Verint Systems — Proxy Contest (May 2019)
58 slides from Verint Systems's proxy contest presentation, May 29, 2019
Slide 1: The Need for Change at Verint Systems Inc.
THE NEED FOR CHANGE AT VERINT SYSTEMS INC. From a long-term investor’s perspective May 2019 www.BetterVerint.com Vote the GOLD proxy card
Slide 2: Important Information
Disclosures On May 13, 2019, Neuberger Berman Investment Advisers LLC, Neuberger Berman Investment Advisers Holdings LLC, Neuberger Berman Group LLC, NBSH Acquisition LLC, Neuberger Berman Breton Hill ULC, NB Acquisitionco ULC, Neuberger Berman Canada Holdings LLC, Benjamin Nahum, Scott Hoina, Amit
Slide 3: Table of Contents
Table of Contents Executive Summary 4 Our Attempts to Engage Constructively With Verint 15 Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems, IncVerint Has Underperformed Every Relevant Index and Peer for YearsVerint’s Return on its Capital Allocation Has Been DismalVerint’s Conglomerate Structure Has Led t
Slide 4: Executive Summary: Overview of Verint Systems
Executive Summary: Overview of Verint Systems Overview Stock Price (1/31/2019) $48.37 Market Cap $3.2B Market Cap 5 Years Ago (1/31/2014) $2.4B Investments* since 1/31/2014 $2.2B 5-Year Return on Investment ($1.4B) CEO Tenure 25 Years Average Board Tenure 9 Years Longest-Serving Independent Board Me
Slide 5: Executive Summary: Overview of Neuberger Berman
Executive Summary: Overview of Neuberger Berman Founded in 1939, Neuberger Berman is a private, independent, employee-owned investment manager with more than 2,100 professionals in 23 countries.Our Intrinsic Value Strategy Team employs a research-intensive approach that seeks to identify companies t
Slide 6: Executive Summary: Our Engagement Objectives
Executive Summary: Our Engagement Objectives Neuberger Berman is Seeking to Improve Verint’s Performance, Capital Allocation, Corporate Structure, Financial Reporting and Corporate GovernanceVerint has been slow to transition to a modern cloud business model and its stock has suffered.Verint’s inves
Slide 7: Executive Summary: Governance and Engagement Principles
Executive Summary: Neuberger Berman’s Governance and Engagement Principles Our Engagement with Companies and Boards is Focused on the Following Eight Principles Strategy Incentives Board Independence Shareholder Representation Capital Deployment Transparency and Communications Risk Management Enviro
Slide 8: Executive Summary: Verint Has Vastly Underperformed the Market
Executive Summary: Verint has Vastly Underperformed the Market Prior to Neuberger Berman’s recent engagement*, Verint vastly underperformed the broad market as well as its own benchmarks and its close competitor, NICE, Ltd.Verint has invested heavily in R&D + CapEx + Acquisitions without delivering
Slide 9: Executive Summary: Verint's Stock Began to Recover Following Our Engagement
Executive Summary: Verint’s Stock Began to Recover Following Our Recent Engagement Verint’s stock value has remained flat for approximately 5 years until Neuberger Berman’s recent engagement began on December 8, 2018 Verint stock chart from 1/31/2014 through 4/30/2019 Verint Stock Price at Close 1/3
Slide 10: Executive Summary: Verint's Investments Destroyed Almost $2 Billion of Value
Executive Summary: Verint’s Investments Destroyed Almost $2 Billion of Value Over the last 12 years+ in which we owned the stock, Verint has spent nearly $2.1 billion on acquisitions and over $1.9 billion on R&D and capital expenditures, for a total of over $4.0 billion of investments, which is more
Slide 11: Executive Summary: Verint's Opaque Reporting to Shareholders
Executive Summary: Verint’s Opaque Reporting to Shareholders is Evident Verint has not kept pace with industry-standard reporting practices January 10, 2019, Jefferies Research“…Verint’s revenue disclosures are lacking...it does not provide inorganic revenue, maintenance revenue, or cloud revenue, m
Slide 12: Executive Summary: Verint Lacks Necessary Experience on the Board
Executive Summary: Verint Lacks Necessary Experience on the Board Verint’s long-tenured directors have overseen Verint’s poor performance Board Member Board Tenure Senior Executive Software Experience % TSR Performance Relative to NASDAQ Computer & Data Processing Index** Dan Bodner 25 Years (18%)
Slide 13: Executive Summary: Board Experience in Contrast to Peers
Executive Summary: Verint’s Lack of Board Experience is in Sharp Contrast to Peers Peer Board of Directors Profile: All of Verint’s close peers have an overwhelming majority of Board members with senior executive software expertise # Independent Directors # Independent Directors with Software Execut
Slide 14: Executive Summary: Our Nominees Bring Critical Experience
Executive Summary: Our Nominees Bring a Wealth of Critical Experience Our Nominees bring extensive experience as software CEOs and Board members Beatriz Infante Dr. Mark Greene Oded Weiss Executive Experience Software CEO Software CEO Software CEO Relevant Industry Experience SaaS/Cloud, cybersecuri
Slide 15: Neuberger Berman's Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint
Neuberger Berman’s Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Neuberger Berman began engaging with Verint in 2016 following the underperformance of the Kana acquisition
Slide 16: Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint
Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Over a ten-year period, our Intrinsic Value Strategy has engaged with 7 Boards of portfolio companies regarding capital allocation, communication of long-term strategic goals and corporate governance. We remain invested in 5 of the 7 companies or thei
Slide 17: Our Attempt to Engage Constructively: Recommended Directors
Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Ms. Herscher served on the Board of JDSU and helped create substantial stockholder value by separating the company into two publicly-traded entities, Lumentum and Viavi. Dr. Greene is a senior financial software and analytics executive with 35+ years
Slide 18: Neuberger Berman Re-engaged on Board Refreshment and Disclosures
Following Verint’s continued underperformance, Neuberger Berman re-engaged with the Company about its Board refreshment, improving its financial disclosures and establishing reasonable performance targets Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Mr. Warren Jenson is President and CFO of Live
Slide 19: Highlighting Risks of Poor Disclosures
Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Our attempt to engage constructively includes highlighting the risks associated with Verint’s poor disclosures April 8, 2019 letter to the Board communicating Neuberger Berman’s concerns and warning that short sellers were taking issue with Verint’s l
Slide 20: Recent Short Research Highlights Lack of Transparency
Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Recent short research highlights lack of transparency and risk to shareholders On May 23, 2019 an independent research firm issued a “Short Call Report” highlighting Verint’s lack of disclosures and financial transparency.Neuberger Berman does not end
Slide 21: Verint's Hostile Responses to Our Attempt to Engage
Our Attempt to Engage Constructively With Verint Verint’s hostile responses to Neuberger Berman’s attempt to engage constructively Delayed the Board candidates’ interview process and refused to accommodate conflicting travel and Board meeting schedules.Dismissed seven of our eight suggested Board ca
Slide 22: Why Change is Warranted: Underperformance
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems, Inc Verint has Underperformed Every Relevant Index and Peer for Years
Slide 23: Verint Has Underperformed the Market and Indexes
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Verint Systems has underperformed the market and all relevant indexes over the past 5- and 15-years Source: FactSet Note: NASDAQ Computer refers to the NASDAQ Computer & Data Processing index which is used by Verint as a stock comparator in its Form 10-K. 5
Slide 24: Verint Has Underperformed Its Peers
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Verint has significantly underperformed its peers on a 5-year, 3-year and 1-year basis 5YR 3YR 1YR Verint 6% 32% 16% NICE 192% 90% 20% Pegasystems 152% 142% 11% Zendesk* 323% 207% 75% ServiceNow 247% 254% 48% Five9* 583% 514% 97% Source: FactSet. Financials
Slide 25: 15-Year Head-to-Head Comparison With NICE
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems A 15-year head-to-head comparison with NICE shows how poorly Verint performs against its close peer $455M 2004 Market Cap + $4.2B Investments $6.8B Ending Market Cap Revenue growth over 15 years = 472% $737M 2004 Market Cap + $4.3B Investments $3.2B Ending M
Slide 26: Verint's Return on Capital Allocation Has Been Dismal
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems, Inc Verint’s return on its capital allocation has been dismal
Slide 27: 5-Year Return on Capital Allocation vs Peers
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Compared to its peers, Verint’s 5-Year return on its capital allocation has been dismal Revenue growth over 5 years = 8.98% $2.4B 2014 Market Cap + $2.1B Investments $3.2B Ending Market Cap $352M 2014 Market Cap + $142M Investments $3.0B Ending Market Cap Re
Slide 28: Gartner Research Report Quote
“Verint continues to acquire vendors to strengthen its offering, but this adds complexity to its portfolio and makes it more difficult to provide a seamlessly integrated and supported suite” Gartner Research ReportMagic Quadrant for Workforce Engagement ManagementFebruary 12, 2019
Slide 29: Approximately $1 Billion Spent on 15 Acquisitions Since 2014
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Verint has spent approximately $1 billion on 15 acquisitions since 2014 with very little to show for it Verint Acquisitions Since 2014Verint has acquired 15 companies since 2014Verint has only disclosed transaction value for 8 of the acquisitionsVerint has o
Slide 30: Verint Has Not Disclosed Transaction Information
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Verint has not disclosed transaction-related information for 7 of the 15 companies acquired since 2014Verint has not disclosed acquired revenues for 11 of the 15 companies acquired since 2014 Announce Date Company Acquired Transaction Value($M) Revenue Acqui
Slide 31: Conglomerate Structure Has Led to a Valuation Discount
Why Change is Warranted Verint’s Conglomerate Structure Has Led to a Discount in Verint’s Market Value
Slide 32: Verint Operates Two Disparate Businesses
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Verint operates two disparate businesses with no operational synergies, making capital allocation decisions complex These two divisions serve different markets, have unrelated products and service offerings, and share no operational synergies.At a minimum, w
Slide 33: Verint's Valuation Is Depressed Compared to Peers
20.0x 18.0x 16.0x 14.0x 12.0x 10.0x 8.0x 6.0x 4.0x 2.0x 0.0x Verint’s businesses receive very different valuation multiples from the market.The valuation expansion opportunity in the CES and into the pure Cloud space is significant. There may be additional opportunities for value multiple expansion
Slide 34: Lacks Medium and Long-Range Financial and Performance Targets
Why Change is Warranted Verint Lacks Sensible Medium and Long-Range Financial and Performance Targets
Slide 35: Requesting Better Metrics and Financial Projections
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Neuberger Berman continues to request better metrics and financial projections for ALL of Verint’s businesses Neuberger Berman has requested Verint provide shareholders with sensible business measurements and financial targets, including:Explain how M&A comp
Slide 36: Verint Continues to Lack Sensible Medium- and Long-Range Measurements
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Despite recent disclosure promises, Verint continues to lack sensible medium- and long-range measurements Dan Bodner, Verint CEOMay 21, 2019“To help investors understand how our financial model will evolve over time as we continue our cloud transition, we ar
Slide 37: Corporate Governance Concerns
Why Change is Warranted Corporate Governance Concerns
Slide 38: Board Remains Long-Tenured and Lacks Necessary Skills
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Despite poor performance, Verint’s Board remains long-tenured and lacks the necessary skills to effectively guide Verint’s cloud transformation Board Member Age Board Tenure Commentary Dan Bodner 60 25 years Served as a Director, President and/or CEO since C
Slide 39: Combined Chairman and CEO; Weak Independent Director Authorities
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems The positions of Chairman and CEO have been combined for almost two years.Weak Independent Director AuthoritiesVerint appointed a Lead Independent Director (Mr. Egan), without assigning specific and necessary authorities, which we believe should include:Sett
Slide 40: Poor Executive Compensation Structure
Why Change is Warranted at Verint Systems Poor Executive Compensation StructureExcessive CEO PayBodner’s FYE 2019 total compensation of $8.8 million is approximately 4x the average NEO payTime-vested equity, rather than performance-based equity, made up 32% of the CEO’s total payAll executive office
Slide 41: Board Members Who Can Drive Results
Board Members Who Can Drive Results Leaders for a Transforming Business
Slide 42: Verint Needs Board Members Who Can Lead Transformation
Verint Systems Needs Board Members Who Can Lead Transformation Verint needs deep industry expertise to help navigate a complicated and shifting industry
Slide 43: Nominees Recruited for Industry Knowledge and Operating Expertise
Neuberger Berman’s nominees were recruited for their industry knowledge, operating expertise, business acumen and history of creating shareholder value Verint Systems Needs Board Members Who Can Lead Transformation Beatriz V. Infante is a software industry veteran and a four-time CEO with a track re
Slide 44: Nominees Are Accomplished Professionals
Neuberger Berman’s Nominees Are Accomplished Professionals Seasoned executives will bring needed skills to Verint Board Neuberger Berman Nominees Verint Long-Tenured Underperforming Directors Infante Safir Nottenburg Egan Experienced Software CEO ✖ ✖ ✖ Cloud Expertise ✖ ✖ ✖ Corporate Governance
Slide 45: Our Nominees Have a Clear Focus
Our Nominees Have a Clear Focus If elected, the Neuberger Berman Nominees have several initiatives they intend to ask the full Board to address within the first 90 days Corporate GovernanceConsider separating the Chairman/CEO position or appoint a new, stockholder-focused Lead Independent Director a
Slide 46: Verint's Disappointing Response to Our Campaign
Verint’s Disappointing Response to Neuberger Berman’s Campaign Verint’s plans to spend $6.5 million to preserve the status quo is astonishing The Board has been unwilling to commit to improving its financial transparency, adopting a full suite of industry-standard metrics, and genuinely evaluating o
Slide 47: Opposing Re-election of Three Long-tenured Incumbent Directors
Neuberger Berman is Opposing the Re-election of Three Long-tenured Incumbent Directors Mr. Howard SafirMr. Safir has been a director since 2002.Mr. Safir’s experience is primarily as a law enforcement officer and has never been a senior executive of any public company.Over the course of his 17-year
Slide 48: Conclusion
Conclusion It is time for Verint to improve its disclosures, implement capital allocation discipline and upgrade its Board Prior to Neuberger Berman’s recent engagement, Verint vastly underperformed the broad market and its peers.Verint has invested heavily in R&D + CapEx + Acquisitions without deli
Slide 49: Neuberger Berman's Nominees Appendix
Neuberger Berman’s Nominees Appendix
Slide 50: Beatriz V. Infante
Beatriz V. Infante Beatriz V. Infante, age 65. Since 2009, Ms. Infante has served as Chief Executive Officer of BusinessExcelleration LLC which provides management consulting services to companies at strategic inflection points. From 2010 until its acquisition by Infor, Inc. in 2011, Ms. Infante was
Slide 51: Dr. Mark Greene
Dr. Mark Greene Dr. Mark Greene, age 65, is a senior financial technology executive with extensive experience leading and growing complex global businesses. He is a recognized thought-leader on banking and economic trends and related techniques including risk management, forecasting and trading, and
Slide 52: Oded Weiss
Oded Weiss Oded Weiss, age 48, has 25+ years of experience in building value and creating high-performing leadership teams. Mr. Weiss is Senior Advisor and former President of Temenos AG (SIX:TEMN), a $12bn market cap publicly traded financial software company. From July 2009 through March 2015, Mr.
Slide 53: Neuberger Berman's Principled Commitment to ESG and Impact Investing
Neuberger Berman’s Principled Commitment to ESG and Impact Investing Appendix
Slide 54: Employee-Owned Investment Manager
Employee-Owned Investment Manager Partnering with clients to achieve their unique objectives 1. Institutional-oriented equity and fixed income assets under management (“AUM”) includes the firm’s equity and fixed income institutional separate account (“ISA”), registered fund, and managed account/wrap
Slide 55: Employee Ownership Fosters Team Stability and Alignment
Employee Ownership Fosters Team Stability and Alignment with Clients Industry-leading experience, retention and culture 1. Employee assets include current and former employees and their family members. of clients’ assets managed by lead PMs who have 20+ years of industry experience Manager Experienc
Slide 56: Investment Platform
Investment Platform Breadth of independent perspectives across asset classes 1. As of December 31, 2018. Firm assets under management (AUM) includes $89.8 billion in Equity assets, $139.8 billion in Fixed Income assets and $74.5 billion in Alternatives assets. Alternatives “AUM and Committed Capital
Slide 57: Our Collaborative Approach Across Asset Classes
Our Collaborative Approach Across Asset Classes Setting goals, measuring performance and driving ESG priorities across the firm ESG Investing TeamPrimary responsibility is setting and implementing the global ESG strategy by deepening the integration of ESG themes into new and existing investment str
Slide 58: Neuberger Berman's Governance and Engagement Principles
Neuberger Berman’s Governance and Engagement Principles Our firm has a long and deep history of engaging with public companies Managements should set and communicate clearly defined long-term goals which avoid strategies oriented to short-term benefits, implement value-driven M&A strategies, and sub