Instructure — Proxy Contest (January 2020)
24 slides from Instructure's proxy contest presentation, Jan 22, 2020
Slide 1: Investor Presentation January 2020
Investor Presentation January 2020Investor Presentation January 2020
Slide 2: All-cash $47.60 per share Thoma Bravo deal is a compelling price
All-cash $47.60 per share Thoma Bravo deal is a compelling price, exhaustively shopped, and materially better than standalone option Market speculation just prior to announcement distorted the view ● Comprehensive review of strategic options, including remaining standalone, Bridge separation, strate
Slide 3: A year long, conflict-free process with 55 parties
A year long, conflict-free process with 55 parties Thoughtful, Comprehensive Strategic Process “We have read lots of interesting merger background • Led by directors with significant deal experience materials... We have never seen such an exhaustive list • Board engaged with any parties interested i
Slide 4: 4th highest revenue multiple paid for a public SaaS company by a private equity acquiror
4th highest revenue multiple paid for a public SaaS company by a private equity acquiror Transaction enterprise value (EV)-to-next twelve months (NTM) revenue multiple 8.6x 7.9x 7.0x 6.8x 6.7x 6.6x 6.2x 6.0x 5.9x Median (excluding Instructure): 5.3x 4.6x 4.6x 4.5x 3.9x 3.4x 2.2x 1.7x Source: Company
Slide 5: Significant premium to stock price prior to speculation driven by activists and market rumors
Significant premium to stock price prior to speculation driven by activists and market rumors In thousands (k) $55 5,000 Significant, speculative 1 J $53 increase in volume 4,500 $51 4,000 I Thoma Bravo deal price: $47.60 K $49 3,500 B G $47 3,000 A H $45 2,500 28% premium $43 2,000 F $41 E 1,500 C
Slide 6: Transaction delivers material premiums to undisturbed stock prices
Transaction delivers material premiums to undisturbed stock prices Thoma Bravo deal price: $47.60 Premium: Premium: Premium: 28% 12% 18% $42.44 $40.47 $37.23 1 Low point achieved once Q1/Q2 earnings Closing price prior to unaffected price 3-month VWAP prior to unaffected price absorbed by market 1 C
Slide 7: Slowing growth constrains standalone intrinsic value despite forecast EBITDA improvement
Slowing growth constrains standalone intrinsic value despite forecast EBITDA improvement Thoma Bravo deal price: $47.60 Key Observations Premium: Premium: ● Rapid deceleration of growth from 2017 to 2019 with no recovery in out years A 27% 12% ● EBITDA margins relatively flat 2019-2020 B ● EBITDA ma
Slide 8: Analyst response validates comprehensiveness of process and fairness of offer price
Analyst response validates comprehensiveness of process and fairness of offer price “We have read lots of interesting merger background materials as part of proxy reviews related to M&A transactions. We have never seen such an exhaustive list of financial sponsors and potential strategic acquirers i
Slide 9: Analysts' estimates recognize Instructure's challenging operating environment
Analysts’ estimates recognize Instructure’s challenging operating environment Consensus Estimates Key Observations Revenue growth Operating margin 2020E 2021E 2020E 2021E • Reduced growth and profitability expectations highlight 1 In Jan 2019 23.6% 20.1% (3.9%) 0.5% challenges facing the business •
Slide 10: Recent quarterly results have exposed the risks to the standalone plan
Recent quarterly results have exposed the risks to the standalone plan Q4-18 Q1-19 Q2-19 Q3-19 T+1 stock price reaction (5%) (8%) (1%) 6% Rev. growth (Qtr. guide vs. consensus) (5%) 1% (0%) (3%) Revenue growth (change vs. pre-announce) : 2020 consensus 22% / (2%) 21% / (0%) 21% / (1%) 18% / (3%) 202
Slide 11: Our standalone alternative faces serious headwinds
Our standalone alternative faces serious headwinds Rapid deceleration of revenue growth underscores the standalone risk about which we had been warning the market…. “We expect our revenue growth rates to slow in future periods 1 Revenue growth (Education only) due to a number of reasons, which may i
Slide 12: The Board ran a thoughtful, exhaustive and deliberate process that thoroughly tested buyer interest
The Board ran a thoughtful, exhaustive and deliberate process that thoroughly tested buyer interest Transaction Announced 12/4/19 5/13/19 2/12/19 2/4/19 12/24/18 11/12/18 11/11/18 3/6/18 11/27/17 5/30/17 5/1/17 5/31/16 4/18/16 2/14/16 Transaction value $2.0 $0.5 $3.7 $10.9 $1.9 $5.7 $1.9 $1.1 $0.5 $
Slide 13: A year long, conflict-free process with 55 parties
A year long, conflict-free process with 55 parties Thoughtful, Comprehensive Strategic Process “We have read lots of interesting merger background • Led by directors with significant deal experience materials... We have never seen such an exhaustive list • Board engaged with any parties interested i
Slide 14: Stage 1 (Initial inbound discussions) – Board oversaw initial discussions with financial sponsors
Stage 1 (Initial inbound discussions) – Board oversaw initial discussions with financial sponsors ● Received inbound interest from 3 financial sponsors including a “preliminary proposal” from one party in January 2019 ● Board evaluated the preliminary proposal, with assistance from external advisors
Slide 15: Stage 2 (Focused strategic review) – Strategic Actions Committee review of strategy and options
Stage 2 (Focused strategic review) – Strategic Actions Committee conducted a review of the company strategy and options ● Mandate: evaluate strategic business decisions for the Company including capital raises, cost reductions, divestures, and M&A Standalone Alternatives Buzz Waterhouse Lead Indepen
Slide 16: Stage 3 (Explore sale transaction) – Transaction Committee oversaw a robust and exhaustive process
Stage 3 (Explore sale transaction) – Transaction Committee oversaw a robust and exhaustive process ● Mandate: explore interest of third parties in acquiring Instructure and manage the sale process ● Prior to signing the Thoma Bravo deal, 40 parties were contacted (20 prior to public announcement) an
Slide 17: The Board went above and beyond to engage with Praesidium
The Board went above and beyond to reach out and engage with Praesidium, who actively pushed publicly and privately for a sale, prior to announcement • Since the 13D filing, the Company had extensive interactions with Praesidium, including 75+ emails, 15+ calls, and 2 meetings • When briefed on the
Slide 18: Praesidium's objections are not based in fact
Praesidium’s objections are not based in fact Praesidium Claim: Fact: th ● The Board ran a thoughtful process over a year-long period that resulted in the 4 highest revenue multiple paid by a PE firm in a SaaS take private ● The Board responded to every inbound expression of interest, retained advis
Slide 19: Praesidium's objections are not based in fact (continued)
Praesidium’s objections are not based in fact (continued) Praesidium Claim: Fact: ● Non-executive directors ran the process, and the full Board unanimously approved the transaction ● Dan had no role on the Transaction Committee Dan Goldsmith is biased in favor of Thoma Bravo ● Dan removed himself fr
Slide 20: Instructure Board recommends that stockholders vote to approve the transaction
Instructure Board recommends that stockholders vote to approve the transaction ● Now is the right time for this transaction, given the material execution risk in continuing as a standalone public company ● The robust strategic review process considered a broad range of options before the Board ultim
Slide 21: Appendix
Appendix > INSTRUCTURE
Slide 22: Roadmap to completion
Roadmap to completion Transaction remains on track to close in Q1 2020 Secured fully Seek Preliminary Seek Received Filed Anticipated Mailed equity financed stockholder proxy remaining early definitive closing date proxy transaction on approval at statement foreign termination proxy statement to sig
Slide 23: Additional Information and Where to Find It & Participants in the Solicitation
INVESTOR PRESENTATION, ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND WHERE TO FIND IT & PARTICIPANTS IN THE SOLICITATION This investor presentation (this presentation ) is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy or a recommendation to purchase any equ
Slide 24: Notice Regarding Forward-Looking Statements, Non-GAAP Measures & Use of Projections
NOTICE REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS, NON-GAAP MEASURES & USE OF PROJECTIONS This presentation contains “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 related to Instructure and the acquisition of Instructure. Forward-looking statements