Pennichuck — Merger or Acquisition (April 2011)
25 slides from Pennichuck's merger presentation, Apr 29, 2011
Slide 1: Settlement of Eminent Domain Dispute with City of Nashua
Pennichuck Corporation NENAWC Presentation Settlement of Eminent Domain Dispute with City of Nashua April 29, 2011
Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements
Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may contain forward-looking statements with respect to the business of Pennichuck Corporation and the merger agreement between the Company and the City of Nashua, New Hampshire. Forward-looking statements are based on current information and expectations
Slide 3: Additional Information and Where to Find It
Additional Information and Where to Find It The Company filed with the SEC on April 22, 2011 a definitive proxy statement regarding the special meeting of shareholders that will be held on June 15, 2011 to consider and vote on the merger agreement. The definitive proxy statement contains important i
Slide 4: Pennichuck Corporation operating subsidiaries
Pennichuck Corporation 5 operating subsidiaries - Pennichuck Water (PWW) - water utility Pennichuck East (PEU) - water utility Pittsfield Aqueduct (PAC) - water utility Pennichuck Water Service Co. (PWSC) - water services The Southwood Corporation - real estate PWW has been the "eminent domain" targ
Slide 5: Pennichuck Water (PWW)
Pennichuck Water (PWW) Serves City of Nashua and 11 surrounding communities Comprises about 75% of our revenues and assets ...PWW constitutes lion's share of our entire business.
Slide 6: Looking Back
Looking Back 2002 - Company announced plan to be acquired by Philadelphia Suburban (now Aqua America) 2002 - City initiated "eminent domain" condemnation proceedings 2003 - Planned sale to Philly Suburban abandoned 2006 - We advised City that any "negotiated settlement" should be structured as a PNN
Slide 7: July 2008 - PUC Issues Eminent Domain Order
July 2008 - PUC Issues Eminent Domain Order By vote of 2:1, Nashua can "take" PWW assets for $203 million Dissenting Commissioner (Below) valued assets at $151 million Nashua must also pay $40 million into "mitigation fund" because separating PWW from PEU and PAC Therefore, Nashua must pay $243 mill
Slide 8: Nashua Not Happy With PUC Order
Nashua Not Happy With PUC Order Liked form of transaction (asset purchase), but... $243+ million too much to pay Especially since would not be getting the undeveloped land it wants ...$40 million mitigation fund determinative?
Slide 9: PNNW View of PUC Order
PNNW View of PUC Order $243 million a lot of money, but... $40 million mitigation fund not go to our shareholders Asset sale by PWW would trigger ~ $50 million income tax at corporate level Deferral of tax via like-kind reinvestment not generally feasible Would likely wind up and liquidate the entir
Slide 10: Both Parties Appealed to NH Supreme Court
Both Parties Appealed to NH Supreme Court City's appeal aimed at getting total cost reduced argued Commissioner Below got it right We appealed "public interest" determination 3/25/10 - Court unanimously affirmed PUC order in its entirety Neither party requested rehearing Decision final as of 4/7/10
Slide 11: Parties Agree to PNNW Stock Sale via Merger
11/11/10 - Parties Agree to PNNW Stock Sale via Merger Nashua to buy all common stock of PNNW $29.00 per share, or $138 million, in cash (~$200 mil EV) Nashua to become sole stockholder of PNNW (2007 legislation) All three utilities kept together and regulated by PUC Existing personnel to run PNNW b
Slide 12: From Bad Deal to Good Deal for Both: Key Factors
From Bad Deal to Good Deal for Both: Key Factors No $50 million corporate-level tax effectively charged to PNNW shareholders No $40 million mitigation reserve funded by Nashua since three utilities staying together
Slide 13: $29.00 Per Share for Pennichuck Stockholders
$29.00 Per Share for Pennichuck Stockholders (Financial Metrics) 2.4X book value 46% premium over implied trading price (i.e., without acquisition premium) 38% premium over recent stock issue 34X trailing four quarters earnings (adjusted for non-operating eminent domain-related costs)
Slide 14: Additional PNNW Considerations
Additional PNNW Considerations Time it would take to organically grow trading price to $29.00 Risks and uncertainties of accelerating growth by utility acquisitions Avoids future eminent domain risk in aftermath of Supreme Court decision Acquisition interest in PNNW and valuation by other IOU's infl
Slide 15: Observations Regarding Nashua
Observations Regarding Nashua Gains control over water system and watershed land it wants Pays less for more assets vs. eminent domain taking $138 million + assumed debt = ~$200 million no $40 million mitigation reserve get land and other four subsidiaries in the transaction But, tax law affects str
Slide 16: Remaining Closing Conditions & Time Line
Remaining Closing Conditions & Time Line Two-thirds majority vote of PNNW shareholders (June 2011) PUC approval without "burdensome conditions" (e.g., allowed rates inadequate to service bonds) Financing completed after other conditions met Closing in late Q4 2011 ...a true win-win outcome for PNNW,
Slide 17: NHPUC Approval Process
NHPUC Approval Process PENNICHUCK
Slide 18: Operating Plan Goal
Operating Plan Goal Develop an operating plan that meets the needs of all stakeholders City of Nashua Communities Customer Employees Investors Regulators
Slide 19: Operating Models Considered by Nashua: Eminent Domain Model
Operating Models Considered by Nashua Eminent Domain Model Own only PWW. PWW operated by third party contractor Oversight of third party contractor by Engineering firm Operate as regulated municipal entity Sell PWSC, PAC and PEU Loss of Operating Efficiencies Could not sell for purchase premium Mana
Slide 20: Operating Models Considered by Nashua: Plug and Play Model
Operating Models Considered by Nashua Plug and Play Model Maintain current Corporate structure but privately owned Eliminates SEC and other costs estimated at $1.7 million Allows use of 100% debt financing Maintains essentially all of the operating employees Same employees doing same jobs No loss of
Slide 21: Meeting Stakeholder Needs
Meeting Stakeholder Needs Customer Needs Lower rates with same service Independent arbitrator when disagreements arise Decisions based on customer needs, not politics All existing contracts honored City of Nashua Needs Rate treatment that insures cash flow required to pay debt service and retirement
Slide 22: Meeting Stakeholder Needs
Meeting Stakeholder Needs Regulator Needs No loss in operating efficiencies Same level of service Proof of lower revenue requirement Conventional Rate making methodology Except for Fixed Revenue Bond Requirement and Rate Stabilization Fund. Employee Needs Job security Job support Investors Proposed
Slide 23: Elements of Proposed Acquisition Rate Making Model
Elements of Proposed Acquisition Rate Making Model Fixed Revenue Requirement - 30 year fixed rate for city bond principal and interest Replaces Equity Rate Stabilization Fund - $5 million booked as equity and recognized in rate base - to enable the utilities to meet the city bond obligation due to a
Slide 24: Rate Comparisons
Rate Comparisons Pennichuck Water Works City Revenue Requirement based on Bond rate of 6.5% City Revenue Requirement based on Bond rate of 6.5% City Revenue Requirement based on Bond rate of 6.5% Required PWW Rates w/ recovery of Eminent Domain Expenses - $ 28,858,834 $27,244,453 PWW rates are based
Slide 25: Disclaimer
Disclaimer It is not possible to predict whether all the approvals, contingencies and other conditions precedent to closing will be obtained, resolved or satisfied, as applicable, and therefore if and when the transaction will close.