Airgas — Proxy Contest (July 2010)
35 slides from Airgas's proxy contest presentation, Jul 21, 2010
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement - Airgas, Inc.
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ¨ Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy
Slide 2: It's All About Value
It’s All About Value July 21, 2010
Slide 3: Forward-Looking Statements
FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS This presentation contains statements that are forward looking. Forward-looking statements include the statements identified as forward- looking in the Company’s press release announcing its quarterly earnings, as well as any statement that is not based on historical fact,
Slide 4: Airgas Has Consistently Created Shareholder Value
Airgas Has Consistently Created Shareholder Value… Absolute Total Shareholder Return 4,201% Since Airgas’ IPO (a) Total Shareholder Return CAGR 18% Since Airgas’ IPO (a) Total Shareholder Return Since January 1, 1987 #26 highest out of 500 Ranking in S&P 500 (b) Officer and Director Stock Beneficial
Slide 5: Our Board Believes Air Products' Offer Would Deprive You of Full Value
Our Board Believes That Air Products’ Offer Would Deprive You of Full Value • Airgas’ management has a proven track record of exceptional shareholder value creation • The Airgas Board unanimously believes that Air Products’ offer grossly undervalues Airgas • We believe strongly that Airgas will gene
Slide 6: Why We Expect a Clear Path to EPS of $4.20+ by CY 2012
Why We Expect a Clear Path to EPS of $4.20+ by CY 2012… • Unfolding macro-economic recovery underpins our Same-Store Sales (“SSS”) growth of ~7% per year – Comparable to SSS growth in the prior recovery period • As SSS increase, the operating leverage inherent in Airgas business model has historical
Slide 7: What Happened in the Last Recovery?
What Happened in the Last Recovery? 18% CAGR * See attached reconciliations of non-GAAP measures. Note: “CAGR” = Compound Annual Growth Rate. 5
Slide 8: Recovery is Demonstrated in Our 1Q FY2011 Earnings
Recovery is Demonstrated in Our 1Q FY2011 Earnings Announced First Fiscal Quarter Revised Guidance EBITDA Margin* 1Q FY2011 – Adj. EPS* FY2011 – Adj. EPS* Actual 1QF11 CY12 Goal We have exceeded the high end of Strong operating momentum 1Q11 has resulted in the highest our guidance and consensus is
Slide 9: Expected Earnings Growth and Strong Cash Flow Underpin Shareholder Value
Expected Earnings Growth and Strong Cash Flow are Projected to Underpin Our Shareholder Value Creation • Five key factors drive our earnings goal of $4.20+ in CY 2012 I. Expected recovery of Same-Store Sales growth II. Demonstrated operating leverage in the business model III. Continued focus on cut
Slide 10: Projections Assume SSS Growth Comparable to the Last Expansion
I. Our Projections Assume SSS Growth Comparable to the Last Expansion Calendar Year Same-Store Sales Growth Rate 2003-2005 Avg: 6% 2010-2012 Avg: ~7% 20 % 70.0 11 % 10 % 7% 10 % 8% 6% 60.0 - 0% 50.0 (2)% 0% (10)% 40.0 (20)% (16)% 30.0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011E 2012E Non-Tech
Slide 11: SSS Growth Drives Substantial EBITDA Growth Due to Operating Leverage
II. SSS Growth Drives Substantial EBITDA* Growth Due to Operating Leverage Calendar Year Same-Store Sales Growth Rate 20 % 10 % 10 % 6% 7% 6% ~7% 0% (10)% (20)% (16)% 2003-2005 Avg 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010-2012 Avg 1 Operating Leverage Drives Improved Fall Through (Change in EBITDA* / Change in Sale
Slide 12: Operating Leverage Further Enhanced by Ongoing Cost Savings
III. Operating Leverage Expected to be Further Enhanced by Ongoing Cost Savings • Achieved original goal of aggregate $25M annual run-rate cost savings – Target announced in September 2007 – Achieved three quarters ahead of schedule in December 2009 • In December 2009, we announced incremental savin
Slide 13: Business Mix Improvement Produces Higher Margins
IV. Business Mix Improvement Produces Higher Margins 1 Last Recession CY 2009 CY 2012E Gas/Rent Gas/Rent Gas/Rent 65% 65% 55% Hardgoods 45% Hardgoods Hardgoods 35% 35% Sales $1.7B $3.9B $5.2B+ RADNOR Private Label ~7% ~12% 12-15% (% of Hardgoods Sales) Atmospheric Gas Production (% Total Atmos. Cons
Slide 14: Substantial Investments Since Last Cycle Should Generate Higher Margins
V. Substantial Investments Since Last Cycle Should Generate Higher Margins Last Recession CY‘02 CY’09 Cylinders (in millions) 5+ 10+ Bulk Tanks 6,000+ 13,500+ Substantial Investments Locations ~800 ~1,100 ASU Production Capacity (liquid tons per day) 475 6,700 ASU Capacity Utilization ~87% ~70% Goal
Slide 15: First Quarter Fiscal 2011 Already Within Range of CY 2012 EBITDA Margin
First Quarter Fiscal 2011 Already Within the Range of Our CY 2012 EBITDA Margin Goal EBITDA Margin Source: Airgas Management. * See attached reconciliations of non-GAAP measures. 13
Slide 16: On Track To Achieve CY 2012 EPS Goal
On Track To Achieve CY 2012 EPS Goal • 1H CY2010 Adjusted EPS* increased +13% vs. 1H CY2009 • 1Q FY2011 Adjusted EPS* increased +26% vs. 1Q FY2010 16% CAGR 18-23% Increase $ 3.30 to $ 3.05 to $ 3.15 $ 2.95 Source: Airgas Management. * See attached reconciliations of non-GAAP measures. 14
Slide 17: EPS Growth Consistent with Past Recoveries
As a Result, We Expect EPS Growth Consistent with Past Recoveries Calendar Year Adjusted EPS* 2002 -2005 $1.60 $1.50 $1.53 $1.40 18% CAGR $1.30 $1.20 2 Adj. EPS* $1.10 $1.00 $0.90 $0.94 $0.80 Dec -02 Dec -03 Dec -04 Dec -05 Calendar Year EPS 2009 -2012 $4.60 $4.20 $4.20+ (CY12 Goal) $3.80 16% CAGR $
Slide 18: Track Record of Meeting or Beating Mid-Term Goals
We Have a Track Record of Meeting or Beating Our “Mid-Term” Goals Case 1: FY05 Case 2: FY08 (Goals Published May 2001 Analyst Meeting) (Goals Published November 2004 Analyst Meeting) $2.4B $4.0B $476M $2.0B $200M $209M $3.0B $315M 13.2% 10.3% 11.9% 11-12% 10.0% 10.0% 10-11% 8.8% Sales Op. Profit* Op
Slide 19: Returns from Significant Recent Investments Yet to be Fully Realized
In Addition, Returns from Significant Recent Investments Yet to be Fully Realized... Total Capital Deployed ($ in millions) Since January 1, 2007 ASUs (Carrollton, New Carlisle) $ 80 SAP Implementation to Date 62 CO2 Plants 25 Capital Plant Upgrades / Consolidation 100 Expenditures Cylinders & Bulk
Slide 20: While Airgas Has Continued to Repay Debt and Build Value
...While Airgas Has Continued to Repay Debt and Build Value for Shareholders Air Products’ Initial Proposal Note: Dollars in millions. *See attached reconciliations of non-GAAP measures. 18
Slide 21: The Industrial Gas Sector has Steadily Consolidated
The Industrial Gas Sector has Steadily Consolidated… Major Industrial Gas Players in 2000 Major Industrial Gas Players in 2010 Company Company Enterprise Value ($bn) AGA Air Liquide $38 Air Liquide Praxair 31 Air Products Linde 28 Airgas Air Products 19 The BOC Group Airgas 7 Hede Nielsen Taiyo Nipp
Slide 22: Only Remaining Independent Packaged Gas Company of Scale
Airgas is the Only Remaining Independent Packaged Gas Company of Scale in the World Airgas Airgas 25% 25% ~900 ~900 Praxair PDI Independents Independents 50% 50% Matheson Tri-Gas Air Liquide Linde $12B+ $12B+ U.S. U.S. Packaged Packaged Gases Gases && Welding Welding Hardgoods Hardgoods Market Marke
Slide 23: Airgas Represents Significant Strategic Value
Airgas Represents Significant Strategic Value • As an independent company, Airgas has demonstrated a strong track record of earnings growth and stock price appreciation – Strongly positioned to grow leading share in packaged gas – Also strongly positioned to grow share in bulk gases • As a result, w
Slide 24: Timing Matters: U.S. Economic Recovery is Just Beginning
Timing Matters: U.S. Economic Recovery is Just Beginning Source: Bloomberg consensus estimates as of July 16, 2010. ¹ Data indexed to January 2006. 22
Slide 25: Air Products Concluded the Timing is Ideal
“Given that the economy is just beginning to emerge from recession, Air Products concluded that the timing is ideal...” - Air Products Schedule TO dated February 11, 2010 (deleted in Schedule 14A dated June 16, 2010) • Air Products’ proposal would amend Airgas’ bylaws to require Airgas to hold futur
Slide 26: Air Products' Proposals Haven't Kept Pace With Peer Equity Values
...But Air Products’ Proposals Haven’t Even Kept Pace With the Growth in Peer Equity Values 1 Average change in share price of Praxair, Air Liquide, and Linde between February 5, 2010, the date Air Products’ $60 proposal was made public, and July 8, 2010, the date of Air Products’ offer of $63.50. S
Slide 27: Airgas' Nominees are Keenly Aware of Their Fiduciary Duties
Airgas’ Nominees are Keenly Aware of Their Fiduciary Duties • Peter McCausland – Chairman and CEO of Airgas since 1987 – Airgas Director since 1986 IPO – Beneficial ownership of ARG nearly 8.6 million shares* 1 – 4,201% Total Shareholder Return since joining the Airgas Board • W. Thacher Brown – Cha
Slide 28: Air Products' Proposals Would Facilitate Its Grossly Inadequate Offer
We Believe Air Products’ Proposals Would Facilitate Its Grossly Inadequate Offer • While Air Products' nominees may not be controlled by Air Products, we believe their views could be colored by their relationship with Air Products • To consider strategies other than the Air Products offer, we believ
Slide 29: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 30: Reconciliation: Adjusted Operating Income and Adjusted Operating Margin
Reconciliation: Adjusted Operating Income and Adjusted Operating Margin Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2005 Sales $ 2,367,782 Operating Income 202,454 Adjustment: Acquisition integration costs 6,400 Adjusted Operating Income $ 208,854 Adjusting Operating Margin 8.8% The Company believes the above Adjus
Slide 31: Reconciliation: Return on Capital
Reconciliation: Return on Capital Fiscal Year Ended March 31, Calendar Year (In thousands) 2005 2008 2008 Operating Income - Trailing Four Quarters $ 210,454 $ 476,146 $ 541,422 Five Quarter Average of Total Assets $ 2,134,362 $ 3,708,389 $ 4,122,411 Five Quarter Average of Securitized Trade Receiva
Slide 32: Reconciliation: Adjusted EBITDA Margin
Reconciliation: Adjusted EBITDA Margin Calendar Year 2012 Target Three Months Ended Six Months Ended Low High 2009 2002 June 30, 2010 June 30, 2010 Sales $ 5,200,000 $ 5,200,000 $ 3,886,671 $ 1,714,527 $ 1,052,656 $ 2,035,964 Operating Income $ 648,000 $ 675,000 $ 432,221 $ 142,442 $ 122,751 $ 204,6
Slide 33: Reconciliation: Adjusted EBITDA Fall Through
Reconciliation: Adjusted EBITDA Fall Through Calendar Year Average Average (in thousands) 2003 to 2005 2006 2007 2008 2010E to 2012E Sales $ 2,246,184 $ 3,098,086 $ 3,792,509 $ 4,456,256 $ 4,700,000 Change in sales $ 337,518 $ 371,006 $ 694,423 $ 663,747 $ 435,000 Operating Income $ 201,877 $ 322,30
Slide 34: Reconciliation: Adjusted Earnings Per Share
Reconciliation: Adjusted Earnings Per Share (Updated Guidance) Fiscal Year Ending March 31, 2011 Three Months Ended Calendar Year Low High June 30, 2010 2009 2005 2004 2003 2002 Earnings per diluted share $ 3.08 $ 3.23 $ 0.76 $ 2.55 $ 1.48 $ 1.18 $ 1.04 $ 0.82 Adjustments: Costs related to unsolicit
Slide 35: Reconciliation: Adjusted Debt & EBITDA
Reconciliation: Adjusted Debt & EBITDA Reconciliation of Adjusted debt: June 30, December June 30, December June 30, December June 30, (In thousands) 2007 2007 2008 2008 2009 2009 2010 Current portion of long-term debt $ 41,773 $ 40,554 $ 43,458 $ 10,227 $ 11,033 $ 10,103 $ 9,589 Long-term debt, exc