NorthWestern Energy Group, Inc. · NASDAQ:NWE

NorthWestern Energy — Technical Presentation (October 2021)

25 slides from NorthWestern Energy's technical presentation, Oct 18, 2021

  1. Slide 1: Price Forecasting Methods

    Price Forecasting Methods October 18, 2021 1

  2. Slide 2: Outline

    Outline • Methodology for forecasting prices • Results of 2020 Forecast (2021 Forecast in progress) • Scenarios o High Electrification o Carbon Pricing 2

  3. Slide 3: Methodology

    A n Analytics Better models. Better decisions. g a <x

  4. Slide 4: Ascend's Forecasting Philosophy

    Ascend’s Forecasting Philosophy • Don’t argue with markets o If your forecast (or forecasting consultant) thinks the forward market is wrong, you should invest immediately or get a new forecast • Don’t argue with long-run equilibrium o Out-of-market profit opportunities won’t continue indefinitely o

  5. Slide 5: Forecasting Process Inputs

    Forecasting Process Inputs Supply Stack Projection Forward Price Curve Price Volatility / Shapes Energy and Capacity Historical power and Simulated Renewable Mix gas prices Generation Tx Interconnection Forward market Renewable gen effect Queue prices on volatility Announced Energy storage effect Re

  6. Slide 6: Economics is not the whole story with future supply

    Economics is not the whole story with future supply • The ESG Trajectory: o Large companies increasingly pursuing renewable energy (e.g. Google, Amazon, Facebook) o Customer demand for renewables is driving behind-the-meter installations • The Policy Trajectory: o States are not likely to relax clea

  7. Slide 7: Forecasting Supply Stacks

    Forecasting Supply Stacks • Renewables are increasingly the least cost source of energy (but not capacity) o Most new resources will be renewables and storage • Economics are not the only driving force for renewable buildout o Future policy, off taker demand, and stakeholder pressure -> more renewab

  8. Slide 8: Supply Projection Details

    Supply Projection Details • Ascend’s is updating its assessment of the supply forecast for the region o IRP document reviews o Regional reports (NWPCC, PNUCC, NWPP, etc.) o Model updates • Capacity may be tight in the near term due to fossil fuel retirements • High clean energy requirements in WA an

  9. Slide 9: Long-run Equilibrium

    Long-run Equilibrium • Power prices must sustain new supply resources in the long run, BECAUSE: o If prices are too low  supply will not get built (until prices rise) o If prices are too high  more resources will enter, driving down prices o Long run: quantity of resources will be built so as not

  10. Slide 10: Forecasting Market Conditions

    Forecasting Market Conditions • Supply mix is fundamentally changing; forecasts must account for the impacts of high renewable penetration on price behavior • A base forecast should align to the best expectation of future conditions (rather than continuation of the status quo) • Forecasts should adh

  11. Slide 11: Challenges with Mid-C price forecasts

    Challenges with Mid-C price forecasts • Market data on Mid-C is scarce compared to ISO/RTO regions (who have hourly data on renewables, ancillary prices, system load, etc.) • Hydro power dominates the PNW  high levels of seasonal and annual uncertainty (dry years vs wet years) • Resource adequacy n

  12. Slide 12: Pacific Northwest Supply

    Pacific Northwest Supply • Demand side management (DR and EE) expected to play a large role in meeting carbon targets o NWPCC estimates high DR potential in the region (>2.7 GW) o Utility IRP documents plan for more aggressive push with EE and DR • Coal generation is low and declining quickly o Wash

  13. Slide 13: 2020 Forecast Results

    Forecast Results 4 Asce Better models. Better decisions.

  14. Slide 14: Ascend 2020 Forecasts – Power Prices

    Ascend 2020 Forecasts – Power Prices • Mid-C prices projected to decline slightly in nominal dollars o Prices adjusted for inflation decline more substantially • Expected growth in renewables is primary driver of the decline o Growth in renewables driven by utilities’ plans, state policies in OR and

  15. Slide 15: Ascend Current Forecasts – Price Shapes (2020 Vintage)

    Ascend Current Forecasts – Price Shapes (2020 Vintage) • Price shapes in the 2020 forecast were expected to become more pronounced in February and August with flatter profiles in spring and fall months o Price shapes are determined by net load profiles (load minus renewable gen) o Future load profil

  16. Slide 16: Ascend Current Forecasts – Price Volatility (2020 Vintage)

    Ascend Current Forecasts – Price Volatility (2020 Vintage) • Price volatility projected to grow modestly until the mid 2030s then level off o Renewable growth  increase volatility o Energy storage  decreases volatility • Recently, volatility is highest in May and June • Flexible generation will pr

  17. Slide 17: More Details

    A n Analytics Better models. Better decisions. g a <x More Details

  18. Slide 18: Price Depression with Increasing Renewables Occurs Across Markets

    Price Depression with Increasing Renewables Occurs Across Markets Across all markets with substantial renewable penetrations, prices are negatively correlated with renewable generation in both the DA and RT markets. With large amounts of renewables in the queues, these price dynamics are expected to

  19. Slide 19: Curtailed Power Becomes Increasingly Common at High Penetration

    Curtailed Power Becomes Increasingly Common at High Penetration Curtailment and negative prices are becoming more frequent, with weather uncertainty and operational constraints causing curtailment at much lower penetrations than predicted by many production cost models. These price dynamics will spr

  20. Slide 20: Renewables affect daily price shapes

    Renewables affect daily price shapes • Renewable growth in CAISO has pushed mid-day prices down while keeping prices higher in the evenings. • Ascend’s forecasts are consistent with historical trends in regions with high renewable growth rates • The Pacific Northwest will have different prices shape

  21. Slide 21: Price Volatility Increases with Renewable Penetration

    Price Volatility Increases with Renewable Penetration • Renewables add volatility to the amount of generation in the system • Generation swings from wind and solar cause shifts in the supply stack  price volatility ERCOT CAISO Renewable DA Price RT Price Renewable DA Price RT Price Year Share of Ge

  22. Slide 22: Real Time Price Volatility Increases with Renewable Penetration

    Real Time Price Volatility Increases with Renewable Penetration Real-time price volatility tends to be short in duration, generating value for flexible resources that hourly models do not capture. This volatility grows as intermittent renewables provide an increasing share of supply. 22

  23. Slide 23: Scenarios

    A n Analytics Better models. Better decisions. g a <x

  24. Slide 24: Price Scenario – High Electrification

    Price Scenario – High Electrification • A high electrification scenario requires a re-run of the price forecast models with a higher load forecast o High load means more resources are required to meet load o Supply stacks will adjust in the capacity expansion phase o Load will follow a different mod

  25. Slide 25: Price Scenario – Carbon Prices

    Price Scenario – Carbon Prices • Carbon prices increase dispatch costs for thermal generators which increases the cost of power • Ascend applied the carbon price used in previous PSC dockets and the 2019 plan o Carbon prices begin in 2025 at $20 per ton ramping up to $40 per ton by 2042 • PowerSimm

NorthWestern Energy Group — Technical Presentation (October 2021) on 6ix