Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — Technical Presentation (March 2017)
145 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's technical presentation, March 2017
Slide 1: The Reanchoring Channel of QE
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References The Reanchoring Channel of QE The ECB’s Asset Purchase Programme and Long-Term Inflation Expectations Philippe Andrade Johannes Breckenfelder Fiorella De Fiore Peter Karadi Oreste Tristani European Central Bank* Mar
Slide 2: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) I Key policy tool of all major central banks I Substitute for interest rates stuck at their effective lower bound (ZLB)
Slide 3: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) I Key policy tool of all major central banks I Substitute for interest rates stuck at their effective lower bound (ZLB) I In a frictionless world, LSAP no impact (Curdia
Slide 4: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) I Key policy tool of all major central banks I Substitute for interest rates stuck at their effective lower bound (ZLB) I In a frictionless world, LSAP no impact (Curdia
Slide 5: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) I Key policy tool of all major central banks I Substitute for interest rates stuck at their effective lower bound (ZLB) I In a frictionless world, LSAP no impact (Curdia
Slide 6: This paper
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References This paper I Event-study evidence on ECB’s LSAP (APP) announcements on inflation expectations I Unconventional easing leads to subsequent rise in 5-year-ahead inflation expectations
Slide 7: This paper
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References This paper I Event-study evidence on ECB’s LSAP (APP) announcements on inflation expectations I Unconventional easing leads to subsequent rise in 5-year-ahead inflation expectations I DSGE model with I Balance-sheet
Slide 8: This paper
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References This paper I Event-study evidence on ECB’s LSAP (APP) announcements on inflation expectations I Unconventional easing leads to subsequent rise in 5-year-ahead inflation expectations I DSGE model with I Balance-sheet
Slide 9: Findings
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Findings I Reanchoring channel is potent I Explains 1/3 of the inflation impact of APP I Amplified impact on short-term inflation I Mechanism (ZLB and financial accelerator): I Higher target implies easier policy I
Slide 10: Findings
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Findings I Reanchoring channel is potent I Explains 1/3 of the inflation impact of APP I Amplified impact on short-term inflation I Mechanism (ZLB and financial accelerator): I Higher target implies easier policy I
Slide 11: Reanchoring Channel: Related Literature
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Reanchoring Channel: Related Literature I Event-study evidence on QE I Broad asset-price impact (Rogers, Scotti and Wright, 2014; Swanson, 2015) I Scarce evidence on impact on long-term inflation expectations I Mark
Slide 12: Reanchoring Channel: Related Literature, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Reanchoring Channel: Related Literature, cont. I Information in introducing QE I Related to signalling at ZLB (Bhattarai, Eggertsson and Gafarov, 2015) I There: QE helps commitment of discretionary CB I Here: QE rev
Slide 13: Reanchoring Channel: Related Literature, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Reanchoring Channel: Related Literature, cont. I Information in introducing QE I Related to signalling at ZLB (Bhattarai, Eggertsson and Gafarov, 2015) I There: QE helps commitment of discretionary CB I Here: QE rev
Slide 14: EA event study
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References EA event study I ECB press conferences I January 2013 - June 2016 I Special ECB: IR announcements separate from press conferences I Press conferences (36) I Robustness: exclude 3 with key FG announcements (June 5, 2
Slide 15: EA event study
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References EA event study I ECB press conferences I January 2013 - June 2016 I Special ECB: IR announcements separate from press conferences I Press conferences (36) I Robustness: exclude 3 with key FG announcements (June 5, 2
Slide 16: EA event study, cont
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References EA event study, cont I Inflation expectations I 5-year ahead inflation expectations in the SPF I Robustness: 5-year inflation swap yields 5-year-ahead
Slide 17: EA event study, cont
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References EA event study, cont I Inflation expectations I 5-year ahead inflation expectations in the SPF I Robustness: 5-year inflation swap yields 5-year-ahead I Methodology: Quarterly regressions EA ˜ t−1 + εt , ∆yt = α + β
Slide 18: Impact on 5-year inflation expectations
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Impact on 5-year inflation expectations (1) (2) (3) (4) Post 2013 Pre 2013 APP APP, No FG Change in 5-year-ahead inflation expectations 5-year German yield -0.599*** 0.0932 -0.583** -0.508*** surprise (-4.392) (1.55
Slide 19: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Quantitative DSGE model I Representative family with Households I Consumption habits I Monopolistically competitive labor market; staggered wage setting I Portfolio adjustment costs HH assets I Intermedia
Slide 20: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Quantitative DSGE model I Representative family with Households I Consumption habits I Monopolistically competitive labor market; staggered wage setting I Portfolio adjustment costs HH assets I Intermedia
Slide 21: Overview
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Overview I Quantitative DSGE model I Representative family with Households I Consumption habits I Monopolistically competitive labor market; staggered wage setting I Portfolio adjustment costs HH assets I Intermedia
Slide 22: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance
Slide 23: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance I With iid. probability 1 − σ, a banker becomes a worker. (Limits bankers’ ability to save themselves out of the financia
Slide 24: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance I With iid. probability 1 − σ, a banker becomes a worker. (Limits bankers’ ability to save themselves out of the financia
Slide 25: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance I With iid. probability 1 − σ, a banker becomes a worker. (Limits bankers’ ability to save themselves out of the financia
Slide 26: Asset Returns
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Asset Returns I Return on capital (state-contingent debt) Zt+1 + Qt+1 Rkt+1 = Qt
Slide 27: Asset Returns
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Asset Returns I Return on capital (state-contingent debt) Zt+1 + Qt+1 Rkt+1 = Qt I Return on long term gov’t bonds Ξ/Pt + qt+1 Rbt+1 = qt
Slide 28: Financial Intermediaries
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries I Intermediary Balance Sheet Qt st + qt bt = nt + dt
Slide 29: Financial Intermediaries
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries I Intermediary Balance Sheet Qt st + qt bt = nt + dt I Evolution of net worth nt = Rkt Qt−1 st−1 + Rbt qt−1 bt−1 − Rt dt−1
Slide 30: Financial Intermediaries
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries I Intermediary Balance Sheet Qt st + qt bt = nt + dt I Evolution of net worth nt = Rkt Qt−1 st−1 + Rbt qt−1 bt−1 − Rt dt−1 I FI’s objective ∞ X Vt = Et (1 − σ)σ i−1 Λt,t+i nt+i (1) i=1
Slide 31: Limits to Arbitrage
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to Arbitrage I Agency problem: banker can divert I the fraction θ of loans and I ∆θ of gov’t bonds, with 0 ≤ ∆ ≤ 1.
Slide 32: Limits to Arbitrage
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to Arbitrage I Agency problem: banker can divert I the fraction θ of loans and I ∆θ of gov’t bonds, with 0 ≤ ∆ ≤ 1. I Lenders can recover the residual funds and shut the bank down.
Slide 33: Limits to Arbitrage
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to Arbitrage I Agency problem: banker can divert I the fraction θ of loans and I ∆θ of gov’t bonds, with 0 ≤ ∆ ≤ 1. I Lenders can recover the residual funds and shut the bank down. I Incentive constraint Vt ≥
Slide 34: Implications
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Implications Solution I ‘Risk-adjusted’ leverage constraint Qt st + ∆qt bt = φt nt where φt is an endogenous leverage ratio.
Slide 35: Implications
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Implications Solution I ‘Risk-adjusted’ leverage constraint Qt st + ∆qt bt = φt nt where φt is an endogenous leverage ratio. I ‘Arbitrage’ between corporate and sovereign bonds ∆Et β Ω̃t+1 (Rkt+1 − Rt+1 ) = Et β Ω̃t
Slide 36: Aggregation
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Aggregation I Aggregate leverage Qt Spt + ∆qt Bpt ≤ φt Nt
Slide 37: Aggregation
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Aggregation I Aggregate leverage Qt Spt + ∆qt Bpt ≤ φt Nt I Aggregate net worth Nt = σ [(Rkt − Rt )Qt−1 Spt−1 + (Rbt − Rt )qt−1 Bpt−1 +Rt Nt−1 ] + X.
Slide 38: Credit Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit Policy I Central bank: Less efficient in providing credit I τ efficiency cost
Slide 39: Credit Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit Policy I Central bank: Less efficient in providing credit I τ efficiency cost I Not balance sheet constrained
Slide 40: Credit Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit Policy I Central bank: Less efficient in providing credit I τ efficiency cost I Not balance sheet constrained I Asset purchases I Gov’t: Reducing the supply of long-term assets I Private: Direct credit to the
Slide 41: Credit Policy, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit Policy, cont. I Composition of Assets between banks and central bank St =Spt + Sgt Bt =Bpt + Bgt
Slide 42: Credit Policy, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit Policy, cont. I Composition of Assets between banks and central bank St =Spt + Sgt Bt =Bpt + Bgt I Private Securities Demand Qt St =φt Nt + Qt Sgt + ∆qt (Bgt − Bt ) Et Ω̃t+1 (Rbt+1 − Rt+1 ) = ∆Et Ω̃t+1 (Rkt+1
Slide 43: Credit Policy, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit Policy, cont. I Composition of Assets between banks and central bank St =Spt + Sgt Bt =Bpt + Bgt I Private Securities Demand Qt St =φt Nt + Qt Sgt + ∆qt (Bgt − Bt ) Et Ω̃t+1 (Rbt+1 − Rt+1 ) = ∆Et Ω̃t+1 (Rkt+1
Slide 44: Resource Constraint and Government Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Resource Constraint and Government Policy I Resource constraint It Yt = Ct + It + f It + G + Φ t It−1 where Φt is the portfolio transactions costs.
Slide 45: Resource Constraint and Government Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Resource Constraint and Government Policy I Resource constraint It Yt = Ct + It + f It + G + Φ t It−1 where Φt is the portfolio transactions costs. I Central bank balance sheet Qt Sgt + qt Bgt = Dgt
Slide 46: Resource Constraint and Government Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Resource Constraint and Government Policy I Resource constraint It Yt = Ct + It + f It + G + Φ t It−1 where Φt is the portfolio transactions costs. I Central bank balance sheet Qt Sgt + qt Bgt = Dgt I Gov’t budget c
Slide 47: Central Bank
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Central Bank I LSAP: Ψt = (Qt Sgt + ∆qt Bgt )/4Ȳ I Follows a second order autoregressive process
Slide 48: Central Bank
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Central Bank I LSAP: Ψt = (Qt Sgt + ∆qt Bgt )/4Ȳ I Follows a second order autoregressive process I Interest rate policy with ZLB: it it = max(0, i∗t ) i∗t =ρi it−1 + (1 − ρi ) [πt∗ + κπ (πt − πt∗ ) + κy yt ] + κ∆π
Slide 49: Central Bank
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Central Bank I LSAP: Ψt = (Qt Sgt + ∆qt Bgt )/4Ȳ I Follows a second order autoregressive process I Interest rate policy with ZLB: it it = max(0, i∗t ) i∗t =ρi it−1 + (1 − ρi ) [πt∗ + κπ (πt − πt∗ ) + κy yt ] + κ∆π
Slide 50: Learning
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Learning I Imperfect information: πt∗ , εt are unobserved
Slide 51: Learning
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Learning I Imperfect information: πt∗ , εt are unobserved I Learning rule, ∗e πt+1 =ρπ∗e πte∗ − ξ {st − set } st =it − ςΨt − [(1 − ρi )κπ + κ∆π ] πt − [(1 − ρi )κy + κ∆y ] yt set =Ẽt−1 [st ]
Slide 52: Learning
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Learning I Imperfect information: πt∗ , εt are unobserved I Learning rule, ∗e πt+1 =ρπ∗e πte∗ − ξ {st − set } st =it − ςΨt − [(1 − ρi )κπ + κ∆π ] πt − [(1 − ρi )κy + κ∆y ] yt set =Ẽt−1 [st ] I Idea I Motivated by c
Slide 53: Learning
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Learning I Imperfect information: πt∗ , εt are unobserved I Learning rule, ∗e πt+1 =ρπ∗e πte∗ − ξ {st − set } st =it − ςΨt − [(1 − ρi )κπ + κ∆π ] πt − [(1 − ρi )κy + κ∆y ] yt set =Ẽt−1 [st ] I Idea I Motivated by c
Slide 54: Solution
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution I Learning equilibrium I Agents optimize, learn about CB target I CB sets LSAP policy and interest rates s.t. ZLB I All markets clear
Slide 55: Solution
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution I Learning equilibrium I Agents optimize, learn about CB target I CB sets LSAP policy and interest rates s.t. ZLB I All markets clear I First-order appr. solution: impulse response analysis I Optimality con
Slide 56: Solution
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution I Learning equilibrium I Agents optimize, learn about CB target I CB sets LSAP policy and interest rates s.t. ZLB I All markets clear I First-order appr. solution: impulse response analysis I Optimality con
Slide 57: Calibration
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Calibration I Tightness of credit conditions I Average credit spreads I Private: 2.45% (LT CCB - Eonia) I Sovereign: 2.1% (EA 10-year yield - Eonia) I FI leverage: 6 I Assets over equity of FIs, NFCs in EA SA
Slide 58: Calibration
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Calibration I Tightness of credit conditions I Average credit spreads I Private: 2.45% (LT CCB - Eonia) I Sovereign: 2.1% (EA 10-year yield - Eonia) I FI leverage: 6 I Assets over equity of FIs, NFCs in EA SA I Lear
Slide 59: Calibration, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Calibration, cont. I Conventional parameters I Price- and wage stickiness, consumption habits, investment adjustment costs, policy rule Parameters I As estimated in NAWM (Christoffel et al., 2008) Monpol I High nomi
Slide 60: Calibration, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Calibration, cont. I Conventional parameters I Price- and wage stickiness, consumption habits, investment adjustment costs, policy rule Parameters I As estimated in NAWM (Christoffel et al., 2008) Monpol I High nomi
Slide 61: Results
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Results I Stylized demand shock Level I Persistent shock to savings preference I Inflation: −2.4%, Output −7%, 10-year rate -100bps I Deanchoring: perceived target −15 bps, expected liftoff: 7 quarters
Slide 62: Results
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Results I Stylized demand shock Level I Persistent shock to savings preference I Inflation: −2.4%, Output −7%, 10-year rate -100bps I Deanchoring: perceived target −15 bps, expected liftoff: 7 quarters I APP Impact
Slide 63: Results
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Results I Stylized demand shock Level I Persistent shock to savings preference I Inflation: −2.4%, Output −7%, 10-year rate -100bps I Deanchoring: perceived target −15 bps, expected liftoff: 7 quarters I APP Impact
Slide 64: Other channels
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Other channels I Duration channel Figure
Slide 65: Other channels
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Other channels I Duration channel Figure I “Stealth recapitalization” Recapitalization
Slide 66: Conclusion
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Conclusion I Inflation-expectation reanchoring: key channel I Event-study evidence I Quantified in a DSGE macromodel
Slide 67: Conclusion
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Conclusion I Inflation-expectation reanchoring: key channel I Event-study evidence I Quantified in a DSGE macromodel I Policy conclusions I Inactivity particularly costly with deanchoring I Reanchoring enhances poli
Slide 68: Euro Area Inflation Expectations
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Euro Area Inflation Expectations 0.2 2 1.9 0.15 1.8 1.7 0.1 1.6 Percent Percent 0.05 1.5 1.4 0 1.3 1.2 -0.05 1.1 -0.1 1 5-year ahead inflation expectations (q-o-q change, one quarter lead) 5-year German rate (intrad
Slide 69: Euro Area Inflation Expectations
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Euro Area Inflation Expectations 0.2 2.2 0.15 2 0.1 1.8 Percent Percent 0.05 1.6 0 2001Q1 2001Q3 2002Q1 2002Q3 2003Q1 2003Q3 2004Q1 2004Q3 2005Q1 2005Q3 2006Q1 2006Q3 2007Q1 2007Q3 2008Q1 2008Q3 2009Q1 2009Q3 2010Q1
Slide 70: Impact on 5x5 inflation-linked swap rates
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Impact on 5x5 inflation-linked swap rates (1) (2) (3) (4) Post 2013 Pre 2013 APP APP, No FG Change in 5x5 inflation-linked swap yields 5-year German yield -1.222** 0.571*** -1.533** -1.189** surprise (-2.754) (4.303
Slide 71: Impact of an interest rate innovation
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Impact of an interest rate innovation Policy rate Inflation Output Employment 0.2 0.3 0.6 0.6 0 0.2 0.4 0.4 %∆ from ss −0.2 0.1 0.2 0.2 −0.4 New Area−Wide 0 Model 0 0 Baseline −0.6 −0.1 −0.2 −0.2 5 10 15 20 5 10 15
Slide 72: Demand shock and APP
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Demand shock and APP Savings preference CB purchases Policy rate 5 10 0 %∆ from ss % of GDP 5 −2 0 0 −4 0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20 Inflation Output Consumption 0 10 20 %∆ from ss −2 0 0 −4 −10 −20 0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10
Slide 73: APP and maturity extension
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References APP and maturity extension Savings preference CB purchases Policy rate %∆ from no policy 5 20 0.5 % of GDP 10 0 0 0 0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20 Inflation Output Consumption 1 2 1 % impact 0.5 1 0.5 0 0 0 0 10 20 0 10 20
Slide 74: APP with and without reanchoring channel
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References APP with and without reanchoring channel CB purchases Policy rate Inflation 10 0.5 0.5 %∆ from no policy % of GDP 5 0 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20 Output Consumption Investment 1.5 0.8 4 %∆ from no policy 1
Slide 75: APP and monetary policy shock
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References APP and monetary policy shock CB purchases Output Inflation 10 2 1 %∆ from no policy % of GDP 1 5 0.5 0 0 −1 0 0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20 Policy rate Consumption Investment 0.5 1 10 %∆ from no policy 0 5 0.5 −0.5 0 −1
Slide 76: APP and forward guidance
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References APP and forward guidance CB purchases Policy rate Inflation 10 0.4 0.8 8 0.3 0.6 % of GDP % impact 6 0.2 0.4 4 0.1 0.2 2 0 0 0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20 Baseline APP with Forward Guidance Output 10 year rate Expected Li
Slide 77: References I
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References References I Altavilla, Carlo, Giacomo Carboni, and Roberto Motto (2015) “Asset Purchase Programmes and Financial Markets: Evidence from the Euro Area,” ECB working paper no 1864. Bhattarai, Saroj, Gauti Eggertsson,
Slide 78: References II
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References References II Christoffel, Kai, Guenter Coenen, and Anders Warne (2008) “The New Area-Wide Model of the Euro Area: A Micro-Founded Open-Economy Model for Forecasting and Policy Analysis,” Working Paper Series 0944,
Slide 79: References III
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References References III Gertler, Mark and Peter Karadi (2011) “A Model of Unconventional Monetary Policy,” Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 58, pp. 17–34. (2013) “QE 1 vs. 2 vs. 3...: A Framework for Analyzing Large-Scale
Slide 80: References IV
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References References IV Krishnamurthy, Arvind and Annette Vissing-Jorgensen (2011) “The Effects of Quantitative Easing on Interest Rates,” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. Rogers, John H, Chiara Scotti, and Jonathan H W
Slide 81: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Maximize utility ∞ χ L1+ϕ X i Et β ln(Ct+i − hCt+i−1 ) − 1 + ϕ t+i i=0 I subject to Ct + Dht+1 = Wt Lt + Πt + Tt + Rt Dt I where I Dht : short term debt (deposits and government debt) I Πt : payouts to
Slide 82: Wage setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Wage setting I Labor supply is a composite of heterogeneous labor services Z 1 εW W εW −1 ε −1 Nt = Nf t εW df (3) 0 where Nf t is the supply of labor service f .
Slide 83: Wage setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Wage setting I Labor supply is a composite of heterogeneous labor services Z 1 εW W εW −1 ε −1 Nt = Nf t εW df (3) 0 where Nf t is the supply of labor service f . I From cost minimization by firms: −εW Wf t Nf t = N
Slide 84: Wage setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Wage setting I Labor supply is a composite of heterogeneous labor services Z 1 εW W εW −1 ε −1 Nt = Nf t εW df (3) 0 where Nf t is the supply of labor service f . I From cost minimization by firms: −εW Wf t Nf t = N
Slide 85: Wage Setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Wage Setting I Optimal Wage Setting ∞ Wt∗ Π†t,t+i " # − µW Nfϕt+i X i i γ β Λt+i Nf t+i = 0 (5) Pt+i i=0 1 with µW = 1−1/ε W .
Slide 86: Wage Setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Wage Setting I Optimal Wage Setting ∞ Wt∗ Π†t,t+i " # − µW Nfϕt+i X i i γ β Λt+i Nf t+i = 0 (5) Pt+i i=0 1 with µW = 1−1/ε W .
Slide 87: Wage Setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Wage Setting I Optimal Wage Setting ∞ Wt∗ Π†t,t+i " # − µW Nfϕt+i X i i γ β Λt+i Nf t+i = 0 (5) Pt+i i=0 1 with µW = 1−1/ε W . I From the law of large numbers, h i 1 Wt = (1 − γW )(Wt∗ )1−εW + γW (Πγt−1 Wi Π∗1−γ t W
Slide 88: Household Asset Holdings
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Household Asset Holdings I Households can directly hold private securities and long-term gov’t bonds subject to transactions costs I Private: holding costs: 12 κ(Sht − S h )2 for Sht ≥ S h . I Gov’t bonds: holding c
Slide 89: Household Asset Holdings
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Household Asset Holdings I Households can directly hold private securities and long-term gov’t bonds subject to transactions costs I Private: holding costs: 12 κ(Sht − S h )2 for Sht ≥ S h . I Gov’t bonds: holding c
Slide 90: Household Asset Holdings
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Household Asset Holdings I Households can directly hold private securities and long-term gov’t bonds subject to transactions costs I Private: holding costs: 12 κ(Sht − S h )2 for Sht ≥ S h . I Gov’t bonds: holding c
Slide 91: Credit policy with HH asset demand
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit policy with HH asset demand I Composition of Assets St = Spt + Sht + Sgt Bt = Bpt + Bht + Bgt
Slide 92: Credit policy with HH asset demand
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit policy with HH asset demand I Composition of Assets St = Spt + Sht + Sgt Bt = Bpt + Bht + Bgt I Private Asset Demands Qt (St − S h ) = φt Nt + Qt Sgt + ∆qt Bgt − (Bt − B h ) + Et Λt,t+1 (Rkt+1 − Rt+1 ) (Qt +
Slide 93: Credit policy with HH asset demand, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Credit policy with HH asset demand, cont. I Relative effects of securities versus gov’t bond purchases similar to before. I Larger effects of purchases with fixed demand. I Responses of household asset demands can m
Slide 94: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance
Slide 95: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance I With iid. probability 1 − σ, a banker becomes a worker. (Limits bankers’ ability to save themselves out of the financia
Slide 96: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance I With iid. probability 1 − σ, a banker becomes a worker. (Limits bankers’ ability to save themselves out of the financia
Slide 97: Households
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Households I Representative family I f bankers, 1 − f workers I Perfect consumption insurance I With iid. probability 1 − σ, a banker becomes a worker. (Limits bankers’ ability to save themselves out of the financia
Slide 98: Assets
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Assets I Return on state-contingent debt (capital) Zt+1 + Qt+1 Rkt+1 = Qt
Slide 99: Assets
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Assets I Return on state-contingent debt (capital) Zt+1 + Qt+1 Rkt+1 = Qt I Return on long term gov’t bonds Ξ/Pt + qt+1 Rbt+1 = qt
Slide 100: Financial Intermediaries
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries I Intermediary Balance Sheet Qt st + qt bt = nt + dt
Slide 101: Financial Intermediaries
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries I Intermediary Balance Sheet Qt st + qt bt = nt + dt I Evolution of net worth nt = Rkt Qt−1 st−1 + Rbt qt−1 bt−1 − Rt dt−1
Slide 102: Financial Intermediaries
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries I Intermediary Balance Sheet Qt st + qt bt = nt + dt I Evolution of net worth nt = Rkt Qt−1 st−1 + Rbt qt−1 bt−1 − Rt dt−1 I FI’s objective ∞ X Vt = Et (1 − σ)σ i−1 Λt,t+i nt+i (7) i=1
Slide 103: Limits to Arbitrage
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to Arbitrage I Agency problem: banker can divert I the fraction θ of loans and I ∆θ of gov’t bonds, with 0 ≤ ∆ ≤ 1.
Slide 104: Limits to Arbitrage
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to Arbitrage I Agency problem: banker can divert I the fraction θ of loans and I ∆θ of gov’t bonds, with 0 ≤ ∆ ≤ 1. I Lenders can recover the residual funds and shut the bank down.
Slide 105: Limits to Arbitrage
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to Arbitrage I Agency problem: banker can divert I the fraction θ of loans and I ∆θ of gov’t bonds, with 0 ≤ ∆ ≤ 1. I Lenders can recover the residual funds and shut the bank down. I Incentive constraint Vt ≥
Slide 106: Implications
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Implications Solution I ‘Risk-adjusted’ leverage constraint Qt st + ∆qt bt = φt nt where φt is an endogenous leverage ratio.
Slide 107: Implications
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Implications Solution I ‘Risk-adjusted’ leverage constraint Qt st + ∆qt bt = φt nt where φt is an endogenous leverage ratio. I ‘Arbitrage’ between corporate and sovereign bonds ∆Et β Ω̃t+1 (Rkt+1 − Rt+1 ) = Et β Ω̃t
Slide 108: Aggregation
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Aggregation I Aggregate leverage Qt Spt + ∆qt Bpt ≤ φt Nt
Slide 109: Aggregation
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Aggregation I Aggregate leverage Qt Spt + ∆qt Bpt ≤ φt Nt I Aggregate net worth Nt = σ [(Rkt − Rt )Qt−1 Spt−1 + (Rbt − Rt )qt−1 Bpt−1 +Rt Nt−1 ] + X
Slide 110: Resource Constraint and Government Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Resource Constraint and Government Policy I Resource constraint It Yt = Ct + It + f It + G + Φ t It−1 where Φt is the portfolio transactions costs.
Slide 111: Resource Constraint and Government Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Resource Constraint and Government Policy I Resource constraint It Yt = Ct + It + f It + G + Φ t It−1 where Φt is the portfolio transactions costs. I Central bank balance sheet Qt Sgt + qt Bgt = Dgt
Slide 112: Resource Constraint and Government Policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Resource Constraint and Government Policy I Resource constraint It Yt = Ct + It + f It + G + Φ t It−1 where Φt is the portfolio transactions costs. I Central bank balance sheet Qt Sgt + qt Bgt = Dgt I Gov’t budget c
Slide 113: Financial Intermediaries' Problem
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries’ Problem I End-of-period value function Vt Vt−1 (st−1 , bt−1 , nt−1 ) = Et−1 Λt−1,t {(1 − σ)nt + σWt (nt )}
Slide 114: Financial Intermediaries' Problem
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Financial Intermediaries’ Problem I End-of-period value function Vt Vt−1 (st−1 , bt−1 , nt−1 ) = Et−1 Λt−1,t {(1 − σ)nt + σWt (nt )} I Beginning-of-period value function Wt Wt (nt ) = max Vt (st , bt , nt ) st ,bt s
Slide 115: Solution
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution I Conjecture: linear end-of-period value function Vt = µst Qt st + µbt qt bt + νt nt
Slide 116: Solution
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution I Conjecture: linear end-of-period value function Vt = µst Qt st + µbt qt bt + νt nt I Beginning-of-period Lagrange function (1 + λt )(µst Qt st + µb qt bt + νt nt ) − λt (θQt st + ∆θqt bt )
Slide 117: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I FONC: st λt µst = θ 1 + λt I FONC: bt λt µbt = ∆ θ 1 + λt = ∆µst I FONC: λt (µst Qt st + µbt qt bt + νt nt ) − (θQt st + ∆θqt bt ) = 0
Slide 118: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I Endogenous ‘risk-adjusted’ leverage constraint: Qt st + ∆qt bt = φt nt where φt is the leverage ratio: νt φt = θ − µst
Slide 119: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I Endogenous ‘risk-adjusted’ leverage constraint: Qt st + ∆qt bt = φt nt where φt is the leverage ratio: νt φt = θ − µst I Beginning-of-period value function Wt (nt ) =µst (Qt s∗t + ∆qt b∗t ) + νt nt
Slide 120: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I End-of-period value function µst−1 Qt−1 st−1 + µbt−1 qt−1 bt−1 + νt−1 nt−1 = Et−1 Λt−1,t {(1 − σ)nt + σWt (nt )}, subject to nt = (Rkt − Rt )Qt−1 st−1 + (Rbt − Rt )qt−1 bt−1 + Rt nt−1
Slide 121: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I End-of-period value function µst−1 Qt−1 st−1 + µbt−1 qt−1 bt−1 + νt−1 nt−1 = Et−1 Λt−1,t {(1 − σ)nt + σWt (nt )}, subject to nt = (Rkt − Rt )Qt−1 st−1 + (Rbt − Rt )qt−1 bt−1 + Rt nt−1 I After subst
Slide 122: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I Partial marginal values µst =Et Ω̃t+1 (Rkt+1 − Rt+1 ) µbt =Et Ω̃t+1 (Rbt+1 − Rt+1 ) = ∆µst νt =Et Ω̃t+1 Rt+1 Ω̃t =Λt,t+1 [1 − σ + σθφt ] where Ω̃t > 1 is the FI’s discount factor.
Slide 123: Solution, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Solution, cont. I Partial marginal values µst =Et Ω̃t+1 (Rkt+1 − Rt+1 ) µbt =Et Ω̃t+1 (Rbt+1 − Rt+1 ) = ∆µst νt =Et Ω̃t+1 Rt+1 Ω̃t =Λt,t+1 [1 − σ + σθφt ] where Ω̃t > 1 is the FI’s discount factor. I End-of-period v
Slide 124: Capital producers
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Capital producers I Profit Maximization ∞ X t Iτ + I max Et β Λt,τ (Qτ − 1)Iτ − f (Iτ ) (9) τ =t Iτ −1 where f (1) = f 0 (1) = 0 and f 00 (1) > 0.
Slide 125: Capital producers
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Capital producers I Profit Maximization ∞ X t Iτ + I max Et β Λt,τ (Qτ − 1)Iτ − f (Iτ ) (9) τ =t Iτ −1 where f (1) = f 0 (1) = 0 and f 00 (1) > 0. I “Q” relation for investment: 2 It 0 It+1 Qt = 1 + f (·) + f (·) −
Slide 126: Intermediate Goods Producer
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Intermediate Goods Producer I Production Yt = At (Kt )α L1−α t (11)
Slide 127: Intermediate Goods Producer
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Intermediate Goods Producer I Production Yt = At (Kt )α L1−α t (11) I Evolution of firm capital Kt+1 = [It + (1 − δ)Kt ]
Slide 128: Intermediate Goods Producer
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Intermediate Goods Producer I Production Yt = At (Kt )α L1−α t (11) I Evolution of firm capital Kt+1 = [It + (1 − δ)Kt ] I Share issue St = Kt+1
Slide 129: Intermediate Goods Producers, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Intermediate Goods Producers, cont. I FONC labor: Yt Pmt (1 − α) = Wt , (12) Lt Pmt be the price of intermediate goods output I Capital rental Yt+1 Zt = Pmt α − δ, Kt+1 the replacement price of used capital is fixed
Slide 130: Retailers and price setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Retailers and price setting I Final output as a composite of retail output Z 1 ε ε−1 ε−1 Yt = Yf t ε df (13) 0 where Yf t is output by retailer f .
Slide 131: Retailers and price setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Retailers and price setting I Final output as a composite of retail output Z 1 ε ε−1 ε−1 Yt = Yf t ε df (13) 0 where Yf t is output by retailer f . I From cost minimization by users of final output: −ε Pf t Yf t = Y
Slide 132: Retailers and price setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Retailers and price setting I Final output as a composite of retail output Z 1 ε ε−1 ε−1 Yt = Yf t ε df (13) 0 where Yf t is output by retailer f . I From cost minimization by users of final output: −ε Pf t Yf t = Y
Slide 133: Price Setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Price Setting I Price Setting Problem ∞ Pt∗ Π†t,t+i " # X i i max γ β Λt,t+i − Pmt+i Yf t+i (15) Pt+i i=0
Slide 134: Price Setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Price Setting I Price Setting Problem ∞ Pt∗ Π†t,t+i " # X i i max γ β Λt,t+i − Pmt+i Yf t+i (15) Pt+i i=0 I Optimal Price Setting ∞ Pt∗ Π†t,t+i " # X γ i β i Λt,t+i − µPmt+i Yf t+i = 0 (16) Pt+i i=0 1 with µ = 1−1/ε
Slide 135: Price Setting
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Price Setting I Price Setting Problem ∞ Pt∗ Π†t,t+i " # X i i max γ β Λt,t+i − Pmt+i Yf t+i (15) Pt+i i=0 I Optimal Price Setting ∞ Pt∗ Π†t,t+i " # X γ i β i Λt,t+i − µPmt+i Yf t+i = 0 (16) Pt+i i=0 1 with µ = 1−1/ε
Slide 136: Parameters
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Parameters Households β 0.994 Discount rate h 0.567 Habit parameter χ 20.758 Relative utility weight of labor B/Y 0.700 Steady state Treasury supply K̄ h /K 0.000 Proportion of direct capital holdings of the HHs B̄
Slide 137: Parameters, cont.
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Parameters, cont. Capital Producing Firms ηi 5.169 Inverse elasticity of net investment to the price of capital Retail Firms 3.857 Elasticity of substitution γP 0.920 Probability of keeping the price constant γP,−1
Slide 138: Bond yields around announcement and implementation
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Bond yields around announcement and implementation I Both announcement and implementation of the PSPP have sizable impact on yields I High duration bonds are impacted significantly more I Not only purchased bonds sh
Slide 139: Impact of purchases on bond yields
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Impact of purchases on bond yields I No significant effect of individual trades on daily yield changes (excludes first two weeks) I Three different setups: (i) simple panel, (ii) event study around the first purchas
Slide 140: The impact of the PSPP on euro area banks
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References The impact of the PSPP on euro area banks I QE as a form of bank capital relief: the larger the sovereign bonds holdings, the larger the benefits I Event study: reaction of each bank’s stock price to PSPP announceme
Slide 141: Equity price reactions between January 21 and 23, 2015
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Equity price reactions between January 21 and 23, 2015 (SNL sample) (1) (2) (3) constant 2.55∗∗∗ 2.09∗∗∗ 1.74∗∗∗ (4.38) (3.81) (3.21) ∆yield 15.67∗∗∗ 9.12∗∗∗ 8.76∗∗∗ (4.61) (2.83) (2.76) ∆SM 0.39∗∗∗ 0.80∗∗∗ 0.77∗∗∗
Slide 142: Signal of lower future policy rates
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Signal of lower future policy rates I Impact on average expectation from SPF I 2015Q1-2015Q3: MRO rate forecasts declined from 11 to 6bps for 2016 and from 43 to 31bps for 2017 I What do low interest rates mean? (An
Slide 143: Expected deviations from normal times policy
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Expected deviations from normal times policy .4 .2 0 −.2 −.4 −.6 2008q1 2010q1 2012q1 2014q1 2016q1 1 year ahead 2 years ahead Source: ECB SPF and Own calculations Back
Slide 144: Risk of reduced effectiveness of the APP
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Risk of reduced effectiveness of the APP I Increased issuance of long-term bonds by national governments would raise investors’ exposure to duration risk, offsetting the impact of APP. I Following announcement of PS
Slide 145: Limits to the effectiveness
Overview Literature Event study Model Solution Results Conclusion Figures References Limits to the effectiveness All eligible issuers All maturities average weighted maturity (years) 600 6 400 total amount (bill.) 5 200 4 0 −200 3 −400 2 2014q2 2014q3 2014q4 2015q1 2015q2 2015q3 2015q4 Maturity of a
Banque Nationale De Belgique — Technical Presentation (March 2017) on 6ix