Slide 1: Designing and Specifying FRP Materials for Structural Strengthening of Bridges
24/10/2023 DESIGNING AND SPECIFYING FRP MATERIALS FOR THEIR USE IN STRUCTURAL STRENGTHENING OF BRIDGES PRESENTED BY: ERI VOKSHI, P.E. SIKA CORPORATION, LYNDHURST, NJ 1 This program is registered with the AIA/CES for continuing professional education. As such, it does not include content that may be
Slide 2: AIA/CES Program
24/10/2023 Sika Corporation is a Registered Provider with the American Institute of Architects Continuing Education Systems. Credit earned on completion of this program will be reported to CES Records for AIA members. Certificates of Completion for non-AIA members is available upon request. 3 AIA/CE
Slide 3: Key Learning Objectives; Sika at a Glance
24/10/2023 KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVES 01 DETERMINE WHY STRUCTURES NEED TO BE STRENGTHENED AND TYPICAL STRENGTHENING TECHNIQUES DESIGN AND SPECIFICATION CONSIDERATIONS, ALONG WITH AVAILABLE 02 INDUSTRY GUIDELINES, FOR SUCCESSFUL USE OF MATERIALS HIGHLIGHT MATERIALS THAT CAN BE USED FOR STRUCTURAL STRENG
Slide 4: Focus on Attractive Markets; Concrete Repair & Protection
24/10/2023 FOCUS ON ATTRACTIVE MARKETS: CROSS-SELLING, LIFE-CYCLE MANAGEMENT, ONE STRONG BRAND Concrete Waterproofing Roofing Building Finishing Flooring & Coating Sealing & Bonding Refurbishment Industry 7 7 CONCRETE REPAIR & PROTECTION Products Product Families Bonding Agents Sika® Armatec®, Sikad
Slide 5: Why Do Structures Need Strengthening
24/10/2023 DECK REPAIRS Concrete protection solutions Crack Repair and Healer Sealer Joint materials Bridge deck Overlays High friction surface treatments Anchoring and grouting Segmental Bridge Adhesives BELOW DECK REPAIRS Concrete patching Epoxy injection Structural strengtheni
Slide 6: Why Do Structures Need Strengthening? U.S. Infrastructure State
24/10/2023 U.S. INFRASTRUCTURE STATE American Society of Structural Engineers – Report Card Overall grade: C- Over 600,000 bridges in U.S. 231,000 bridges need repair 4 in 10 bridges are 50 years or older Total infrastructure needs: $5.94 TRILLION over 10 years 11 WHY DO STRUCTURES NEED
Slide 7: How Are Structures Strengthened; What Are FRP Systems?
24/10/2023 HOW ARE STRUCTURES STRENGTHENED TYPICAL STRENGTHENING METHODS Flexible picture height EXTERNALLY BONDED SECTION ENLARGEMENT EXTERNAL POST- SUPPLEMENTAL SUPPORTS FRP OR STEEL TENSIONING Traditionally done with Used frequently, this For cases where high- Supplemental supports are steel, mos
Slide 8: Most Common FRP Materials: Glass vs Carbon
24/10/2023 MOST COMMON FRP MATERIALS GLASS VS CARBON Carbon Systems Glass Systems (GFRP) Seismic strengthening (CFRP) Damp/wet conditions Dry conditions Stiffness driven Extreme acidic conditions Extreme alkaline conditions Economical Stronger, stiffer, more durable Economical, used co
Slide 9: Advantages of FRP Repairs
24/10/2023 ADVANTAGES OF FRP REPAIRS Cost/scheduling benefits “Get in, Get out, Stay out!” - FHWA Mantra for accelerated construction Reduced maintenance costs Light weight materials puts less strain on the structure Non-corrosive, designed for long-term performance 17 17 LIMITED ACCESS
Slide 10: Typical Applications: Bridge Applications
24/10/2023 TYPICAL APPLICATIONS 19 TYPICAL USE BRIDGE APPLICATIONS 1 Pier confinement 2 Shear strengthening of girders 2 4 3 Shear strengthening of pier caps 1 4 Flexural strengthening of girders 5 5 Deck Stiffening 1 3 20 20 10
Slide 11: Pier Confinement and Pier Cap Shear Strengthening; Girder Flexural Strengthening
24/10/2023 PIER CONFINEMENT AND PIER CAP SHEAR STRENGTHENING 21 21 GIRDER FLEXURAL STRENGTHENING 22 22 11
Slide 12: Typical Applications: Bridge Deck Stiffening; Parking Structures
24/10/2023 BRIDGE DECK STIFFENING 23 23 TYPICAL APPLICATIONS Parking Structures Shear Strengthening Corrosion Damage Column strengthening Corbel Upgrades 24 24 12
Slide 13: Typical Applications: Buildings; Design Guides and Principals
24/10/2023 TYPICAL APPLICATIONS Buildings Modifications (wall or slab openings) Change in use Seismic upgrades Wall strengthening 25 25 DESIGN GUIDES AND PRINCIPALS 27 13
Slide 14: Designing with FRP: Codes and Standards
24/10/2023 CODES AND STANDARDS AASHTO Guide 2nd Ed Guide Specification for Design of Bonded FRP Systems for Repair of Strengthening Concrete Bridge Elements ACI 440.2R-17 Guide for the Design and Construction of Externally Bonded FRP Systems for Strengthening Concrete Structures 28 28 DESIGN
Slide 15: FRP Limitations
24/10/2023 FRP Limitations “SUPPLEMENTAL REINFORCEMENT” AASHTO STRENGTHENING LIMIT ACI 440 STRENGTHENING LIMIT ( ) ≥ (1.1 + 0.75 ) 31 LIVE LOAD LIMIT DURING FRP APPLICATION 32 15
Slide 16: Flexural Strengthening: Material Requirements
24/10/2023 MATERIAL REQUIREMENTS Environmental reduction factors Material properties (non bond-critical applications Interface strain (bond critical) 85% strength retention for various exposures Glass transition temperature – 40 degrees higher than max design temp 33 FLEXURAL STRENGTHENING
Slide 17: How Does CFRP Affect a Reinforced Beam? Flexural Strengthening
24/10/2023 HOW DOES CFRP AFFECTS A REINFORCED BEAM? FLEXURAL STRENGTHENING FRP Contribution 35 36 36 17
Slide 18: Shear Strengthening: Detailing Requirements
24/10/2023 DETAILING REQUIREMENTS Check for shear to prevent end debonding. If needed provide: U-wraps Spike Anchors If FRP-concrete interface strain is to be increased U-wraps along beam length Spike anchors 37 37 SHEAR STRENGTHENING 38 38 18
Slide 19: Combined Strengthening
24/10/2023 COMBINED STRENGTHENING 39 39 MAIN TYPES OF STRENGTHENING SHEAR 1 2 40 19
Slide 20: Shear Strengthening
24/10/2023 SHEAR STRENGTHENING Members are U-wrapped or fully wrapped Can be discrete strips or a Steel and concrete FRP continuous strips Contribution Contribution 41 SHEAR STRENGTHENING 42 42 20
Slide 21: Strengthening in Torsion
24/10/2023 STRENGTHENING IN TORSION 43 43 TYPES OF STRENGTHENING CONFINEMENT 44 44 21
Slide 22: Confinement Design per ACI 440
24/10/2023 TYPES OF STRENGTHENING CONFINEMENT To avoid the lateral expansion, its necessary to ensure a confinement around the element using a rigid material with a high strength such as FRPs. CFRP strengthening • Increase in both axial and flexural strength • Commonly used for seismic retrofitting
Slide 23: FRP Design Software
24/10/2023 FRP DESIGN SOFTWARE 47 47 SIKA® CARBODUR® SOFTWARE We have 5 different modules: RC section FRP confinement design RC section FRP flexural strengthening design RC section FRP shear strengthening design RC beam FRP flexural strengthening design RC beam FRP shear strengthening de
Slide 24: Specifying FRP Systems
24/10/2023 SPECIFYING FRP SYSTEMS 51 HOW TO SPECIFY FRP? Were strengthening limits checked? Who will perform the design? In-house design Specify min material properties req’d Be inclusive Delegate it Geometrical data (size of members and rebar amount and layout) Concrete and steel pr
Slide 25: Specification Documents; Example 1
24/10/2023 SPECIFICATION DOCUMENTS Spec documents Align drawings and spec documents Specifying minimum material properties: Tensile strength, stiffness, and elongation Prevent sole-sourcing - review various manufacturer’s PDSs for min requirements 53 53 EXAMPLE 1 54 54 25
Slide 26: Example 2; Example 3
24/10/2023 EXAMPLE 2 56 56 EXAMPLE 3 57 57 26
Slide 27: Protective Coatings; Project Completion
24/10/2023 PROJECT COMPLETION 58 PROTECTIVE COATINGS 59 59 27
Slide 28: QC Acceptance Criteria; FRP Systems at Glance
24/10/2023 QC ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA Delamination Limited to ensure proper bond Bond Pull off tests to determine bond strength to concrete Minimum 200 psi (1.4 MPa) Laminate tensile Testing Panel making is an art-form Panels must be flat and have smooth finish Pull test 60 60 FRP SYSTEM
Slide 29: Surface Prep
24/10/2023 SURFACE PREP All defects repaired using epoxy mortar Concrete prepared by sandblasting Concrete smoothed out using grinders Open pores Remove laitance Smooth and level Corners rounded to ½” min 62 MECHANICAL PREPARATION 63 63 29
Slide 30: Primer Application for FRP Systems; Available FRP Systems
24/10/2023 PRIMER APPLICATION FOR FRP SYSTEMS Mix & Apply Epoxy Primer 64 64 AVAILABLE FRPS SYSTEMS Epoxy Wet Lay-up Pre-saturated Wet Dry Lay-up Systems Pultruded Plates Systems Lay-up Systems Post-tensioned FRP Anchorage FRP NSM Rods FRCM System Plates System 65 65 30
Slide 31: Fabric Based FRP Systems; Field Saturated FRP System
24/10/2023 FABRIC BASED FRP SYSTEMS FIELD SATURATED SYSTEMS AND PRE-SATURATED SYSTEMS 66 FIELD SATURATED FRP SYSTEM The ORIGINAL FRP system Longest in the market and most trusted Most common resin used is epoxy Durable in various environments Saturation is done in the field 67 31
Slide 32: Wet Lay-up and Dry Lay-up Installation Methods
24/10/2023 WET LAY-UP INSTALLATION METHOD Saturate Fabric with Resin – Table or Saturator 68 DRY LAY-UP INSTALLATION METHOD 69 69 32
Slide 33: Field Saturated FRP Systems
24/10/2023 FIELD SATURATED FRP SYSTEMS 70 FIELD SATURATED FRP SYSTEMS Remove air bubbles 71 33
Slide 34: Presaturated System
24/10/2023 PRESATURATED SYSTEM Open foil pouches when ready to apply 72 PRESATURATED SYSTEM Cut “wet” fabric if necessary 73 34
Slide 35: FRP Plates and NSM System; CFRP Plates
24/10/2023 FRP PLATES AND NSM SYSTEM 74 74 CFRP PLATES Clean the CFRP strips Cut the laminate to size Apply even amount of epoxy to the laminate Apply and roll the CFRP strip onto concrete 75 75 35
Slide 36: FRP Rods – NSM Reinforcement
24/10/2023 FRP RODS – NSM REINFORCEMENT Cut and clean grooves Place rods in the groove 76 NSM REINFORCEMENT Fill the groove with epoxy 77 77 36
Slide 37: Post-Tension FRP Plates; Post-Tensioning FRP System - Anchors
24/10/2023 POST-TENSION FRP PLATES 78 78 POST-TENSIONING FRP SYSTEM - ANCHORS Standard anchor Type III P0 = 220kN Fixed anchor side movable anchor – tensioning side 79 37
Slide 38: Post-Tensioning FRP System Application
24/10/2023 POST-TENSIONING FRP SYSTEM Application Define location Drilling Chipping Installation & injection 80 POST-TENSIONING FRP SYSTEM Application Installation of tendon Apply adhesive Tensioning of tendon Protection (optional) (if bonded) 81 38
Slide 39: Conclusions
24/10/2023 CONCLUSIONS FRP’s are cost and time effective solutions for reinforcement of infrastructure Typical FRP strengthening applications in RC include flexural, shear, confinement, and seismic strengthening Specifying FRP properly will prevent delays, headaches, and RFI’s on projects. P