in

  36. Slide 36: Board Supports Efficient Capital Allocation Strategy

    Board Supports Efficient Capital Allocation Strategy e $400 million of authorized common stock repurchases © Shutterfly has repurchased ~$160 million in common stock in the last 15 months at an average price of $45.29 per share © The Shutterfly Board supports additional future common stock repurchas

  37. Slide 37: 10+ Year Track Record of Disciplined Acquisitions

    10+ Year Track Record of Disciplined Acquisitions CONSOLIDATION* ~$490M ADJACENCIES ~$48M. ~ 1.7x TTM Rev; ~9.4x TTM EBITDA ~1.2x TTM Rev; ~3x TTM EBITDA MES PTPnOre!) GROOVE BOOK (huprustisuen Kodak Gallery FunFi pasteworks tinyprints WEDDING PAPER DIVAS Imagestation “YAHOO! Protos 2014 2013 2012 2

  38. Slide 38: The Facts About Operating Performance

    The Facts About Operating Performance Marathon suggests our earnings quality is declining based on GAAP EBIT contribution. Their analysis ignores critical facts: © Shutterfly embarked on a growth investment cycle in 2012, consistently telling stockholders that profitability would expand beginning in

  39. Slide 39: The Facts About Our Stock Price

    The Facts About Our Stock Price Marathon has focused on Sh ly’s stock perf e over the recent period of investments in future growth. Our recent financial performance indicates these investments are beginning to yield results, and we expect more to come. Shutterfly Stock Performance Over Time* DOW NA

  40. Slide 40: Commitment to Maximizing Stockholder Value

    Commitment to Maximizing Stockholder Value © In 2014, following receipt of inbound interest in a potential transaction, the Shutterfly Board conducted a robust and structured strategic sale process that included: Active supervision by all independent Board members, including an independent M&A commi

  41. Slide 41: Conclusions & Recommendations

    CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS SHUTTEREFLY ©

  42. Slide 42: Conclusions & Recommendations

    Conclusions & Recommendations [ Shutterfly’s Board Nominees are Superior to the Marathon Slate [ Executive C i itiati i Address Concerns Downsized SBC Program is Vital to Our Growth and Competitiveness Accomplished, Engaged Board Dedicated to Strong Corporate Governance [ Demonstrated Track Record o

  43. Slide 43: Appendix

    APPENDIX

  44. Slide 44: Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Items

    RECONCILIATION OF NON-GAAP ITEMS oe tone ee) sou sm sme sm om oy sm smi suns ae em wm SHUTTERFLY © 44

Shutterfly — Proxy Contest (May 2015) on 6ix