GCP Applied Technologies — Proxy Contest (May 2020)
29 slides from GCP Applied Technologies's proxy contest presentation, May 11, 2020
Slide 1: Supplemental Materials May 2020
Supplemental Materials (To Be Viewed In Combination With Starboard Investor Presentation Dated April 30, 2020) May 2020
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer This presentation and any of the information contained herein (this “Presentation”) is for general informational purposes only and is not complete. Under no circumstances is this Presentation intended to be, nor should it be construed as advice or a recommendation to enter into or conclud
Slide 3: Executive Summary
Executive Summary On April 30, 2020, Starboard published a detailed investor presentation outlining: –1 GCP’s track record of poor operating and financial performance; 2– Management’s lack of accountability and track record of missed expectations; 3– Significant management compensation(1) and gove
Slide 4: I. GCP Appears to Have Misled Shareholders Regarding Stock Price Performance
I. GCP Appears to Have Misled Shareholders Regarding Stock Price Performance 4
Slide 5: Despite GCP's Attempts to Claim Credit For Key Milestones, Stock Price Performance Has Been Poor
Despite GCP’s Attempts to Claim Credit For Key Milestones, Stock Price Performance Has Been Poor GCP would like to take credit for value creation milestones over the last several years, but stock price performance relative to peers and broader indices has underperformed since each such milestone.
Slide 6: Board's Choice of the S&P 600 as a Basis of Comparison Seems Disingenuous
In Addition, the Board’s Choice of the S&P 600 as a Basis of Comparison Seems Disingenuous The Company has never presented the S&P 600 as a benchmark for stock price performance, yet the Board chose to make it a reference index for its May 1, 2020 presentation to shareholders, while ignoring compari
Slide 7: II. GCP Appears to Have Cherry-Picked Segment Benchmarks and Manipulated Numbers
II. GCP Appears to Have Cherry-Picked Segment Benchmarks and Manipulated Numbers In An Attempt to Justify Poor Results 7
Slide 8: GCP Highlights Numerous Bolt-On M&A Transactions Yet Total Revenue Has Declined Since Spin-Off
GCP Highlights Numerous Bolt-On M&A Transactions Yet Total Revenue Has Declined Since Spin-Off The Company has spent approximately $200 million on six bolt-on M&A transactions since spin-off, yet total revenue has declined. The Company stated that GCP acquired approximately $90 million of revenue
Slide 9: GCP Claims of Dramatic Improvement In Its SCC Segment Are Extremely Misleading
GCP Claims of Dramatic Improvement In Its SCC Segment Are Extremely Misleading GCP has taken an extremely rosy view of its operating performance while seemingly ignoring years of poor results. SCC Adjusted Gross Profit Has Declined(1) $18 million decline ($ in millions) Misleading Operational Improv
Slide 10: We Are Puzzled By the Company's Selection of SBM's Peer Group
We Are Puzzled By the Company’s Selection of SBM’s Peer Group We believe the questionable benchmarking is either a disingenuous attempt to mislead investors by comparing oranges to apples, or a troubling and fundamental misunderstanding of GCP’s SBM business. What is GCP’s SBM Business? Why Are Buil
Slide 11: A More Appropriate Measure of SBM's True Operating Capabilities is Management's Own Targets
A More Appropriate Measure of SBM’s True Operating Capabilities is Management’s Own Targets Before Era of Underperformance Shareholders should disregard the Board’s erroneous and misleading benchmarking on SBM. We believe the business has great and exciting potential, with the right level of investm
Slide 12: GCP Claims Aggressive SG&A Management But Actual Results Reflect a Different Story
GCP Claims Aggressive SG&A Management But Actual Results Reflect a Different Story The Board has overseen a period of rising SG&A – both absolute expense and as a percent of revenue – and has used selective and misleading data points in an attempt to convince shareholders otherwise. Excerpt From GCP
Slide 13: The Board Is Also Portraying SG&A in a Highly Misleading Manner
The Board Is Also Portraying SG&A in a Highly Misleading Manner GCP is misleading shareholders by using adjusted non-GAAP metrics in some cases, and GAAP metrics in others cases, where it serves the Company’s purpose. The Company Provides Extensive Non-GAAP Disclosures Each Quarter… GCP has told sha
Slide 14: GCP Seems to be Justifying Poor Performance by Pointing to Misleading Data Points
In Addition, GCP Seems to be Justifying Poor Performance by Pointing to Misleading Data Points The peer metrics that the Company uses as comparison for its SG&A expense ratio are misleading. Excerpt From GCP May 2020 Investor Presentation Adjusted SG&A Expense Ratio Comparison(1) GCP is significantl
Slide 15: GCP Continues to Tout Its Expensive Restructuring Efforts Despite a Lack of Improvement
GCP Continues to Tout Its Expensive Restructuring Efforts Despite a Lack of Improvement Despite spending $78 million on restructuring and repositioning activities, operating income has declined. The Company has consistently touted its restructuring efforts, but fails to acknowledge or meaningfully
Slide 16: GCP Also Fails To Address the Lack of Free Cash Flow
GCP Also Fails To Address the Lack of Free Cash Flow Despite Significant Restructuring Efforts From 2017 to 2019, GCP’s cumulative free cash flow generation has been negative, largely due to significant restructuring and repositioning costs that have yet to yield tangible benefits for shareholders.
Slide 17: III. GCP Has Attempted to Impugn the Backgrounds of Our Nominees
III. GCP Has Attempted to Impugn the Strong and Highly Relevant Backgrounds of Our Nominees, While Failing to Adequately Address Its Own Governance and Board Composition Shortcomings 17
Slide 18: GCP's Characterization of Its Settlement Proposal to Starboard is Highly Misleading
GCP’s Characterization of Its Settlement Proposal to Starboard is Highly Misleading GCP had only proposed one new director recommended by Starboard and one new mutual appointee. While the Board is attempting to suggest that it had offered Starboard three board seats, the offer included both Clay K
Slide 19: GCP Claims Credit For Board Refreshment But Has Increased Board Interlocks
GCP Claims Credit For Significant Board Refreshment But Has Actually Increased Concerning Board Interlocks GCP wants to take credit for refreshing the Board, but has in fact taken every opportunity to appoint directors who have relationships with, and/or are former colleagues of, existing board memb
Slide 20: GCP has Failed to Address the Monopolization of Board Leadership Roles
GCP has Failed to Directly Address the Monopolization of Board Leadership Roles by Three Directors With Longstanding Relationships We question whether Elizabeth Mora, Janice Henry and Gerald Colella – three directors monopolizing leadership positions on GCP’s Board – are truly capable of acting inde
Slide 21: Our Board Nominees' Operating Experience Is Superior
Our Board Nominees’ Operating Experience Is Superior Industry Experience Experience Highlights Key Skills Fmr EVP, Led 40 operating plants globally (~9,500 employees and over 5,000 contractors) Procurement & Manufacturing LyondellBasell (LYB) Responsible for a cost budget of over $2B/year and
Slide 22: Starboard's Slate Would Include Six New Directors and Four Incumbent Directors
Starboard’s Slate, If Elected, Would Include Six New Directors And Four Incumbent or Company-Nominated Directors We have compiled a diverse slate of experienced industry experts who can propel GCP forward. Starboard Nominees Construction / Prior Public C-Level / President Turnaround Chemicals Compan
Slide 23: Protect and Enhance Your Investment by Voting on the WHITE Proxy Card Today
Protect and Enhance Your Investment by Voting on the WHITE Proxy Card Today Starboard has a long history of driving operational, financial, and strategic turnarounds. We believe we have a better plan to create value. We believe we have a superior slate of directors. Vote on Starboard’s WHITE
Slide 24: Appendix A
Appendix A 24
Slide 25: We Were Shocked by the Board's Decision to Appoint Greg Poling Executive Chairman
We Were Shocked by the Board's Decision to Appoint Greg Poling Executive Chairman of the Company Randy Dearth had previously been the CEO of a public company and Messrs. Dearth and Poling had overlapped at GCP for almost one year, providing adequate time to transition by the time Mr. Dearth was appo
Slide 26: GCP's Closest Peers' Very Positive Performance Reflects a Robust Macro Environment
GCP’s Closest Peers’ Very Positive Performance Reflects a Robust Macro Environment As an example, over the last two years, GCP’s closest peers for the SBM segment have enthusiastically discussed the growth they’ve been able to achieve – indicating both a healthy macro environment and share capture –
Slide 27: GCP Has Disappointed Shareholders Since the Spin-Off
GCP Has Disappointed Shareholders Since the Spin-Off GCP has had poor financial and stock price performance. GCP Performance Since 2016 Organic Revenue Direct Peers(1) (4.9%) 5.1% Growth Has Relative Underperformed (2) Performance 0.2% Direct Peers(1) 13.4% Operating (3.4%) Margin Has Relative Under
Slide 28: Despite GCP's Struggles, Its Closest Peers Have Not Faced Similar Challenges
Despite GCP’s Struggles, Its Closest Peers Have Not Faced Similar Challenges While GCP has struggled to improve both revenue growth and operating margins, its direct competitors have fared significantly better. 2015 – 2019 Organic Sales CAGR (1) 2015 – 2019 Change in Adj. EBIT Margin GCP 2016 Invest
Slide 29: GCP Has Underperformed Peers Since Spinning Off From W.R. Grace
GCP Has Underperformed Peers Since Spinning Off From W.R. Grace Despite a favorable industry backdrop and possessing an enviable portfolio of high quality products, GCP has lagged peers on both revenue growth and profitability over the past few years. Construction Industry Trends Have Been Favorable