ASA Gold and Precious Metals Limited · NYSE:ASA

ASA Gold and Precious Metals — Proxy Contest (March 2024)

25 slides from ASA Gold and Precious Metals's proxy contest presentation, Mar 12, 2024

  1. Slide 1: ASA Gold & Precious Metals Fund Managed by Merk Investments

    Slide 1: ASA Gold & Precious Metals Fund Managed by Merk Investments

    March 2024 ASA Gold & Precious Metals Fund Managed by Merk Investments Since April 2019 (*) Established 1958 (*) Peter Maletis started managing ASA on April 1, 2019. On April 12, 2019, ASA shareholders approved Merk Investments as ASA’s investment manager. On April 1, 2022, Jamie Holman joined the A

  2. Slide 2: Executive Summary

    Slide 2: Executive Summary

    Executive Summary 2 ▪ ASA : Proven Value for Long - Term Investors : ▪ Deep expertise in gold and precious metals markets ▪ Bespoke investment access ▪ Strong governance ▪ Outperformance ▪ Board believes that Saba could be potentially detrimental to ASA : ▪ Saba’s toolbox does not work for ASA ▪ Sab

  3. Slide 3: Merk Overview

    Slide 3: Merk Overview

    Merk Overview 3 ▪ Merk Investments is a boutique investment advisory firm with specific expertise in gold markets . ▪ Headquartered in Menlo Park, California and, as of January 31 , 2024 , holds over $ 1 . 1 bn in assets under management . ▪ Long - term relationships with custodians, administrators,

  4. Slide 4: Fund Management

    Slide 4: Fund Management

    Fund Management 4 Axel Merk – Chief Investment Officer Axel Merk is the President and Chief Investment Officer of Merk Investments, and manager of the Merk Funds . He holds a B . A . in Economics ( magna cum laude) and a M . Sc . in Computer Science from Brown University . Axel founded Merk Investme

  5. Slide 5: Merk Advantage

    Slide 5: Merk Advantage

    Merk Advantage 5 ▪ Extensive investing experience in the metals complex . ▪ Demonstrated investment principles in conjunction with a fund structure that allows investment across the capital structure in less liquid instruments . ▪ Trusted network of management teams, entrepreneurs, and industry expe

  6. Slide 6: Research and Investments

    Slide 6: Research and Investments

    Research and Investments 6 ASA Research and Investments Deep Fundament Analysis Diverse Industry Relationships and Deal Flow Regular Onsite Due Diligence Exclusive Focus on Metals & Mining Bespoke deals and deal structures

  7. Slide 7: ASA Fund Attributes

    Slide 7: ASA Fund Attributes

    ASA Fund Attributes 7 ▪ Active Management, Deep Expertise: ▪ Our hands - on approach leverages decades of precious metals experience, fundamental research, and our team's macroeconomic understanding. ▪ Differentiated Exposure: ▪ We invest across the capital structure, source proprietary deals, and i

  8. Slide 8: Fund Performance

    Slide 8: Fund Performance

    Fund Performance 8 ▪ ASA outperformance since April 2019 ▪ XXASAXX: ASA’s NAV • GDMNTR: NYSE Arca Gold Miners Total Return Index • GDX: VanEck Gold Miners ETF • GDXJ: VanEck Junor Gold Miners ETF The NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index (Total Return) is a modified market capitalization weighted index compri

  9. Slide 9: ASA Performance

    Slide 9: ASA Performance

    ASA Performance 9 Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Current performance may differ from that shown. The Company concentrates in the gold and precious minerals sector. This sector may be more volatile than other industries and may be affected by movements in commodity prices trigger

  10. Slide 10: Holdings as of January 31, 2024

    Slide 10: Holdings as of January 31, 2024

    Holdings as of January 31, 2024 ASA Investment Focus 10 Div : Diversified PGM: Platinum Group Metals

  11. Slide 11: ASA Holdings

    Slide 11: ASA Holdings

    ASA Holdings 11 Holdings as of January 31, 2024

  12. Slide 12: Actively Engaged Board

    Slide 12: Actively Engaged Board

    Actively Engaged Board 12 ▪ Deep Expertise: ▪ Board has expertise in precious metals, finance, fund oversight and fund regulation. ▪ Active Oversight: ▪ The Board facilitated a transition from weekly to daily NAV pricing in 2019. ▪ The Board transitioned to an external management team to move from h

  13. Slide 13: ASA Board

    Slide 13: ASA Board

    ASA Board 13 William Donovan Director since 2020 Mr. Donovan has extensive investment and asset management experience. Mr. Donovan served as President of United States Steel and Carnegie Pension Fund from 2011 - 2017, in which capacity he researched and implemented investment decisions for defined b

  14. Slide 14: ASA Discount

    Slide 14: ASA Discount

    ASA Discount 14 ▪ Fund Discounts Common in Vast Majority of Closed - End Funds ▪ Fund shares trade in the stock market separate and apart from fund NAV. ▪ Many factors contribute to a fund’s discount. ▪ Any investor who does not like a discount from NAV has the option of not buying shares of a close

  15. Slide 15: ASA Discount: Liquidation to Close the Discount

    Slide 15: ASA Discount: Liquidation to Close the Discount

    ASA Discount 15 ▪ Liquidation to “Close the Discount” ▪ If shareholders want ASA to be liquidated, the current Board should oversee the process given the unique considerations for ASA. ▪ Liquidation of ASA needs to consider the substantial holdings in relatively illiquid securities. Liquidation may

  16. Slide 16: ASA Discount: Practices in Place

    Slide 16: ASA Discount: Practices in Place

    ASA Discount 16 ▪ Practices in Place: ▪ Board monitors the discount and will take action should discounts become extreme and reflect broad shareholder dissatisfaction ▪ Daily NAV publication introduced in April 2019 ▪ Monthly fact sheets listing all holdings ▪ Implementing a consistent investment pr

  17. Slide 17: Saba's Toolbox

    Slide 17: Saba's Toolbox

    Saba’s Toolbox 17 In our assessment, Saba’s thesis could be potentially detrimental to ASA for the following reasons: ▪ Tender Offers ▪ Tender offers could trigger a forced sale of illiquid assets . With a large portion of illiquid assets, a tender offer announcement might put pressure on fund holdi

  18. Slide 18: Saba

    Slide 18: Saba

    Saba 18 In our assessment, Saba should not manage ASA for the following reasons: ▪ No precious metals expertise ▪ No experience overseeing a Bermuda based fund operating in US ▪ As previously noted, ASA operates under an SEC exemptive order granted pursuant to § 7(d) of the ‘40 Act. There are numero

  19. Slide 19: Saba

    Slide 19: Saba

    Saba 19 Your Board believes that Saba’s strategies could be potentially costly for the following reasons: ▪ Saba Capital's strategy burdens closed - end fund investors with costs, evidenced by their unilateral actions in fund management changes without prior engagement. ▪ Control over fund boards by

  20. Slide 20: Saba Example: PPR

    Slide 20: Saba Example: PPR

    Saba Example: PPR 20 ▪ Saba takeover Voya Prime Rate Trust (PPR) now BRW ▪ Saba reduced stake in 2021 by 72%, down 88% by end of 2023 Published Saba holdings Q2 2014 – Jan 2024 Source: BBG Jan 2019 – Jan 2024. Source: BBG

  21. Slide 21: Saba Example: GIM

    Slide 21: Saba Example: GIM

    Saba Example: GIM 21 ▪ Saba takeover of Templeton Global Income Fund (GIM) now SABA: ▪ In Q4 2023 alone, Saba’s fund holding (green in chart below) declines by 71% Jan 2021 – Jan 2024. Source: BBG Published Saba holdings 2014 – Jan 2024 Source: BBG

  22. Slide 22: Conflicts & Lack of Expertise

    Slide 22: Conflicts & Lack of Expertise

    Conflicts & Lack of Expertise 22 ▪ Conflicts of Interest ▪ All of Saba's proposed directors already have a relationship with Saba, which ASA’s board believes jeopardizes their independence and raises concerns about prioritizing Saba's gains over the interests of ALL shareholders. ▪ Lack of Diversity

  23. Slide 23: Proposals

    Slide 23: Proposals

    Proposals 23 ▪ The election of four directors to the Company’s Board of Directors. ▪ The ratification and approval of the appointment of Tait, Weller & Baker LLP as the Company’s independent auditors for the fiscal year ending November 30, 2024, and the authorization of the Nominating, Audit and Eth

  24. Slide 24: Contact

    Slide 24: Contact

    Contact Merk Investments LLC 1150 Chestnut Street Menlo Park, CA 94025 asa@merkinvestments.com www.merkinvestments.com (650) 323 - 4341 24

  25. Slide 25: Important Information & Disclosures

    Slide 25: Important Information & Disclosures

    Important Information & Disclosures Forward - Looking Statements pertaining to ASA Gold & Precious Metals Ltd . (the "Company") This presentation includes forward - looking statements within the meaning of U . S . federal securities laws . The Company’s actual performance or results may differ from

Source: SEC EDGAR · DEFA14A filed Mar 12, 2024

More decks from ASA Gold and Precious Metals Limited

All 6 ASA Gold and Precious Metals decks