Perot Systems — Technical Presentation (July 2002)
53 slides from Perot Systems's technical presentation, Jul 2, 2002
Slide 1: Inter-SC Trade Adjustment Bids
Inter-SC Trade Adjustment Bids Modeling Adjustment Bids on Inter-SC Trades as Adjustment Bids on Virtual Resources
Slide 2: Topics
Topics Use of virtual resources to hedge inter-SC trades against changes in the PX zonal prices .....(Slide 3) Use of virtual resources to hedge inter-SC trades against changes in transmission usage charges (PX not involved) ...........................(Slide 30) Comparison to modeling adjustment bid
Slide 3: Use of virtual resources to hedge trades against changes in the PX zonal prices
Use of virtual resources to hedge - trades against changes in the PX zonal prices
Slide 4: Inter-SC Trades with the PX
Inter-SC Trades with the PX We look at an approach to modeling adjustments to inter-SC trades that involve the PX. We recap the process outlined in the previous presentation. We also outline a process to net out the virtual resources to produce physical final schedules if desired. We provide a three
Slide 5: Inter-SC Sale To PX
Inter-SC Sale To PX An SC sells energy to the PX in a zone. The SC is to be paid the PX's zonal market clearing price (ZMCP) for the energy. Congestion Management can cause the PX's zonal market clearing price in the zone to change. If the PX's ZMCP falls, the SC may want to decrease its sale to the
Slide 6: Inter-SC Sale To PX
Inter-SC Sale To PX To model the adjustment on the inter-SC sale to the PX, the SC and PX specify a virtual load in the PX's portfolio in the zone of the inter-SC trade. The SC submits an IPS of zero for its virtual load in the PX portfolio. The SC can offer to buy back its inter-SC sale to PX. The
Slide 7: Inter-SC Sale To PX
Inter-SC Sale To PX IPS = 100 $/MWh MWh UMCP = 25 30 20 10 60 135 $/MWh MWh UMCP = 25 IPS = 0 30 20 10 - -35 100 40 A decrease in an SC's sale to PX is equivalent to a buy-back of energy by the SC in the PX's portfolio. That is, a virtual load in PX's market. Model a change to the SC's inter-SC sale
Slide 8: Inter-SC Sale To PX
Inter-SC Sale To PX SC PX Inter-SC Trade of 100 MWh Virtual_LoadA,SCIPS = 0 MWh Adjustment Bid -35 £ Virtual_ LoadA,SC £ 0 @ $30/MWh 0 £ Virtual_ LoadA,SC £ 40 @ $20/MWh 40 £ Virtual_ LoadA,SC £ 100 @ $10/MWh Zone A
Slide 9: Inter-SC Purchase from PX
Inter-SC Purchase from PX An SC buys energy from the PX in a zone. The SC is to pay the PX's zonal market clearing price (ZMCP) for the energy. Congestion Management can cause the PX's zonal market clearing price in the zone to change. If ZMCP rises, the SC may want to decrease its purchase from PX.
Slide 10: Inter-SC Purchase from PX
Inter-SC Purchase from PX MWh UMCP = 15 IPS = 0 $/MWh 30 20 10 - -35 100 40 A decrease in SC's purchase from PX is equivalent to a sell-back of energy by the SC in the PX's portfolio. That is, a virtual generator in PX's portfolio. Model a change to SC's inter-SC purchase as a virtual generator in P
Slide 11: Inter-SC Purchase from PX
Inter-SC Purchase from PX SC PX Inter-SC Trade of 100 MWh Virtual_GenA,SCIPS = 0 MWh Adjustment Bid -35 £ Virtual_ GenA,SC £ 0 @ $10/MWh 0 £ Virtual_ GenA,SC £ 40 @ $20/MWh 40 £ Virtual_ GenA,SC £ 100 @ $30/MWh Zone A
Slide 12: Inter-SC Trades with the PX
Inter-SC Trades with the PX The SC involved in an inter-SC trade with the PX submits the adjustment bid for the inter-SC trade. Suppose that the SC is involved in an inter-SC trade selling energy to the PX: If SC submits the adjustment bid, the SC will have a virtual load in PX's portfolio to model
Slide 13: Example
Example Three zones and three SCs (PX, SC1 and SC2). SC1 Resources: 0 £ GCSC1 £ 220 @ $20/MWh generator in zone C 0 £ GASC1 £ 200 @ $30/MWh generator in zone A 0 £ GBSC1 £ 100 @ $50/MWh generator in zone B LCSC1 = 10 load in zone C LASC1 = 100 load in zone A LBSC1 = 90 load in zone B SC2 Resources:
Slide 14: Example
Example PX Resources: 0 £ GCPX £ 200 @ $30/MWh generator in zone C 0 £ GAPX £ 500 @ $25/MWh generator in zone A 0 £ GBPX £ 200 @ $47/MWh generator in zone B LCPX = 100 load in zone C LAPX = 20 load in zone A LBPX = 300 load in zone B SC1 bids to sell from 0 to 190 MWh to PX in zone C at any price gr
Slide 15: Example (No Adjustment Bids on the Inter-SC Trades)
Example (No Adjustment Bids on the Inter-SC Trades) Zone A Zone B 0 £ GCSC1 £ 220 @ $20/MWh 0 £ GCSC2 £ 2 @ $0/MWh 0 £ GCPX £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC2 £ 101 @ $27/MWh 0 £ GAPX £ 500 @ $25/MWh 0 £ GBSC1 £ 100 @ $50/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 40 @ $100/MWh 0 £ GBPX £ 200 @ $47/MWh Zone C
Slide 16: Final Schedules (No Adjustment Bids on the Inter-SC Trades)
Final Schedules (No Adjustment Bids on the Inter-SC Trades) Zone A Zone B GCSC1 = 210 @ $20/MWh GCSC2 = 0LL @ $0/MWh GCPX = 0LL @ $30/MWh GASC1 = 55 @ $30/MWh GASC2 = 0LL @ $27/MWh GAPX = 65 @ $25/MWh GBSC1 = 100UL @ $50/MWh LBSC2 = 35 @ $100/MWh GBPX £ 200UL @ $47/MWh Zone C LCSC1 = 10 LCPX = 100 L
Slide 17: Example (Using the Virtual Resources)
Example (Using the Virtual Resources) In the IPS, SC1 is selling $20/MWh energy to the PX for $15/MWh in Zone C. SC1 could avoid selling at a loss by buying back the energy if Congestion Management causes the price that the PX pays to fall below $20/MWh. SC1 places a virtual load with IPS = 0 and up
Slide 18: Example (Using Virtual Resources for Adjustment Bids on the Inter-SC Trades)
Example (Using Virtual Resources for Adjustment Bids on the Inter-SC Trades) Zone A Zone B 0 £ GCSC1 £ 220 @ $20/MWh 0 £ GCSC2 £ 2 @ $0/MWh 0 £ GCPX £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC2 £ 101 @ $27/MWh 0 £ GAPX £ 500 @ $25/MWh 0 £ GBSC1 £ 100 @ $50/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 40 @ $100/MWh 0 £ GB
Slide 19: Final Schedules (Using Virtual Resources)
Final Schedules (Using Virtual Resources) GCSC1 = 220UL @ $20/MWh GCSC2 = 2UL @ $0/MWh GCPX = 0LL @ $30/MWh GASC1 = 70 @ $30/MWh GASC2 = 0LL @ $27/MWh GAPX = 50 @ $25/MWh GBSC1 = 100UL @ $50/MWh LBSC2 = 37 @ $100/MWh GBPX = 200UL @ $47/MWh LCSC1 = 10 LCPX = 100 LASC1 = 100 LAPX = 20 LBSC1 = 90 LBPX
Slide 20: Results
Results Without SC1's buy back, PX ZMCP in B would fall to $15MWh. SC1 buys back 12 MWh it sells to PX. SC1's virtual load is PX marginal resource in zone C. PX ZMCP in zone C rises to $20/MWh. Without SC2's sell back, PX ZMCP in B would rise to $115MWh. PX ZMCP in A ($25/MWh) plus DUC ($90/MWh). DU
Slide 21: Imbalances
Imbalances The virtual resources could be left in the final schedules. They would be treated as financial flows that net to zero in real- time. Suppose that the virtual resources are left in the final schedules. In real time: VLCSC1 is actually zero, this causes an imbalance of 12 MWh in PX load. SC
Slide 22: Imbalances
Imbalances VGBSC2 is actually zero, this causes an imbalance of 27 MWh in PX generation. SC2 is pays real time price for the 27 MWh it fails to deliver in real time. SC2 would reduce LBSC2 by 27 MWh to account for the sell-back, this produces a 27 MWh imbalance in SC2's load. SC2 is paid real time p
Slide 23: Adjusting Final Schedules
Adjusting Final Schedules The ISO could adjust the final schedules to remove the virtual resources. The PX has a virtual load in zone C from a trade with SC1. The ISO would reduce SC1's scheduled generation (or increase its adjustable load) in zone C by up to the amount of the virtual load. The SC1'
Slide 24: Adjusting Final Schedules
Adjusting Final Schedules The PX has a virtual generator in zone B from a trade with SC2. The ISO would increase SC2's scheduled generation (or decrease its adjustable load) in zone B by up to the amount of the virtual generation. SC2's resources in zone B would be adjusted in order of increasing co
Slide 25: Adjusted Final Schedules
Adjusted Final Schedules GCSC1 = 208 @ $20/MWh GCSC2 = 2UL @ $0/MWh GCPX = 0LL @ $30/MWh GASC1 = 70 @ $30/MWh GASC2 = 0LL @ $27/MWh GAPX = 50 @ $25/MWh GBSC1 = 100UL @ $50/MWh LBSC2 = 8 @ $100/MWh GBPX = 200UL @ $47/MWh LCSC1 = 10 LCPX = 100 LASC1 = 100 LAPX = 20 LBSC1 = 90 LBPX = 300 SC1 SC2 PX TCS
Slide 26: Location of Inter-SC Trade
Location of Inter-SC Trade An SC wishes to submit an adjustment bid on its inter-SC trade with PX in Zone A. SC should have resources in Zone A that it will use to account for any changes in the virtual resource that models changes to the inter-SC trade that the ISO makes in congestion management. T
Slide 27: Adjusted Final Schedules
Adjusted Final Schedules The ISO does not find other uses for energy that was used to serve a virtual load or sol back by virtual generation. If an inter-SC trade is reduced, the ISO does not attempt to find new optimal uses for the resources that would have been used to support the trade.
Slide 28: Implementation
Implementation Unique resource IDs would be assigned to model resources for adjustments to inter-SC trades. E.g. for each SC the PX would define virtual loads and virtual generators in each zone that would be used to model adjustment bids in inter-SC trades with the SC in the zone. Meter data for th
Slide 29: Use of virtual resources to hedge inter-SC trades against changes in transmission usage charges
Use of virtual resources to hedge inter-SC trades against changes in transmission usage charges (PX not involved in trades)
Slide 30: Adjustment Bids on Inter-SC Trades to Hedge against Transmission Prices
Adjustment Bids on Inter-SC Trades to Hedge against Transmission Prices... The method that the PX proposes to use to model adjustments to inter-SC trades could be used by SCs other than the PX to hedge against transmission prices. Two SCs agree to an inter-SC sale at a fixed price in a zone. One SC
Slide 31: Adjustment Bids on Inter-SC Trades to Hedge against Transmission Prices
..... Adjustment Bids on Inter-SC Trades to Hedge against Transmission Prices If an SC is selling energy in a zone in which it will procure the energy while the SC buying the energy proposes to use the energy to serve load in another zone, the buying SC will pay for transmission congestion and is di
Slide 32: Example: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges
Example: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges Let SC1 and SC2 agree to an inter-SC trade in Zone B. SC1 plans to use transmission from zone A to supply the energy in the trade. SC2 plans to use the energy to serve load in zone B. SC1 and SC2 agree that the trade may be curtailed if the t
Slide 33: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- No Adj. to Inter-SC Trade
Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- No Adj. to Inter-SC Trade Zone A Zone B 0 £ GASCX £ 110 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 100 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GBSCX £ 110 @ $70/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TBSC1->SC2 = 100 - -150 £ FlowA to B £ 150 0 £ GBSC2 £ 110 @ $35/MWh
Slide 34: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules
Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules Zone A Zone B GASCX = 50 @ $10/MWh GASC1 = 100 @ $10/MWh GBSCX= 50 @ $70/MWh LBSC2 = 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TBSC1->SC2 = 100 FlowA to B = 150 Usage Charge = $60/MWh so SC1 would like to curtail its trade to SC2. GBSC2
Slide 35: Example: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges
Example: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges To model its desire to back out of the trade if usage charges rises to $20/MWh, SC1 can add a virtual generator to its portfolio in zone B with a price of $30/MWh and an upper limit equal to the proposed trade.
Slide 36: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Adj. to Inter-SC Trade
Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Adj. to Inter-SC Trade Zone A Zone B 0 £ GASCX £ 110 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 100 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GBSCX £ 110 @ $70/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TBSC1->SC2 = 100 - -150 £ FlowA to B £ 150 0 £ GBSC2 £ 110 @ $35/MWh 0 £ VGBSC1 £ 1
Slide 37: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- CM Final Schedules
Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- CM Final Schedules Zone A Zone B GASCX = 100 @ $10/MWh GASC1 = 50 @ $10/MWh GBSCX= 0 @ $70/MWh LBSC2 = 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TBSC1->SC2 = 100 FlowA to B = 150 SC1 curtails its trade to SC2 by generating 50 MWh with its virtual gener
Slide 38: Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules
Selling SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules Zone A Zone B GASCX = 100 @ $10/MWh GASC1 = 50 @ $10/MWh GBSCX= 0 @ $70/MWh LBSC2 = 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TBSC1->SC2 = 50 FlowA to B = 150 SC1 removes the virtual generator schedule and reduces the inter SC trade to
Slide 39: Example: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges
Example: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges Let SC1 and SC2 agree to an inter-SC trade in Zone A. SC1 plans to use resources in zone A to supply the energy in the trade. SC2 plans to use the energy to serve load in zone B. It will transport the energy and be exposed to the transmission
Slide 40: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- No Adj. to Inter-SC Trade
Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- No Adj. to Inter-SC Trade Zone A Zone B 0 £ GASCX £ 110 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 100 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GBSCX £ 110 @ $70/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TASC1->SC2 = 100 - -150 £ FlowA to B £ 150 0 £ GBSC2 £ 110 @ $35/MWh
Slide 41: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules
Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules Zone A Zone B GASCX = 50 @ $10/MWh GASC1 = 100 @ $10/MWh GBSCX= 50 @ $70/MWh LBSC2 = 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TASC1->SC2 = 100 FlowA to B = 150 Usage Charge = $60/MWh so SC2 would like to curtail its trade with SC1. GBSC
Slide 42: Example: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges
Example: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges To model its desire to back out of the trade if usage charges rises to $20/MWh, SC2 can add a virtual load to its portfolio in zone A with a price of $15/MWh and an upper limit equal to the proposed trade.
Slide 43: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Adj. to Inter-SC Trade
Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Adj. to Inter-SC Trade Zone A Zone B 0 £ GASCX £ 110 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 100 @ $10/MWh 0 £ GBSCX £ 110 @ $70/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TASC1->SC2 = 100 - -150 £ FlowA to B £ 150 0 £ GBSC2 £ 110 @ $35/MWh 0 £ VLASC2 £ 10
Slide 44: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- CM Final Schedules
Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- CM Final Schedules Zone A Zone B GASCX = 100 @ $10/MWh GASC1 = 100 @ $10/MWh GBSCX= 0 @ $70/MWh LBSC2 = 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TASC1->SC2 = 100 FlowA to B = 150 SC2 curtails its trade with SC1 by consuming 50 MWh with its virtual load
Slide 45: Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules
Buying SC Exposed to Transmission Usage Charges -- Final Schedules Zone A Zone B GASCX = 100 @ $10/MWh GASC1 = 50 @ $10/MWh GBSCX= 0 @ $70/MWh LBSC2 = 100 @ $90/MWh LBSCX = 100 SCX SC2 SC1 TaSC1->SC2 = 50 FlowA to B = 150 SC2 removes the virtual load schedule and reduces the inter SC trade to 50 MWh
Slide 46: Comparison to modeling adjustment bids directly on inter-SC trades
Comparison to modeling adjustment bids directly on inter-SC trades
Slide 47: Direct Inter-SC Trade Adjustment
Direct Inter-SC Trade Adjustment Two SCs engaged in an inter-SC trade could give adjustment bids on the trade. Trades between to SCs (SC1 and SC2) are equal but opposite so TSC1->SC2 = -TSC2->SC1: if the range on TSC1->SC2 is TMin £ TSC1->SC2 £ TMax, then the range on TSC1->SC2 is -TMax £ TSC2->SC1
Slide 48: Direct Inter-SC Trade Adjustment
Direct Inter-SC Trade Adjustment The costs in the adjustment bids on the inter-SC trade add to zero, so an adjustment bid on an inter-SC trade effectively only specifies a range over which the trade may be adjusted. The economic cost given in the bid has no effect on congestion management. The adjus
Slide 49: Adjustment Range on the Inter-SC Trades
Adjustment Range on the Inter-SC Trades Zone A Zone B 0 £ GCSC1 £ 220 @ $20/MWh 0 £ GCSC2 £ 2 @ $0/MWh 0 £ GCPX £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC2 £ 101 @ $27/MWh 0 £ GAPX £ 500 @ $25/MWh 0 £ GBSC1 £ 100 @ $50/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 40 @ $100/MWh 0 £ GBPX £ 200 @ $47/MWh Zone C LCSC1 = 10
Slide 50: Adjustment Range on the Inter-SC Trades
Adjustment Range on the Inter-SC Trades GCSC1 = 208 @ $20/MWh GCSC2 = 2UL @ $0/MWh GCPX = 0LL @ $30/MWh GASC1 = 0 @ $30/MWh GASC2 = 0LL @ $27/MWh GAPX = 120 @ $25/MWh GBSC1 = 100UL @ $50/MWh LBSC2 = 10 @ $100/MWh GBPX = 200UL @ $47/MWh LCSC1 = 10 LCPX = 100 LASC1 = 100 LAPX = 20 LBSC1 = 90 LBPX = 30
Slide 51: Impacts on PX
Impacts on PX The marginal resource for the PX may be in another SC that is trading with the PX. The ISO will have to inform the PX of the cost of the marginal unit for the PX. The following example illustrates this. The PX cannot calculate zonal prices if the ISO modifies the prices of PX adjustmen
Slide 52: PX Marginal Resource not in PX
PX Marginal Resource not in PX Zone A Zone B 0 £ GCSC1 £ 220 @ $20/MWh 0 £ GCSC2 £ 2 @ $0/MWh 0 £ GASC1 £ 200 @ $30/MWh 0 £ GASC2 £ 101 @ $27/MWh 0 £ GAPX £ 115 @ $25/MWh 0 £ GBSC1 £ 100 @ $50/MWh 0 £ LBSC2 £ 40 @ $100/MWh 0 £ GBPX £ 200 @ $47/MWh Zone C LCSC1 = 10 LCPX = 100 LASC1 = 100 LAPX = 20 L
Slide 53: PX Marginal Resource not in PX
PX Marginal Resource not in PX GCSC1 = 208 @ $20/MWh GCSC2 = 2UL @ $0/MWh GASC1 = 0 @ $30/MWh GASC2 = 5 @ $27/MWh GAPX = 115UL @ $25/MWh GBSC1 = 100UL @ $50/MWh LBSC2 = 10 @ $100/MWh GBPX = 200UL @ $47/MWh LCSC1 = 10 LCPX = 100 LASC1 = 100 LAPX = 20 LBSC1 = 90 LBPX = 300 SC1 SC2 PX TCSC1->PX = 108 T