Fleetwood Limited · ASX:FWD
Fleetwood — Proxy Contest (June 2016)
46 slides from Fleetwood's proxy contest presentation, June 2016
Slide 1: Fleetwood Corporation Limited
Fleetwood Corporation Limited June 2016 © Sandon Capital Pty Ltd 1
Slide 2: Important information
Important information This presentation has been prepared for use in conjunction with a verbal presentation and should be read in that context. It contains Sandon Capital Pty Limited’s (Sandon Capital’s) view on various matters and is based on publicly available information only. This presentation i
Slide 3: Contents
Contents Company description Investment thesis – time to “Deliver the Promise” Capital management – bloated Balance Sheet provides opportunity Manufactured Accommodation – from “mining boom” to “retiring boom” Recreational Vehicles – caravan manufacturing should be sold or closed if a retu
Slide 4: Company description
Company description Fleetwood provides manufactured accommodation solutions across multiple end markets including the affordable housing, education, commercial and mining sectors. As an extension of this, the company owns the Searipple accommodation village in Karratha, Western Australia. Fleetwoo
Slide 5: Investment thesis – time to "Deliver the Promise"
Investment thesis – time to “Deliver the Promise” FWD sum-of-the-parts is worth significantly more than its current market value The company’s overriding objective is to “outperform financially by providing genuine value”.1 A bloated Balance Sheet with a significant number of assets earning sub-
Slide 6: Investment thesis – time to 'Deliver the Promise'
Investment thesis – time to ‘Deliver the Promise’ The company has very little net debt and $25.7m (42cps) of franking credits, which would allow a significant of amount of excess capital to be returned to shareholders tax efficiently © Sandon Capital Pty Ltd 6
Slide 7: Investment thesis – sum-of-the-parts
Investment thesis – sum-of-the-parts FWD sum-of-the-parts is worth significantly more than the current market value Sandon Capital believes that the combined value of the assets other than Manufactured Accommodation are almost equivalent to the current enterprise value of the company. These asse
Slide 8: Investment thesis – sum-of-the-parts
Investment thesis – sum-of-the-parts The table below does not ascribe any value to the $25.7m (42cps) of franking credits currently held by FWD Basis Multiple Range Value ($m) Camec Tangible Book Value 0.50 1.00 10.0 20.0 Bocar/Flexiglass FY17 EBITDA Multiple 4.00 6.00 8.0 12.0 Caravan manufacturi
Slide 9: Investment thesis – sum-of-the-parts (NTA)
Investment thesis – sum-of-the-parts The waterfall chart below highlights the impact to last reported net tangible assets (NTA) from taking significant write downs to a number of FWD assets Adjusting for punitive write downs to estimated asset values, the current share price is trading in line w
Slide 10: Investment thesis – closing the gap between price & value
Investment thesis – closing the gap between price & value To close the gap between share price and value, Sandon Capital believes there are several opportunities that management should consider: 1. Address the company’s bloated balance sheet by selling or closing assets that fail to earn a decent
Slide 11: Capital management – bloated Balance Sheet
Capital management – bloated Balance Sheet FWD’s Balance Sheet is heavily burdened with assets earning sub economic returns Disappointingly, many of these assets have not generated an adequate return for a number of years In the 13 years to 30 June 2015, the company spent $355 million on capit
Slide 12: Capital management – bloated Balance Sheet
Capital management – bloated Balance Sheet The Balance Sheet has continued to expand as earnings have dropped precipitously. Sandon Capital believes that significantly improved earnings can be generated from a substantially reduced asset base 350 25% 280 20% Total Assets (A$m) 210 15% ROA (%) 140
Slide 13: Capital management – capital release
Capital management – capital release The company has started to release capital through the sale of Osprey Village in mid-2015, however significantly more work needs to be done to ensure the asset base is reduced and earnings power is improved Sandon Capital sees several opportunities to materia
Slide 14: Capital management – capital release: caravan manufacturing
Capital management – capital release 1. Return caravan manufacturing to profitability or close / sell the business Based on public comments made by the company, Sandon Capital estimates that the caravan manufacturing segment lost close to $10 million in FY15 The “turnaround” efforts in this segm
Slide 15: Capital management – capital release: WA manufactured accommodation
Capital management – capital release 2. Return Western Australian manufactured accommodation (WA MA) to profitability or close the business Sandon Capital estimates the WA MA segment lost close to $5 million in FY15. High fixed costs were not reduced sufficiently to offset rapidly falling revenues
Slide 16: Capital management – reduce working capital
Capital management – capital release 3. Reduce working capital Net working capital carried by FWD at 31/12/2015 is historically high at >$50m Given the current reduced level of sales, working capital should be reduced significantly in the short term Sandon Capital believes that one area in par
Slide 17: Capital management – reduce capital expenditure
Capital management – capital release 4. Reduce capital expenditure to minimum levels Since 30 June 2002, Fleetwood has spent $355 million on capital expenditure. This is equivalent to 217% of D&A and 8.6% of sales revenue With significant excess capacity across all of its segments, Sandon Capita
Slide 18: Capital management – return capital to shareholders
Capital management – capital release 5. Return capital to shareholders Fleetwood has a long history of returning capital (and franking credits) to shareholders through normal and special dividends The dividend has been significantly reduced as earnings have deteriorated, to the point that no div
Slide 19: Capital management – return capital to shareholders
Capital management – capital release 5. Return capital to shareholders With the sale of Osprey returning the Balance Sheet to a sound position with minimal net debt, Sandon Capital believes the company is in a position to recommence paying dividends Based on last reported retained earnings of $1
Slide 20: Manufactured Accommodation – description
Manufactured Accommodation – description The Fleetwood Manufactured Accommodation business provides accommodation solutions across multiple end markets including the affordable housing, education, commercial and resources sectors The division is headquartered in Perth and Melbourne and has opera
Slide 21: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity With its Western Australian base, FWD’s Manufactured Accommodation business has historically had a major focus on supplying products to the mining industry Following the acquisition of BRB Modular in 2010, combined with the downturn in the mining industry
Slide 22: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity MHEs operate under a loan/licence agreement in which the resident owns the relocatable home and signs a lease to pay rent on the freehold land which remains the property of the MHE owner/operator Source: Ingenia Communities Group © Sandon Capital Pty Ltd 22
Slide 23: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity Based on analysis by Colliers International, there are over 2,500 locations in Australia providing a level of permanent residential, short-term and/or worker accommodation Source: Colliers International – Healthcare & Retirement Living Report © Sandon Capit
Slide 24: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity These parks are split between MHE, tourist parks and caravan / mixed use parks MHEs make up only 6% of the >2,500 parks. This highlights the relative infancy of the MHE sector in Australia and the significant growth potential the sector offers MHE 6% Cara
Slide 25: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity Key attractions of MHEs for retirement include: growing demand for affordable housing with house prices rising faster than incomes shortage of affordable seniors accommodation largest, fastest growing target is within the seniors living spectrum the
Slide 26: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity The highly fragmented nature of the MHE market has attracted institutional investor interest, both domestic and international Private ownership remains the pre-eminent ownership type, however corporate ownership is rapidly increasing This reflects conso
Slide 27: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity The table below highlights the key MHE operators and their areas of strategic focus MHE MHE Operator Properties Location (conversion) (greenfield) DMF Tourism Mining Gateway Lifestyle 53 NSW, QLD, VIC Ingenia Communities 26 NSW, QLD, ACT Hampshire V
Slide 28: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity In May 2015, Fleetwood announced it had signed an agreement with Gateway Lifestyle (GTY) to become the exclusive manufacturer and supplier of homes to GTY MHEs in Queensland and northern NSW The agreement has an initial term of two years with an option fo
Slide 29: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity Gateway Lifestyle development pipeline Source: Gateway Lifestyle © Sandon Capital Pty Ltd 29
Slide 30: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity Other major players in the MHE space that could provide opportunities are National Lifestyle Villages, Ingenia, RAC Parks & Resorts and Discovery Holiday Parks Fleetwood has previously been an exclusive supplier to both National Lifestyle Villages and Asp
Slide 31: Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity
Manufactured Accommodation – opportunity As INA grows, Sandon Capital believes it will look to diversify its manufactured accommodation supply base to enable an increasing number of new MHE homes to be delivered Ingenia development pipeline: Source: Ingenia Communities Group © Sandon Capital Pty
Slide 32: Recreational Vehicles – description
Recreational Vehicles – description The Fleetwood recreational vehicles business is made up of four distinct segments: 1. Caravan Manufacturing – manufacturer of caravans, pop-tops and campers under the Windsor and Coromal brands, distributed through a national dealer network. Headquarters and man
Slide 33: Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making
Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making Whilst the recreational vehicles business was very profitable last decade, the segment has reported material losses in the past 3+ years Based on public commentary by the board and management, Sandon Capital believes the losses are entirely attrib
Slide 34: Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making
Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making The caravan manufacturing business has displayed very poor financial performance despite a strong end market From 1 February 2008 through 31 January 2015, caravan registrations in Australia grew at a compound annual rate of 5.2%. The chart below s
Slide 35: Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making
Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making Sandon Capital believes the poor performance of the caravan manufacturing business has been a result of poor management as the major competitor, Jayco, appears to have gone from strength to strength1 Sandon Capital believes the two major drivers o
Slide 36: Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making
Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making FWD commented on its FY14 earnings call that it was in the process of addressing the distributor network and product range With respect to the dealer network, MD Brad Denison commented that: “As I said, we are strengthening the dealer networks a
Slide 37: Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making
Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making Unfortunately the improved product range for 2015 didn’t appear to be successful as the earnings profile of the business continued to deteriorate This necessitated a further update to the product range according to comments at the AGM in November
Slide 38: Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making
Recreational Vehicles – caravans are loss making For at least three years now, the company has been in “turnaround” mode in its caravan manufacturing business Over that time, cumulative reported EBIT losses in the Recreational Vehicles segment have amounted to almost $27 million Despite severa
Slide 39: Searipple – core asset?
Searipple – core asset? Fleetwood operates the Searipple accommodation village at Karratha in the Pilbara region of Western Australia The village occupies 15 hectares of land and has more than 1,300 rooms During the mining boom when occupancy was high, the village generated significant profits
Slide 40: Searipple – core asset?
Searipple – core asset? Fleetwood has reported that the village is profitable at current occupancy levels, however increased occupancy is required to significantly improve profitability given the high fixed cost nature of the asset With several competing facilities closed or closing in the next
Slide 41: Searipple – core asset?
Searipple – core asset? Whilst the operating environment for Searipple is difficult, Sandon Capital believes the company should test the waters to see if there is appetite for a third party to purchase the asset, particularly if other accommodation village closures in Karratha result in an improve
Slide 42: Financials – historical
Financials – historical Year ended June 30 (A$m) FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 Profit & Loss Revenue A$m 259.9 262.1 254.1 314.4 344.5 355.3 291.3 466.6 382.6 333.9 366.5 301.9 EBITDA A$m 39.1 33.6 39.2 49.1 62.4 64.7 67.8 89.4 94.2 40.6 28.2 38.4 D&A A$m 7.6 5.9 7.6 8.
Slide 43: Financials – Balance sheet
Financials – Balance sheet ASSETS Current assets Balance sheet notes: Cash 7.3 Receivables 36.5 • The company has retained earnings Inventories 59.8 Other current assets 3.5 of $14.4m at the consolidated level Total current assets 107.0 with which to pay dividends Non-current assets PP&E 96.7 Intang
Slide 44: Valuation
Valuation Share price 1.785 Shares on issue 61.0 Mkt Cap 109.0 Net Debt 9.2 EV 118.2 NTA per share 2.33 Multiples FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16E EV / Revenue 0.31 0.35 0.32 0.39 0.42 EV / EBITDA 1.25 2.91 4.19 3.07 5.07 EV / EBIT 1.49 4.82 11.15 12.67 nmf P/E 1.90 6.42 19.32 27.46 nmf FCF Yield 46.1% -15
Slide 45: Key business risks
Key business risks Loss making businesses continue to operate and, in our view, consume cash Australian economic activity, particularly in the MHE, government provided education and resources accommodation industries Concentrated customer base in manufactured accommodation Demand for recreat
Slide 46: Sandon Capital team
Sandon Capital team Gabriel Radzyminski – Portfolio Manager Gabriel established Sandon Capital in 2008 after having devised and managed a number of successful investment funds for a leading high net worth wealth management firm. Sandon Capital has successfully invested its funds on behalf of whole