BMC Software — Proxy Contest (June 2012)
35 slides from BMC Software's proxy contest presentation, Jun 20, 2012
Slide 1: Elliott's Perspectives on BMC's Significant Value and How to Unlock It
Exhibit B Elliott’s Perspectives on BMC’s Significant Value and How to Unlock It June 20, 2012
Slide 2: Additional Information
Additional Information Elliott Associates, L.P. and Elliott International, L.P. (“Elliott”) have filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission a definitive proxy statement and an accompanying proxy card to be used to solicit proxies in connection with the 2012 Annual Meeting of Stockholders (inc
Slide 3: Situational Summary
Situational Summary What is this election about? Elliott believes BMC can generate significantly more value for stockholders through new perspectives and change at the Board BMC’s Board believes that the status quo is working and it is the best strategy for the Company and its stockholders What is E
Slide 4: I. BMC is Worth Significantly More
I. BMC is Worth Significantly More Multiple Pathways to Realizing Significant, Unlocked Value
Slide 5: Numerous Pathways to Greater Value at BMC
Numerous Pathways to Greater Value at BMC Elliott advocates for BMC’s Board to engage in a full review of all alternatives available to maximize stockholder value. These include both strategic and operational pathways, which should be considered and, we believe, are vastly superior to the Company’s
Slide 6: BMC Unaffected Stock Price
BMC Unaffected Stock Price We believe Elliott's involvement and the market's speculation has supported BMC stock's recent outperformance 1 Period of no involvement, where BMC stock had mixed results as compared to the market and its peers 2 Period beginning 03/19/12 when Elliott’s purchase of ~6.5%
Slide 7: Operational Improvements
1 Operational Improvements “There appears to be significant opportunity for margin expansion – from professional services, tight integration of prior acquisitions and non revenue producing headcount. I think the Company could do far better with a focused approach to efficiency that will drive produc
Slide 8: Operational Improvements (cont'd)
Operational Improvements (cont’d) BMC should be a leader in cloud products for management software. With over 20,000 customers and the inertia of high-quality on-premise solutions like Remedy and Blade, BMC should be driving real growth “BMC has a real opportunity to succeed in SaaS. However, cloud
Slide 9: Sale of the Entire Company
Sale of the Entire Company We believe BMC is significantly attractive to strategic and financial sponsors alike Strategic Buyers Private Equity Buyers BMC offers significant strategic rationale BMC represents a compelling LBO candidate… Extensive customer presence at the IT desk Recurring revenue pr
Slide 10: Separation of Business Segments
Separation of Business Segments BMC is comprised of two separate companies – we believe the Company’s value could be significantly increased by positioning the segments’ growth, investment requirements and capital needs / structures independently Enterprise Service Management (“ESM”) Mainframe Servi
Slide 11: Separation of Business Segments (cont'd)
3 Separation of Business Segments (cont’d) Illustrative Potential Value Creation From Separation of Business Segments Enterprise Service Management (“ESM”) Mainframe Service Management (“MSM”) ($ in millions) ($ in millions) LTM Revenues $1,342 LTM EBITDA ² $506 ESM Peer ¹ LTM Revenue Multiple MSM P
Slide 12: Separation of Business Segments (cont'd)
3 Separation of Business Segments (cont’d) While it is possible to create value through trading each segment on its own, the potential also exists to realize superior returns if as a result of the separation various strategic and financial acquirers are able to purchase the segments of BMC they cove
Slide 13: Leveraged Stock Buyback
4 Leveraged Stock Buyback BMC has significant excess debt capacity given its recurring revenue base, stable free cash flow generation, and current net cash position Company can issue debt or use excess free cash flow and excess cash for stock repurchases Returning capital and addressing operational
Slide 14: Dividends
Dividends Many leading technology companies now embrace dividends to instill managerial discipline and reward stockholders LISTED TECHNOLOGY COMPANIES – U.S. HEADQUARTERED ¹ (As of 06/15/12) Dividend (As of 06/15/12) Dividend (As of 06/15/12) Dividend Company Yield Company Yield Company Yield Apple
Slide 15: Strategic and Operational Review
Strategic and Operational Review We believe that the strategic and operational opportunities to enhance stockholder value outlined in this presentation are absolutely worth evaluating, understanding and implementing as appropriate Furthermore, more than one of the value creating steps could be imple
Slide 16: II. BMC's Plan is For More of the Same…
II. BMC’s Plan is For More of the Same…
Slide 17: BMC's Plan is For the Status Quo
BMC’s Plan is For the Status Quo As recently as last week, BMC reiterated its plan for the Company which made obvious management’s stubbornness to maintain the status quo. A vote for BMC’s Directors appears to be a vote for the following: 1 The same Board 2 The same plan to try to improve execution
Slide 18: The Status Quo – It Hasn't Worked…
1 The Status Quo – It Hasn’t Worked… By almost any objective measure, over just about any relevant time period and against almost any pertinent benchmark, BMC's shares have significantly underperformed 3-YEAR ¹ 2-YEAR ¹ 104.9% 33.8% 87.9% 86.9% 24.3% 64.0% 21.5% 56.8% 16.1% 21.9% 8.0% iShares Market
Slide 19: …Nor does the Status Quo look like the Best Possible Future
…Nor does the Status Quo look like the Best Possible Future Based on various valuation methods, BMC’s current plan doesn’t seem to come close to the appeal of a better Board, considering all operational and strategic options: Under any of Elliott’s proposed operational and strategic improvements, we
Slide 20: Management's Same Story Doesn't Really Fit…
1 Management’s Same Story Doesn’t Really Fit… BMC’s Board and management believe they have done well enough to maintain the status quo. Why should we believe they can execute this time around?? MANAGEMENT’S CLAIMS IN STOCKHOLDER LETTER (6/12/12) ELLIOTT’S PERSPECTIVE “Importantly, your Board and man
Slide 21: Management's Same Story Doesn't Really Fit…(cont'd)
1 Management’s Same Story Doesn’t Really Fit…(cont’d) MANAGEMENT’S CLAIMS IN STOCKHOLDER LETTER (6/12/12) ELLIOTT’S PERSPECTIVE “BMC has made a significant investment in additional ESM direct BMC has made similar claims since 2009, however, it appears sales capacity and adjusted the compensation str
Slide 22: The Same ESM Plan – Again?!
2 The Same ESM Plan – Again?! BMC’s most recent letter to After four years of management “focus” on strengthening ESM sales stockholders reiterates its plan for ESM force, it still remains a major issue “Reducing turnover is an important element to increasing the productivity of our direct sales for
Slide 23: The Status Quo Growth Plan Hasn't Worked
3 The Status Quo Growth Plan Hasn’t Worked BMC says its Board understands the markets and software – but many members don’t have relevant backgrounds and the results don’t bear it out… Market entrants like ServiceNow (launched in 2004) and Solar Winds (launched in 1999) saw the opportunity in the ma
Slide 24: Management's Plan to Return Capital to Stockholders
4 Management’s Plan to Return Capital to Stockholders Despite modest share repurchase activity BMC has historically maintained significant excess cash on balance sheet which presently earns insignificant amount of interest income Additionally, BMC generates positive free cash flow which has aided in
Slide 25: The Same M&A Plan is Not the Answer
The Same M&A Plan is Not the Answer BMC has spent significant amount of stockholder capital on R&D and an M&A strategy which has not contributed meaningfully to organic revenue growth BMC has paid significantly high multiples for its acquisitions — 27 acquisitions for over $2.4 billion aggregate val
Slide 26: The Same Compensation Plan…
6 The Same Compensation Plan… BMC management compensation incentives are misaligned BMC still paid short-term incentives to its CEO and CFO despite a 1-year stockholder return of -19% during FY2012 — If stockholders lose 19% of their investment, why does management get incentive payments? BMC’s CEO
Slide 27: III. Our Director Nominees are a Better Choice
III. Our Director Nominees are a Better Choice
Slide 28: Elliott Has Proposed to Make BMC's Board Stronger
Elliott Has Proposed to Make BMC’s Board Stronger To unlock BMC’s full potential, Elliott believes that BMC’s Board needs members who are strong leaders and who offer fresh perspectives and new ideas — We believe the current resistance to new ideas and thoughtful evaluation of all alternatives stems
Slide 29: Board Oversight Would be Dramatically Improved with More Domain Expertise
Board Oversight Would be Dramatically Improved with More Domain Expertise BMC’s Board stated as recently as June 19 that management’s incentives are aligned with stockholders. But it seems like it could be far better KEY QUESTION KEY REFERENCE POINTS Why has BMC’s Board failed to hold “The assumptio
Slide 30: BMC Board's Interests May Not be Aligned with the Stockholders
BMC Board’s Interests May Not be Aligned with the Stockholders Not only does the BMC Board lack relevant experience, its members also have little vested economic interest in the performance of the Company Outside Director Years on Board Shares Owned Total Beneficial Ownership ¹ Ownership % ² Meldon
Slide 31: Opportunity to Improve BMC's Board
Opportunity to Improve BMC’s Board Elliott has nominated four highly experienced and respected technology industry executives who share the view that BMC is underperforming and undervalued and who will work to explore all strategic and operational alternatives to maximize stockholder value Moreover
Slide 32: Opportunity to Improve BMC's Board (cont'd)
Opportunity to Improve BMC’s Board (cont’d) REPRESENTATIVE CREDENTIALS BOARD AFFILIATIONS THOMAS HOGAN Executive Vice President of Sales, Marketing & Strategy, as well as InForte Corporation ¹ Executive Vice President of Software & Solutions at Hewlett Packard, Experience as top executive at during
Slide 33: Opportunity to Improve BMC's Board (cont'd)
Opportunity to Improve BMC’s Board (cont’d) REPRESENTATIVE CREDENTIALS BOARD AFFILIATIONS JOHN DILLON CEO of Engine Yard, the leading cloud platform for automating and Centerpointe Community Experience as CEO and developing Ruby on Rails and PHP applications (2009 - present) Bank Director for a dive
Slide 34: IV. Conclusion
IV. Conclusion
Slide 35: Conclusion
Conclusion As mentioned in our previous letters to management, we have conducted an exhaustive analysis of BMC and have concluded that there exists significant unrealized value at the Company For the last several weeks, we have actively encouraged BMC’s management and Board of Directors to work prod