Taubman Centers — Proxy Contest (May 2018)
13 slides from Taubman Centers's proxy contest presentation, May 10, 2018
Slide 1: Shareholders Should Not Be Fooled By Taubman's Claims
Shareholders Should Not Be Fooled By Taubman’s Claims May 2018 www.SaveTaubman.com Please email questions or comments to: SaveTaubman@LandandBuildings.com
Slide 2: Shareholders Should Not Be Fooled By Taubman's Claims
Shareholders Should Not Be Fooled By Taubman’s Claims • Taubman Centers, Inc. (“Taubman” or the “Company”) recently released a polished investor presentation touting its purported accomplishments, but the Company can’t change the facts – the reality is that all is not well at Taubman, which has expe
Slide 3: Land & Buildings Non-Binding Advisory Proposal is Only as Dilutive as the Taubman Family Is Unreasonable
Land & Buildings Non-Binding Advisory Proposal is Only as Dilutive as the Taubman Family Is Unreasonable, in Our View Our proposal is to eliminate the dual-class voting share structure Taubman ignores in its presentation a critical part of our non-binding advisory proposal: First, the Board must act
Slide 4: Eliminate the Dual-Class Voting Share Structure
Eliminate the Dual-Class Voting Share Structure A complex chart can’t explain away the fact Taubman’s dual-class voting structure serves that the dual-class voting structure is harming one primary purpose – helping the Taubman shareholders Family avoid taxes, in our view Taubman’s dual-class voting
Slide 5: Taubman is Cherry-Picking its Peers and Distorting Performance, In Our View
Taubman is Cherry-Picking its Peers and Distorting Performance, In Our View Taubman has underperformed its Class A Mall Peers by 20%, 24% and 56% over the past 1-, 3- and 5-year periods through the unaffected share price date Taubman is attempting to take credit for the strong rally its shares enjoy
Slide 6: Taubman's Stated Commitment to Strong Governance and Shareholder Responsiveness is Disingenuous
Taubman’s Stated Commitment to Strong Governance and Shareholder Responsiveness is Disingenuous Taubman’s presentation fails to answer a number of important questions: • Why did it require shareholder pressure for Taubman to begin making any substantial corporate governance changes? • Why did the Bo
Slide 7: Taubman's Capital Allocation is a Far Cry From Disciplined, In Our View
Taubman’s Capital Allocation is a Far Cry From Disciplined, In Our View Does Taubman also believe that “patience” is needed when it comes to its pattern of reductions of development yields, delayed stabilizations and impairments? How does Taubman’s debt-to-EBITDA ratio rising above its targeted rang
Slide 8: Taubman's Operating Results Continued to Underperform in 1Q18
Taubman’s Operating Results Continued to Underperform in 1Q18 Taubman’s operating statistics are skewed – the Company elects to only include specific new development assets in lease-up in certain metrics, such as NOI, and conveniently excludes languishing assets such as the Mall of San Juan Taubman’
Slide 9: Mr. Litt is Better Suited Than Billy Taubman on Maximizing Value For All Common Shareholders
Mr. Litt is Better Suited Than Billy Taubman is on Maximizing Value For All Common Shareholders, In Our View Land & Buildings was compelled to file materials to call a Special Meeting to ensure the Company followed through on its promises, after private requests were ignored If there was no sharehol
Slide 10: Taubman's Claims Are Not Truly Representative of the Analyst Community's Opinions
Taubman’s Claims Are Not Truly Representative of the Analyst Community’s Opinions Only One Analyst Recommends Buying the Stock Source: Wall Street research Note: Sell-side analyst ratings as of 5/9/18 10 www.SaveTaubman.com
Slide 11: Taubman has Underperformed its Class A Mall Peers Based on Various Metrics
Taubman has Underperformed its Class A Mall Peers Based on Various Metrics Core FFO Per Share Growth Dividend Per Share Growth • Consensus estimates of Taubman’s FFO per share continue to decline: Taubman FFO/Share Consensus Estimates $4.90 $4.69 $4.70 $4.50 $4.48 $4.30 $4.10 $3.90 $3.74 $3.70 $3.68
Slide 12: Taubman Continues to Put Philosophy and Aesthetics Ahead of Basic Economics
Taubman Continues to Put Philosophy and Aesthetics Ahead of Basic Economics • On March 8, 2016, Taubman announced that a $500 million investment in Beverly Center in Los Angeles was necessary – the investment community protested given significant unanswered questions and concerns, including the foll
Slide 13: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation is for discussion and general informational purposes only. It does not have regard to the specific investment objective, financial situation, suitability, or the particular need of any specific person who may receive this presentation, and should not be taken as advice o