Alliance Semiconductor — Proxy Contest (September 2005)
28 slides from Alliance Semiconductor's proxy contest presentation, Sep 29, 2005
Slide 1: Alliance Semiconductor Corp. (ALSC) Institutional Shareholder Services Presentation
Alliance Semiconductor Corp. (ALSC) September 28, 2005 Institutional Shareholder Services Presentation Presentation Presentation
Slide 2: Table of Contents
Table of Contents Overview & Key Issues Current Operating and Financial Strategies Our Objective: Value Enhancement Historical Timeline History of Overpromising and Underperforming Corporate Governance Deficiency Notable Conflicts Business Evaluation Recap of Operating Performance Lackluster Operati
Slide 3: Overview & Key Issues
Overview & Key Issues
Slide 4: Our Objective: Value Enhancement
Our Objective: Value Enhancement Evaluate ALSC's operating business and investments with mandate to return maximum value, either through cash or equity distributions to shareholders or significant share repurchases Strengthen management team with addition of an identified seasoned operator with a pr
Slide 5: Historical Timeline
Historical Timeline Historical Timeline Feb '85 ALSC is founded by Damodar & CN Reddy Mar '91 Files for bankruptcy 1994 Raises $18.6MM in IPO Stock Price (Split-Adjusted) 1995 $10MM investment in Chartered Semi guarantees access to wafer production $109MM Follow-on offering; insiders net $13MM Enter
Slide 6: History of Overpromising and Underperforming
History of Overpromising and Underperforming April 30, 2002 - The company announced a number of cost cutting measurements to reduce expenses, including salary reduction for 15% of all vice presidents above starting October 1, 2001. By April 30, 2002 or six months later the company ended the the redu
Slide 7: Corporate Governance Deficiency
Corporate Governance Deficiency Questionable Independence of the Board Asset Mismanagement - Over a 5 year period, the Board sunk roughly $195MM in ALSC's operating business. Investments are systematically liquidated to support a failing business when, in our opinion, that capital should have been d
Slide 8: Notable Conflicts
Notable Conflicts ALSC Director Sandy Kane was the Chairman and CEO of Tower Semiconductor from 1993 to 1995. Between 2001 and 2004, ALSC made $79M in investments in Tower which resulted in a current loss of $65M. Dan Reddy has been on the board of Tower Semiconductor since 2001. ALSC Director Greg
Slide 9: Business Evaluation
Business Evaluation
Slide 10: Recap of Operating Performance - FY '95 to FY '05
Recap of Operating Performance - FY '95 to FY '05 ALSC has not recorded a full year of operating income since FY 2000, when it reported just $300k of income Net operating loss since FY 1995 = $275MM Inventory charges exceeding $200M since FY 1996. Operating margin has been negative since FY 1999, re
Slide 11: Lackluster Operating Performance and Resulting Stock Price
Lackluster Operating Performance and Resulting Stock Price In Millions, except per share data FY '01 FY '02 FY '03 FY '04 FY '05 ALSC 5 Yr. CAGR Peer Group Average 5 Yr. CAGR Net Sales $208.7 $26.5 $18.5 $26.7 $23.6 -35% -4% Gross Profit 20.8 (47.4) (21.2) 5.8 (2.6) -166% -7% Op. Exp. 33.5 30.8 40.7
Slide 12: ALSC Lacks Scale in Each of its Operating Units
ALSC Lacks Scale in Each of its 3 Operating Units FY '05 Revenue $11.8 Million $7.7 Million $4.5 Million '05e Market Size $2.7 Billion $10.7 Billion $1.6 Billion ALSC's Estimated Market Share 0.4% 0.07% 0.28% 13 Memory ("The Past") Analog/Mixed Signals ("The Future") System Solutions ("The Future")
Slide 13: Time to Stop Funding Losses by Liquidating Assets
Time to Stop Funding Losses by Liquidating Assets Between FY '01 and FY '05, ALSC received proceeds of over $410MM from the liquidation of marketable securities and from the sale of interests in AVM & Solar investees: The equivalent of half of these proceeds went into supporting ALSC's operating bus
Slide 14: Time to Stop Funding Losses by Liquidating Assets
Time to Stop Funding Losses by Liquidating Assets Operating Losses ($MM) Cash Proceeds from Liquidation of UMC Shares ($MM) Business Evaluation
Slide 15: Why We Believe a Turnaround is Unfeasible
Why We Believe a Turnaround is Unfeasible... The Memory business operates under a rigid cost structure, putting ALSC at a competitive disadvantage in a declining SRAM market Given its small size and fabless model, dedicated foundries will likely be reluctant to work with ALSC in migrating the compan
Slide 16: Investment Portfolio
Investment Portfolio
Slide 17: Marked to Market Analysis of Investment Portfolio
Marked to Market Analysis of Investment Portfolio Investment Portfolio Portfolio Portfolio ALSC shares trade at a 27% discount to net cash & investments. Clearly, the market is voting against a possible turnaround.
Slide 18: Alliance Venture Management
Investment Portfolio Alliance Venture Management In October 1999, ALSC formed Alliance Venture Management to manage and act as general partner of its investment funds. Subsequently, the company forms three VC investment vehicles, Alliance Ventures I, II, and III, respectively. Alliance Venture Manag
Slide 19: Alliance Venture Management - Key Holdings
Alliance Venture Management - Key Holdings AVM is carried on the books at roughly $24MM but we believe it is worth well in excess of that Total Backing AVM Ownership Estimated Post-Money Valuation Estimated Value of AVM Stake Comments Xceive $28MM in 3 Rounds 38.1% $60MM $23MM Raised $13.5MM in late
Slide 20: Maximizing What is Left
Maximizing What is Left Over the last five years, the Board has kept ALSC's operating business on life support by liquidating investments. Rather than expend further capital in the operating business, we believe capital should be returned to shareholders by: Likely selling the operating business Dis
Slide 21: Biographies of Proposed Board Members: Bob D'Agostino
Biographies of Proposed Board Members Bob D'Agostino Bob D'Agostino, 38, has served as President of Q-mation since 1999. Q- mation is a leading supplier of software solutions targeted at increasing operational efficiencies and asset performance in large manufacturing companies. Joining Q-mation in 1
Slide 22: Biographies of Proposed Board Members: J. Michael Gullard
Biographies of Proposed Board Members J. Michael Gullard J. Michael Gullard, 60, has served since 1984 as a general partner of Cornerstone Management, a venture capital and consulting firm that provides strategic focus and direction for technology companies primarily in the software and data communi
Slide 23: Biographies of Proposed Board Members: Alan B. Howe
Biographies of Proposed Board Members Alan B. Howe Alan Howe, 44, has extensive operational expertise combined with 20 years of corporate finance and business development experience. Mr. Howe is currently a Vice President of Business Development for Covad Communications, focused on wireless last mil
Slide 24: C.N. Reddy
C.N. Reddy C.N. Reddy, 49, is the co-founder of Alliance Semiconductor and has served as a director of Alliance Semiconductor since the company's inception in February 1985. Mr. Reddy served as Secretary to Alliance Semiconductor from February 1985 to October 2000. Beginning in February 1985, Mr. Re
Slide 25: Biographies of Proposed Board Members: Bryant R. Riley
Biographies of Proposed Board Members Bryant R. Riley Bryant Riley, 38, is both founder and Chairman of B. Riley and Company, LLC. B. Riley & Co. is a Southern California based brokerage firm providing research and trading ideas primarily to institutional investors. Founded in 1997, B. Riley & Co. a
Slide 26: Track Record
Track Record 29 Celeritek (CLTK) Established position Oct. 2001 at $6/share; CLTK had $8.70/share in cash After repeated attempts to motivate a disinterested Board to consider change, we called for a special meeting to vote in an alternative Board Replaced half the Board in 2003 Evaluated business,
Slide 27: Summary
Summary The current Board's corporate governance policies are detrimental to shareholders ALSC's operating business is too small to make sense as a stand- alone concern Enough of the Company's resources have been wasted to artificially keep the operating business alive; further investment is not war
Slide 28: Sources of Statistical & Related Data
Sources of Statistical & Related Data Slide 6: Dates referenced in chronological order: Feb '95; Mar '91; Nov '93; Oct '94; Feb '95; Mar 28 '95; Jul '95; Dec '95; Jan 18 '96; Mar '96; Jun '99; Oct '99; Jan '00; Feb '00; Aug '00; Oct '01; Mar '02; May '04 Slide 7: Money sunk in operating business ref
Alliance Semiconductor — Proxy Contest (September 2005) on 6ix