FNCB Bancorp Inc

FNCB Bancorp — Merger or Acquisition (September 2023)

31 slides from FNCB Bancorp's merger presentation, Sep 28, 2023

  1. Slide 1: Transformational Strategic Merger

    Transformational Strategic Merger September 27, 2023 Enhancing Value for our Shareholders, Customers and Communities

  2. Slide 2: Disclaimer & Forward Looking

    2 Disclaimer & Forward Looking FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS This communication includes “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934

  3. Slide 3: Additional Information

    3 Additional Information ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND WHERE TO FIND IT In connection with the proposed transaction, PFIS will file a registration statement on Form S-4 with the SEC. The registration statement will include a joint proxy statement of PFIS and FNCB, which also constitutes a prospectus of

  4. Slide 4: Agenda

    Agenda I. Transaction & Franchise Combination Overview Due Diligence & Key Financial Impacts II. Conclusion III. Appendix IV.

  5. Slide 5: Transaction & Franchise Combination Overview

    I. Transaction & Franchise Combination Overview

  6. Slide 6: Transaction Summary

    Transaction Summary 6 (1) Assumes PFIS 20-day volume weighted average stock price for the period ended September 26, 2023 of $44.13. ▪ Holding Company Merger: Peoples Financial Services Corp. ("PFIS"), FNCB Bancorp, Inc. ("FNCB") ▪ Bank Merger: Peoples Security Bank and Trust Company and FNCB Bank ▪

  7. Slide 7: Strategic Rationale: Key Elements

    7 Strategic Rationale: Key Elements Complementary cultural values & community focus for a better banking experience Favorable post-closing trading liquidity dynamics Excellent share of the Scranton MSA and opportunity to accelerate growth in the expansion markets Material acceleration of each entity

  8. Slide 8: Pro Forma Asset and Deposit Market Rankings

    # Company Assets ($B) 1 First Commonwealth Financial $11.3 2 S&T Bancorp Inc. 9.3 3 Univ est Financial Corp. 7.6 4 CNB Financial Corp. 5.7 Pro Forma Combined 5.5 5 Mid Penn Bancorp Inc. 5.1 6 Peoples Financial Services 3.7 7 Orrstown Financial Serv ices 3.0 8 Citizens Financial Serv ices 2.9 9 Citiz

  9. Slide 9: Opportunity to Accelerate the PFIS Geographic Expansion Strategy

    $92 $310 2017 Current $21 $123 2017 Current $72 $103 $104 $71 $74 Lehigh Valley Greater Delaware Valley Central NJ State of PA US Average Opportunity to Accelerate the PFIS Geographic Expansion Strategy 9 Geographic Expansion Strategy Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence, FDIC, Federal Reserve Ban

  10. Slide 10: Company Overviews

    Company Overviews 10 $ in millions YE 12/31/2022 YTD 6/30/2023 Balance Sheet: Total Assets $1,746 $1,862 Total Loans 1,124 1,201 Total Deposits 1,421 1,476 TCE / TA (%) 6.81 6.66 Leverage (%) 8.77 8.98 CET1 (%) 11.94 11.91 Risk Based (%) 13.11 12.97 Regulatory CRE / TRBC (%) 157 155 Asset Quality: N

  11. Slide 11: Loan Portfolio Composition

    C & I 28% Owner-Occupied CRE 15% Multi-family 5% Nonowner-Occupied CRE 12% Construction & Land 6% Residential Mortgage 21% Consumer Lending 7% Municipal/ Other 6% C & I 18% Owner-Occupied CRE 14% Multi-family 7% Nonowner-Occupied CRE 22% Construction & Land 8% Residential Mortgage 19% Consumer Lendi

  12. Slide 12: Deposit Composition Q2 2023

    Noninterest-bearing Deposits 19% IB Demand, Savings & MMDA 56% Time Deposits 24% Noninterest-bearing Deposits 22% IB Demand, Savings & MMDA 59% Time Deposits 19% 12 Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence, Company Documents. Note: Financial data as of, or for the quarter ended June 30, 2023. Bank-lev

  13. Slide 13: Due Diligence & Key Financial Impacts

    II. Due Diligence & Key Financial Impacts

  14. Slide 14: Key Merger Assumptions

    14 Key Merger Assumptions Structural Elements ▪ Assumed closing date of early second quarter of 2024 ▪ All stock transaction; fixed exchange ratio of 0.146x ▪ Implied consideration per FNCB share of $6.44, or $129.0 million in aggregate deal value(1) ▪ PFIS is the legal and accounting acquiror ▪ PFI

  15. Slide 15: Pro Forma Financial Impact

    15 (1) Shown for illustrative purposes; Contemplates potential new FASB accounting implementation. (2) Assumes removal of all purchase accounting marks. Pro Forma Financial Impact Proposed GAAP Excluding CECL Day 2 Double Count(1) GAAP Financial Results Pro Forma BHC Capital Ratios @ Closing 43% 202

  16. Slide 16: Pro Forma Financial Snapshot: Top-Tier Projected Profitability

    15.8% 1.11% 3.0% 55% 16 Pro Forma Financial Snapshot: Top-Tier Projected Profitability Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence, Company Documents, FactSet. Note: Market data as of September 26, 2023. Note: Please see peer group criteria on page 3. (1) Peer data is based on 2024 Consensus Analysis est

  17. Slide 17: Meaningful Increase in Cash Dividends

    41% 39% 40% PFIS Pro Forma Peers $3.95 $6.29 PFIS Pro Forma $1.64 $2.47 PFIS Pro Forma • PFIS is expected to will raise its cash dividend following the merger to the level which is intended to create a neutral impact to FNCB’s current dividends (therefore FNCB’s shareholders would not incur dividend

  18. Slide 18: Superior Projected Returns Relative to Comparable M&A

    (11.3%) (9.0%) 5.1x 3.1x 2.4yrs 3.0yrs 59.2% 27.5% 18 Superior Projected Returns Relative to Comparable M&A Note: Tangible book value earnback calculated using the crossover method. (1) Includes nationwide bank and thrift deals since 2020 where target (legal seller) assets were 40-60% of buyer (lega

  19. Slide 19: Anticipated Merger Synergies & Profitability Acceleration

    Executives 13% Commercial 5% Retail/Consumer 24% Credit/Other 23% Operations & IT 28% Finance & Audit 6% Risk/Compliance 2% 19 Anticipated Merger Synergies & Profitability Acceleration Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence, Company Documents. Note: Pro forma financials include the impact of purchas

  20. Slide 20: Projected Valuation Upside

    $3-$10 B Asset Sized Public Banks Mid-Atlantic / Northeast Nationwide Profitability(1) 2025 Estimated Earnings Per Share $6.29 $7.46 $7.77 Core ROATCE ~16% 14% 15% Core ROAA ~1.11% 1.0% 1.2% Net Interest Margin ~2.97% 3.1% 3.5% Efficiency Ratio ~55% 60% 58% Balance Sheet and Capital at Close(2) @ Cl

  21. Slide 21: Meaningful Acceleration of FNCB Net Income & EPS

    21 Meaningful Acceleration of FNCB Net Income & EPS FNCB shareholders will own approximately 29% of the combined entity that has year-to-date annualized net income of $47 million(1), inclusive of projected synergies, merger adjustments and purchase accounting impacts $13.1 $19.2 Net Income(1) Dilute

  22. Slide 22: Comprehensive Due Diligence

    Financial Employees & Benefit Plans Legal Trust & Wealth Management 0.82% 1.17% 1.02% PFIS 6/30/23 Pro Forma @ Close Peer Median Deposits Operations & Technology Real Property & Other Contractual Obligations Compliance 22 Comprehensive Due Diligence Corporate Loans Credit Due Diligence Details In de

  23. Slide 23: Conclusion

    III. Conclusion

  24. Slide 24: Impact on Our Constituencies & Key Stakeholders

    Impact on Our Constituencies & Key Stakeholders Our Borrowers / Depositors Our Safety & Soundness ▲ Improved liquidity ratios ▲ Capital ratios remain significantly above well-capitalized levels ▲ Enhances reserves/loans and improves key credit metrics ▲ Lowers CRE concentration ratios ▲ Enhances pro

  25. Slide 25: Investment Thesis

    Investment Thesis 25 ▲ Combined bank projected to have an improved balance sheet and revenue diversification ▲ Expected to improve liquidity through fair value of FNCB’s balance sheet ▲ Projected to meaningfully increase net income, profitability ratios and expected dividends ▲ Accelerated TBV dilut

  26. Slide 26: Appendix

    IV. Appendix

  27. Slide 27: Pro Forma Net Income Reconciliation

    Note: Excludes restructuring charges and After-tax Charge to Establish CECL Day 1 ACL (Non-PCD "Double Count"). Proposed GAAP illustrates the potential new FASB 27 Implementation to eliminate the CECL Day 2 credit provision double count and amortization of Non-PCD credit discount amortization. Pro F

  28. Slide 28: FNCB Year-To-Date Core Net Income Reconciliation

    $ in 000s 2023 YTD Annualized FNCB Core Net Income to Common $13,076 FNCB Average Diluted Shares 19,703.089 FNCB Core Earnings per Share $0.66 Combined Core Net Income to Common $46,956 Plus: Merger Adjustments $19,132 Pro Forma Core Net Income $66,088 Pro Forma Core EPS Adjusted for Exchange Ratio

  29. Slide 29: Pro Forma Tangible Common Equity Reconciliation

    29 Note: Includes restructuring charges and After-tax Charge to Establish CECL Day 1 ACL (Non-PCD "Double Count"). Proposed GAAP illustrates the potential new FASB Implementation to eliminate the CECL Day 2 credit provision double count and amortization of Non-PCD credit discount amortization. Pro F

  30. Slide 30: Uninsured Deposits Walk

    30 Uninsured Deposits Walk Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence, FDIC. Note: Financial data as of, or for the quarter ended, June 30, 2023. Bank-level regulatory data used. (1) Excludes impact of purchase accounting adjustments and balance sheet strategies. $ in millions Uninsured Deposits (per FD

  31. Slide 31: Thank You

    Thank You

FNCB Bancorp — Merger or Acquisition (September 2023) on 6ix