Mercer Insurance — Sandler O'Neill 2009 West Coast Financial Services Conference
24 slides from Mercer Insurance's conference presentation, Mar 3, 2009
Slide 1: Mercer Insurance Group, Sandler O'Neill 2009 West Coast Financial Services Conference
Mercer Insurance Group, Inc. Sandler O'Neill 2009 West Coast Financial Services Conference March 3, 2009
Slide 2: Forward-looking statements
Mercer Insurance Group, Inc. (the "Company") may from time to time make written or oral "forward-looking statements," including statements contained in the Company's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, in its reports to shareholders and in other communications by the Company, which
Slide 3: Company Profile
da) THE MERCER INSURANCE GROUP Company Profile
Slide 4: Mercer Insurance Group (NASDAQ: MIGP) overview
Mercer Insurance Group, Inc. (NASDAQ symbol "MIGP") Holding Company operating through 4 insurance carrier subsidiaries via mutual-to-stock conversion Capital of $137 million as of December 31, 2008 "A" (Excellent) rated by A.M. Best
Slide 5: Direct Written Premium by Line of Business
Direct Written Premium by Line of Business 12 Months Ending 12/31/08
Slide 6: Operating Territory
Actively writing property and casualty business Writing mail order surety (plus Alaska) Licensed but currently inactive Operating Territory
Slide 7: Direct Written Premium by State
Direct Written Premium by State 12 Months Ending 12/31/08
Slide 8: The Basics: Discipline, Diversity and Balance
The Basics Discipline, Diversity and Balance Careful risk selection in all facets of business Long term focus on geographic and product spread Focus on commercial insurance Better ability to control price and risk selection Opportunistic Pursue when found or presented Evaluate strategic M&A Must sup
Slide 9: Strengths
Strengths Strong balance sheet "Clean" investments Non-complexity Regional knowledge and niche expertise in markets served Experienced team with the ability to manage a larger organization Strong relationship with agency plant Long-term, consistency
Slide 10: Challenges
Challenges Current Economy How long will the recession be? Reduced exposures Impact on construction market Automation Speed of change in marketplace Resource limitations Success of recent IT investment Achieving diversity, balance objectives
Slide 11: Gross, Net & Ceded Premium Written
Gross, Net & Ceded Premium Written GAAP presentation; excludes pre-acquisition premiums of Financial Pacific Insurance Company which was acquired October 1, 2005. $ in Millions $62.8 16% ceded $67.9 12% ceded $95.1 21% ceded $188.1 23% ceded $184.3 13% ceded $166.4 11% ceded
Slide 12: Gross, Net & Ceded Premium Written (Pro-forma)
Gross, Net & Ceded Premium Written Pro-forma non-GAAP presentation; includes pre-acquisition premiums of Financial Pacific Insurance Company which was acquired October 1, 2005. $ in Millions $155.4 43% ceded $174.8 35% ceded $185.7 31% ceded $188.1 23% ceded $184.3 13% ceded $166.4 11% ceded
Slide 13: Commercial and Personal Lines NWP
Commercial and Personal Lines NWP $ in Millions
Slide 14: GAAP Combined Ratio
GAAP Combined Ratio * Refund of disputed state retaliatory premium taxes in 2007 reduced combined ratio by 2.4%
Slide 15: Mercer v. Industry Statutory Combined Ratio
Mercer v. Industry comparison 10 year Statutory Combined Ratio Source: Insurance Information Institute; estimated full year 2008 for industry MIGP 2007 combined ratio reduced by 2.4% due to non-recurring effect of retaliatory tax refund
Slide 16: Net Income
4a) Net Income ‘THE MERCER INSURANCE GROUP. Tn (000°s) en 314.235 $14,000 $10,635 $12,000 soot $10,000 $7,020 $8,000 $6,000 $3264 $4,000 $583 $2,000 “7T $0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Slide 17: Operating Income
Operating Income Operating income consists of net earnings adjusted by net realized investment gains/(losses) and taxes related to net realized gains/(losses). $119
Slide 18: Shareholder's Equity
Shareholder's Equity $98,326
Slide 19: Capital management initiatives
Capital management initiatives 2004/05 - 500,000 share buyback authorized and completed for $6.3 million, or an average of $12.34 per share. 2008 - Authorized to repurchase 5% (328,000 shares); 114,300 shares purchased a/o 12/31/08 at an average price of $16.03. Quarterly dividends commenced in July
Slide 20: Book Value per Share
ia) ‘THE MERCER INSURANCE GROUP Book Value per Share $23.00 2148 sea $19.06 $20.00 $19.00 $18.00 $1649 SI734 : ] | $21.00 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 $17.00 $15.65 ae | $15.00
Slide 21: Fixed Maturities as of 12/31/08
Fixed Maturities as of 12/31/08 81% AA rated or better 96% A rated or better Average rating of AA Effective portfolio duration 3.82 years Average yield 4.66% Tax-equivalent yield 5.40% No CDO sub-prime holdings
Slide 22: Investment Portfolio, including Cash & Equivalents
Investment Portfolio, including Cash & Equivalents at December 31, 2008 (in millions)
Slide 23: Summary
Summary Strong, "clean" balance sheet Disciplined, well underwritten book of business Steady Book Value increase Quarterly shareholder dividend Stock trading at a discount to book as well as a discount to peers
Slide 24: Questions
‘ay THE MERCER INSURANCE GROUP Questions
Mercer Insurance Group — Sandler O'Neill 2009 West Coast Financial Services Conference on 6ix