Admiral Group plc · LSE:ADM
Admiral — Investor Presentation (November 2010)
74 slides from Admiral's investor presentation, Nov 3, 2010
Slide 1: Analyst Presentation
Analyst Presentation 3 November 2010
Slide 2: Agenda
Agenda Henry Engelhardt, Group Chief Executive Officer Q3 Group highlights & introduction UK car insurance Marketing Charlotte Bennett Marketing, Pricing, Peter Marissen UK Operations, Nick Weng Kan Claims Stuart Morgan Claims, Questions & Answers International – focus on Italy C
Slide 3: How are we doing? Q3 2010 highlights
How are we doing? Q3 2010 highlights Group turnover* Q3 2010 increased by over 50% v Q3 09 to £446 million Group vehicle count increased 28% v 30 September 2009 to 2.6 million UK ancillary contribution per vehicle remains stable v H1 2010 No change in claims trends from H1 2010 Confused.co
Slide 4: The new reinsurance deals
The new reinsurance deals 2.5% 2.5% 6.25% 10% 2.5% 3% 8.75% 6.25% 8.75% 8.75% 2.5% 3% 10% 10% 11.25% 13.25% 13.25% 7.5% 2.5% 5% 7.5% 7.5% 50% 45% 40% New deals* are fixed cost 40% 40% of around 1.6 – 1.9% including brokerage 27.5% 27.5% 27.5% 25% 25% 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Underwriting Year Admira
Slide 5: What are we here for?
What are we here for? An opportunity to meet the managers UK car insurance; Charlotte, Peter, Nic and Stuart will: Remind you what they do Highlight recent changes Address some common queries “The Italian Job”; Milena, Francisco and Tommaso will introduce you to: The Italian market Chiarez
Slide 6: What I hope you'll take away
What I hope you’ll take away UK car insurance There’s more to car insurance than you might think, everyone has a vital role to play We like change, some of the key changes we’ll be talking about are: Price comparison - has played to our strengths Admiral’s growth - we have a scalable model
Slide 7: Marketing
Marketing Ch l tt Bennett Charlotte B tt 7
Slide 8: Admiral marketing – an introduction
Admiral marketing – an introduction Marketing team Price comparison • Work with PC sites to maximise t team coverage and d conversion i We’re a small team • Advertising creation, planning Advertising and buying of 27 people campaign team • Supported by in-house studio Customer value • Ancillary prod
Slide 9: Admiral marketing – what's important to us?
Admiral marketing – what’s important to us? Marketing in a PC world Our top 3 marketing metrics Clicks to insurer is largely determined b policy by li price i 1 1. PC click to sale conversion 2. Cost per vehicle acquisition Capture “clicks” as sales 3. Ancillary revenue per vehicle Maximise customer
Slide 10: Key change: price comparison growth – UK Market
Key change: price comparison growth – UK Market UK market: price comparison as % new UK market: majority of TV & Press spend is business now made by PC sites* 140 TV and Press Spend (£m) 120 100 5% 34% 48% 16% 80 51% 59% 45% 60 38% 95% 40 84% 66% 57% 24% 52% 20 41% 10% 14% 43% ‐ 2005 2006 2007 2008
Slide 11: Key change: price comparison growth - Admiral
Key change: price comparison growth - Admiral % of Admiral new business sourced from UK insurers TV and press spend price comparison p p 80 70 d Press Spend (£m) 60 50 40 80% 84% 72% 30 TV and 47% 20 10 ‐ 2007 2008 2009 H1 10 2007 2008 2009 H1 10 Churchill Direct Line Aviva (incl RAC) Admiral AXA /
Slide 12: Common query: Will price comparison unify motor insurers' acquisition costs?
Common query: “Will price comparison unify motor insurers’ acquisition costs?” Admiral’ss acquisition cost advantage over the Admiral market has increased 15% 14% 12% 12% 11% 6% 6% 5% 6% 5% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Market acquistion cost ratio Admiral acquisition cost ratio * Both cost ratios are on
Slide 13: Price comparison has contributed to largest players losing marketing edge
It appears that price comparison has contributed to the largest players losing their “marketing edge” Aviva and RBSI have lost share* Aviva and RBSI have experienced erosion of their acquisition cost advantage* advantage posures 8,000 21% 18% e vehicle exp 6,000 17% 14% 11% 4,000 10% Average 2,000 9
Slide 14: What about individual players' acquisition costs?
What about individual players’ acquisition costs? Top 10 private motor insurers acquisition cost ratios* 30% Market RBSI average 25% n average veehicles) hare 2009 market sh 20% 15% (based on 10% Fortis 5% Admiral Esure Aviva LV RSA National AXA / Swiftcover Farmers CIS 0% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
Slide 15: Pricing
Pricing P t Marissen Peter M i 15
Slide 16: Pricing: an introduction
Pricing: an introduction We decide which price to charge each customer Analysis is focussed on how different parts of the portfolio perform relative to each other Our analysis results in prices that are driven by Claims experience P i sensitivity Price iti it 16
Slide 17: Pricing: our analysis
Pricing: our analysis What’s important for our pricing analysis Data Approach • Maximum use of data • Focus on analysis • More detailed data • Common sense & innovation • High quality data • Quick & frequent changes • Use external data • Not afraid to do things differently 17
Slide 18: Key change: price comparison
Key change: price comparison PC sites provide customers with almost 100% transparency of all insurers’ insurers prices, this creates challenges for pricing: Risk of winner’s curse Easy switching 18
Slide 19: Price comparison: risk of winners' curse
Price comparison: risk of winners’ curse “Winner’s curse”: an insurer comes top on price comparison when they shouldn’t and as a result write a large volume of poor quality business Comparison of new business loss ratio performance PC vs Non-PC (Non PC indexed to 1.00) PC business is good quality
Slide 20: Price comparison: easy switching
Price comparison: easy switching PC vs Non-PC: renewal rate PC vs Non-PC: cancellation rate PC vs Non-PC: persistency rate (for year 1 renewals) 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.04 0 93 0.93 0.71 Non PC PC Non PC PC Non PC PC Lower cancellation more than PC customers are more likely But less likely to cancel before
Slide 21: Key change: shifts in business mix
Key change: shifts in business mix Average earned premium (£) 489 488 488 477 We like everyone – as long as the price is right 459 458 438 438 427 +35% Growth helps us identify & exploit more cross +16% subsidies 374 369 372 367 369 369 As a result we’ve written more low risk business 363 364 20
Slide 22: Potential change: European Court of Justice ruling on using gender
Potential change: European Court of Justice ruling on using gender In 2011 ECJ will decide whether using gender as a rating factor is compatible with EU fundamental rights Example Admiral prices: th gender the d diff differential ti l Why remove gender as rating factor? Difference in price reflect
Slide 23: Common query: Does price comparison remove Admiral's pricing advantage?
Common query: “Does price comparison remove Admiral’s pricing advantage as every one has the same questions?” Number of questions asked per insurers’ websites Admiral’s loss ratio performance vs market 94 87 89 80 12 6 71 73 6 4 69 68 74 72 72 74 72 71 51 54 64 44 43 57 52 50 Admiral Direct Line Esu
Slide 24: UK Operations
UK Operations Ni W Nic Weng K Kan 24
Slide 25: UK Operations – a brief overview
UK Operations – a brief overview What? Sales Customer service Where? Renewals Outbound South Wales All Quality Halifax, Nova Scotia Bangalore When? Sales & renewals Customer Service Sales Mon to Fri 8am - 11pm Sat 9am - 8pm How big? Sun 10am - 8pm >10m phone calls C stomer services
Slide 26: UK Operations - our strengths
UK Operations - our strengths Top 10 party 10 year awards Canada – school kids Swansea CS ice skating! Low cost Low Culture attrition Flat hierarchy Stocks Fun Staff St ff share h ownership Ancillaries awards WRU sponsorship Cardiff renewals awards Community chest Movie madness Egg roulette 26
Slide 27: Key change: growth
Key change: growth UK car insurance – vehicle growth 2 308 2,308 2,123 2,000 1,810 1,862 1,732 1,670 1,587 1,552 Q3 08 Q4 08 Q1 09 Q2 09 Q3 09 Q4 09 Q1 10 Q2 10 Q3 10 Total vehicles at period end We’re used to growth ...in 2010 we’re achieving faster growth on a bigger book! 27
Slide 28: Key change: growth
Key change: growth Average number of UK operations Number of vehicles per UK operations staff* staff staff member** member 1600 1,280 1,300 1350 1,260 1200 2008 2009 YTD 2010 2008 2009 YTD 2010 Enabling rapid growth whilst maintaining high quality service Growth has additional benefits Young staff
Slide 29: Common query: Have optional ancillaries suffered in the recession?
Common query: “Have Admiral’s optional ancillaries suffered as a result of the recession?” Indexed comparison of optional ancillary income per new business vehicle Our optional O ti l ancillaries ill i d do nott appear tto b be sensitive to recession PC customers have been more of a challenge, g , t
Slide 30: Common query: Is Admiral the only one that charges admin fees?
Common query: “Is Admiral the only one that charges admin fees?” UK Market administration fees*: how many insurers i charge h th them? ? Admiral: Administration fees 67% 70% Adjustment Adj t t fee f £17.50 £17 50 (market ( k t average** ** ~£19) £19) 37% Duplicate document fee £7.50 (market aver
Slide 31: Claims
Claims St t Morgan Stuart M 31
Slide 32: What do we do in Claims? Four key requirements
What do we do in Claims? It’s complex but there are essentially 4 key requirements What type of What type of accident? claim? How did it happen? 1 1. Deliver great customer service Who’s involved in Is there likely to be the accident? a bodily injury 2. Controlling compensation culture element? Can
Slide 33: What do we do in Claims? Deliver great customer service
What do we do in Claims? Deliver great customer service It’s all about p people, p the claims philosophy: p p y Great service Great cost Great fun ~93% of customers say they would renew their policy following a claim We receive complaints on <1% of all registered claims 33
Slide 34: What do we do in Claims? Controlling compensation culture
What do we do in Claims? Controlling compensation culture Claims structure: Two sides of the same coin: Fault claims Increasing I i proportion ti off claims l i ffrom thi third d party t iinsurers h have a BI element l t Contact centre (inbound & Non Fault claims outbound) Good customer service
Slide 35: What do we do in Claims? Negotiation of settlement
What do we do in Claims? Negotiation of settlement Claims structure: Staff are decision makers – empowered to offer settlement at all stages t off the th process (within ( ithi lilimits) it ) Contact centre (inbound & Negotiations can happen with customer, with lawyer, or with outbound) accident
Slide 36: What do we do in Claims? Reserve conservatively
What do we do in Claims? Reserve conservatively Claims structure: Accurate reserves from first contact C t t centre Contact t to final settlement Conservative approach: (inbound & outbound) Liability & quantum Inflation assumptions Frequently update Monitoring and review (BI claims) Back off
Slide 37: Key change: growth
Key change: growth In recent years increase in vehicles partly But in 2010 we’ve made a significant offset by lower claims frequency increase in claims headcount 1180 2,308 920 920 1,862 820 1,382 1,587 710 620 1,104 1,240 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sep 10 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Sep 10 Closingg acti
Slide 38: Key change: regulation
Key change: regulation What’s happened on Will the the Jackson Review? What’s the discount rate impact of the be reduced? MoJ changes? Cl i Claims iis, and d always l h has b been, a regulated l t d process subject bj t tto regulatory l t change h 1998 1999 2000 2001 2005 2010 Discount rate drop Woo
Slide 39: Common query: Will the recession cause a huge claims spike?
Common query: “Will the recession cause a huge claims spike?” Theft is now only a small proportion of claims* An increasing proportion of claims have a BI element, but this is consistent with the long term trend 14% We’re finding more fraud... 40% Bodily Injury as % of total claims 8% 2006 2009 5% 3
Slide 40: UK Q&A
UK Q&A 40
Slide 41: Admiral Group - Italy
Admiral Group - Italy Italian market Milena Mondini Francisco Garcia Francisco Garcia Tommaso Gamaleri Milena Mondini 41
Slide 42: Italian market
-T 4 ¥) Italian market 42
Slide 43: A very large market despite premiums shrinking since 2006
A very large market despite premiums shrinking since 2006 TOTAL ITALIAN MOTOR GWP* (€bn) NUMBER OF VEHICLES STABLE 21.6 21.5 20.8 20 1 20.1 Private cars 36m 3.2 3.3 3.2 Motor bike 6m 3.1 Other 6m Total vehicles 48m Highest proportion in EU vehicles/drivers 18.4 18.2 17.6 17.0 AVERAGE PREMIUM FALLING
Slide 44: 2009 underwriting results have been the worst in the last 9 years
2009 underwriting results have been the worst in the last 9yrs y ITALIAN MOTOR INSURANCE UNDERWRITING RESULTS (%) 109.4 102 102.7 7 105 105.5 5 96.3 95.4 98.6 94.0 92.6 92.6 93.4 Increased due to lower average premium and reserve 90.3 adjustments arising from new BI 83.8 85.6 77.8 75.7 76.0 79.0 90
Slide 45: Recent challenges for insurance profitability
Recent challenges for insurance profitability Challenge Description Implications Regulations regarding Bonus Malus Impossible to price accurately on Bonus Bersani class*, for example allowed to use Malus class same class as other family members K4K like agreement: non-fault Faster settlement
Slide 46: Italian insurance market increased price by ~25%
As reaction to 2009 UW results Italian insurance market increased price by ~25% SWITCHERS + 45% PRICE INCREASE* 9.3% 6.3% + 25% 2006 2010 GOOGLE IMPRESSIONS** 2009 2010 + 28% Estimate of private motor market price increase in 12 months to June 2009 2010 * Management estimates, utilising market exper
Slide 47: Direct channel is growing steadily…
Direct channel is growing steadily… DIRECT PLAYERS DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS* (%) Direct Players GWP 2009 (2009) (€ M) Genertel 241 4.2 4.5 4.9 Direct Line 238 1.2 1.1 1.6 2 Genialloyd 210 1.1 2.4 1.3 24 2.4 Linear 146 3.2 Zuritel 117 6-8% total direct, of 91.2 which ~20% 20% of GWP Dialogo 27 90 4 90.4
Slide 48: … mainly due to rise of aggregators
… mainly due to rise of aggregators AGGREGATORS QUOTES* Sales: ~10K sales per month, ~70% 70% of which are from direct insurers 650,000 450,000 330,000 130,000 , 70,000 2009 Q3 2009 Q4 2010 Q1 2010 Q2 2010 Q3 Source: ANIA 2009 * Management estimates, utilising market experience combined with indices
Slide 49: Who are these aggregators?
Who are these aggregators? Market leader with over 150k quotes/month #2 with 50k-75k quotes/month Focused on online marketing and white label Significant PR resonance Privately funded Owned by leading mortgage aggregator (MutuiOnline.it, listed mortgage aggregator) Pioneer PC site sinc
Slide 50: Chiarezza.it
lgarezza.it 50
Slide 51: Some facts about Chiarezza.it
Some facts about Chiarezza.it Launched on February 2010, Chiarezza.it joined a young but growing market From “confusion” to “clarity”; we’re tailoring price comparison to the Italian market First aggregator to use offline ff media Radio campaign in July 2010 TV in September 2010 Chiarezz
Slide 52: Leveraging a tried & tested business model, adapted to local taste
Leveraging a tried & tested business model, but adapted to local taste Free to users Insurer friendly Focused F d on car insurance i First on TV Scalable Cost conscious Customer centric People, people, people 52
Slide 53: Approach
Approach Product Panel Leveraged Confused.com technology b t customized but t i d tot local l l taste t t + 10 traditional insurers (via brokers) Marketing Team Davide, Commercial Serena, Admin Francisco, MD Direct Line Michael Page McKinsey, Balumba McKinsey Developing our brand Differentiated
Slide 54: Top priorities
Top priorities Explain benefits of price comparison (e.g. acquisition cost, new 1. Build a customer base etc) strong panel Build trust in service Working closely with insurers on IT 2. Develop Work with insurers and show flexibility y in revenue model ((e.g. g cost appropriate per sale based
Slide 55: In a nutshell
In a nutshell Price comparison looks set to take off in Italy There are challenges, but Chiarezza.it is well placed: Knowledge and support from Confused.com & international PCs Flexible Fl ibl approach h to t partner t relations l ti Leading the change of customer habits (e.g. first on TV)
Slide 56: ConTe.it
ae, Conle.it SI ® Admiral Group plc UK 56
Slide 57: ConTe.it, the Italian branch
ConTe.it, the Italian branch The Italian branch of Admiral Who we are? Launched in 2008, May 30th Quota share/co-insurance agreement with Munich Re at 65% Car and motor bike insurance by phone phone, internet internet, price aggregators What we offer? 3 products (All drivers, >28 years old
Slide 58: Adapting UK competitive advantages to the Italian landscape
Adapting UK competitive advantages to the Italian landscape p Low Sophisticated acquisition pricing Costs 22nd in the 2010 Italian list Motivated talented Strong Team Efficient customer claims focus handling Low fixed expenses structure UK support 58
Slide 59: More sophisticated pricing & underwriting
More sophisticated pricing & underwriting QUESTIONS DISTRIBUTION ConTe.it 100% Direct Line Z i h Connect Zurich C t 80% Quixa 60% North Genialloyd Center 40% 0 10 20 30 40 50 South 20% GRANULARITY: I.E. PROFESSIONS 0% ConTe.it Market Direct* Zurich Connect Direct Line Quixa Potential opportunities f
Slide 60: Low acquisition costs
Low acquisition costs CONTE SALES CHANNELS 100% 80% 60% Phone I t Internet t 40% Agg 20% 0% 2008 2009 2010 Our O approach h Focus on low cost acquisition of traffic through search engines Continuous optimization of website conversion and customer journey Leverage on UK expertise to optimize ag
Slide 61: Efficient claims handling
Efficient claims handling Our approach: Leverage Fast settlement (within 48hrs) of small claims (<€1,000) advantages of Robust network (ca. 420) of approved garages Italian “direct Focus on efficient processes to handle small BI’s (i.e. whiplash) indemnity” system Detailed check when claims
Slide 62: Sustained growth in the first 2 years
Sustained growth in the first 2yrs CONTE GROSS WRITTEN PREMIUM (€m) And this is in only 3 months 14.5 7.9 8.6 4.6 1.0 0.1 H1 08 H2 08 H1 09 H2 09 H1 10 Q3 10 Active Policy Base at period 0.2 3.4 14.8 35.5 57.9 71.9 end (000) Staff # 55 88 117 192 241 248 62
Slide 63: With focus on profitability
With focus on profitability UNDERWRITING RESULTS BASE RATE PREMIUM INCREASES (on an UWY basis) (in each 6 month period) 181% 134% 98% 83% 14% 10% 83% 1% 51% 2009 (H2) 2010 (H1) ‐5% CR LR ER H2 08 H1 09 H2 09 H1 10 GROSS ANCILLARY CONTRIBUTION €33 €36 2009 H1 10 63
Slide 64: Aiming to turn Italian challenges into our strengths
Aiming to turn Italian challenges into our strengths g Challenge Advantage of being part of Admiral Group While traditional insurers are fighting … we have a deep knowledge of this business Aggregators aggregators and directs are getting in the group experience…. Bersani law and direct indemnity … w
Slide 65: Summary
Summary A pretty good start, at just over 2 years old: 2009 H1 10 Active vehicles at period end 35.500 57.900 Total written premium (6 months) n/a €14.5m Total written premium (12 months) €12.5m €22.4m Loss ratio - underwriting year (at period end) 98% 83% Written expense ratio 83% 51% Combined rati
Slide 66: Q&A
BEC rierezzon a Conle.it SE ® Admiral Group plc UK | ¢ I Q&A 66
Slide 67: Appendices
Appendices 67
Slide 68: UK Market – in 2009 the UK market experienced a peak of pain
UK Market – in 2009 the UK market experienced a “peak of pain” UK private motor market profitability 130 123 120 122 120 AY Combined Raatio (% Premiium) 114 110 110 102 99 100 91 90 88 80 82 70 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 AY COR reported (net releases)* AY COR reported less ancillary income & i
Slide 69: So what about Admiral? Combined ratio outperformance has increased
So what about Admiral? We’ve not seen as much “pain”, our combined ratio outperformance has increased Expense ratio advantage (%) Loss ratio advantage (%) 94 29 30 29 87 89 27 27 28 29 27 80 71 73 69 68 72 72 74 72 71 16 16 17 17 17 15 15 15 15 64 57 52 50 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 H1
Slide 70: UK car insurance: reserving
UK car insurance: reserving Loss ratio development by underwriting year 90 89 88 85 87 84 82 84 79 9 79 80 79 76 78 73 75 75 74 70 72 69 67 70 65 67 63 60 56 57 59 54 58 53 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 H1 10 Underwriting Year 2003 Accounts 2004 Accounts 2005 Accounts 2006 Accounts 2007 Account
Slide 71: Summary income statement
Summary income statement UK car insurance Price comparison Non‐UK car insurance Other Admiral Group H1 08 H1 09 H1 10 H1 08 H1 09 H1 10 H1 08 H1 09 H1 10 H1 08 H1 09 H1 10 H1 08 H1 09 H1 10 Turnover 407.2 470.1 639.3 36.6 40.2 38.0 14.7 24.5 37.2 4.9 5.3 6.0 463.5 540.1 720.5 Total premiums written
Slide 72: Balance sheet
Balance sheet June 09 Dec 09 June 10 £m £m £m ASSETS p y, p Property, plant and equipment q p 11.5 12.1 11.7 Intangible assets 78.2 77.0 79.1 Financial assets 688.2 630.9 827.7 Reinsurance contracts 195.7 212.9 283.0 Deferred income tax 0.0 0.0 1.2 Trade and other receivables 36.2 32.7 45.9 Cash and
Slide 73: Admiral Group key performance indicators
Admiral Group key performance indicators KPI 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 H1 08 H1 09 H1 10 Revenue £m 540 627 698 808 910 1,077 463 540 721 ancial Group Fina Customers 1,040,700 1,141,000 1,284,700 1,490,800 1,745,800 2,076,000 1,629,500 1,921,500 2,372,500 Group pre‐tax profit £m 98.1 119.5 147.3
Slide 74: Disclaimer notice
Disclaimer notice The information contained in this document has not been independently verified and no representation or warranty, express or implied is made as to, implied, to and no reliance should be placed on, on the fairness, fairness accuracy, accuracy completeness or correctness of the infor
Admiral Group — Investor Presentation (November 2010) on 6ix