D-Link Corporation · TWSE:2332
D-Link — Proxy Contest (May 2020)
54 slides from D-Link's proxy contest presentation, May 2020
Slide 1: Management's AGM Presentation to Shareholders
D-Link 2332 TT Management’s AGM Presentation to Shareholders Chairwoman and CEO: Lori HU Senior Vice-President: Evelyn WANG May 2020
Slide 2: Executive Summary – why we are here
Executive Summary – why we are here R&D Investment Management-supported Dissident shareholder’s Support us to secure is key to future gains board will add value objectives are unclear D-Link’s future We have started to make Management-supported There are numerous We are asking for your gains after f
Slide 3: D-Link Who We Are At a Glance
D-Link Who We Are At a Established in 1986, one of the world‘s leading networking companies Glance Performance 2019 Revenue USD 568 million Staff Over 2,000 employees. Approximately 500 employees in R&D Business Segments Consumer / Enterprise / Carrier 2
Slide 4: Global Presence
Global Presence 120 Local Sales Offices Over 120 local sales offices in 50+ countries. 21 Regional Warehouses 21 Regional warehouses in 15 countries. 50 RMA Repair Centers Over 50 RMA repair centers around the globe. ● Consumer ● Enterprise ● Carrier 3
Slide 5: Product Portfolio
Product Portfolio Business Networking Integrated Business Solutions Wireless Broadband Mobile Access Surveillance Integrated Consumer Solutions Passive 4
Slide 6: Global Recognition
Global Recognition CES Good iF Innovation Design DESIGN Awards Award AWARD CES Innovation Computex TAIWAN Awards d&i Award EXCELLENCE 5
Slide 7: Our Customers
Our Customers U.K. Hungary Germany Poland France Czech Italy Croatia Spain Bulgaria Netherlands Romania Belgium Russia Greece Belarus Switzerland Ukraine Austria Estonia Taiwan U.S.A. Canada Denmark Lithuania China Mexico Finland Latvia Japan Argentina Norway Uzbek South Korea Brazil Sweden Kazakhst
Slide 8: Our Customers
Our Customers Hospitality Health Care Retail Education Government E-tailer 7
Slide 9: Our Customers
Our Customers North America EMEA ASIA South America 8
Slide 10: Company performance and future strategy
Company performance and future strategy D-Link 2332 TT
Slide 11: Transforming from traditional to future-proof
Transforming from traditional to future-proof Transform to Service-centric service-centric company 9
Slide 12: D-Link 2.0 – Business transformation plan
D-Link 2.0 – Business transformation plan 1 2 3 Investing in Reviewing and R&D in software reorganizing Building effective and ecosystem company resources teams to bring in to enhance and shutting down enterprise and user experience loss-making areas carrier customers 10
Slide 13: Current management needs time to build up capabilities
Current management needs time to build up capabilities Increasing R&D as a % of our revenue Surpassing We are in the 7.0% 1,412 6% In 2019 process of… M 1,237 6.0% M 1,009 1,124 900 M Adjusting our business 1,065 951 M M models to accommodate 5.0% 912 M 843 M 819 M the needs for different 4.0% M M c
Slide 14: We must continuously invest in R&D
We must continuously invest in R&D Net purchases from Alpha Networks (3380 TT) have been reduced as we focus on long-term competitiveness We must continuously invest in R&D to build up our own software 40.0% capability and strengthen our long-term competitiveness, 30.0% although it will not drive ma
Slide 15: Seeing initial results from investment in R&D
Seeing initial results from investment in R&D Gross margin has improved significantly from 24.2% to close to 30% in four years Gross Margin Operating Margin Margins improved with the 32.0% 10.0% execution of transformation 27.0% 5.0% 22.0% 0.0% 17.0% -5.0% Operating loss has been Severe competition
Slide 16: Enterprise exposure has been increasing
Enterprise exposure has been increasing D-Link Revenue Contribution by Segment 100% 80% 58% 54% 54% 60% 61% 60% Consumer 40% Telco 20% 20% 21% 16% 11% Enterprise 20% 25% 27% 26% 28% 21% 0% 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 14 Source: Company data
Slide 17: Taiwan brands face strong competition
Taiwan brands face strong competition Comparison vs. Branded Taiwan Peers Comparison vs. Index Bloomberg TSR - annualized YTD 3 Yr 5Yr Bloomberg TSR - annualized YTD 3 Yr 5Yr D-Link Corporation (2332 TT) -2.03% 4.72% -1.44% D-Link Corporation (2332 TT) -2.03% 4.72% -1.44% ASUS (2357 TT) -31.48% -4.9
Slide 18: ESG a priority in D-Link's future
ESG a priority in D-Link’s future A more diversified board in terms of skillsets and knowledge, gender and age that can better support future strategies with growing competition Board Evaluation policy and process Work to improve disclosure in both languages for internal policies, financial an
Slide 19: AGM – Contested Election
AGM – Contested Election A dissident shareholder, Taiwan Steel Group, has a pattern of seeking control of boards using a small percentage of shareholding and collecting local retail proxy. As a private entity with little transparency there is also evidence of destroying shareholder value for the pub
Slide 20: Domestic retail investors hold the majority of D-Link's shares
Domestic retail investors hold the majority of D-Link’s shares Top 10 Shareholders Ownership Foreign Investors Sapido Technology Inc. 5.16 % Gaoju Investment Co., Ltd. 3.38 % 14% Jerry Investments Limited 2.82 % Chia-Hwa Investment Co., Ltd. 2.69 % Domestic 22% 64% Pu Chu Investment Co., Ltd. 1.92 %
Slide 21: June 1st EGM: Background & Concerns
June 1st EGM : Former independent Directors (CHUNG and FONG) Background & have initiated a redundant and resource-wasting EGM only weeks before the regularly scheduled Concerns annual shareholder meeting Legality of the June 1st EGM is under question: Removing 5 directors would leave only 1 board me
Slide 22: June 1st EGM: Background & Concerns
June 1st EGM : EGM may have been convened only to obtain Background & access to the shareholder list to source proxies Concerns FONG Chun-Peng’s EGM intentions are questionable: ormer independent director ( FONG, Chung-Peng馮忠鵬) has also been nominated as a corporate representative of the dissident s
Slide 23: Dissidents backed by Taiwan Steel Group (TSG)
Dissidents backed by Taiwan Steel Group (TSG) Sources: MOPS, Bloomberg; D-Link annual report; Company Data; Public Company Registration for D-Link Investment Co (友訊投資有限公司) 20 Articles referenced: Taiwan Steel Group acquires D-Link shares for three years
Slide 24: Dissidents backed by Taiwan Steel Group (TSG)
Dissidents backed by Taiwan Steel Group (TSG) Sources: MOPS, Bloomberg; D-Link annual report; Company Data; Public Company Registration for D-Link Investment Co (友訊投資有限公司) Articles referenced: Taiwan Steel Group acquires D-Link shares for three years 21
Slide 25: Taiwan Steel Group: Clear track record of destroying shareholder value
Taiwan Steel Group: Clear track record of destroying shareholder value 2019 5yr - Total % of shares held by Foreign Corporate Year that Shareholder Return Public (TSR) Ticker TSG-related entities TSG - Controls Board? investor Governance TSC entered Companies* or persons ownership % Rank (lower is t
Slide 26: Taiwan Steel Group
Taiwan Steel Group Found guilty of embezzlement Kuei Hung was Hsieh’s family business and was listed publicly in 1993 (delisted in 2001). In 1996, Hsieh co-established Kuei Yi with the National Development Fund, Executive Yuan, China Development, and China Steel. In 1998, during the Asian financial
Slide 27: Taiwan Steel Group
Taiwan Steel Group 慶欣欣鋼鐵 台灣鋼鐵 友訊_2332 TT 金智富資產 易通圓投資 (E-TOP Metal Co.) (Taiwan Steel Company) (D-LINK) (Jin Zhi Fu Asset ) (E-TOP invest) Private Company Private Company 易昇鋼鐵 金智宏投資 加捷生醫_4109 TT 台苯_1310 TT 天權投資 (E-SHENG STEEL CO.,) (Jin Zhi Hong invest (Jia Jie Bio) (T.S.M. C) (Tian Quan Co. ) Privat
Slide 28: Taiwan Steel Group - Who are you supporting?
Taiwan Steel Group - Who are you supporting? 25 http://www.gkr.com.tw/
Slide 29: TSG's Sapido & Amigo not a strategic fit for us
TSG’s Sapido & Amigo not a strategic fit for us D-link’s market cap is Amigo’s revenue is not even 5-year 29x bigger than Amigo’s 1% of D-Link’s 2019 revenue Total Shareholding Return 16,996 mn NTD 0% Amigo D-Link D-Link US$290mn -50 % vs. -100 % 210 mn NTD Amigo US$10mn Amigo has significantly unde
Slide 30: Taiwan Steel Group declares they have 50% of global institutional shareholder votes
Taiwan Steel Group declares they have 50% of global institutional shareholder votes Public records on Bloomberg show that ~70% of foreign investment is held by 6 global institutional funds. It is well-known to all corporate governance professionals that these funds do not comment on investors suppor
Slide 31: Retail investor vote is key to control
Retail investor vote is key to control Taiwan’s unique cumulative voting Potentially secure 5/9 system provides the opportunity for Investment 1% of the board an investor with very low Co Own shareholding to allocate proxies to 1% Shareholding 1 4 his/her preferred candidates. + 2 5 With as little a
Slide 32: TSG-funded "Investment" companies misleading
TSG-funded “Investment” companies misleading On Dec 5, 2019 associates of the Taiwan Steel Group Hi, I’m calling from Hi, I’m calling from established an investment D-Link Investment Co, D-Link Corporation, company called D-Link Investment Co. (友訊投資有限 “We need your support 公司) . Most retail sharehol
Slide 33: Dissident nominees unlikely to add value
Dissident nominees unlikely to add value There are too many concerns and unanswered questions regarding many of the candidates nominated by “D-Link Investment Corp”. Dissident Nominated Role Concerns or Questions KEY ISSUE Nominee on Board CHUNG, Independent Director 1. Discharged as Independent Dir
Slide 34: Dissident nominees unlikely to add value
Dissident nominees unlikely to add value There are too many concerns and unanswered questions regarding many of the candidates nominated by “D-Link (You Xun) Investment Co”. Dissident Nominated Role Concerns or Questions KEY ISSUE Nominee on Board WU, Yu-Chun Director - Corporate 1. WU is an Indepen
Slide 35: Dissident nominees unlikely to add value
Dissident nominees unlikely to add value There are too many concerns and unanswered questions regarding many of the candidates nominated by “D-Link Investment Corp”. Dissident Nominated Role Concerns or Questions KEY ISSUE Nominee on Board CHEN, Yen- Director - Corporate 1. Resigned on March 16th th
Slide 36: Our Nominees
Our Nominees Management-supported Board of Director Candidates
Slide 37: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Lori HU 胡雪 Incumbent Chairwoman Senior Management Leadership Industry Experience Corporate Social Responsibility and Philanthropy Lori (Hsueh) HU is the current Chairw
Slide 38: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Dr. Yi-Chin LEE 李亦秦 Board experience Communication media technology expert Audit & Remuneration Committee International Business consulting and operations Senior Manag
Slide 39: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board David TAI 戴偉衡 Investment expertise Board experience Semiconductor and Electronics Audit & Remuneration Committee Industry experience Senior Leadership David (Wei-Heng)
Slide 40: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Howard KAO 高宏毅 Incumbent Director Board experience Programming and Start-up expertise International experience Mr. Howard (Hung-Yi) Kao currently works as the director
Slide 41: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Jerry CHIEN 簡志豪 Senior Management Strategy Development Industry expertise Board Experience International Business Incumbent Director Jerry (Chih-Hao) CHIEN has been an
Slide 42: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Spencer CHEN 陳壽山 Communications Industry expertise Internet Protocol Pioneer Senior Leadership Strategy Development Spencer (Shou-Shan) CHEN holds a Bachelor of Commun
Slide 43: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Independent Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Incumbent Director Accounting and Financial Expertise Freda CHEN 陳立君 Independence Senior Leadership Board experience Audit & Remuneration Committee Freda (
Slide 44: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Independent Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Legal Background NGO Experience Chien-Min WANG 王健珉 Minority Shareholder rights Independence Government and Regulatory Knowledge Chien-Min WANG brings over
Slide 45: Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value
Management-supported candidates will add much-needed diversity and value to the board Independent Director Nominee Key Skills and Value to Board Dr. Chen-Yi LEE 李鎮宜 Independence Regulatory Knowledge Electronics Engineering Board Experience Industry Expert Audit & Remuneration Committee Dr. Chen-Yi L
Slide 46: How you can help
How you can help Voting for our candidates will help to ensure that all shareholder rights are protected and that D-Link can continue to execute and improve upon current transformation plans.
Slide 47: Vote FOR mgmt-supported candidates
Vote FOR mgmt-supported candidates Management-supported candidates for the board of directors Recommendation 3.3 CHIEN, Chih-Hao (Jerry) 簡志豪 FOR 3.4 CHEN, Shou-Shan (Spencer) 陳壽山 Representative of Pu Ju Investment Co., Ltd FOR 3.7 HU Hsueh (Lori) 胡雪 Representative of Pu Ju Investment Co., Ltd FOR 3.
Slide 48: Financial Statements
Financial Statements D-Link Financials
Slide 49: D-Link Corporation Income Statement Highlights
D-Link Corporation Income Statement Highlights YoY (%) NT$ million 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 1Q20 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 1Q20 Sales Revenue 26,614 22,922 19,316 19,383 16,996 3,672 (12.2) (13.9) (15.7) 0.3 (12.3) (12.6) Gross Profit 6,433 6,017 5,199 5,602 4,740 1,081 (22.2) (6.5) (13.6) 7.8 (15.4)
Slide 50: D-Link Corporation Balance Statement Highlights
D-Link Corporation Balance Statement Highlights % of Total Assets NT$ million 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 1Q20 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 1Q20 TOTAL ASSETS 21,263 19,391 17,204 17,607 15,711 13,939 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 Cash 3,917 4,314 3,706 4,425 3,141 2,858 18.4 22.2 21.5 25.1 20.0 20.5
Slide 51: Media References
Media References Links to news articles
Slide 52: Media References
Media References In this article he states that TSG has held D-Link Shares for 3 years. He states that when TSG took a major stake in Chunyu, GTMC, Taiwan Styrene Monomer and hired professional managers to lead the operation they played the role of supporter and fixed profits. He states in this arti
Slide 53: Media References
Media References May 6th, 2020 Fong Chung-Peng stated in this press conference that he did not receive any compensation from the company because of its poor performance the past few years but started to receive compensation this year and showed his January statement of NT$70,000. Note: Annual Report
Slide 54: References
References May 9th, 2020 D-Link's response to concerns of legality of discharge of independent directors Jan 31, 2019 TSG wins management rights of Taiwan Styrene Monomer This article references a public statement by Jin Zhi Fu Asset Management (Taiwan Steel Group) that both ISS and Glass Lewis supp