Dynegy — Proxy Contest (November 2010)
67 slides from Dynegy's proxy contest presentation, Nov 5, 2010
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Soliciting Material
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION WASHINGTON, DC 20549 SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a Party other than th
Slide 2: Saving Dynegy: The Power of Change
SAVING DYNEGY: THE POWER OF CHANGE Seneca Capital NOVEMBER 2010
Slide 3: Disclaimer
DISCLAIMER This presentation contains forward-looking statements about future events and sets forth a presentation of our beliefs. The forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, and we caution you not to rely unduly on them. We have based many of these forward-looking state
Slide 4: We Vote No – To the Proposed Deal
WE VOTE NO – TO THE PROPOSED DEAL WRONG PRICE We believe worth more than $6 per share today and up to $16 - $18 in a recovery scenario Valued at less than 1/3 of replacement cost Nearly 7.5% unlevered free cash flow yield at low point in electricity price cycle rising to as much as 14 - 17% in a pow
Slide 5: And Yes to the Power of Change
AND YES TO THE POWER OF CHANGE NEW LEADERSHIP What if… shareholders elect two high-quality directors that believe in the value proposition for a re-focused Dynegy? ALIGNMENT OF INTERESTS What if… shareholders propose a compensation plan that properly aligns directors/management with shareholder valu
Slide 6: Why Is Seneca Speaking Out?
WHY IS SENECA SPEAKING OUT? Seneca is the largest economic equity holder in Dynegy 11.8% total interest includes 9.3% of voting common stock and economic exposure to an additional 2.5% of common stock through non-voting $0.01 European call options Seneca only benefits if stock price improves and los
Slide 7: A Difference in Alignment Drives a Difference of Opinion
A DIFFERENCE IN ALIGNMENT DRIVES A DIFFERENCE OF OPINION Dynegy Seneca - Only $1 million of unrestricted common - 12% economic interest in Dynegy OWNERSHIP stock (much less than 1% of company) (9.3% voting stock) - $38 million cash if deal consummates - Only motivation is increasing - misaligned wit
Slide 8: Premier Vehicle for Playing Power Market Recovery
PREMIER VEHICLE FOR PLAYING POWER MARKET RECOVERY 7
Slide 9: Lots of Ways to Win
LOTS OF WAYS TO WIN Capacity value – EPA-driven retirements are a game changer for Midwest capacity margins Currently earning $17/ MW-day vs. $175/MW-day in nearby markets with tighter reserve margins Dark spread recovery – current weak dark spreads do not seem sustainable long-term Spark spread imp
Slide 10: Sell Now??
SELL NOW?? When the stock is back at post-Enron distressed levels? 1200% July of 2002 July 24: $4.90 July 25: $2.55 Sept 06 ($30.35): July 26: $3.40 LS Power / DYN 1000% July 27: $6.00 Marriage DYN Averts Bankruptcy with Sale of Northern Natural Gas 800% NRG Aug 10 ($2.78): Oct 02 ($4.55): Merger An
Slide 11: EPA Clean Air Rules Are Just Around the Corner
EPA CLEAN AIR RULES ARE JUST AROUND THE CORNER Proposed EPA rules for sulfur/ 2011 Calendar of Events NOx/mercury emissions are a game March: Final CATR rule expected changer for electricity prices as many March: Proposed HAP MACT rule un-scrubbed plants should close May: PJM 2014/15 capacity auctio
Slide 12: And Dynegy's Assets Are Primed to Benefit
AND DYNEGY’S ASSETS ARE PRIMED TO BENEFIT Dynegy is extremely well positioned to benefit from EPA Clean Air rules given its substantial investment in pollution control equipment Its largest, most efficient plants will have been scrubbed We estimate pollution control equipment for Dynegy’s coal fleet
Slide 13: The Natural Gas Pain Has Already Been Suffered
THE NATURAL GAS PAIN HAS ALREADY BEEN SUFFERED Natural gas has traded down to 2002 levels as a result of the shale drilling frenzy Credit Suisse estimates that many of the low cost plays require at least $5/mcf(1) to earn a fair return Signs of drilling slowdown in response to low prices – gas rig c
Slide 14: Liabilities Are an Asset
LIABILITIES ARE AN ASSET When has an undrawn revolver ever caused Dynegy Inc. a liquidity crisis? Undrawn Revolver Dynegy Holdings Inc. Synthetic L/C facility matched with cash $1,080 Million Revolver $0 Cash (10/1/10) $680 $680 mm of available cash at 10/1/2010 (2) Term L/C Facility $850 Restr. Cas
Slide 15: There Is Substantial Leverage to Efficiency Gains
THERE IS SUBSTANTIAL LEVERAGE TO EFFICIENCY GAINS We believe that a refocused Dynegy has a fresh opportunity to optimize costs Dynegy’s overhead structure was originally designed to support a larger asset base with a substantial trading operation The Merger Proxy highlights an additional $50 million
Slide 16: Wrong Price
WRONG PRICE 15
Slide 17: Worth >$6/Share on Sum of the Parts Valuation
WORTH >$6/SHARE ON SUM OF THE PARTS VALUATION ($ in millions) 2010 Maint Unlevered Net Valuation (1) EBITDA Capex FCF MWs $/KW $MMs Commentary Midwest Coal Scrubbed Coal ($45) 2,241 $700 $1,569 Based on DCF Analysis (3); Scrubber/SCR/baghouse have repl. cost of $800/kw (3) Unscrubbed Coal ($18) 903
Slide 18: What Could Dynegy Be Worth?
WHAT COULD DYNEGY BE WORTH? $20.00 $2.50 $18.25 $18.00 $1.25 $15.75 $16.00 $2.50 $14.00 $2.00 $12.00 $3.50 $10.00 $8.00 $6.50 $6.00 $4.00 $4.50/Share Merger Price $2.00 – Base Valuation CCGT Delivered Coal Incremental $500mm Asset Upside Gas Recovery Upside Newbuild Cost Reduced $50mm Annual Sale Pr
Slide 19: Substantial Operating Cash Flow Through the Trough
SUBSTANTIAL OPERATING CASH FLOW THROUGH THE TROUGH Dynegy does not pay cash taxes and has low maintenance capex therefore we believe free cash flow is the most accurate valuation metric for Dynegy Dynegy trades in line with peers on free cash flow but has better leverage to power market upside ($ in
Slide 20: With Huge Cash Flow Upside as Power Prices Recover
WITH HUGE CASH FLOW UPSIDE AS POWER PRICES RECOVER Adjusting Dynegy’s trough free cash flow for expectations of a market recovery could double the free cash flow yield Gas price improvements would be additive to impact of a capacity / coal price driven dark spread recovery Base Case Upside Case $MM
Slide 21: Leverage to Cyclical Recovery
LEVERAGE TO CYCLICAL RECOVERY Cyclical industries tend to trade around replacement cost during cyclical peaks and at substantial discounts during cyclical troughs (1) Dynegy trades at the lower end of its peers as a % of replacement cost and its stock price is much more sensitive than its peers to r
Slide 22: The Proposed Deal Raises Questions
THE PROPOSED DEAL RAISES QUESTIONS 21
Slide 23: The Wrong Time to Sell
THE WRONG TIME TO SELL 22
Slide 24: Timeline of a Tragedy (Travesty)
TIMELINE OF A TRAGEDY(TRAVESTY) $10.00 4/11: NRG/DYN Executives meet to discuss possible Buyback 30% of Stock at $9.65 stock deal, NRG involves 8/4: Blackstone $9.00 Blackstone revises proposal to $5.00 upon agreement with DYN not to use proceeds $8.00 6/23: NRG Determines from sale of gas not to pr
Slide 25: This Is a Cyclical Business Near a Cyclical Trough
THIS IS A CYCLICAL BUSINESS NEAR A CYCLICAL TROUGH Electricity prices and dark spreads have fallen to near 6-year lows Weak demand has exacerbated the excess supply The decline of natural gas prices relative to coal has significantly impacted coal plant profitability Source: Growth from Subtraction.
Slide 26: But Recovery Is Within Sight
BUT RECOVERY IS WITHIN SIGHT We expect that Midwest power markets will recover over the next several years: EPA Clean Air rules Rational decisions by plant owners to retire old and inefficient capacity Gradual increase in demand Industry leaders and research analysts are already discussing the 2014/
Slide 27: Natural Gas Price Dynamics
NATURAL GAS PRICE DYNAMICS Natural gas prices are currently at levels not seen for 8 years The current gas price is not sustainable as many plays that are considered “low cost” do not earn an acceptable return at less than $5 gas Breakeven Gas Price Required for Different Basins Source: Bloomberg da
Slide 28: Liquidity Is on Our Side
LIQUIDITY IS ON OUR SIDE Given substantial asset value, limited secured debt and no significant bond maturities until 2015, we believe Dynegy has substantial liquidity to execute on its plan Encumbered Assets Liabilities Sithe/Independence 1064 MW SitheBonds $257 Danskammer/Roseton 1693 MW Central H
Slide 29: Dissenting Director
DISSENTING DIRECTOR Victor Grijalva, former Vice Chairman of Schlumberger, voted AGAINST approval of the merger: Sharp and anomalous drop in Dynegy’s stock price over prior 3-month period Stock trading at historically low price Price did not reflect its trading price over a longer period of time or
Slide 30: Wrong Reasons
WRONG REASONS 29
Slide 31: On August 6 the Future Seemed Bright
TH ON AUGUST 6 THE FUTURE SEEMED BRIGHT Excerpt from Dynegy second quarter results presentation, August 6, 2010 30
Slide 32: Management Has Suddenly Changed Its Tune
MANAGEMENT HAS SUDDENLY CHANGED ITS TUNE August 6, 2010 Post Announcement (1) (week before merger announcement) Financial • “No significant bond maturities until • “Significant risk associated with a Management 2015” stand-alone strategy” • “Simple, flexible capital structure” • “Limited access to c
Slide 33: Why the Change of Heart?
WHY THE CHANGE OF HEART? Management will be able to realize an almost $38 mm change-of- control payout, 90% of which has no relation to the deal price(3) Deal Price Sensitive Deal Price Insensitive Stock Performance Equivalents(1) Units Severance Total Bruce Williamson $2,029,883 $5,400,000 $6,959,8
Slide 34: Misalignment Leads to Poor Decisions
MISALIGNMENT LEADS TO POOR DECISIONS Poor performance created a situation where certainty of a $10 million change-of- control payment (part of the overall $38 million package) outweighed the effort required to achieve EBITDA and stock price targets Performance awards have been awarded to executives
Slide 35: Cash Outflows Are Not Operating Losses
CASH OUTFLOWS ARE NOT OPERATING LOSSES The $1.1 billion cumulative cash outflows in management’s 5-year forecasts are not recurring Environmental capex – completion of scrubber program Debt reduction – scheduled maturities (including amortization of Sithe Independence debt) Central Hudson lease paym
Slide 36: Dynegy Is Much Less Gas Sensitive Than Mgmt Thinks
DYNEGY IS MUCH LESS GAS SENSITIVE THAN MGMT THINKS We have modeled Dynegy’s gross margin change based on commodity curves (1) from June 7, 2010 and November 3, 2010: Included hedges as disclosed by Dynegy (2) $122 million impact over 2011 – 2015 period vs. ~$500 million impact according to managemen
Slide 37: Why the Go-Shop Didn't Maximize Value
WHY THE GO-SHOP DIDN’T MAXIMIZE VALUE Dynegy administered a 40-day go-shop period that did not produce any offers superior to $4.50 per share 40-day time frame was insufficient Conducted during mid / late August, a traditionally slow period Sale of assets to NRG was exclusive Incumbent right to matc
Slide 38: Lengthy and Extensive Board Process?
LENGHTY AND EXTENSIVE BOARD PROCESS? Did not yield benefits for shareholders and likely exhausted the board and management $20.00 Discussions with NRG $18.00 Energy Solicited interest from 16 $16.00 potential acquirors; 3 engaged in preliminary $14.00 discussions Re-engaged in discussions with Unnam
Slide 39: The LS Power Relationship
THE LS POWER RELATIONSHIP The Marriage… …And the Divorce Announced on September 15, 2006 Announced on August 10, 2009 Dynegy was a buyer at ~$500/kw, an 8.5% Dynegy was a seller at ~$280/kw, a 9.2% unlevered unlevered free cash flow yield (1) free cash flow yield (1) Dynegy Received:(2) Dynegy Recei
Slide 40: The Power to Change
THE POWER TO CHANGE 39
Slide 41: A Path to Value
A PATH TO VALUE Shortly after the defeat of the Merger, shareholders have the power to refocus Dynegy for success Dynegy’s shareholder-friendly charter and bylaws allow a majority of stockholders to replace directors and adopt shareholder resolutions acting by written consent in lieu of a meeting No
Slide 42: Shareholder Resolutions
SHAREHOLDER RESOLUTIONS Resolutions would encourage the new Directors to: Determine which of the current top management team is appropriate for Dynegy going forward Create proper alignment of interests between management / board of directors and shareholders (through revised compensation plans) Anal
Slide 43: Staying Public: The Phoenix Rises
STAYING PUBLIC: THE PHOENIX RISES Public market will recognize value of new board / management Properly aligned with shareholders Reinvigorated and focused on creating shareholder value Public markets demonstrate a willingness to price in mid-cycle well in anticipation of recovery Numerous examples
Slide 44: Without the Reverse Split Would Dynegy Have Traded Below $1.00/Sh?
WITHOUT THE REVERSE SPLIT WOULD DYNEGY HAVE TRADED BELOW $1.00/SH? Or allowed the Company to be potentially sold for $0.90 / share (pre-reverse split)? $2.00 130% $1.90 3/12: 5 for 1 CPN 120% $1.80 Reverse stock split proposed $1.70 110% $1.60 NRG 100% $1.50 RRI $1.40 90% MIR $1.30 80% $1.20 5/25: 5
Slide 45: Reverse Stock Splits Are a Recipe for Underperformance
REVERSE STOCK SPLITS ARE A RECIPE FOR UNDERPERFORMANCE Credit Suisse conducted a 30 year extensive study of reverse splits and concluded… Reverse Stock Splits Consistently Perform Poorly… “The dismal short-term and long-term performance of reverse-split stocks is consistent across time. Reverse spli
Slide 46: The Premier Vehicle to Play Power Recovery
THE PREMIER VEHICLE TO PLAY POWER RECOVERY Compelling valuation with catalysts Sum-of-the-parts valuation supports stock price of greater than $6 per share, 7.5% un- levered free cash yield at low point in the cycle, trading at less than 1/3 of replacement cost EPA-driven plant retirements will be a
Slide 47: Summary
SUMMARY Seneca owns 12% economic interest and is solely motivated by increasing shareholder value Fully aligned with shareholders Alignment Management owns less than 1% and receives $38 million change of control if deal consummates Misaligned with shareholders Last year management bought back nearly
Slide 48: Conclusion
CONCLUSION WE VOTE NO TO THE PROPOSED DEAL WRONG PRICE We believe worth more than $6 per share today and up to $16 - $18 in a recovery scenario Valued at less than 1/3 of replacement cost Nearly 7.5% unlevered free cash flow yield at low point in electricity price cycle rising to as much as 14 - 17%
Slide 49: Appendix
APPENDIX 48
Slide 50: EPA Clean Air Rules Will Change Market Dynamics
EPA CLEAN AIR RULES WILL CHANGE MARKET DYNAMICS Upcoming EPA rules will likely force coal generators to either invest in expensive control technologies or shut down Stringent Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT) Rules would require compliance as early as 2014 Environmental controls are very
Slide 51: EPA Rules: Who Is at Risk?
EPA RULES : WHO IS AT RISK? According to Credit Suisse, only 34% of the coal capacity in the US has installed (or is announced plans to install) both scrubbers and SCRs and 30% have no environmental controls at all. Smaller coal plants are less likely to invest in environmental controls as the capit
Slide 52: EPA Rules: What Does It All Mean?
EPA RULES: WHAT DOES IT ALL MEAN? Credit Suisse base case assumes that 60GW of coal capacity will be retired, causing several 1st and 2nd order impacts on power and commodity markets: Tightening reserve margins leading to higher capacity prices Reduction in demand for coal Increase in demand for nat
Slide 53: EPA Rules: CATR
EPA RULES: CATR Proposed rule issued in July 2010, that would set emission caps for SO2 and NOx for 31 eastern states and Washington D.C. Final rule expected in March 2011 EPA projects that, by 2014, the proposed rule would (in the covered area): Reduce generating unit SO2 emissions by 71% compared
Slide 54: EPA Rules: Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP) MACT
EPA RULES: HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANT (HAP) MACT The Clean Air Act requires the EPA to develop an emission control program for hazardous pollutants, including mercury and acid gases The EPA is mandated pursuant to consent decree to draft a proposed Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT) rule by M
Slide 55: Dynegy Environmental Overview
DYNEGY ENVIRONMENTAL OVERVIEW Source: Second Quarter 2010 Results page 19. 54
Slide 56: Key DCF Valuation Assumptions
KEY DCF VALUATION ASSUMPTIONS All DCF-based valuation metrics included the following assumptions: Capacity factors based on historical plant-by-plant data and management guidance from public presentations Strip gas prices through 2015 as of 10/29/10 with a flat $6 long-term natural gas price thereaf
Slide 57: Comparable Companies: Unlevered Free Cash Flow
COMPARABLE COMPANIES: UNLEVERED FREE CASH FLOW ($ in millions) DYN CPN NRG RRI MIR Stock Price $4.50 $12.50 $19.91 $3.76 $10.61 Diluted Shares Outstanding 121 487 266 353 145 Equity Value $543 $6,086 $5,291 $1,328 $1,538 Financial Enterprise Value $4,547 $15,178 $8,390 $2,989 $2,992 2011E Generation
Slide 58: Comparable Companies: Replacement Cost Analysis
COMPARABLE COMPANIES: REPLACEMENT COST ANALYSIS ($ in millions) DYN CPN NRG RRI MIR Stock Price $4.50 $12.50 $19.91 $3.76 $10.61 Diluted Shares Outstanding 121 487 266 353 145 Equity Value $543 $6,086 $5,291 $1,328 $1,538 Financial Enterprise Value $4,547 $15,178 $8,390 $2,989 $2,992 $/KW Ave Repl D
Slide 59: Refining: A Replacement Cost Case Study
REFINING: A REPLACEMENT COST CASE STUDY Source: Barclays Capital research report “Sunoco: Good Value for Patient Investors” dated April 30, 2010. 58
Slide 60: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Midwest Coal
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: MIDWEST COAL 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Capacity (MW) 3,144 2,980 2,980 2,687 2,687 Capacity factor 85.0% 85.0% 85.0% 85.0% 85.0% Generation (millions of MWh) 23.4 22.2 22.2 20.0 20.0 Cinergy Around-the clock power price ($ / MWh) 6/7/2010 $34.54 $36.02 $38.82 $41.96 $46.33 11
Slide 61: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Danskammer Coal
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: DANSKAMMER COAL 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Generation (MWh @ 85% capacity factor) 2.8 2.8 2.8 2.8 2.8 New York Zone G Around-the clock power price ($ / MWh) 6/7/2010 $54.67 $56.32 $58.55 $60.01 $62.84 11/3/2010 45.61 48.68 51.10 $53.40 $55.63 Change - $ / MWh (9.06) (7.64) (7.
Slide 62: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Ontelaunee
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: ONTELAUNEE 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Capacity (MW) 580 580 580 580 580 Capacity factor 48% 48% 48% 48% 48% Generation (millions of MWh) 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 6/7/2010 PJM East on-peak power price ($ / MWh) 60.67 61.57 63.48 65.30 69.39 TETCO M3 gas price ($ / MMBtu) 6.14 6.30 6
Slide 63: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Kendall
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: KENDALL 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Capacity (MW) 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 Capacity factor 48% 48% 48% 48% 48% Generation (millions of MWh) 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 6/7/2010 PJM West (COMED) on-peak power price ($ / MWh) 41.94 42.08 44.09 48.81 53.69 Chicago City Gate gas price
Slide 64: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Casco Bay
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: CASCO BAY 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Capacity (MW) 540 540 540 540 540 Capacity factor 48% 48% 48% 48% 48% Generation (millions of MWh) 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 6/7/2010 NEPOOL on-peak power price ($ / MWh) 59.50 61.21 64.18 65.43 68.98 Less: Basis ($ / MWh) (4.50) (4.50) (4.50) (4
Slide 65: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Independence
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: INDEPENDENCE 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Capacity (MW) 1,064 1,064 1,064 1,064 1,064 Capacity factor 48% 48% 48% 48% 48% Generation (millions of MWh) 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 6/7/2010 NY Zone A on-peak power price ($ / MWh) 44.32 44.40 44.80 45.11 47.92 Transco Zone 6 gas price ($ /
Slide 66: Natural Gas Sensitivity: Moss Landing 1&2
NATURAL GAS SENSITIVITY: MOSS LANDING 1&2 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Capacity (MW) 1,020 1,020 1,020 1,020 1,020 Capacity factor 57% 57% 57% 57% 57% Generation (millions of MWh) 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.1 6/7/2010 NP-15 on-peak power price ($ / MWh) 53.84 57.42 59.83 62.96 65.75 PG&E South gas price ($ / MMB
Slide 67: Certain Information Concerning the Participants
CERTAIN INFORMATION CONCERNING THE PARTICIPANTS Seneca Capital International Master Fund, L.P., Seneca Capital, L.P., Seneca Capital Investments, L.P., Seneca Capital Investments, LLC, Seneca Capital International GP, LLC, Seneca Capital Advisors, LLC and Douglas A. Hirsch (together with each of the