First · NYSE:FCF
First — First Commonwealth Financial — Q3 2026 Earnings Presentation
42 slides from First's earnings presentation, Nov 12, 2026
Slide 1: First Commonwealth NYSE: FCF
@| ~FIRST fi Commonwealth. ee ee ee ee ee © NYSE: FCF
Slide 2: 3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials 2
Slide 3: Franchise Overview
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials FRANCHISE OVERVIEW FCF Branches (126) FCF Headquarters FCF Mortgage LPO (3) FCF Commercial LPO (4) FCF Equipment Finance Leasing Office ▪ Diversified community bank with 126 retail branches in Pennsylvania and Ohio ▪ Total Assets: $12.2 billion ▪ Activ
Slide 4: Investment Thesis
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials INVESTMENT THESIS A digitally-enabled, growth-oriented franchise positioned for long-term value creation ▪ Forward-looking operating model built to enable profitable growth o Commercial/Consumer balance; regional leadership; strong brand loyalty; commu
Slide 5: 2026 Regional Loan and Deposit Growth
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials 2026 REGIONAL LOAN AND DEPOSIT GROWTH Northern OH $ balance Community PA(1) Loans $1.6B $ balance Deposit $1.1B Pittsburgh Metro Loans $2.4B $ balance Deposits $4.5B Loans $1.9B OH Deposits $3.1B PA Central OH $ balance Loans $1.3B Deposits $0.9B Cinci
Slide 6: A Diversified Community Bank
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials A DIVERSIFIED COMMUNITY BANK Loan Portfolio Composition ($mm) Loan Portfolio Repricing ($mm) Non-Owner Occupied Interest rate floors exist for CRE / Total 48% of variable rate loans Capital Ratio: 171.0%(1) WA Floor of 3.35% < WA C&D Loans / Total Rate
Slide 7: Stable Low-Cost Deposit Advantage
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials STABLE LOW-COST DEPOSIT ADVANTAGE Deposit Composition ($mm)(1) Geographic Breakdown(1) 12% Business/88% Retail 65% Business/35% Retail $10.4 $10.4 billion billion 38% Business 62% Retail 54% Business/46% Retail 26% Business/74% Retail Deposit Costs (%)
Slide 8: Digital Strategy
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials DIGITAL STRATEGY Drive sustainable growth by expanding Accelerated our customer base through digital Customer Growth acquisition, targeted market expansion, and deeper community engagement. Leverage data and AI to deliver Data & AI-Driven personalized
Slide 9: A Culture of Continual Transformation
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials A CULTURE OF CONTINUAL TRANSFORMATION New New New New New Equipment New Legacy core team Experienced Consumer Commercial Lending Chief Mtg. Exec. New augmented with new Lending Finance Credit Banking Regional CIO Leadership Head Head Head Officer Head
Slide 10: A History of Successful Acquisitions
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials A HISTORY OF SUCCESSFUL ACQUISITIONS Successful Expansion Efforts Recent Acquisition Overview Announcement Completion Deal Value Total Loans Total Deposits ▪ Expansion efforts leverage our significant management Target Date Date $MM(2) Acquired $MM Acq
Slide 11: Successful Expansion History and Strong Core Organic Growth
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials Successful Expansion History and Strong Core Organic Growth 10 Year CAGRs Organic Loans... +6.9% Organic Deposits... +8.9% Total Assets... +6.2% TBV/ Share… +6.1% 14 Santander Branches 13 FirstMerit Branches 11
Slide 12: Investments Aligned with Revenue Growth
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials INVESTMENTS ALIGNED WITH REVENUE GROWTH Consistent growth in our revenue producing lines of businesses (Mortgage, SBA, Equipment Finance, and Indirect Auto) has outpaced expense growth, reflecting favorable operating leverage and controlled expense man
Slide 13: Fee Income Growth: Diversified Revenue Streams
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials FEE INCOME GROWTH: DIVERSIFIED REVENUE STREAMS $104.5 $96.9 $98.3 $99.2 $96.7 $96.2 $85.8 $78.3 Fee Income/ Operating Revenue 24.0% 26.4% 27.2% 26.7% 20.0% 20.7% 18.4% 18.6% ▪ Pleased with growth in Wealth and Insurance to business owners ▪ Reentered M
Slide 14: Expense Control: Operating Expense Trend
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials EXPENSE CONTROL: OPERATING EXPENSE TREND (1) $284.9 $265.3 $255.9 $224.7 $223.1 $191.0 $203.6 $206.4 $210.0 $190.1 $156.5 ▪ Mindful of operating budgets by region and line of business ▪ Incentive plans tied to objective measures ▪ Largest investments i
Slide 15: Asset Quality Trends
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials ASSET QUALITY TRENDS Nonperforming Assets / Assets(1) (%) Net Charge-Offs / Loans (%) (2) (2) Reserves / Nonperforming Loans (%) Nonperforming Loans / Loans (%) (2) (1) Nonperforming assets include nonaccrual loans and leases, renegotiated loans and le
Slide 16: Capital Return
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials CAPITAL RETURN Payout Ratios (1) • Strong capital levels allow us to continue to return capital to shareholders • There were 4,154,764 shares repurchased in 3Q 2026 • On October 27, 2026, the Board of Directors authorized an additional $25 million shar
Slide 17: Performance Highlights
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials PERFORMANCE HIGHLIGHTS Trailing 5 Quarters 2016Y 2017Y 2018Y 2019Y 2020Y 2021Y 2022Y 2023Y 2024Y 2025Y 3Q25 4Q25 1Q26 2Q26 3Q26 Earnings growth Operating revenue(1) $267 $309 $334 $357 $367 $384 $412 $484 $479 $524 $136 $138 $134 $139 $143 Provision fo
Slide 18: Performance Relative to Peers $5-20B
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials PERFORMANCE RELATIVE TO PEERS $5-20B Pre-Provision ROAA (%)(1) Efficiency Ratio (%)(1) Pre-Provision ROATCE (%)(1) Net Interest Margin (%)(1)(2) (1) Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence (2) Taxable equivalent 18
Slide 19: 2026 Strategic Themes
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials 2026 STRATEGIC THEMES Eight strategic themes have been identified to enable FCF to achieve its vision and its strategic and financial objectives Mission Live the Mission Grow Profitably Grow our low-cost deposits and our lending businesses Improve Get
Slide 20: How We Succeed
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials HOW WE SUCCEED ▪ Remain an authentic, mission-driven community bank – Continue to support our employees, customers and communities – Proactively engage borrowers and assist them with charting a path forward – Win customers through better speed to marke
Slide 21: Additional Areas of Focus
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials ADDITIONAL AREAS OF FOCUS 21
Slide 22: Sources of Liquidity
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials SOURCES OF LIQUIDITY As of September 30, 2026 Total Amount Net Available Used Availability Internal Sources: Unencumbered Securities $529.6 $0 $529.6 Other (Excess Pledged) $121.3 $0 $121.3 External Sources: FHLB $2, 654.6 $156.5 $2,498.1 Federal Reser
Slide 23: Investment Securities Portfolio
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials INVESTMENT SECURITIES PORTFOLIO Securities Portfolio Composition(1) ▪ Conservative investment portfolio intended to act as a pool of liquidity ▪ There were $8.0 million of investment securities purchased during the quarter with a weighted average life
Slide 24: Granular Core Deposit Franchise
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials GRANULAR CORE DEPOSIT FRANCHISE ▪ Strong, granular, well-diversified depository Insured Deposits − Average deposit account size ~$21,000 − Average retail account size ~$13,000 − Average business account size ~$77,000 − 76% of deposits were insured or s
Slide 25: CRE Portfolio
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials CRE PORTFOLIO Total Loans Commercial Real Estate Portfolio % of total 3Q 26 loans Owner-occupied CRE $ 772.1 8.1% Multifamily 671.3 7.0% Retail 583.4 6.1% Office 314.5 3.3% Office - Medical 47.0 0.5% Hospitality 180.3 1.9% $9.6B Industrial Distr./Wareh
Slide 26: CRE Portfolio: Office
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials CRE PORTFOLIO: OFFICE Risk profile reflects well-diversified, granular portfolio and conservative credit culture ▪ Office credits >$1 million (90% of Office portfolio balances) are formally reviewed annually Geographic Breakdown(1) ▪ Average Office loa
Slide 27: Earnings Detail
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials 3Q 2026 Earnings Detail 27
Slide 28: Third Quarter 2026 Highlights
Investor Relations 3Q 2026 Earnings Discussion Materials Webcast Presentation THIRD QUARTER 2026 HIGHLIGHTS Diversified balance sheet and revenue streams continue to Highlights support the fundamental earnings of the company ▪ Core EPS of $0.45 was an increase of $0.01 from the previous quarter $65.
Slide 29: Net Interest Income and Net Interest Margin
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NET INTEREST INCOME AND NET INTEREST MARGIN Net Interest Income(1) ▪ Net interest income (FTE) of $116.7 million increased $3.9 million from LQ and increased $5.2 million YoY ▪ Net interest margin of 4.11% increased 10bps from LQ but increased 19bps Yo
Slide 30: Loans
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials LOANS Average Loans(1) Average ▪ Average loans increased $104.8 million from LQ but decreased $88.3 million YoY due to the sale of $210.4 million of held for sale commercial loans in 1Q26 ▪ The yield on loans increased 2bps from LQ and increased 1bps Y
Slide 31: Deposits
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials DEPOSITS Average ▪ Average deposits decreased $87.1 million or Average Deposits 3.3% annualized from LQ ▪ Average deposits increased $104.2 million, or 1.0% from prior year quarter ▪ Average noninterest-bearing deposits increased $72.4 million from LQ
Slide 32: Noninterest Income
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NONINTEREST INCOME Change from 3Q26 2Q26 3Q25 2Q26 3Q25 Interchange $4.0 $4.0 $4.0 $0.0 $0.0 Service Charges 6.0 5.7 5.9 0.3 0.1 ▪ Fee income (excl. securities) remained flat to Trust 3.9 3.6 3.5 0.3 0.4 LQ and increased $2.2 million YoY Retail Brokera
Slide 33: Noninterest Expense
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NONINTEREST EXPENSE Change from 3Q26 2Q26 3Q25 2Q26 3Q25 Salaries and benefits Occupancy $44.4 5.3 $42.7 5.0 $40.7 5.1 $1.7 0.3 $3.7 0.2 ▪ Total operating expense increased $4.0 Furniture and equipment 4.9 4.2 4.4 0.7 0.5 million from LQ and increased
Slide 34: Credit Quality
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials CREDIT QUALITY Provision Expense and Net Charge-offs ▪ Provision expense of $14.2 million increased $5.3 million from LQ ▪ The allowance for credit losses as a percentage of end-of- period loans was 1.40% as compared to 1.35% in LQ ▪ Nonperforming loan
Slide 35: Appendix
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials APPENDIX 35
Slide 36: Non-GAAP Measures
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NON-GAAP MEASURES Operating Revenue 3Q26 2Q26 1Q26 4Q25 3Q25 Net Interest Income $116.3 $112.4 $109.0 $113.2 $111.1 Tax equivalent adjustment 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.4 0.4 Net Interest Income (FTE) 116.7 112.8 109.3 113.6 111.5 Noninterest Income (Reported) 26.7
Slide 37: Non-GAAP Measures
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NON-GAAP MEASURES Core Earnings per Share 3Q26 2Q26 1Q26 4Q25 3Q25 Net Income (GAAP) $44.9 $44.6 $37.5 $44.9 $41.3 (after tax) Less: Realized gains/ (losses) on securities (after tax) 0.0 (0.3) (0.1) (0.3) (0.2) Less: Merger and acquisition related (af
Slide 38: Non-GAAP Measures
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NON-GAAP MEASURES Tangible Common Equity / Tangible Assets (Tangible Common Equity Ratio) 3Q26 2Q26 1Q26 4Q25 3Q25 Total Equity $1,484 $1,569 $1,552 $1,554 $1,542 Less: Intangible assets 399 398 399 400 401 Less: Preferred stock 0 0 0 0 0 Tangible Comm
Slide 39: Non-GAAP Measures
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NON-GAAP MEASURES Core Return on Average Tangible Common Equity (%) 3Q26 2Q26 1Q26 4Q25 3Q25 Average Equity $1,559 $1,563 $1,562 $1,550 $1,531 Less: Average intangible assets 398 399 400 401 402 Average Tangible Common Equity $1,160 $1,165 $1,163 $1,14
Slide 40: Non-GAAP Measures
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NON-GAAP MEASURES Core Earnings per Share 2025Y 2024Y 2023Y 2022Y 2021Y 2020Y 2019Y 2018Y Net Income (GAAP) $152.3 $142.6 $157.1 $128.2 $138.3 $73.4 $105.3 $107.5 (after tax) Less: Covid-19 related (after tax) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.3 0.8 0.0 0.0 Less: Earl
Slide 41: Non-GAAP Measures
3Q 2026 Investor Relations Discussion Materials NON-GAAP MEASURES Tangible Common Equity / Tangible Assets (Tangible Common Equity Ratio) 2025Y 2024Y 2023Y 2022Y 2021Y 2020Y 2019Y 2018Y Total Equity $1,554 $1,405 $1,314 $1,052 $1,109 $1,069 $1,056 $975 Less: Intangible assets 400 383 387 313 315 317
Slide 42: Forward-Looking Statements
FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS Certain statements contained in this release that are not historical facts may constitute “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exch
First Commonwealth Financial — Q3 2026 Earnings Presentation on 6ix