Forest Laboratories — Proxy Contest (July 2012)
10 slides from Forest Laboratories's proxy contest presentation, Jul 26, 2012
Slide 1: Icahn Responds to Forest Management Presentation
Icahn Responds to Forest Management Presentation
Slide 2: Forest's Management & Board Have Presided Over a Massive Destruction of Shareholder Value
Forest’s Management & Board Have Presided Over a Massive Destruction of Shareholder Value • Forest states on Page 1 of its investor presentation that it has “ a track record of delivering on commitments to build shareholder value ” • But, we believe in reality they have a long track record of destro
Slide 3: We Believe 20 Year Stock Chart Distorts True Underperformance
We Believe 20 Year Stock Chart Distorts True Underperformance • On Page 4 of its investor presentation, Forest shows a 20 year stock chart and states it has had a “ strengthening stock price ” • Unfortunately, for most investors who have not owned the stock for the last 20 years, Forest’s stock has
Slide 4: Distorting Our Point Related to Achieving Its Cost of Capital
Distorting Our Point Related to Achieving Its Cost of Capital • On page 21 of Forest’s investor presentation, the company states that “Mr. Icahn created a misleading chart” • Management is taking the chart out of context and attempting to confuse investors • The chart being referenced from the Appen
Slide 5: Distorting the Facts on Compensation vs. Its Proxy Peers
Distorting the Facts on Compensation vs. Its Proxy Peers • On slide 28 of its presentation, management purportedly compared CEO compensation to its proxy peers • However, the proxy peers it used in the analysis are NOT the same proxy peers it lists in its 2012 proxy statement • We believe it used la
Slide 6: We Believe Corporate Governance Remains A Problem Because of Only Cosmetic Changes
We Believe Corporate Governance Remains A Problem Because of Only Cosmetic Changes Actions Cited By Forest Since Last Meeting Reason We Question Actions Added new independent directors While three new directors were added, after we commenced our proxy contest, we believe that Solomon’s “inner circle
Slide 7: New Products Have Been Underperforming Company Guidance
New Products Have Been Underperforming Company Guidance • In slide 10 of its presentation, management shows the growth trajectory of older products, but fails to share that newer products have missed company guidance 8 of 11 times • Because of weaker than expected launches, we are concerned that new
Slide 8: Where is the Operating Leverage?
Where is the Operating Leverage? • On slides 12 & 13 of its presentation, management discusses “significant operating leverage from cross - promoting multiple products to PCPs” • But, analysts expect operating margins to deteriorate from 33.3% in FY 11 to 6.9% in FY13 and expect them to remain depre
Slide 9: We Believe Extremely Optimistic Growth Goals Set By Management Are Unlikely to Be Achieved
We Believe Extremely Optimistic Growth Goals Set By Management Are Unlikely to Be Achieved • On slide 16 of its presentation, management states its growth goals from FY13 to FY18, which we believe are overly optimistic and self - serving • Based on the company’s stated “growth goals,” it is expectin
Slide 10: Vote the GOLD Proxy Card
Vote the GOLD Proxy Card