Equal Energy — Proxy Contest (April 2014)
21 slides from Equal Energy's proxy contest presentation, Apr 11, 2014
Slide 1: Proposal to Maximize Shareholder Value
Proposal to Maximize Shareholder Value Montclair Energy, LLC April 11, 2014
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Montclair Energy, LLC 1 Disclaimer This presentation is the property of Montclair Energy, LLC (“Montclair”) and is for discussion and general informational purp ose s only. While the opinions and projections within this presentation are not those of Equal Energy Ltd. (the “Company”, “Equal” or “EQU”
Slide 3: Introduction to Montclair
Montclair Energy, LLC 2 Introduction to Montclair ▪ Overview – Montclair Energy is an independent oil and gas exploration and production company (“E&P”) operating in central Oklahoma led by William Cobb “Chip” Hazelrig and Frederick G. Wedell (jointly, the “Principals”) ▪ Experience of Principals –
Slide 4: The Case for Opposition to the Petroflow Transaction
Montclair Energy, LLC 3 The Case for Opposition to the Petroflow Transaction Montclair believes the Petroflow Transaction significantly undervalues Equal ▪ Inadequate Value to Shareholders – The Petroflow Transaction significantly undervalues Equal relative to the peer group based on multiple valuat
Slide 5: The Case for Opposition to the Petroflow Transaction, Cont.
Montclair Energy, LLC 4 The Case for Opposition to the Petroflow Transaction, Cont. ▪ Leveraged Recap Should b e Worth $7.01 (1) - $9.97 (2) per share – We estimate a conservative leveraged recap in which the company borrows money, repurchases shares and improves operations to deliver a post - recap
Slide 6: Refined Peer Group Selection
Montclair Energy, LLC 5 Refined Peer Group Selection Equal is a Hunton “pure play” and, given the unique characteristics of the formation, requires a refined peer group to conduct a proper comparable company analysis ▪ Montclair believes a peer group comprised of Approach Resources, Gastar Explorati
Slide 7: Production and Reserve-Based Valuation Metrics
Montclair Energy, LLC 6 Production and Reserve - Based Valuation Metrics ▪ Montclair believes that production and reserve - based metrics are a more meaningful proxy for value than TEV/EBITDA and P/E multiples ▪ TEV/EBITDA and P/E multiples may understate Equal’s value due to Equal management’s inab
Slide 8: Financial Valuation Metrics
Montclair Energy, LLC 7 Financial Valuation Metrics Footnotes: (1) Refer to p. 45 of 12/31/13 EQU Proxy Statement (2) Refer to p. 18 - 19 for financial and production/reserve valuation metrics of the peer group; note that these amounts include pro forma adjustments to TEV derived from company filing
Slide 9: Financial Valuation Metrics, Cont.
Montclair Energy, LLC 8 Financial Valuation Metrics, Cont. Footnotes: (1) Refer to p. 18 - 19 for financial and production/reserve valuation metrics of the peer group (2) Petroflow Transaction P/E calculated using $5.43 offer and 2013 EQU normalized EPS of $0.25; r efer to p. 17 for 2013 EQU normali
Slide 10: Peer Group Share Price Improvement Since Transaction Agreed To
Montclair Energy, LLC 9 Peer Group Share Price Improvement Since Transaction Agreed To ▪ Equal’s decision on 10/6/13 to enter into a transaction with Petroflow including a $5.43 offer price, effectively created a ceiling on the share price – Since that time, share prices of the peer group have incre
Slide 11: Commodity Price Improvement
Montclair Energy, LLC 10 Commodity Price Improvement ▪ Natural gas and NGL prices have steadily improved since the Petroflow Transaction was announced in early December – Current 2014 Henry Hub natural gas strip prices are 11.9% higher than the estimates within the proxy statement ▪ As illustrated b
Slide 12: Operational Improvements
Montclair Energy, LLC 11 Operational Improvements ▪ Equal’s cost structure is unfavorable relative to the peer group and Montclair believes substantial savings opportunities exi st – Equal’s normalized SG&A as a % of revenue of 18% is 27% higher than the peer group median ▪ Normalized SG&A expenses
Slide 13: Leveraged Recapitalization Maximizes Shareholder Value
Montclair Energy, LLC Leveraged Recapitalization Maximizes Shareholder Value 12 ▪ Operating improvements to yield $2.5 million in incremental annual EBITDA ▪ $105 million share repurchase funded using Equal’s cash of $16 million and a $92 million revolver draw less $2 million in estimated transactio
Slide 14: Levered Share Repurchase
Montclair Energy, LLC 13 Levered Share Repurchase ▪ Montclair fundamentally disagrees with management’s capital allocation policy and underutilization of an attractively - priced cre dit facility Existing $125 million credit facility priced at L+200 - 350 bps is undrawn Given Equal’s recent reserve
Slide 15: Levered Share Repurchase, Cont.
Montclair Energy, LLC 14 Levered Share Repurchase, Cont. ▪ Montclair believes a levered share repurchase would deliver incremental value to shareholders versus the Petroflow Transaction – The proposed share repurchase price of $6.00 represents a 10.5% premium to the Petroflow Transaction per share o
Slide 16: Conclusion
Montclair Energy, LLC 15 Conclusion ▪ The Petroflow Transaction Significantly Undervalues EQU – Depending upon the valuation metric, the Petroflow offer represents a discount ranging from 34% - 62% versus the peer group – The Petroflow offer, when viewed in the context of reserve and production-base
Slide 17: Appendix: 2013 EBITDA Calculations
Montclair Energy, LLC 16 Appendix: 2013 EBITDA Calculations Footnotes: (1) EQU non - recurring G&A and severance costs represent costs associated with the Special Committee, resolution of certain litigation issues, shutdown of Calgary operation and headquarter relocation to Oklahoma City; refer to p
Slide 18: Appendix: 2013 Normalized EPS Calculations
Montclair Energy, LLC 17 Appendix: 2013 Normalized EPS Calculations Footnotes: (1) Amounts provided within Company filings (2) Refer to p. 16 for calculation of EQU, GST and NSLP non - recurring G&A and severance costs; note that PQ non - recurring G&A and severance costs represent acquisition costs
Slide 19: Appendix: Financial Valuation Metrics of Comps
Montclair Energy, LLC 18 Appendix: Financial Valuation Metrics of Comps Footnotes: (1) Source: CapitalIQ , share prices as of 4/2/14 (2) GST net debt based on 12/31/13 total debt of $325 million which includes $12 million of original issue discounts; refer to 1 2/3 1/13 10K (3) NSLP PF 12/31/13 net
Slide 20: Appendix: Production/Reserve Valuation Metrics of Comps
Montclair Energy, LLC 19 Appendix: Production/Reserve Valuation Metrics of Comps Footnotes: (1) AREX 4 Q13 daily production volume from 8K dated 2/13/14; proved reserve volume and PV - 10 provided within 12/31/13 10K (2) GST 4Q13 daily production volume from 8K dated 3/13/14; proved reserve volume a
Slide 21: Appendix: PF Analysis Assumptions
Montclair Energy, LLC 20 Appendix: PF Analysis Assumptions PF Analysis Assumptions Category Model Assumption Driver Tender Offer $105 million tender offer at $6.00 per share resulting in 17,500,00 shares repurchased Shares Outstanding Before Tender Offer Revolving Credit Facility Upsized facility of