Tetra Tech, Inc. · NASDAQ:TTEK
Tetra Tech — Technical Presentation (May 2004)
65 slides from Tetra Tech's technical presentation, May 25, 2004
Slide 1: Review of Progress on Developing Nutrient Criteria in California
Review of Progress on Developing Nutrient Criteria in California Presentation to RTAG May 25, 2004 EPA Region IX, San Francisco, California 1
Slide 2: Overview
Overview • Update on previous results • Review of data and modeling for Ecoregion 6 • Recommended strategy for moving toward numeric criteria 2
Slide 3: Approach Presented in EPA Guidance Documents
Approach Presented in EPA Guidance Documents Cum. Frequency (%) Reference 75th Percentile Frequency (%) 75th Percentile 25th Percentile General Population General 25th Percentile Reference Population TN, TP, etc TN, TP, etc Benefit: - Data easily accessible with adequate QA, especially for general p
Slide 4: The Importance of “getting it right”
The Importance of “getting it right” • ~ 150 CA water bodies impaired (1998 303(d) list) for nutrients and nutrient related parameters (DO, pH) • Once established, nutrient criteria will be incorporated into state standards • Are the 304(a) criteria correctly specified? Misspecification could lead t
Slide 5: California Ecoregions
California Ecoregions 1 Coastal Range 4 Cascades 5 Sierra Nevada 6 Southern and Central California Chaparral and Oak Woodlands 8 Southern California Mountains 9 Eastern Cascades Slopes & Foothills 13 Central Basin and Range 14 Southern Basin & Range 22 Arizona/New Mexico Plateau 23 Arizona/New Mexic
Slide 6: The Importance of “getting it right”: Total Phosphorus
The Importance of “getting it right” Total Phosphorus (approx. mg/L) 304(a) Reference %> STORET %> Ecoregion Criterion 75% 304(a) 25% 304(a) 1 0.010 0.03 70 0.01 70 5 0.015 0.04 85 0.02 85 6 0.030 .09 0.06 88 8 0.011 na na 0.002 44 9 0.030 0.13 67 na na 14 0.010 0.03 47 0.03 80 22 0.015 0.07 62 0.02
Slide 7: The Importance of “getting it right”: Total Nitrogen
The Importance of “getting it right” Total Nitrogen (approx. mg/L) 304(a) Ecoregion Criterion Reference % > STORET %> 75% 304(a) 25% 304(a) 1 0.13 na na 0.17 85 5 0.29 0.36 33 0.22 62 6 0.50 0.5 0.40 69 8 0.52 na na 0.10 17 9 0.15 0.40 97 na na 14 0.67 0.25 0 0.55 66 22 0.23 0.48 60 0.18 47 23 0.28
Slide 8: Example Comparisons of Reference and STORET Data for Ecoregions
Example Comparisons of Reference and STORET Data for Ecoregions Ecoregion 14, Southern Basin and Range Ecoregion 5, Sierra Nevada 100 100 Default Criterion 75 75 Percent Less Than Percent Less Than STORET Data STORET Reference Reference 50 50 Default Criterion 25 25 0 0 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25
Slide 9: Relationship of Data & Analysis Elements for Nutrient Criteria and TMDLs
Natural N,P Background Loads Limited use in Pilot Propose expanded use in Next steps —_—— Concentrations > Primary Biological > ow > Impairment of Impacts f 9 Beneficial Use impacts L J u J L J —r er er Default 304 (a) e.g., e.g., EPA Methodology DO, Chl a, fish spawning benthic IBI and survival, od
Slide 10: Modified Strategy for Developing Criteria
Modified Strategy for Developing Criteria • Focus on a individual ecoregion, not aggregated ecoregion • Greater emphasis on biological responses to link to protection of beneficial uses • Use statistical and simulation models to provide better estimates of reference loads • Models used to estimate b
Slide 11: Conceptual Model of Linkage Between Nutrients and Beneficial Uses for Streams
Conceptual Model of Linkage Between Nutrients and Beneficial Uses for Streams Conceptual Model for Impairment of Streams by Nutrients STRESSOR Nutrient Load Major Exogenous Factors Altered pH Nutrient Flow (dilution capacity, Concentration velocity) Excess Excess planktonic Excess Periphyton Direct
Slide 12: Region Selected for Study: California Oak and Chaparral (Ecoregion 6)
Region Selected for Study: California Oak and Chaparral (Ecoregion 6) • 680 stations with data • Stations evenly distributed over ecoregion • Data obtained from federal, state, and municipal agencies, and research institutions 12
Slide 13: Empirical Data Analysis: Station Classification
Empirical Data Analysis: Station Classification 13
Slide 14: NO3 Levels in Streams by Impairment Classification
Empirical Data Analysis for Ecoregion 6: NO3 Levels in Streams by Impairment Classification of Water Body 1000 NO3-N, Summer Months 100 Concentration (mg/l) 10 1 Default TN Criterion 0.1 0.01 0.001 Minim Impact Unimpaired Imp (unknown) Imp (Nutr) 14
Slide 15: TKN Levels in Streams by Impairment Classification
Empirical Data Analysis for Ecoregion 6: TKN Levels in Streams by Impairment Classification of Water Body 100 TKN, Summer 10 Concentration (mg/l) 1 Default TN Criterion 0.1 0.01 Minim Impact Unimpaired Imp (unknown) Imp (Nutr) 15
Slide 16: TP Levels in Streams by Impairment Classification
Empirical Data Analysis for Ecoregion 6: TP Levels in Streams by Impairment Classification of Water Body 100 TP, Summer Months 10 Concentration (mg/l) 1 0.1 Default TP 0.01 Criterion 0.001 Minim Impact Unimpaired Imp (unknown) Imp (Nutr) 16
Slide 17: Summary of Nutrient Data for Ecoregion 6
Summary of Nutrient Data for Ecoregion 6 Lakes-Median Concentrations Constituent Impaired (mg/l) Unimpaired (mg/l) Minimally Impacted (mg/l) NH3 0.082 0.082 0.010 NO2 0.010 0.021 0.002 NO3 0.700 0.100 0.050 PO4 0.010 0.142 0.017 TKN 0.400 0.500 0.200 TP 0.020 0.033 0.050 Streams-Median Concentration
Slide 18: Empirical Data Analysis: TN:TP Ratios
100 a) Ecoregion 6 Streams 10 Empirical Data 1 TP (mg/l) Redfield Ratio Analysis: 0.1 N-Limited TN:TP Ratios 0.01 P-Limited 0.001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 TKN + NO3 + NO2 (mg/l) 100 b) Ecoregion 6 Lakes 10 1 TP (mg/l) Redfield Ratio Finding: Nitrogen 0.1 limitations are very 0.01 common in Ecoregion
Slide 19: Watersheds Associated with Monitoring Stations
Watersheds Associated with Monitoring Stations • Watershed for 82 stream stations with enough data were mapped • Stations evenly distributed over ecoregion • Data obtained for: – Land cover (urban, agriculture, conifer, shrub, etc.) – Precipitation – Slope – Elevation – Soil erodibility – Soil organ
Slide 20: Nutrient Concentrations and Developed Land: Entire Year
Nutrient Concentrations and Developed Land Data for Entire Year 100 10 Nutrients Concentration (mg/L) NO3 Nutrients Concentration (mg/L) NH3 10 1 1 0.1 0.1 0.01 0.01 0.001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 Developed Land Developed Land 10 10 Nutrients Concentration (mg/L) Nutrients Con
Slide 21: Nutrient Concentrations and Developed Land: May Through September
Nutrient Concentrations and Developed Land Data for May Through September 1 100 NH3 NO3 10 Nutrients (mg/L) Nutrients (mg/L) 0.1 1 0.1 0.01 0.01 0.001 0.001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 Developed Land Developed Land 10 10 TKN TP 1 Nutrients (mg/L) 1 Nutrients (mg/L) 0.1 0.1 0.01 0
Slide 22: Nutrient Concentrations and Mean Precipitation
Nutrient Concentrations and Mean Precipitation Data for Entire Year 10 100 NH3 NO3 Nutrient Concentration (mg/l) Nutrient Concentration (mg/l) 1 10 0.1 1 0.01 0.1 0.001 0.01 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Mean Precipitation (inches) Mean Precipitation (inches) 10 10 TKN TP Nutrient Concentr
Slide 23: Classification and Regression Tree (CART) Analysis: I
Classification and Regression Tree (CART) Analysis: I TKN in May through September 23
Slide 24: Classification and Regression Tree (CART) Analysis: II
Classification and Regression Tree (CART) Analysis: II TP in May through September 24
Slide 25: Classification and Regression Tree (CART) Analysis: III
Classification and Regression Tree (CART) Analysis: III PO4 in May through September 25
Slide 26: Findings from Data Analysis
Findings from Data Analysis • Chemistry data alone is difficult to directly link to impairment, although some land characteristics are good estimators of concentrations (such as the proportion of developed land and precipitation) • Insufficient, consistently-measured biological data collected over E
Slide 27: Additional Sources of Information
Additional Sources of Information • Estimates of reference loads of nutrients – Simulation modeling using SWAT – Empirical approaches such USGS-SPARROW • Estimates of biological responses – Lake responses using the BATHUB model – Stream responses using • Empirical responses (Dodds, Biggs, etc.) • Mo
Slide 28: Watershed Modeling Using SWAT
Watershed Modeling Using SWAT • SWAT (Surface Water Assessment Tool) was used to estimate nutrient loads and concentrations in streams. • Designed for use without calibration. • A set of eight, relatively unimpaired watersheds was used for validation testing. • Goal: To identify landscape stratifica
Slide 29: SWAT Validation
SWAT Validation • Data sparse for unimpaired watersheds; potentially unrepresentative • SWAT expected to perform best on loads, not instantaneous concentration • Problems encountered in default SWAT parameters for biomass simulation when applied to Ecoregion 6 29
Slide 30: Comparison of Data and Modeled Values from SWAT
Comparison of Data and Modeled Values from SWAT NH3 - Annual M ed ian M o d eled NO3 - Annual M ed ian M o d eled Flo w-weig hted M o d eled Flo w-weig hted M o d eled 10 10 M ed ian M eas ured M ed ian M eas ured Concentration (mg/l) Concentration (mg/l) 1 1 0.1 0.1 0.01 0.01 0.001 0.0001 0.001 313
Slide 31: Role of SWAT in California Nutrient Criteria Development
Role of SWAT in California Nutrient Criteria Development • Validation efforts have been inconclusive • Without calibration, the model is most appropriate for a qualitative or relative evaluation of nutrient load response to soils, cover, and other factors • Proper calibration requires monitoring dat
Slide 32: USGS SPARROW Approach
USGS SPARROW Approach • SPARROW = Spatially Referenced Regression on Watersheds • A statistical approach to estimate loading rates and concentrations of nutrients in streams based on regressions using NAWQA water quality data • SPARROW has been used in two modes: for calculating loads and concentrat
Slide 33: Predicted Total Nitrogen Concentrations
Predicted Total Nitrogen Concentrations Source: Smith et al., 2003 33
Slide 34: Predicted Total Phosphorus Concentrations
Predicted Total Phosphorus Concentrations Source: Smith et al., 2003 34
Slide 35: Role of SPARROW in California Nutrient Criteria Development
Role of SPARROW in California Nutrient Criteria Development • We have used SPARROW in conjunction with SWAT- calculated terrestrial loads to estimate downstream concentrations in streams • Smith et al. (2003) natural background concentrations estimated are also proposed to be used in our framework •
Slide 36: Lake Modeling Using BATHUB
Lake Modeling Using BATHUB • BATHTUB is a steady-state model that calculates nutrient and chlorophyll-a concentrations, turbidity, and hypolimnetic oxygen depletion based on nutrient loadings, hydrology, lake morphometry, and internal nutrient cycling processes • BATHTUB was used to establish allowa
Slide 37: BATHUB Lake Model Results
BATHUB Lake Model Results P limited Chlorophyll-a Concentration (ug/L) 4.2 Total Nitrogen Loading normalized to lake volume (ug/Year-L, Log Scale) 4.0 3.8 3.6 3.4 N limited 3.2 3.0 2.0 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6 Total Phosphorous Loading normalized to lake volume (ug/Year-L, Log Scale) 37 Lake
Slide 38: BATHUB Lake Model Results
BATHUB Lake Model Results -0.35 -0.40 -0.45 -0.50 -0.55 Residence Time (years, Log Scale) -0.60 -0.65 -0.70 -0.75 le) -0.80 (years, Log Sca -0.85 -0.90 e -0.95 lum -1.00 vo -1.05 e lak -1.10 e to Residence Tim -1.15 d e) alize -1.20 g S orm -1.25 -1.30 Lo ous n c al r Total ear ospho N (ug/Y itrogen
Slide 39: BATHUB Lake Model Summary of Results
BATHUB Lake Model Summary of Results • Phosphorous limited algal growth when nitrogen loadings exceed 5,000 ug/L- year and phosphorous loadings are less than 200 ug/L-year • Nitrogen limited algal growth when phosphorous loadings exceed 500 ug/L- year and nitrogen loadings are less than 2,000 ug/L-y
Slide 40: Empirical Analysis of Stream Response to Nutrients
Empirical Analysis of Stream Response to Nutrients • Goal is to develop statistical relationships using available data, either from Ecoregion 6 or from larger scale national studies; no mechanistic modeling • Examples: – Global relationship between benthic Chl a and nutrient concentrations (e.g., Do
Slide 41: Empirical Data Analysis: Planktonic Chl a in Streams
Empirical Data Analysis: Planktonic Chl a in Streams 10000 10000 TKN--May through September TP--May through September 1000 1000 100 100 Chlorophyll a (mg/l) Chlorophyll a (mg/l) 10 10 1 1 0.1 0.1 r ² = 0.22 r ² = 0.13 0.01 0.01 0.001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 TKN (mg/l) TP (mg/
Slide 42: Dodds et al. (1997) Relationship Between Benthic Chl-a and Total Nitrogen
Dodds et al. (1997) Relationship Between Benthic Chl-a and Total Nitrogen – US streams Nutrients define upper bound, not mean of observations Biggs (2000): Similar results for New Zealand 42
Slide 43: Boundaries for Stream Trophic Classifications Proposed by Dodds et al. (1998)
Boundaries for Stream Trophic Classifications Proposed by Dodds et al. (1998) Variable Oligotrophic- Mesotrophic- Mesotrophic Eutrophic Boundary Boundary Mean benthic 20 70 chlorophyll a (mg/m2) Maximum benthic 60 200 chlorophyll a (mg/m2) TN (µg/L) 700 1500 TP (µg/L) 25 75 43
Slide 44: Provisional Data from Regional Board
Provisional Data from Regional Board 6 RB 6 Provisional Data RB 6 Provisional Data 100 100 Periphyton (mg/m 2 chl-a) Periphyton (mg/m 2 chl-a) 10 10 1 1 0.1 0.1 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 Total N (mg/L) Total P (mg/L) log(mean Chl a) = -3.20 + 2.94 log(TN) – 0.512 (log(TN))2 + 0.0914 log(TP)
Slide 45: EMAP Data For California
EMAP Data For California 1000 1000 Benthic Chlorophyll a (mg/m 2) Benthic Chlorophyll a (mg/m 2) 100 100 10 10 1 1 0.1 0.1 10 100 1000 10000 100000 1 10 100 1000 10000 Total N (µg/L) Total P (µg/L) 45
Slide 46: Periphyton Response
Periphyton Response • Benthic chlorophyll a limited by light availability, scour, and grazing pressure • Nutrients predict maximum potential, rather than average observed chlorophyll a • Biggs (2000) approach to incorporating scour via days of accrual gave large increase in R2 (from 32% to 74%). 46
Slide 47: Fraction of Potential Maximum Periphyton Biomass vs Days of Accrual
Fraction of Potential Maximum Periphyton Biomass as a Function of Days of Accrual (Biggs, 2000) 1 0.8 B(d0)/Bmax 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 50 100 150 200 da 47
Slide 48: Summary of Empirical Analysis of Stream Biological Response
Summary of Empirical Analysis of Stream Biological Reponse • Both RB-6 and EMAP data showed greater sensitivity to TN than to TP • Both data sets indicate that the chl-a values lie near the mean values predicted by regression equations in Dodds et al. (2002) • Nutrients generally explain <50% of chl
Slide 49: Modeling Stream Response Using QUAL2K
Modeling Stream Response Using QUAL2K • QUAL2K is a revised version of the QUAL2E water quality model and incorporates benthic algal growth • In the absence of adequate site-specific data, QUAL2K can be run using reasonable default parameters and can be “tuned” to a Dodds-type model • Estimated Chl-
Slide 50: Predicted Maximum Periphyton Biomass
Predicted Maximum Periphyton Biomass (in the absence of light limitation) Nitrogen Limited Phosphorus Limited 400 400 350 350 300 Periphyton (g/m 2) 300 Periphyton (g/m 2) 250 250 200 200 150 150 100 100 50 50 0 0 0 00 01 03 05 10 15 20 30 50 00 00 00 00 00 50 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 01 02 05 10
Slide 51: Response Surface for Maximum Periphyton Biomass
Response Surface for Maximum Periphyton Biomass 10 Periphyton (g/m 2) 1 350 325 300 Inorganic N (mg/L) 275 .1 250 225 200 175 150 .01 125 100 75 50 .001 25 0 .0001 .0001 .001 .01 .1 1 10 Inorganic P (mg/L) 51
Slide 52: Relating Dodds et al. Data to Model Output
Relating Dodds et al. Data to Model Output 3 Log Dodds Max Predicted Chl a (mg/m2) 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 Log QUAL2K Predicted Chl a (mg/m2) Based on QUAL2K parameters that were adjusted to Dodds et al.’s results 52
Slide 53: Application of QUAL2K Framework to RB-3 Data
Application of QUAL2K Framework to RB-3 Data 53
Slide 54: Cumulative Distribution of Maximum Potential Benthic Algal Biomass, No Light Limitation
Cumulative Distribution of Maximum Potential Benthic Algal Biomass Predicted by QUAL2K Approach for RB 3 Sites without Considering Light Limitation Maximum Benthic Biomass (g/m 2 AFDW) 250 200 Eutrophic 150 100 Mesotrophic 50 Oligotrophic 0 305THU 308MIL 314MIG 312OFC 306MC 312CUY 306CAR 308LSU 310A
Slide 55: Cumulative Distribution of Maximum Potential Benthic Algal Biomass, With Light Limitation
Cumulative Distribution of Maximum Potential Benthic Algal Biomass Predicted by QUAL2K Approach for RB 3 Sites with Light Limitation by Shade and Turbidity 250 Maximum Benthic Biomass (g/m 2 AFDW) 200 Eutrophic 150 Mesotrophic 100 50 Oligotrophic 0 317CHO 309GRN 306CAR 310CAN 309NAC 305CHE 317EST 30
Slide 56: Effects of Light Limitation on Benthic Biomass Predictions
Effects of Light Limitation on Benthic Biomass Predictions Maximum Benthic Biomass (g/m 2 AFDW) 250 Predictions without light limitation 200 150 100 Predictions 50 with light limitation 0 309GRN 317CHO 309ATS 304APT 317EST 309NAC 305CHE 306CAR 310CAN 308LSU 315JAL 313SAI 310BER 309SBR 309USA 310SCP
Slide 57: Nutrient and Light Limitation in RB Data Set
Nutrient and Light Limitation in RB 3 Data Set 1.2 High High Nutrients, Nutrients, 1 High Light Low Light 0.8 Nutrient Limitation 0.6 0.4 Low Nutrients, 0.2 High Light 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 Light Limitation 57
Slide 58: Role of QUAL2K Modeling in California Nutrient Criteria
Role of QUAL2K Modeling in California Nutrient Criteria • Riparian shading/turbidity limitations on light can be incorporated directly • As structured the model does not directly account for factors such as flood scour, but these can be incorporated using alternative correlations (Biggs) • QUAL2K be
Slide 59: Phased Approach to Implement Criteria: Phase One Recommendation
Phased Approach to Implement Criteria: Phase One Recommendation • Use combination of data and estimated values to classify water bodies into three categories (a “triad” approach) – Nutrient impairment unlikely and/or corresponds to natural background range (Tier I) – Nutrient impairment possible and
Slide 60: Form of the Standard
Form of the Standard Likelihood of Impairment • Includes chemical and Likelihood of Impairment Tier III Tier III biological parameters Tier II Tier II • All individual criteria Tier I must be exceeded Tier I before water body is Concentration Species 1 Concentration Species 2 placed in higher tier L
Slide 61: Consequences of Classification
Consequences of Classification • Tier I: No action needed • Tier II: Further study to determine whether beneficial uses are threatened – Site specific factors influencing response – Potential anti-degradation analysis • Tier III: Nutrient load reduction may be needed; possible permit load caps and T
Slide 62: Relationship of Data & Analysis Elements for Nutrient Criteria and TMDLs
Natural N,P Background Loads Limited use in Pilot Propose expanded use in Next steps —_—— Concentrations > Primary Biological > ow > Impairment of Impacts f 9 Beneficial Use impacts L J u J L J —r er er Default 304 (a) e.g., e.g., EPA Methodology DO, Chl a, fish spawning benthic IBI and survival, od
Slide 63: How the Tiered Criteria May Be Used
How the Tiered Criteria May Be Used Tier 2: Mid-Range Concentrations / Low Tier 3: High Concentrations / High Biological Response Biological Response • Are physical / chemical factors affecting • Is this system naturally eutrophic? biological activity? W9 Are these conditions consistent with 9 Evalu
Slide 64: Summary of Approach
Summary of Approach • Use available data, make estimates where no data are available • Use best available information to develop a framework for criteria that recognizes uncertainties • Leave open the door for improvement in the criteria framework if new chemical or biological data become available
Slide 65: Next Steps
Next Steps • Continue to refine modeling data analysis tools • Provide a “Monitoring Needs Report” to SWAMP and collaborators • Assist with data collection • Conduct case study using enhanced QUAL2K and BATHTUB tools • Provide technical support to workgroup to develop language for triad categories -