Topps — Proxy Contest (July 2006)
21 slides from Topps's proxy contest presentation, Jul 5, 2006
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement Information
SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) Information Required In Proxy Statement SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant o Filed by a Party other than the Registrant þ Check the appropriate box: o Prelimina
Slide 2: Slide 2
Slide 3: Topps Full Value Committee Presentation
On June 23, 2006, the Topps Full Value Committee (the "Committee"), together with the other participants (as defined below), made a definitive filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") of a proxy statement and accompanying GOLD proxy card to be used to solicit votes for the election
Slide 4: Our objective
Our objective We are one of the largest TOPP stockholders. Our goal is to maximize stockholder value for all stockholders. Step 1: Replace three incumbent directors at the Annual Meeting on July 28, 2006 Deterioration of the operating results Poor stock performance Excessive compensation to manageme
Slide 5: Step 1: Replace three incumbent directors at the Annual Meeting
Step 1: Replace three incumbent directors at the Annual Meeting on July 28, 2006 3
Slide 6: Although our nominees would represent a minority of the board
Although our nominees would represent a minority of the board, their election would provide a strong signal to the current Board of Directors that the stockholders of Topps want a change in the direction of the Company (i.e., focus on profitability, better capital allocation) and support the formati
Slide 7: Poor financial performance
Poor financial performance Over the last five years, income from operations fell significantly from $36.6 million in 2002 to a LOSS of $2.3 million in 2006. March March February February February 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Net sales 300,180 290,115 294,917 294,231 293,838 Cost of sales 186,339 188,375
Slide 8: Poor stock performance
Poor stock performance Topps’ stock has lagged peers and indexes … 6
Slide 9: Poor stock performance
Poor stock performance … while absolute performance has been very poor. 7
Slide 10: Excessive compensation to management
Excessive compensation to management Compensation of management should be more closely aligned with the Company's financial performance. Very high base salary for CEO in line with the salary of CEOs of much larger companies: Position Company 3-year average salary Sales CEO Kraft Foods $1,079,175 $34
Slide 11: Poor capital allocation
Poor capital allocation Cash should be promptly returned to stockholders Balance Sheet is underleveraged. Topps has not been able to invest its cash at a sufficiently high rate of return and therefore, the company should return cash to its stockholders. Over the last 3 years, Topps has kept a cash b
Slide 12: Lack of accountability & sub-standard corporate governance practices
Lack of accountability & sub-standard corporate governance practices Related party dealings raise serious issues as to the independence of this board. Related party dealings Scott A. Silverstein, the President and Chief Operating Officer of the Company is the son-in-law of Arthur T. Shorin, the Chai
Slide 13: Lack of accountability & sub-standard corporate governance practices
Lack of accountability & sub-standard corporate governance practices Where does Topps currently stand on corporate governance practices? It is obvious that Topps has long-ignored proper corporate governance: Classified board Chairman and CEO roles are combined Supermajority voting provisions A super
Slide 14: The Committee's Corporate Governance Proposals
The Committee’s Corporate Governance Proposals A proposal recommending that the Topps Board amend the Restated Certificate of Incorporation of the Company (the "COI") to declassify the Topps Board A proposal recommending that the Topps Board amend the COI to allow stockholders of the Company to call
Slide 15: Topps' Presentation (filed with the SEC on 6/19/2006)
Topps’ Presentation (filed with the SEC on 6/19/2006) What the company says vs. facts! Whom should you trust? “Topps has consistently returned capital to shareholders” Fact: The company has kept an average balance of $103 million cash on its balance sheet for the last 5 years yielding a pre-tax retu
Slide 16: Topps' Presentation (filed with the SEC on 6/19/2006)
Topps’ Presentation (filed with the SEC on 6/19/2006) What the company says vs. facts! “Topps’ director nominees possess critical industry and business experience” Facts: What was the Board doing during the last 5 years when SG&A went up by $23 million and gross margin went down significantly? Three
Slide 17: Step 2: Take action to maximize stockholder value
Step 2: Take action to maximize stockholder value 15
Slide 18: Why our nominees should replace the three incumbent directors
Why our nominees should replace the three incumbent directors The Full Value Committee is incentivized to maximize stockholder value The Committee has a substantial financial incentive to maximize stockholder value The Topps Full Value Committee owns approximately 7.4% of Topps – our incentive is al
Slide 19: Take action to maximize stockholder value
Take action to maximize stockholder value Our plan Operate the Company for optimal profitability… Pursue an operational and strategic analysis in order to determine how to best manage business moving forward Analyze internal growth opportunities … while concurrently reviewing various strategic alter
Slide 20: Why our nominees should replace the current directors
Why our nominees should replace the current directors Experienced team with clear mandate – maximize stockholder value Timothy E. Brog President of Pembridge Capital Management and Portfolio Manager of Pembridge Value Opportunity Fund Managing Director of The Edward Andrews Group Inc., a boutique in
Slide 21: Certain Information Concerning the Participants
CERTAIN INFORMATION CONCERNING THE PARTICIPANTS THE TOPPS FULL VALUE COMMITTEE FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION ("SEC") ON JUNE 23, 2006 A DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT AND ACCOMPANYING GOLD PROXY CARD, TO BE USED TO SOLICIT VOTES FOR THE ELECTION OF ITS SLATE OF DIRECTOR NOMINEES AND