Texas Industries — Proxy Contest (October 2009)
53 slides from Texas Industries's proxy contest presentation, Oct 13, 2009
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Definitive Additional Materials
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a
Slide 2: The Case for Change at Texas Industries, Inc.
Shamrock The 1(NYSE: CaseTXI) for Capital Change Advisors, at TexasInc. Industries, Inc.
Slide 3: Shamrock's Purpose
Shamrock Purpose Nominating Proposing We Operational A Inadequate Poor 2Our history believe nominees shareholder governance of Activist three management Texas underperformance three over-promising will corporate policies communication Industries candidates Value seek to accountability Fund, and gove
Slide 4: TXI Is Undervalued
TXI Poor A Board The 3We pattern believe board Company’s has operating stock shareholder and aof history has management TXI TXI’s over-promising underperformed unilaterally margins is board communication of compensation undervalued underperformance nominees and interests implemented return andits be
Slide 5: Shamrock's Goal
Shamrock’s Make Goal Review Our Perform Carefully Promote Majority Require Eliminate Provide 4Annual nominees isoperational to elections shareholder strategic shareholders shareholder acorporate appropriate voting consider all improve promote comprehensive nominees supermajority will standard altern
Slide 6: TXI Shareholders Support Change
TXI Southeastern Nassef In 5increasing hisshareholders letter Sawiris, shareholder publicly Asset 14.9% representing Management Management, expressing value” shareholder, 24.2% support, and Inc., announced Nassef of9.3% the Nassef TXI shareholder, Sawiris support Sawiris outstanding support on state
Slide 7: Leading Proxy Advisory Firm Recommendation
Leading RiskMetrics “…on as Further, Proxy “Because well 6Note: well asPermission Governance, balance as poor we proxy the the believe governance Group dissidents prevalence we advisory to conclude recommended the Inc. reprint dissidents’ have recommended firms practices of RiskMetrics that several
Slide 8: TXI's Record of Poor Performance
7TXI’s Record of Poor Performance
Slide 9: TXI Stock Performance Summary
TXI’s 40% 1-YR TXI (1) (2) (3) (4) per TSR TXI 6/29/09 Peer 2008 Historical (3) 31% TSR(2) stock returns Peer group isTXI 29% total was has Group(4) proxy 3-YR (VMC, Stock 30% assume shareholder the underperformed date TSR statement. 23% Performance MLM, that SAVF 5-YR 20%Chaparral returns, EXP) 10%
Slide 10: TXI Price Multiples and ROIC versus Peers
Materials TXI Price ROIC Eagle (2) Current Vulcan Martin 50.0x TXI (1) (2) stock /Materials ROIC EPS Martin Materials(3) Average -Texas Year traded 5.0x Source: stock VMC Price Industries Year Marietta Materials Texas Eagle Vulcan 8.1% has Marietta(2) 4.0% 10.0x Capital at / Tangible Materialsa disc
Slide 11: TXI EBIT Margins versus Peers
TXIbelieve LTM Lafarge Materials Vulcan Mitsubishi 0% We Source: 10 5% margins EBIT Materials 10% Capital Titan Cementos Materials TXI’s Margins 15% have Cement IQHeidelbergCement low 20% been for Portland 5-Year Mitsubishi Buzzi relative the 0% among quarter 5% Average Unicem Valderrivas margins 10
Slide 12: TXI Return on Invested Capital versus Peers
TXI’s LTM Buzzi Holcim Italcementi CEMEX 0% We Source: 11 believe 5% 2% Return Unicem return 10% 4% Cementos Capital Holcim the Italcementi 6%on 15% Eagle Company’s 8% IQ invested Invested Cementos 20% Portland for 10% Materials the Eagle capital Capital quarter low Valderrivas Portland Materials Ma
Slide 13: Lack of Effective Board Oversight
Lack of Effective Board Oversight 12
Slide 14: Better Board Oversight of Capital Allocation
(1) Better $$427 + $0 Board 294 55 (2) in Grandemillion Source: 13 million profit(2) board has SAVF TXI authorized plant SEC of oversight spent FY iscapitalized 2009 estimates. onHunter filings, “not management Oro suspended 10-K. overinterest Grande capital profitable” TXI earnings Hunter (2005-200
Slide 15: Delayed Reaction to Market Downturn
While indefinitely TXI Delayed 14 board misjudged has competitors been reaction and suspended slow management declining toconserved toa severe right-size cement misjudged market capital itsdemand cost downturn to structure preserve theinmarket itsdemonstrates markets balance to match and sheet deman
Slide 16: TXI Management Underperformance versus Targets
TXI Grande Issue Management Announced Oro margins Company potential Source: (1)SAVF 15 has Target TXI 20% a$383 calculation EBIT EBITDA history budget EBIT Reality earnings has 5.2% million repeatedly of $60 (LTM) $350 Underperformance over-promising based conference $108 million million $114 on mil
Slide 17: Management Over-Promising: Oro Grande
TXI On Management to Reality: would we Source: 16 be believe the has atbe Oro least TXI “You aable history itGrande, earnings $60 will Claim: will to sell million take of recall California over-promising “In roughly conference usCalifornia, that or longer inwe the terms expansion to have full call r
Slide 18: Management Over-Promising: Hunter Expansion
TXIthe On Analyst happened Management CEMEX Brekhus Reality: afford (CEO), Source: 17 has us Hunter, TXI TXI Question: “Finally, a(CEO), is incremental here history going Q2’09 earnings Claim: in Texas TXI California.” we to of “And Earnings come over-promising “The have Q1’09 expansion earnings con
Slide 19: Management Over-Promising: Margin Goals
On Margin Management our just Reality: FY TXI Source: 18 2006 goal our hasgoal EBIT TXI TXI’s aat FYhistory Margin all. Improvements earnings 2007 of Claim: EBIT When reaching of FY 9.4% over-promising margins “…we you conference 2008 13.5% an look EBIT FY had have at9.6% 2009 previously overall cal
Slide 20: Pay for Performance: Executive Compensation
(1) Pay 2003 $7 $6 $4 $5 $5.2 $3 $3.0 $2 $1.7 $2.4 $1.9 $1 $1.1 $1.4 $0.5 FY 31% 40% (21%) (20%) (10%) (40%) 1-YR From Over TXI Short-term Using TXI’s (2) $1.2 (3) 19 $5.7 $3.8 $2.7 $1.8 2003 not Top Historical Peer should $1.6 $1.2 $0.9 $0 29% the -2003 TSR ROE (30%) 2008 $3.3 $2.7 $2.2 proportiona
Slide 21: TXI's Current Compensation Practices
TXI’s Current TXI Calculation No Recommended Other Disclosure Annual Equity Should Clawback 20 holding clawback uses metrics compensation incentives require bonus practice ROE should should period methodology should cash potential in holding practice be setting have should clearly required incentive
Slide 22: TXI's Record of Poor Shareholder Communication
TXI’s Record of Poor Shareholder Communication 21
Slide 23: TXI's Communication with Shareholders
TXI’s him Meryl –Mel The “In to Source: 22TXI him response “explanation aBrekhus: Brekhus Board communication Q1’09 Witmer Witmer: that SEC itsseat. to filings, (CEO): Earnings “That’s “You Board (Eagle “What “That thein I request think have front TXI of “No, it’s Capital correct.” with do Call Dire
Slide 24: Is the Board Listening to Shareholders?
Is the % Proxy 2008 24% 2007 Not The 25% (1) to 23 retire Votes Eugenio up board Not board Year for at withheld(1) up has the election Mel listening R. for 2008 never Clariond G. election Brekhus Annual explained to the is 49% not shareholders? Meeting David 49% shown or responded S. Not after Coats
Slide 25: Poor Communication on Director Replacement
Poor In proxy TXI The Why 24 thehigh has communication the 2008 statement never board withhold director addressed circumvented forvotes the election, regarding 2008 from or explained: Annual the the TXI board normal 2007 director was circumvented and director retiring. 2008 elections election direct
Slide 26: Is the Board Dominated by Robert Rogers?
Is the Robert Almost At He When nominees 25 asuggested recent board asked D. alllacked Rogers of meeting of why TXI’s that directors independence the has even current with Governance been ifdominated Shamrock our adirectors director nominees – apparently Committee by representatives, have ofRobert a
Slide 27: Shamrock Nominees (Election of Directors - Proposal 1)
Shamrock Nominees (Election of Directors - Proposal 1) 26
Slide 28: Shamrock's Highly Qualified Nominees
Shamrock’s Our which Marjorie Dennis Gary Detailed 27 highly L.we A. Pechota information L.believe Johnson, qualified Bowen nominees isTexas President is CFA nominees regarding aare former Industries isqualified portfolio andcollectively Managing theCEO needs background tomanager address of substant
Slide 29: Shamrock's Goal
Shamrock’s Make Promote Review Our Perform Carefully Recommend Majority Require Eliminate Provide Annual 28 nominees operational elections shareholder strategic shareholders shareholder aappropriate voting consider all comprehensive nominees corporate supermajority will standard alternatives for imp
Slide 30: The Shareholder Proposals
(1) Shamrock 29 The Shareholder full text ofProposals(1) the three Shamrock proposals is in Annex B of this presentation.
Slide 31: Corporate Governance Improvements
TXIshareholder Current SAVF Classified Plurality Supermajority No Majority “Poison Simple Shareholders Annual Our 30 three has Recommendation majority elections shareholder policy pills” avoting vote shareholder number board cannot should in implemented submitted shareholder “say in voting all for o
Slide 32: Our Three Proposals
TXI Our Declassify -Institute Obtain We TXI’s Whose 31Majority believe three should opposition shareholder interests majority proposals Voting the the makeboard financial are to voting Resolution) appropriate approval they our request andthree performance in protecting? require uncontested that of p
Slide 33: Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3)
Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3) 32
Slide 34: Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3)
Board TXI’s We Directors TXI Shamrock’s accountable Meeting 33 believe shareholders classified Declassification ofshould Shareholders, the three right board stand cannot nominees to currently on hold Resolution act iftheir the have directors by individual board written provides agreed (Proposal acco
Slide 35: Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4)
Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4) 34
Slide 36: Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4)
TXI’s aBy Majority We as 35new requested contrast, believe also plurality nominee, believe Voting voting, plurality ainmajority our voting will that Resolution coupled Board majority voting do) standard voting awith Declassification good in (Proposal voting the standard aensures job requirement elec
Slide 37: Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5)
Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5) 36
Slide 38: Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5)
Shareholder TXI’s first second third We Statutory No 37 value Vote believe poison poison board poison =protections No the poison pill pill Vote has Transparency. pill shareholders unilaterally unilaterally adopted on unilaterally pills Poison (such should three as adopted Pills adopted should Becaus
Slide 39: Annexes and Additional Information
Shareholder TXI’s first second third We Statutory No Annexes 37 value 38 Vote believe poison poison board poison =and protections No the poison pill pill Vote has Additional Transparency. pill shareholders unilaterally unilaterally adopted on unilaterally pills Poison (such should Information three
Slide 40: Annex A
Annex A 6 39
Slide 41: Shamrock's Nominees: Marjorie L. Bowen
Shamrock’s Marjorie was advised shareholder for and companies. Airlines, operators. 40 Euramax Western one corporations, of Inc., L.Ms. five Since Bowen: value, Nominees Europe. International, both Bowen members April debt U.S.- Ms. Since directors graduated (page and 2008, Bowen certificated ofInc.
Slide 42: Shamrock's Nominees: Dennis A. Johnson
Shamrock’s Dennis of Value September Directors California U.S. Hospital Analyst 41 Shamrock Congress Fund. A. (CFA) atof Johnson, Chapter, 2005 UCLA. Nominees the Prior Partners on Charterholder. Council until various toMr. from CFA: joining Activist July (page Johnson of September Since investor 20
Slide 43: Shamrock's Nominees: Gary L. Pechota
Shamrock’s Gary the cement in Mr. magazine stock January April Inc. BKH), received 1974, 42 mid-1992 Administrative, Pechota (Nasdaq: L. 1981. performance. and an operations Pechota: 1983 his recognized energy isMr. Nominees B.S. was served aasuntil IIIN), Certified its Pechota ain Since company cem
Slide 44: Annex B
Annex B 43
Slide 45: Text of Shamrock's Proposals
Text and The “RESOLVED, Board in standing 44 anpromptly Board Majority of uncontested ofShamrock’s for Directors, Declassification election Voting institute thatelection the each Proposals Resolution exceeds annual shareholders director shall Resolution the elections (page be (Proposal number shall
Slide 46: Text of Shamrock's Proposals (Poison Pills)
Text Shareholder The “RESOLVED, November Shareholders purchase affirmative 45 of Shamrock’s rights 1, vote 2006, and, that issued of Vote (b) the between Proposals if on under holders shareholders the Poison holders the (page ofCompany Rights Pills a majority of of 2Resolution of atthe Agreement lea
Slide 47: Annex C
Annex C 46
Slide 48: About Shamrock
About Shamrock “SAVF”). SCA The 47 Shamrock manages Shamrock SCA Capital funds Activist is Capital aAdvisors, subsidiary with Value Advisors, 5 distinct Inc. Fund of (“SCA”) Shamrock Inc. holds combines has strategies $810 2.8 isHoldings, the million with a deep manager total value in shares Inc. co
Slide 49: Annex D
Annex D 48
Slide 50: Most Valuable Path to Restore TXI Value
Most To TXI The Our We 49 restore believe do seek TXI three continues management industry not to board nominees, value believe improve TXI’s in TXI’s this participants to must istoexperience stock needs not that TXI operational long-term who engage the this shares, istoright possess trading are be m
Slide 51: TXI's Low Stock Price versus Replacement Cost
TXI’s ($ Low Cement #Aggregate Replacement TXI Net Diluted Total Share Premium (1) p. (2) (3) (4) 50 of 6. and Aggregate $275/ton Net Debt Ready-Mix Replacement High TXI Price stock metric debt Shares Capacity including to Net Reserves as trades Current includes cement Cost tons reserves and Replace
Slide 52: TXI Low Stock Price versus Strategic Value
…and TXI ($ Low Exit EBITDA Total Less: Equity Diluted Value Share Premium (1) (2) (3) 51 inTXI Based Net Strategic Multiple(1) High millions, Enterprise Net Price Per aValue debt Shares management steep Potential to Debt Share onas Current includes industry $2,486.9 discount Value except of Outstan
Slide 53: Important Information
The proxy Information http://www.shamrock-txiproxy.com. is Shamrock that Shareholders txi@mackenziepartners.com. contained may Shamrock materials beActivist sent regarding inwho Activist Shamrock Shamrock toneed Value youwhy Value by assistance Fund, Activist Activist or Shamrock on Fund, L.P. behal