Philippine Stock Exchange, Inc. · PSE:PSE
Philippine Stock Exchange — Asian Development Bank — SEC-PSE Corporate Governance Forum 2014
20 slides from Philippine Stock Exchange's conference presentation, Oct 21, 2014
Slide 1: ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard
ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard THE SEC-PSE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE FORUM 21 October 2014 Presented by: Mohd Sani Ismail Financial Sector Economist Southeast Asia Department Asian Development Bank
Slide 2: Overview
Overview ASEAN regional integration - why it is important to ADB and ASEAN? Why ASEAN Corporate Governance? Goals and Objectives Structure & Methodology Overall Findings Country Specific Findings Best Practices and Areas for Improvements Opportunities & Challenges
Slide 3: ADB & regional integration
ADB & regional integration Strategy 2020 Strategic Agenda: regional integration – (i) regional markets for goods, services, and capital will raise efficiency of resource use and enhance the region’s global competitiveness. (ii) Closer regional coordination will elevate the quality of policy and rein
Slide 4: ASEAN & regional integration
ASEAN & regional integration ASEAN Economic Community 2015 Implementation Plan endorsed by ASEAN Finance Ministers in 2009. Harmonised equity and debt disclosure standards MOU on expedited entry framework for secondary listings Cross-border fund raising Corporate governance ranking of ASEAN PL
Slide 5: Why ASEAN Corporate Governance? Goals & Objectives
Why ASEAN Corporate Governance? Goals & Objectives i. Importance of corporate governance to brand ASEAN as an asset class - Showcase and enhance the visibility of well-governed PLCs regionally and internationally ii. Corporate Governance is an important factor in investment decision-making iii. Reco
Slide 6: Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard
Structure & Methodology of the Structure of the ASEAN CG Scorecard ASEAN CG Scorecard There are two levels to the ASEAN CG Scorecard Level 1 Level 2 Five major sections that corresponds Two additional sections to the OECD Principles Bonus & Penalty Bonus items for companies Part A: Right of Sharehol
Slide 7: Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard
Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard Distribution of assessment questions and scores Number of questions • The assessments continue to be based 2012 2013 2014 on publicly available and accessible information such as annual reports, 26 25 25 corporate websites, notices, and Part A [10] [
Slide 8: Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard
Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard The Scorecard is mainly based on OECD Principles of Corporate Governance… …and takes into account other global and regional best practices and initiatives Global & national best practices Initiatives within ASEAN OECD Principles of CG CG Scorecard CG
Slide 9: Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard
Structure & Methodology of the ASEAN CG Scorecard Summary – peer review process Domestic assessor to assess top 100 PLCs from each 100 100 100 100 100 100 country Peer review on top 50 PLC s 50 50 50 50 50 50 Top 20 Review by 2 external Peer Reviewer Next 30 PLCs Review by 1 external Peer Reviewer C
Slide 10: Overall Findings
Overall Findings Demography of ASEAN PLCs assessed Distribution of PLCs based on country Distribution of PLCs based on market 120 capitalisation* USD20b-55b Indonesia USD10b-20b 100 100 16 34 95 100 94 Malaysia 52 USD5b-10b 100 Thailand USD3b-5b 55 USD1b-3b 80 Singapore USD500m-1b Philippines 124 up
Slide 11: Overall Findings
Overall Findings Comparison of 2012 & 2013 final scores No. of companies - 2012 No. of No. of companies - 2013 companies 80 74 69 70 60 56 56 55 56 56 56 51 48 50 42 40 40 34 36 33 33 33 31 28 30 26 21 17 18 20 16 16 13 13 12 9 10 5 4 1 1 2 2 1 1 0 5.01 - 10.00 50.01 - 55.00 100.01-105.00 105.01-110
Slide 12: Overall Findings
Overall Findings Average scores by part Indonesia Malaysia Rights of Part A Shareholders Philippines (Max: 10 points) Singapore Thailand Equitable Vietnam Part B Treatment of Shareholders (Max: 15 points) Part C Role of Stakeholders (Max: 10 points) Part D Disclosure and Transparency (Max: 25 points
Slide 13: Country Specific Findings (Indonesia)
Country Specific Findings (Indonesia) Strengths • Shareholders have the right to approve remuneration of members of the board • Clear disclosure on voting rights of for any class of shares • Clear policies on employee safety, health and welfare • Clear disclosure of key risks, financial performance
Slide 14: Country Specific Findings (Malaysia)
Country Specific Findings (Malaysia) Strengths • Notice of AGM is published in a timely manner and all AGMs are held in easy to reach locations • There is no bundling of resolutions in annual general meeting • Corporate social responsibility is disclosed in the annual report • There is disclosure of
Slide 15: Country Specific Findings (Thailand)
Country Specific Findings (Thailand) Strengths • Shareholders are allowed to elect directors individually • There is no bundling of several items into the same agenda in the notice • There is a separate corporate responsibility report or section in the annual report • Corporate group structure is di
Slide 16: Some exemplary practices of ASEAN PLCs
Some exemplary practices of ASEAN PLCs …. Notice of AGM released at least 28 days before meeting Audited annual financial report/statement released within 60 days from FY end Having female independent directors on board Nominating Committee Details of remuneration comprising entirely of of CEO discl
Slide 17: …and areas for further improvement
…and areas for further improvement Lack of performance Lack of adoption enhancing measures for of sustainability employee participation practices Lack of succession plans for CEO/Managing Director/President and key Lack of disclosure of management direct and indirect (deemed) shareholdings of senior
Slide 18: Opportunities & Challenges
Opportunities & Challenges Opportunities i. Scorecard can be used as a diagnostic tool to identify areas for improvement in specific ASEAN countries and ASEAN wide. Year to year comparison can identify trend of improvement or areas that are digressing. ii. Recommendations in the Scorecard should als
Slide 19: Opportunities & Challenges
Opportunities & Challenges Challenges i. Sustainability & cost recovery : Assessment using the scorecard should be continuous, several iterations before scorecard becomes stable and sustainable – annual or biennial event to award top performing PLCs ii. Private sector dissemination: How to make the
Slide 20: Comments Welcomed Thank you
Comments Welcomed Thank you
Asian Development Bank — SEC-PSE Corporate Governance Forum 2014 on 6ix