PDC Energy Inc

PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (May 2019)

60 slides from PDC Energy's proxy contest presentation, May 21, 2019

  1. Slide 1: Forward-Looking Statements

    Forward-Looking Statements This presentation contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933 ("Securities Act") and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 ("Exchange Act") regarding our business, financial condition, results of operatio

  2. Slide 2: The Right Assets – Dual Basin Strategy in Two Prolific Basins

    The Right Assets – Dual Basin Strategy in Two Prolific Basins Core Wattenberg PDC is a best-in-class operator in the Wattenberg, which makes up >75% of the Company’s production and proved reserves • • Compared to 2015, PDC drilled ~18% more lateral feet with ~40% fewer rigs in 2018 ~30% improvement

  3. Slide 3: PDC Energy – Positioned to Drive Long-Term Value for Shareholders

    PDC Energy – Positioned to Drive Long-Term Value for Shareholders • • • Top-tier asset positions in the Core Wattenberg and Delaware Basin Core Wattenberg wellhead returns among the best in the Lower 48 Delaware Basin positioned in the high-value core with long-term growth potential and significant

  4. Slide 4: Strategy – Adapting to the Changing Landscape

    The Right Strategy – Adapting to the Changing Landscape Developed Multi-Year Plan Focused to Achieve Specific Targets at $50 Oil & $3 Gas 1 Sustainable FCF PRI2ORITIE Target both G&A and LOE per Boe of < $3/Boe S 3 Emphasis on FCF Margin1 4 Solid Growth 1 Free cash flow divided by capital investment

  5. Slide 5: Strategy – Returning Capital to Shareholders

    The Right Strategy – Returning Capital to Shareholders Board approved program – Up to $200mm program, dependent upon market conditions Near-term value-creation – Execution of program with target completion date of December 31, 20201 Differentiated return of capital – Funded entirely through cash flo

  6. Slide 6: Results – Consistently Solid Relative TSR Performance

    The Right Results – Consistently Solid Relative TSR Performance Since Bart Brookman’s CEO appointment on January 1st, 2015, PDC has delivered solid relative TSR returns over the short-and long-term, despite unique regulatory challenges given its Colorado-based operations • • Beginning in August of 2

  7. Slide 7: Governance – Corporate Governance Structured to Promote Accountability

    The Right Governance – Corporate Governance Structured to Promote Accountability provides strong leadership and oversight of management thoughtful refreshment directors and officers are in compliance with ownership guidelines Source: PDC definitive proxy filed 04/17/2019; company filings. 8 May 2019

  8. Slide 8: Team – Highly Experienced in Large-Scale E&P Operations and Colorado Regulations

    The Right Team – Highly Experienced in Large-Scale E&P Operations and Colorado Regulations the Board Financial/accounting Midstream oil & gas Financial/accounting Oil & gas services Capital markets Source: PDC definitive proxy filed 04/17/2019 9 May 2019 PDC’s continually refreshed Board consists of

  9. Slide 9: Team – PDC's Slate of Directors Have Substantially More Experience

    The Right Team – PDC’s Slate of Directors Have Substantially More Experience Relative to Kimmeridge’s Director Nominees • • PDC’s nominees possess an incredible breadth of both industry and operational experience A vote for Kimmeridge’s slate removes CEO Bart Brookman as a Director, thus removing an

  10. Slide 10: Alignment – PDC Executive Compensation Demonstrates Pay-for-Performance Alignment

    The Right Alignment – PDC Executive Compensation Demonstrates Strong Pay-for-Performance Alignment • Approximately 2/3rds of PDC executives’ pay consists of equity incentives that are highly correlated with the absolute and relative performance of PDC stock, ensuring strong alignment between executi

  11. Slide 11: EH&S – Committed to Corporate Social Responsibility

    The Right EH&S – Committed to Corporate Social Responsibility • • • • Full disclosure of Safety Data Sheets for employees, customers, suppliers, and others Extensive employee training on topics like defensive driving, personal protective equipment, spill prevention control & countermeasures, and fir

  12. Slide 12: Size – PDC's G&A and Employee Headcount Appropriately Sized

    The Right Size – PDC’s G&A and Employee Headcount is Appropriately Sized for its Scale and Multi-Basin Presence • PDC’s G&A is solidly in line with peers when adjusted for capitalized G&A and stock-based compensation Kimmeridge proposal to cut $80mm of G&A fails to contemplate sustainability as a go

  13. Slide 13: Return of Capital Framework

    The Right Return of Capital Framework Return Opportunities – PDC Continues to Holistically Evaluate Appropriate Capital 2018 FCF2 2018 OCF Dividend as % of: 2018 OCF: 11%3 2% 2% No dividend 90% 10% Dividend dividend and yield in the ($616) PDCE RRC SM Source: FactSet as of 05/10/19 1 Companies inclu

  14. Slide 14: What Does Kimmeridge Really Want?

    What Does Kimmeridge Really Want? By its own admission, Kimmeridge has repeatedly requested preferential inside access to PDC’s management, Board and non-public information under “wall cross arrangements” to “assist” the Company in exploring strategic alternatives Kimmeridge has indicated on multipl

  15. Slide 15: Conclusion – Kimmeridge's Demands Lack Substance

    The Right Conclusion – Kimmeridge’s Demands Lack Substance and Ignore PDC’s Top-Tier Track Record Peer leading operational performance Since Bart Brookman became CEO, PDC has delivered peer-leading returns on capital by Kimmeridge’s own analysis Clear track record of delivering on commitments Cut SG

  16. Slide 16: Corporate Governance – Reflection On Recent Proxy Advisor Publications

    Corporate Governance – Reflection On Recent Proxy Advisor Publications • • Kimmeridge’s thesis is ever-changing and analytically flawed -“…disconcertingly large sections of [Kimmeridge’s] materials are indeed bogged down in self-contradicting perspectives and Key facts which ISS ignored in its analy

  17. Slide 17: Choice – Support PDC Energy's High-Quality Director Nominees

    The Right Choice – Support PDC Energy’s High-Quality Director Nominees PDC Energy has taken decisive steps to reposition its portfolio and is executing a long-term strategy to capitalize on the Company’s high-quality assets and operational capabilities to deliver superior returns for investors PDC E

  18. Slide 18: Choice — Support PDC Energy's High-Quality Director Nominees

    The Right Choice — Support PDC Energy’s High-Quality Director Nominees SUPPORT WHITE Y PDC Energy has taken decisive steps to reposition its portfolio and is executing a long-term strategy to capitalize on the Company's high-quality assets and operational capabilities to deliver superior returns for

  19. Slide 19: Assets – Well-Positioned to Deliver Sustainable Free Cash Flow

    The Right Assets – Well-Positioned to Deliver Sustainable Free Cash Flow 20 May 2019 Delaware Basin •Robust inventory potential • Strong execution from development primarily targeting the Wolfcamp A and Wolfcamp B zones within PDC’s oilier Eastern and North Central areas •Focused on multi-well pads

  20. Slide 20: Assets – Independent Third Parties Agree PDC is a Differentiated Operator

    The Right Assets - Independent Third Parties Agree that PDC is a Differentiated Operator in the Wattenberg 120% and highest implied 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 Developed Acreage Value ($/acre) Higher implied acreage value1 Source: RS Energy

  21. Slide 21: Assets – 2019 Plan Significantly Enhances Efficiencies

    The Right Assets – 2019 Plan Significantly Enhances Efficiencies Core Wattenberg TILs by Lateral Length 2019 2018 SRL MRL XRL 139 TILs 110-125 TILs Net WI Lateral Feet (thousands) 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 YE17 2018 TILs YE18 1 DCP press release dated 2/11/19; 2 Reflects impact of 2018 strategic acr

  22. Slide 22: Core Wattenberg – Track Record of Operational Excellence

    Core Wattenberg – Track Record of Operational Excellence Wattenberg Drilling Feet per Day (Per Rig) 2,775 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 2015 2016 2017 2018 # of rigs 5.0 3.7 3.8 3.0 Wattenberg Well Costs (MRL) ($mm) $6 $5.4 $4 $2 $0 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 12Q019 # of TIL wells 110 - 1251 86 136 140 130 139

  23. Slide 23: Assets – Efficiency Gains & Commitment to Capital Discipline

    The Right Assets – Efficiency Gains & Commitment to Capital Discipline Core Wattenberg Well Costs Below Budget $5.0 $5.0 $4.0 $3.0 $2.0 SRL MRL XRL 2019 Budget 1Q19 Actual 24 May 2019 $mm $4.0 $4.8 $3.0$2.9 $3.8 Operational Efficiencies •Core Wattenberg – benefiting from consolidated acreage positio

  24. Slide 24: Assets – Steady Progress Towards Development Mode

    The Right Assets – Steady Progress Towards Development Mode Delaware Basin TILs by Lateral Length 2019 2018 SRL MRL XRL 26 TILs 20-25 TILs Costs per Well – MRL/XRL $12.5 - $15.0 $16 $12 $8 $4 $0 2018 2019e 1 Gross operated inventory primarily targeting the WCA and WCB zones within PDC’s oilier Easte

  25. Slide 25: Assets – PDC Wells Perform Favorably Relative to Other Delaware Operators

    The Right Assets - PDC Wells Perform Favorably Relative to Other Delaware Basin Operators 239 236 236 235 229 226 222 218 213 210 208 204 202 192 186 182 181 167 166 164 159 156 153 142 141 140 136 133 132 128 126 125 125 124 119 118 118 118 110 110 102 98 97 95 89 Source: CapitalOne 10/09/18 study

  26. Slide 26: Assets – PDC Has Significantly Improved upon Kimmeridge's Delaware Operations

    The Right Assets - PDC Has Significantly Improved upon Kimmeridge’s Delaware Operations PDC vs Kimmeridge (Wells on same pad) 160,000 PDC Lost Saddle well performance 120,000 143% improvement by PDC 80,000 40,000 Kimmeridge Lost Saddle well performance 0 1 101 201 301 401 501 601 701 801 901 Days On

  27. Slide 27: Delaware Basin – Systematic Efficiency Gains Since Acquisition

    Delaware Basin – Systematic Efficiency Gains Since Acquisition Delaware Drilling Feet per Day (Per Rig) 925 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 2017 2018 1Q19 Average Completion Costs ($/ft.) $1,200 $981 $800 $400 e investment in other nology enhancements $0 1Q17 2Q17 3Q17 4Q17 1Q18 2Q18 3Q18 4Q18 1Q19 28 May 2

  28. Slide 28: Assets – Delaware Basin Well Costs Below Budget

    The Right Assets – Efficiency Gains & Commitment to Capital Discipline Delaware Basin Well Costs Below Budget $14.0 $13.0 $12.9 $12.0 $11.5 $10.0 $8.0 $6.0 $4.0 $2.0 $0.0 MRL XRL 2019 Budget 1Q19 Actual 29 May 2019 $mm $10.8 Operational Efficiencies •Delaware Basin – continued operational improvemen

  29. Slide 29: Assets – Basin Inventory Decline Driven by PDC Efficiency

    The Right Assets – Basin Inventory Decline Driven by PDC Efficiency PDC Delaware Basin Inventory (Number of Delaware locations acquired) 785 se in Delaware acquisitions West-Culberson County locations Current locations (incl. drilled wells) Current locations (incl. drilled wells) Average 5,000’ late

  30. Slide 30: Strategy – Impairments Do Not Reflect Value Destruction

    The Right Strategy – Impairments Do Not Reflect Value Destruction • • Contrary to Kimmeridge’s statements, PDC has in fact been able to extract incremental value from its Delaware Basin acquisition At announcement of the transaction, Arris/Kimmeridge was valued at ~$1.6bn (inclusive of ~$120mm bolt-

  31. Slide 31: Strategy – 2019 Plan Expected to Deliver Differentiating Results

    The Right Strategy – 2019 Plan Expected to Deliver Differentiating Results Adjusted Guidance to Reflect $55/Bbl WTI and $3/Mcf NYMEX Prices Adj. Cash Flow from Ops ($880 - $930mm) Capital Investment1 ($810 - $870mm) 1000 900 DE Midstream (~$40mm) 800 Oil & Gas 700 Investment ($770 - $830mm) 600 500

  32. Slide 32: Strategy – Prioritizing Free Cash Flow & Debt-Adj. Per Share Growth

    The Right Strategy – Prioritizing Free Cash Flow & Debt-Adj. Per Share Growth Adjusted Outlook to Reflect $55/$3 NYMEX Production and Leverage Ratio Outlook 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2.0x Production Leverage Ratio 1.5x 1.0x 0.5x 0.0x 2018 2019e 2020e 1 Stock repurchase plan of up to $200mm with targ

  33. Slide 33: Strategy – PDC Compares Favorably to Peers on Development Efficiency

    The Right Strategy – PDC Compares Favorably to its Peers on Measures of Development Efficiency • Contrary to Kimmeridge’s methodology for calculating recycle ratio, using an appropriate peer group and generally accepted methodologies for calculating recycle ratio shows PDC comparing favorably to its

  34. Slide 34: Strategy — PDC Compares Favorably to Peers on Development Efficiency

    The Right Strategy — PDC Compares Favorably to its Peers on Measures of Development Efficiency + Contrary to Kimmeridge’s methodology for calculating recycle ratio, using an appropriate peer group and generally accepted methodologies for calculating recycle ratio shows PDC comparing favorably to its

  35. Slide 35: Team – Proper Mix of Skills and Experience

    The Right Team – Proper Mix of Skills and Experience to Drive Long Term Value Jeffrey C. Swoveland Anthony J. Crisafio Christina M. Ibrahim Randy S. Nickerson David C. Parke Source: PDC definitive proxy filed 04/17/2019 36 May 2019 The three PDC 2019 nominees bring the following attributes, furtheri

  36. Slide 36: Team – Continuous Refreshment Has Resulted in a Balanced Board

    The Right Team – Continuous Refreshment Has Resulted in a Balanced Board of Directors • Rigorous, thoughtful selection criteria has produced a balanced, highly qualified Board, with each member bringing a complementary set of skills and expertise that aligns with the Company’s long-term strategic go

  37. Slide 37: Corporate Governance – Shareholder-Focused Pay-for-Performance Philosophy

    Corporate Governance – PDC’s Shareholder-Focused Pay-for-Performance Philosophy CEO All Other NEOs 14% • Annual incentive plan incorporates production, cash flow, and capital efficiency metrics that are critical to PDC’s strategic plan and highly correlated with shareholder value creation in the ind

  38. Slide 38: Corporate Governance – Compensation Framework Ensures Shareholder Alignment

    Corporate Governance – Compensation Framework Ensures Further Shareholder Alignment • PDC’s executive compensation relative to price performance has historically performed very favorably vs. peers Shareholders have consistently and resoundingly approved of PDC’s executive compensation via “say on pa

  39. Slide 39: Analysis of Kimmeridge Demands

    ANALYSIS OF KIMMERIDGE DEMANDS

  40. Slide 40: Kimmeridge's Changing Demands Highlight a Lack of Public Company Operating Experience

    Kimmeridge’s Changing Demands Highlight a Lack of Public Company Operating Experience Develop a plan to earning a return on average capital employed (ROACE) above PDC’s weighted average cost of capital (WACC) at $50/bbl and $3/mcf PDC is already a leader in proactively adopting a free cash flow and

  41. Slide 41: PDC Takes a Systematic Approach to Selection of Proxy Peers

    PDC Takes a Systematic Approach to Selection of Proxy Peers • Based on input from Meridian Compensation Partners LLC, a leading independent compensation consulting firm, PDC takes a systematic approach to proxy peer selection and annually refreshes the peer group to reflect changes relating to size

  42. Slide 42: Kimmeridge's Ever-Changing Peer Group Analysis

    Kimmeridge’s Ever-Changing Peer Group Analysis 1 • • Kimmeridge’s use of peer groups has been ever-changing, misleading and misguided from Day 1 Kimmeridge’s most recent attempt at a peer group is vastly different from peer groups used in its prior presentations (including one published on May 6); t

  43. Slide 43: Kimmeridge's Criticism of PDC's Peer Group is Self-Serving

    Kimmeridge’s Criticism of PDC’s Peer Group is Self-Serving, Misguided and Misleading 1 2-year 3-year Kimmeridge peer group (as filed 5/10/19) (34%) 25% Kimmeridge peer group (as adjusted by PDC)1 (40%) (9%) Original Kimmeridge 13D (2/22/19) PDC’s earnings call/operational update (2/27/19) Colorado S

  44. Slide 44: PDC's FCF Margin and CROCI Benchmark at Top-End of Peer Set

    PDC’s FCF Margin and CROCI Consistently Benchmark at the Top-End of PDC’s Appropriate Peer Set 1 • Free cash flow margin is a short-term metric which identifies relative profitability of a company’s asset base and the ability to drive free cash flow from capital spend In both 2019 and 2020, the mark

  45. Slide 45: PDC's FCF Margin and CROCI Benchmark at Top-End of Peer Set

    PDC’s FCF Margin and CROCI Consistently Benchmark at the Top-End of PDC’s Appropriate Peer Set 1 1 SRCI 19% JAG 11% JAG 23% JAG 28% JAG 20% JAG 21% SRCI 14% SRCI 17% SRCI 14% 3 SM 13% PE 11% XOG 14% CDEV 15% WPX 14% 4 OAS 13% WPX 9% WPX 13% SRCI 14% 5 XOG 12% XOG 9% PE 10% PE 14% XOG 13% XOG 14% 6 C

  46. Slide 46: CROCI Provides a Better Measure of Cash Returns Than ROACE

    CROCI provides a better measure of cash returns on investment than ROACE, which can be skewed by accounting methodology 1 Successful Efforts Accounting Full Cost Accounting PDCE (successful efforts) 23% 12% 12% 10% 9% 8% 14% 6% 6% 13% 5% 5% 13% 12% 4% 11% 10% 10% 10% 10% 9% 1% 6% 6% 6% (0%) (1%) (7%

  47. Slide 47: Kimmeridge's Own Analysis Shows PDC's Returns Have Exceeded Peers

    Kimmeridge’s Own Analysis Shows that PDC’s Returns Have Exceeded Peers 1 • PDC employs a disciplined approach that considers both prudent capital allocation and free cash flow, as well as growth • Since 2008, PDC has made great strides to realign its portfolio to become an oil-focused operator in tw

  48. Slide 48: PDC's G&A Costs are Consistent with Peer Metrics

    PDC’s G&A Costs are Consistent with Peer Metrics 2 Diversified peers Permian peers DJ peers $4.86 $4.62 $4.22 $3.99 $3.70 $3.30 $3.29 $3.09 $2.62 $2.27 $2.26 $2.17 Capitalized G&A / full-cost accounting policy • Kimmeridge proposal to cut $80mm of SG&A fails to contemplate sustainability as a going

  49. Slide 49: PDC Has Already Shown Significant Improvement in G&A in 1Q19

    PDC has already shown significant improvement in G&A in 1Q19 2 G&A per Boe $6.00 Responsible Operations Scalability Legal $4.78 $3.00 $0.00 1Q18 2Q18 3Q18 G&A per Boe 4Q18 1Q19 $5.85 $6.00 $3.00 $0.00 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019e 50 May 2019 $5.07 $4.25 $3.78 $3.00 - $3.40 $4.01$3.97 $4.19 $3.53 •1Q19

  50. Slide 50: PDC is Returning Capital to Shareholders

    PDC is Returning Capital to Shareholders 3 Board approved share repurchase program – Up to $200mm program, dependent upon market conditions Near-term value-creation – Execution of program with target completion date of December 31, 20201 Longer-term value creation – Continued free cash flow generati

  51. Slide 51: PDC has Efficiently Executed on its Development Program, Exceeding Expectations

    PDC has Efficiently Executed on its Development Program, Exceeding Expectations 4 • Kimmeridge “cherry picks” 2018 as a year in which some actual results did not meet expectations without consideration of the drivers of the deviation, much of which was due to capital efficiency benefits throughout t

  52. Slide 52: PDC has Opportunistically Enhanced its Asset Scale in Core Areas

    PDC has Opportunistically Enhanced its Asset Scale in Core Areas 5 • • Since 2016, PDC has made multiple asset trades across the Wattenberg to acquire contiguous acreage and focus on longer lateral lengths to increase efficiencies Since entry into the Permian, PDC’s Board and management have taken a

  53. Slide 53: PDC's Slate of Directors Have Substantially More Experience

    PDC’s Slate of Directors Have Substantially More Experience Relative to Kimmeridge’s Director Nominees 6 • • PDC’s nominees possess an incredible breadth of both industry and operational experience A vote for Kimmeridge’s slate removes CEO Bart Brookman as a Director, thus removing any management re

  54. Slide 54: Management Compensation is Aligned with Shareholder Interests

    Management Compensation is Aligned with Shareholder Interests and Compares Favorably to the Industry 7 Use of a strict non-discretionary metric-based quantitative payout for 50% of the annual cash incentive for 2019 2018 2019e Total comp as Total comp as # Company a % of EBITDA # Company a % of EBIT

  55. Slide 55: Kimmeridge's Interests are Not Aligned with Other Stockholders

    Kimmeridge’s Interests are Not Aligned with Other Stockholders • Kimmeridge does not have a track record of enhancing long term shareholder value Activist Ends Campaign Against Oil Company, Walks Off With $90mm “Kimmeridge had urged Carrizo to sell its South Texas drilling fields and focus instead o

  56. Slide 56: PDC Energy – Corporate Social Responsibility

    PDC Energy – Corporate Social Responsibility SAFE OPERATIONS EMPLOYEES MATTER COMMUNITY OUTREACH 57 May 2019

  57. Slide 57: PDC's Highly Qualified Board of Directors

    PDC’s Highly Qualified Board of Directors Bart Brookman (President & CEO) Director since 2015 Mr. Brookman, the Company’s President and Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”), was appointed to the Board in January 2015, simultaneous with his appointment as the Company’s CEO. Mr. Brookman originally joined

  58. Slide 58: PDC's Highly Qualified Board of Directors

    PDC’s Highly Qualified Board of Directors Jeffrey C. Swoveland (Non-Executive Chairman) Director since 1991 Mr. Swoveland, a National Association of Corporate Directors Board Leadershop Fellow, was first elected to the Board in 1991 and was elected Non-Executive Chairman of the Board in June 2011. F

  59. Slide 59: PDC's Highly Qualified Board of Directors

    PDC’s Highly Qualified Board of Directors Randy S. Nickerson Director since 2017 Mr. Nickerson joined the Board in March 2017. Mr. Nickerson most recently served as the Executive Vice President, Corporate Strategy of Marathon Petroleum Corporation (“MPC”) and Executive Vice President and Chief Comme

  60. Slide 60: PDC's Highly Qualified Board of Directors

    PDC’s Highly Qualified Board of Directors Randy S. Nickerson Director since 2017 Mr. Nickerson joined the Board in March 2017. Mr. Nickerson most recently served as the Executive Vice President, Corporate Strategy of Marathon Petroleum Corporation ("MPC") and Executive Vice President and Chief Comme

PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (May 2019) on 6ix