Bob Evans Farms — Proxy Contest (December 2013)
32 slides from Bob Evans Farms's proxy contest presentation, Dec 9, 2013
Slide 1: Unlocking Shareholder Value at Bob Evans
Bob Evans Farms, Inc. Unlocking Shareholder Value at Bob Evans December 2013
Slide 2: Disclaimer
2 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. THIS PRESENTATION WITH RESPECT TO BOB EVANS FARMS, INC . (“BOB EVANS” OR THE “COMPANY’”) IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY . IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY OR PARTICULAR
Slide 3: Bob Evans - Restaurant Investment Landscape
3 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Bob Evans - Restaurant Investment Landscape Intense Operational Focus What Restaurant investors of today expect: Poor Restaurant Execution Focus On SSS Not Sow Costs What 2Q earnings show: What can solve this: Prudent Capital Use Poor ROIC on
Slide 4: Bob Evans – Current Valuation
4 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The following illustrates the current public market valuation of Bob Evans: Bob Evans – Current Valuation (1) Internal estimates, adjusted for 1 - time and other costs. (2) Pro - rata FY2014E and FY2015E estimates. (3) Average of analyst est
Slide 5: Bob Evans is Materially Undervalued
5 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Bob Evans is Materially Undervalued ♦ Bob Evans is trading at a discount to what we believe are the most comparable publicly - traded family - dining restaurant companies and at an even bigger discount to what we believe are the most comparabl
Slide 6: Dramatic Stock Price Under-Performance
6 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Bob Evans has dramatically under - performed its more relevant family - dining peers over every selected time period Dramatic Stock Price Under - Performance Source: Bloomberg as of 12/5/13. Family - Dining Stock Price Performance
Slide 7: Three core reasons the Company remains undervalued
7 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ We believe there are three core reasons why the Company continues to remain undervalued : 1. Conglomerate Discount – The Company suffers from a conglomerate discount as a result of the Company’s two disparate business segments, Bob Evans Res
Slide 8: Three ideas to unlock significant value
8 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ We believe there are three general ideas, with many different underlying permutations, that if properly implemented could unlock significant value for the shareholders of Bob Evans : 1. Separation of BEF Foods – We believe there are many way
Slide 9: Board has taken no action on our ideas
9 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Close to five months have elapsed since we made contact with the management of Bob Evans to discuss our ideas to enhance shareholder value and the Board has decided to take no action with respect to these ideas, nor has the Board shown willi
Slide 10: Separation of BEF Foods would not lose synergies
10 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ We are confident that a separation of BEF Foods would result in no material loss of corporate “synergies” ● Bob Evans Restaurants and BEF Foods operate independently, have separate management teams, and the Company reports each segment sepa
Slide 11: Separate BEF Foods – Historical Precedent
11 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Two of the largest food products companies in the United States had previous association with restaurant companies and took steps almost two decades ago to separate these disparate businesses ● General Mills and Darden Restaurants – In 1995
Slide 12: Separate BEF Foods – Analyst Coverage
12 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Separate BEF Foods – Analyst Coverage Bob Evans Equity Analyst Coverage (Bloomberg) Primary Firm Analyst Sector CL King Michael Gallo Restaurants Janney Montgomery Scott Mark Kalinowski Restaurants KeyBanc Christopher O'Cull Restaurants Mille
Slide 13: Separate BEF Foods – Valuation Differential
13 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. Separate BEF Foods – Valuation Differential ♦ Packaged food companies are typically afforded a higher valuation in both the public market, as well as in M&A transactions Source: Bloomberg, various analyst reports Selected Recent Transactions
Slide 14: Why packaged food trades at a premium to restaurants
14 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Why do packaged food companies typically trade at a premium to restaurants? ● The business profile of a packaged food company is very different from that of a restaurant, with many favorable characteristics that result in higher associated
Slide 15: Investors Can Diversify on Their Own
15 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The following Company exhibit illustrates the growing market share differential between restaurants and packaged food companies: Separate BEF Foods – Investors Can Diversify on Their Own ♦ Investors can make their own diversification decisi
Slide 16: Separation of BEF Foods through sale or IPO
16 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ We advocate a separation of BEF Foods through either a sale or an IPO as a precursor to a spin - off or split - off ● Sale – There has been significant M&A activity in the packaged foods space and recent private market transactions involvin
Slide 17: Substantial Real Estate Holdings
17 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The Company has expended a tremendous amount of capital for the land and buildings associated with its 482 owned Bob Evans Restaurants ● Bob Evans owns the real estate of 86% of the Company’s restaurants, all of which are expected to be rem
Slide 18: Unlock $723 million from real estate
18 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Bob Evans could unlock $723 million of value from its real estate by pursuing a sale - leaseback transaction Real Estate Sale - Leaseback – Unlock Significant Value ● Significant 3 rd party interest in pursuing a sale - leaseback transactio
Slide 19: Sale-Leaseback – Unconvincing Excuses
19 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The following statement by CEO Steven Davis is the essence of the Company’s unconvincing excuse for refusing to pursue a sale - leaseback transaction: Real Estate Sale - Leaseback – Unconvincing Excuses “We view real estate ownership as an
Slide 20: Management's desire for flexibility is misguided
20 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Management’s desire for “flexibility” is a misguided and unconvincing excuse for refusing to pursue a sale - leaseback transaction ● Over the last three years the Company has spent approximately $ 225 , 000 per restaurant on its “Farm Fresh
Slide 21: Sale-Leaseback – Value Creation
21 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The following compares a $ 720 million self - tender financed by additional debt or with the proceeds raised from a sale - leaseback transaction . Due to the “multiple arbitrage” that exists, repurchasing shares with the proceeds raised fro
Slide 22: Sale-Leaseback – Accretion
22 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ Due to the substantial reduction in depreciation, a $720 million self - tender financed with the proceeds raised from a sale - leaseback transaction is even more accretive than that financed by additional debt Real Estate Sale - Leaseback -
Slide 23: Accretion – Implications for Shareholder Value
23 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ As discussed on the previous page, the significant accretion that would result due to shares repurchased with proceeds raised from the incurrence of additional debt or from a sale - leaseback transaction would imply a material increase in s
Slide 24: Sale-Leaseback – Reality
24 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The Company attempts to mislead investors with exhibits similar to the following… Real Estate Sale - Leaseback – Reality ...but due to the reduction of depreciation in a sale - leaseback transaction, we believe the below exhibit better refl
Slide 25: A Reasonable and Balanced Strategy
25 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ We advocate a reasonable and balanced strategy incorporating our key ideas in order to unlock shareholder value . For illustrative purposes we suggest the following, as we view it as prudent, actionable, and completely within the control of
Slide 26: Yielding Over $80 per Share in Value
26 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ For simplicity, the following assumes a $575 million self - tender at $60 per share and full split - off of BEF Foods, with BEF Foods shares exchanged for Bob Evans shares at $60 per share Unlocking Shareholder Value – Yielding Over $80 per
Slide 27: Manageable Capital Structure
27 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The preceding transactions leave the resulting company with a very manageable capital structure Unlocking Shareholder Value – Manageable Capital Structure ♦ The Company’s pro - forma financial profile indicates a reasonable amount of levera
Slide 28: Further Potential Alternative - LBO
28 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ In addition to the preceding transactions that Bob Evans could pursue to unlock shareholder value, the Company’s unique characteristics make it a very viable LBO candidate Further Potential Alternative - LBO ● Under - levered balance sheet
Slide 29: Operational improvements after an LBO
29 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ There are numerous operational improvements that could be implemented subsequent to an LBO of the Company Further Potential Alternative – LBO (cont’d) ● Bob Evans Restaurants Re - Franchising • Develop franchise sales division within Bob Ev
Slide 30: Action is Needed - Favorable Current Environment
30 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The Company needs to take advantage of the many compelling opportunities presented by today’s environment ● Cap rates are favorable, interest rates are low, there is robust M&A activity in the packaged foods space, and the IPO market remain
Slide 31: Company has not shown willingness to unlock value
31 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. ♦ The Company has not demonstrated any willingness to take steps to unlock shareholder value ● We have made numerous attempts to engage with management and the Board in a constructive manner . The Board had over four months to consider taking
Slide 32: Participants and proxy legend
32 Strictly Confidential. Do Not Duplicate or Distribute. SANDELL ASSET MANAGEMENT CORP . , CASTLERIGG MASTER INVESTMENTS LTD . , CASTLERIGG INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, CASTLERIGG INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LIMITED, CASTLERIGG OFFSHORE HOLDINGS, LTD . , CASTLERIGG MERGER ARBITRAGE AND EQUITY EVENT FUND, LTD