NorthWestern Energy Group, Inc. · NASDAQ:NWE
NorthWestern Energy — Technical Presentation (July 2022)
37 slides from NorthWestern Energy's technical presentation, Jul 13, 2022
Slide 1: July ETAC Meeting Agenda
July ETAC Meeting Agenda July 13, 2022 Item Lead Start Time End Time Kickoff and Introductions S. Schmitt, NorthWestern 9:00 9:10 D. Millar, B. Mauch Preliminary Model Results 9:10 10:30 Ascend Analytics Open Comments / Responses S. Schmitt 10:30 10:50 Wrap up S. Schmitt 10:50 11:00 1
Slide 2: The Role of the IRP in NorthWestern Resource Procurement
The Role of the IRP in NorthWestern Resource Procurement • Identify NorthWestern’s capacity and energy position and determine the least-cost resources to meet future requirements • Balance reliability, affordability, and sustainability • Supply planning must follow rules set forth in Montana Law • M
Slide 3: The Analytical Planning Process
Define ELCC Curves, Technology Objectives, Costs Curves, Constraints Assumptions, and Inputs Using PowerSimm’s ARS least-cost least risk capacity expansion tool Capacity Expansion Runs Test if portfolio meets 0.1 LOLE Metric. Adjust portfolio if needed. The Analytical Check Reliability Planning Proc
Slide 4: Scenario Approach – Core Cases
Scenario Approach – Core Cases • Four capacity expansion runs with various Colstrip retirement dates 1. 12/31/2042 (base case) 2. 12/31/2035 3. 12/31/2030 4. 12/31/2025 • Sensitivity Runs • All QFs and ½ of QFs • Add social cost of carbon $50/ton with 5% annual growth rate • Test SMR replacement of
Slide 5: Modeling Status – Core Scenarios
Modeling Status – Core Scenarios Scenario ARS Resource Production Adequacy Cost Base Case Complete In Progress In Progress Colstrip Retire 2035 Complete In Progress In Progress Colstrip Retire 2030 Complete In Progress In Progress Colstrip Retire 2025 Complete In Progress In Progress
Slide 6: Modeling Status – Sensitivities (completed)
Modeling Status – Sensitivities (completed) ½ and all QFs Run Base Case with added Social Cost of Carbon
Slide 7: Modeling Status – Sensitivities (to do)
Modeling Status – Sensitivities (to do) • Joint Environmental Group Proposal • Add Social Cost of Carbon (Early Retirement Cases) • SMR Replacement of Colstrip
Slide 8: Early Results – Key Take Aways
Early Results – Key Take Aways • NorthWestern is “long” energy but “short” capacity • This is especially true in the “all QF” cases (assumes all QFs in the queue are built) • Capacity need starting in the mid 2020s of up to 300 MW by 2030 • Model favors adding long-duration storage to manage the “en
Slide 9: ARS Model Inputs
ARS Model Inputs Market Prices Supply Accredited Constraints Resource Capacity Selection Criteria Variable Capital Costs Cost
Slide 10: ARS Results – Base Case
ARS Results – Base Case Capacity Added with All QFs 300 Capacity (MW) Model selects 200 • Long-duration storage and natural 100 gas generation pre-2035 0 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 • Post 2035, shorter duration storage Long Duration Storage Short Duration Storage Gas CT Gas ICE is selected Capacity Ad
Slide 11: Energy Position - Base Case
Energy Position - Base Case Energy Position with All QFs New Resources • NWE is projected to be long on 15 QF Resources (Million MWh) energy for several years if all QFs Existing Resources Generation 10 are built Load 5 • New resources are needed for capacity, but also add to the - 2023 2027 2031 20
Slide 12: Reserve Margin – Base Case
Reserve Margin – Base Case 2000 Capacity Position – Base Case with All QFs Resource additions 1500 Capacity (MW) maintain a 16% reserve 1000 margin 500 0 2022 2026 2030 2034 2038 2042 Capacity Position – Base Case with Half QFs 2000 1500 Capacity (MW) 1000 500 0 2022 2026 2030 2034 2038 2042 Coal Na
Slide 13: CO2 Emissions
Carbon Emissions – Base Case CO2 Emissions with All QFs 2.5 • Colstrip is the dominate source of 2.0 CO2 Emissions (Millions Tons) carbon with over 75% of 1.5 emissions 1.0 0.5 • With half of the QFs, overall 0.0 emissions are higher due to 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 higher operation of thermal CO2 Em
Slide 14: Clean Energy Generation – Base Case
Clean Energy Generation – Base Case Clean Energy with All QFs 12 100% • Clean Energy Resources % of Clean Energy 10 (Million MWh) 80% Generation Generation provide nearly 60% of 8 6 60% NWE generation, rising to 4 40% nearly 80% in 2042 if all 2 - 20% 0% QFs come online 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 • Fo
Slide 15: Colstrip retirements
rc Colstrip retirements NorthWestern Ene TSy
Slide 16: ARS Results – Colstrip Retirements (with all QFs)
ARS Results – Colstrip Retirements (with all QFs) Capacity Added – 2035 Colstrip Retirement 400 Model selects Capacity (MW) 200 • Long-duration storage and natural 0 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 gas generation pre-2035 Long Duration Storage Short Duration Storage Gas CT Cas ICE • Post 2035, shorter dura
Slide 17: Energy Position – Colstrip Retirements
Energy Position – Colstrip Retirements Energy Position with 2035 Colstrip Retirement New Resources QF Resources • Colstrip provides significant (Million MWh) 10 Generation Existing Resources energy to NWE due to the min 5 Load run requirement - • When Colstrip retires the energy 2023 2027 2031 2035
Slide 18: Carbon Emissions – Colstrip Retirements
Carbon Emissions – Colstrip Retirements Carbon Emissions - Colstrip 2035 Retirement • When Colstrip retires, the carbon 4 (Million Tons) emissions drop considerably Carbon 2 • The natural gas units replacing 0 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 Colstrip have much lower Colstrip Basin Creek CELP Dave Gates Yel
Slide 19: Base Case with Social Cost of Carbon
Base Case with Social Cost of Carbon
Slide 20: ARS Results – Base Case with Social Cost of Carbon
ARS Results – Base Case with Social Cost of Carbon Model selects New Capacity Added (NamePlate MW) • A small amount of natural gas for 600 capacity 500 Capacity (MW) 400 • Lots of wind and solar in the mid- 300 2030s 200 • Lots of storage 100 0 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 Long Duration Storage Short Du
Slide 21: Energy Position with Social Cost of Carbon
Energy Position with Social Cost of Carbon Additional wind and solar push the energy position high in the later years Energy Position New Resources QF Resources Base Case with All QFs Exsiting Resources 12 Generation (Million MWh) 10 8 Load 6 4 2 - (2) 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039
Slide 22: Base Case with Social Costs of Carbon – Carbon Emissions
Base Case with Social Costs of Carbon– Carbon Emissions Emissions are primarily due to must run thermal resources CO2 Emissions - Base Case with Social Costs of Carbon 3.0 CO2 Emissions (Million Tons) 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 2023 2027 2031 2035 2039 Colstrip Basin Creek 1-9 David Gates Generating St
Slide 23: Next Steps
Next Steps • Sensitivity runs • Check results for resource adequacy and adjust as necessary • Production cost modeling for all scenarios • Comparison of scenarios for cost, reliability, and emissions
Slide 24: Appendix
Appendix NorthWestern
Slide 25: Technology Cost Forecasts
Technology Cost Forecasts • Major market disruption and inflationary pressures on all energy technologies • Supply chain bottlenecks • Fundamental changes in supply and demand for clean energy raw materials • Commerce Department investigation into the solar panel tariff evasion • Approach to current
Slide 26: Candidate resource list
Candidate resource list Technology/Fuel Resource Size Wind 50 MW Solar 50 MW Renewable Solar Storage hybrid 50 MW Wind Storage hybrid 50 MW Stand Alone Storage 25 MW (4- hour) Stand Alone Storage Storage 25 MW (8-hour) Pumped Hydro 100 MW (9 - hour storage) Aeroderivative gas turbine 50 MW Natural G
Slide 27: Inflation
Inflation What is inflation? Inflation is the rate of change in price levels over time. What are the causes? Stimulative fiscal and monetary policy Supply side shocks (coronavirus) Changes in demand/supply fundamentals causing “disequilibrium”
Slide 28: Clean energy supply chain prices went up dramatically in 2021
Clean energy supply chain prices went up dramatically in 2021 Shipping Lithium 900% 500% Wages Nickel >5% 26% Polysilicon Cobalt 400% 150%
Slide 29: Mining capacity unlikely to keep pace with demand for many years
Mining capacity unlikely to keep pace with demand for many years Committed mine production and primary demand for selected minerals Global average lead times from discovery to production, 2010-2019 Share of processing volume by country for selected minerals, 2019 EVs now 9% of new cars sold globally
Slide 30: Montana Wind
Montana Wind $1,784 $1,784 WIND - 100 MW (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,784 $1,800 $1,719 • With near term $1,623 $1,600 $1,654 inflation, wind is $1,589 $1,524 $1,784/kW $1,400 $1,459 $1,395$1,381 ($44/MWh) through $1,367$1,353 $1,339$1,325 $1,311$1,297 2025. CAPEX ($/kW) $1,283$1,269 $1,255$1,241 $1,2
Slide 31: Montana Solar
Montana Solar SOLAR - 100 MW (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,700 $1,605 $1,605 $1,605 • With near term $1,500 $1,460 $1,520 inflation, solar is $1,436 $1,605/kW $1,300 $1,351 $1,266 ($60/MWh) through 2025. CAPEX ($/kW) $1,181 $1,100 $1,096$1,086$1,077$1,067 $1,057$1,047$1,038$1,028 $1,018$1,008$998 $989
Slide 32: Lithium Ion Battery – 4 Hour Duration
Lithium Ion Battery – 4 Hour Duration BESS - Li-Ion - 4-Hr (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,800 $1,496 $1,645 $1,645 $1,645 • With near term $1,600 inflation, BESS is $1,516 $1,400 $1,461 $1,407 $1,645/kW through $1,352 $1,298 2025. $1,243$1,228$1,212 • Declines to CAPEX ($/kW) $1,200 $1,197$1,181$1,166 $
Slide 33: Gas Fired Power Plants
Gas Fired Power Plants Gas Resources (NOMINAL$) - NREL + MKT $1,700 $1,611 • Gas fired power $1,600 $1,557 $1,547 plants increase due to $1,495 Aeroderivative Turbines inflation but decline $1,500 $1,523 Reciprocating $1,491 modestly in cost Engines CAPEX ($/kW) $1,400 Combined Cycle $1,300 $1,200 C
Slide 34: Geothermal and Pumped Hydro
Geothermal and Pumped Hydro NREL ATB (CONS) + MKT ADJ (NOMINAL$) $4,000 $3,656 • Geothermal can Geothermal produce 24-7 clean $3,500 energy, however they $3,000 are expensive and $3,238 Pumped Hydro “Clean firm” non- must be located in $2,500 nuclear resources geologically specific CAPEX ($/KW) $2,0
Slide 35: The challenge ahead
The challenge ahead • Massive uncertainties • Effect of conflict in Ukraine • COVID Zero policy in China • Solar tariff investigation • Mining capacity • “onshoring of supply chain” • Build Back Better? • When will we see declining costs again? • Our plan: • Start modeling with these numbers. See if
Slide 36: New Website
New Website • Supply Planning Website: • https://www.northwesternenergy.com/about-us/gas-electric/electric-supply- resource-procurement-plan • Please sign up for the email distribution list: • https://lp.constantcontactpages.com/su/XE0SdNG • Submit portfolio requests and other feedback via the new f
Slide 37: NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting
NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting August 4, 2021 Thank you. 37
NorthWestern Energy Group — Technical Presentation (July 2022) on 6ix